We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Great day from Oz - should only be 2 down as well
|
|
By:
Well played, Australia
![]() |
|
By:
hmmmmm. no idea what the price on draw will do now....
|
|
By:
usually shortens overnight
|
|
By:
oh right...hope so
|
|
By:
Niceone WD
![]() |
|
By:
tempting to ride the draw for a while now
|
|
By:
wp oz
|
|
By:
fair play to Aus.....had their best day of the series thus far when they needed it most. Eng may well be relying on the weather to preserve the 2-0 lead so it'll be a stiff test for them if we only get minimal rain over the next few days...
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
Good performance under pressure from Aus today - didn't think Eng bowled badly just good batting from Aus.
|
|
By:
5-0 backers....
....... ...wait for it.... SEETHINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG ![]() |
|
By:
lol... need a miracle
![]() |
|
By:
Can anyone please offer me even a shred of hope having backed England from 1.98 pre-match out to 2.9? No, thought not.
I've not felt this hopeless and out of the hunt at the end of Day 1 of a Test for yonks. England's body language is awful, can't see where the next wicket is coming from. But fair play and credit to the Aussies for applying themselves much better in this match so far. When was the last time Anderson failed to take a wicket on the first day of a Test when he's played and England have been bowling? And yet . . . DAY 2: Aussies all out by tea. DAY 3: England level scores by tea and all out. DAY 4: Aussies all out by tea for 150-ish on rank turner. DAY 5: England snatch winning runs in the last half-hour. Can I possibly dare to dream? |
|
By:
Even if Aus are all out by tea tomorrow they'll have 480 on the board so no way Eng will achieve level scores on Day 3! Other than that I'd say you've got a fair chance Plechy...
![]() |
|
By:
Yep. This aint over by a long way. Fortunately, I kept some green on the draw. But not much rain in the forecast, and needs England to bat well 1st Inn for the draw to stay fav.
Looking to be an old fashioned Test match. Current prediction Aus 475 England 325 By last session day 3 |
|
By:
OK kruger76, let's have the Aussies all out by lunch, then!
I know I'm clutching at some very fine straws. |
|
By:
there's nothing I'd enjoy more! gl
|
|
By:
I reckon Aus 575 by tea day 2. England 360 by tea day 3. Eng 420 all out by lunch day 4 ( all out ). Oz 225 declared by close day 4 leaving Eng 400 to chase which they will either not get or force the draw.
|
|
By:
England should be near 410 on Last session Day 3 if Aus all out for 475. This pitch is not that slow, run rate should stay near 3.25 for third day.
|
|
By:
England won't be in any rush facing a big Aus 1st in score.
|
|
By:
I see the draw shortening tomorrow for how long I am not sure.
I also think Australia are at an attractive price and think they may well shorten too as the day moves on after the rain. The pitch is going to take more and more spin. We will see tomorrow when Aus continue. Assuming England make a big score is I think a dangerous assumption. I can't decide whether to be on the draw or Aus so am happy to be on both equally right now. |
|
By:
just watching the highlights and how does Smith not get given out to Broad lbw
regardless of the DRS/3rd umpiring etc.. it is clear that umpires are making decisions based on reviews left. if you cannot give that out lbw you should not be in a job imo it reminds me of the two lbws in a row where McGrath gets inzi lbw and the home umpire doesn't give them |
|
By:
been happening all series, bad calls once reviews are used up.. not just bad calls but bad calls that made teams pay and you could put the Agar stumping in that category
they were sure as **** the caught behind decision was out and fair enough too, there was a pretty ominous sound but nothing visual backed it up but the lbw call where it spun a mile, it was rising as well.. I think that was one of those ones where the weight of the decision bares heavily on the decision on field and would be classified a 50/50 more so than a howler the howler in hindsight is the one that was given not out, given how confident Broad was.. the way he appealed was one of those ones when you know it's out you're just waiting for the tick, the tick never came |
|
By:
I call Broad's lbw poetic justice
and the fact that the reviews were used up made it all the sweeter![]() Mistakes are made. That is part of the game. We shouldn't be vilifying Umpires like footballs fans do referees. There have been plenty of mistakes by both sides on review. There are ways of dealing with it but nailing the Umpires to the cross is not one. ( no offence intended to non Christians but I don't know how you would murder the son of your God ) |
|
By:
Khuwaja's call is the real blatant howler of the day and alot of people say "oh that's just justice!" when Smith gets given not out when he is out, how is it justice? poor khuwaja is trying to make it into the side and has been given limited opportunities, gets his chance at 3 on a flat wicket and cops that ****
it's not only costing teams games it's costing individuals their careers |
|
By:
yup the lbw was plainly out
the DRS system is a mess, designed to stop the howler decision yet we have had clearly incorrect decisions allowed to stand because the arbitary number of reviews has been used up the idea should be to get the correct decision not turn it into a skill required by captains on how to use technology |
|
By:
I entirely disagree with you, Whisperingdeath, and I would consider myself a moderate on this forum! Mistakes as basic and often as these shouldn't be made! No reason for it whatsoever and it won't improve until the problem is looked at and resolved. The third umpire needs to be more culpable and is making cricket look stupid - bringing the game into disrepute if you like.
The only solution is to stand those that make mistakes down, until you get a third umpire who understands his job and his responsibility properly. I agree with what someone else said on here and take the third umpiring job away from the umpires and give it to someone younger - anyone in the Sky commentary team would be able to do it easily, in fact a chimp should be able to get it right more often than the current guys do.... |
|
By:
Also agree with Judorick's previous post. What astonishes me is how often simple decisions are wrong! It shouldn't happen once!
|
|
By:
by the current DRS rules surely the third umpire made the right decision with khawaja
particularly as hot spot obv cannot be trusted the on field umpire made that howler |
|
By:
No. Because the ball clearly didn't hit the bat in the slo