We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
language bizzo
![]() |
|
By:
Ha'way biscuit. I'm not a Celtic fan but the refs don't like them in big games. That pen today
![]() |
|
By:
I completely agree, was a shocking decision. But worth it to see Lennon seething!!
|
|
By:
Feck will be along soon,crash helmets at the ready chaps because personally I think the queen was behind todays result
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
|
|
By:
Feck N. Eejit
15 Apr 12 14:45 Joined: 10 Jan 02 | Topic/replies: 6,917 | Blogger: Feck N. Eejit's blog Will THEY p1ss further on our parade today? This is Euan Norris's chance to become one of our "top referees" just like the eyes in the back of the head man Willie Collum, the only ref in the world to award a hat trick of penalties to the same team twice within a year (source c.f. the late Bob Crampsey). Assistant referee 1 is our old cross eyed friend Willie Conquer. Yip, that's Euan one of our "top referees" now. ^ he's here ![]() |
|
By:
lot of big calls went against celtic recently, unusual for league champions. Today, the Ibrox game and the League Cup final
i thought the ledley handball was nailed-on pen though |
|
By:
Feeling a bit embarrassed Biscuit?
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
I don't know if there has been other threads re: the match but Neil Lennon needs a reality check. His team get beat by two mediocre teams in mickey mouse cups. They proceed to win the leauge against a worse than mediocre Rangers side, and yet in yesterday's paper he says he plans to conquer europe!!!!!!!!
I've nothing against him personally, but the man is delusional. (nap) |
|
By:
PS And I'm not speaking about the europa cup, he genuinely belives he can win the champions league. Its all there in black and white....
|
|
By:
Feck N. Eejit 15 Apr 12 15:06
Feeling a bit embarrassed Biscuit? Why would i be feeling embarrassed? I find it highly amusing you lost, and whilst i think the penalty was debatable there have been similar ones given recently in the premier league. And you can have no complaints over the referee because you got a break with Hoopers goal being allowed to stand even though he was clearly offside. So no, i can't see why i'd be feeling embarrassed. You on the other hand should be embarrassed at failing to beat a poor Hearts side, Lennon bottling it in a big game again, Lennons antics after the game and the fact that once again you blame the ref instead of your own sides poor performance. |
|
By:
If the Hearts penalty was a penalty (debatable to say the least)the Celtic claim a couple of minutes later was a penalty. Nobody (not even some of the nutters on here) would surely argue against this. So what have we to think ? The ref saw one as deliberate handball and the other as accidental. Considering how close Ledley was to the Hearts player who struck the ball it would seem there would be a strong argument that this was indeed accidental. Perhaps it was a mistake by the ref or would it be ludicrous to suggest that it was plain and simple cheating ?
|
|
By:
Pollensa I agree ref had a shocker,as Biscuit quite rightly pointed out how Celtics goal was allowed to stand was shocking,if I did not know better I would have said the ref was influenced by outside agencies.
|
|
By:
But I do know better,it was just a bad decision.
|
|
By:
"or would it be ludicrous to suggest that it was plain and simple cheating"
Yes it would be ludicrous. If the officials wanted Hearts to go through, why did they allow Hooper's offside goal? Blame Ki for hitting the post twice from 4 yards out, not the ref. |
|
By:
Celtic had 70% of the possesion yet still lost the game against a poor Hearts team,they should have won by 2 or 3 yet once again the deluded Celtic fans resort to clutching at straws blaming the ref and bad decisions,jeez.
|
|
By:
Biscuit....please explain why the ref gave one penalty and not the other. I consider myself to be open minded and look forward to your explanation.
|
|
By:
Only explanation i could give would be that the Celtic handball was because his arms were up and it was blocking a shot at goal. The Hearts one was an accidental deflection with the ball going nowhere near the goal.
So now i've answered your question, perhaps you can answer mine. If the officials wanted Hearts to go through, why did they allow Hooper's offside goal to stand? |
|
By:
And you can have no complaints over the referee because you got a break with Hoopers goal being allowed to stand even though he was clearly offside.
From where the ref was standing the goal was clearly offside? Are you the full shilling? Your argument would appear to be that if any incorrect decision goes Celtic's way then there cannot be bias within the SFA. |
|
By:
Don't linesmen decide offsides? What has the ref's position got to do with it? If the ref is in a position to see the lino's flag, then his position is good enough.
|
|
By:
Only explanation i could give would be that the Celtic handball was because his arms were up and it was blocking a shot at goal. The Hearts one was an accidental deflection with the ball going nowhere near the goal.
Had neither player handled the ball, the Hearts shot was headed way over the bar whereas at the other end a Celtic player would've had a goal scoring opportunity. If the Ledley one was a penalty the other one was a penalty and a sending off. |
|
By:
Don't linesmen decide offsides? What has the ref's position got to do with it? If the ref is in a position to see the lino's flag, then his position is good enough.
Tell him that. |
|
By:
Feck - are you denying that Hooper's goal was offside?
|
|
By:
Not that it was ever clearly anything until the replay.
|
|
By:
^ feck I would have thought the assistant referee would be in a better position to judge and as a result would have communicated with the referee.
Either way the 3 officials got it wrong I'm sure you will agree which would have resulted in Hearts staying 1-0 up. |
|
By:
It was marginally offside. Certainly more marginal than Rangers offside goal in the recent 3-2 old firm game.
|
|
By:
"If the Ledley one was a penalty the other one was a penalty and a sending off"
Ha ha so now not only do you want a pen for an accidental handball, you think he should've been sent off as well!! ![]() ![]() |
|
By:
Feck N. Eejit 15 Apr 12 15:58
It was marginally offside. At last!! |
|
By:
If there's a conspiracy, then surely marginal decisions would go in favour of the conspirators? It stands to reason that if a decision is shown clearly to be wrong via a replay, then in 'real-time' the call would be a marginal one...and thus given in favour of the conspirators.
|
|
By:
Feck N. Eejit 15 Apr 12 15:58
It was marginally offside. ^ So the goal should not have stood,eureka ![]() |
|
By:
If there's a conspiracy, then surely marginal decisions would go in favour of the conspirators? It stands to reason that if a decision is shown clearly to be wrong via a replay, then in 'real-time' the call would be a marginal one...and thus given in favour of the conspirators.
You're assuming the linesman saw it as marginal. It seems to be the case that unless all Celtic goals are called offside then there's no conspiracy. |
|
By:
So after all this we can finally agree that Celtic's goal shouldn't have stood and that neither injury time incidents were really pens. End result, Hearts still win the game and go through. What conspiracy?
|
|
By:
It's immaterial whether justice was done. It's the referees intent I'm talking about.
|
|
By:
Yes, I am making the assumption that he saw it as marginal because a replay showed it to be clear.
Normally, regarding offside decisions, replays do not show polar opposites of what we saw in real-time, but tend to confirm/dis-confirm marginal calls. I can't read the lino's mind, so sadly we will never know the truth. Instead, I will have to think that there is no conspiracy in this case. |
|
By:
Biscuit1979 15 Apr 12 15:32
Lennon bottling it in a big game again can you point to where lennon bottled it that cost celtic the game |
|
By:
Only explanation i could give would be that the Celtic handball was because his arms were up and it was blocking a shot at goal. The Hearts one was an accidental deflection with the ball going nowhere near the goal.
Biscuit are you being serious ? Celtic were clearly denied an opportunity to score when the Hearts player handled the ball...For the record I did not think the Celtic goal was offside until I saw the replay. However my point relates to the two penalty decisions and your explanation is completely ludicrous. |
|
By:
It must be something in the water at Parkhead that makes Celtic players bottle the big games. Ditto for the fact that Rangers always seem to have the bottle to scrape through in such games. Surely that's the only explanation as the majority of old firm players come from countries the world over? There again, maybe it's just that a very special group of Rangers supporters are able to influence these games.
|
|
By:
Hooper was not offside when he scored which makes the marginal offside decision all the more marginal.
|
|
By:
Ross county, Inverness CT, Kilmarnock, Hearts, Utrecht, Sion, There will be more they're just off the top of my head.
All big games Lennon has fell short.Say what we want about dodgy refs and decisions (and there has been umpteen) but at the end of the day Lennon just does not have the tactical brain to take Celtic to the next Level.He is almost useless when it matters. A good not great player in his time at Parkhead.More loved because of his Irish situation and because he's "Celtic minded". Well being "Celtic minded" doesnt make him a good manager. He has to go and fast.He can take his backing staff with him as well. Mjalby,Thompson and Lennon. Celtic park is not a place to learn your trade. |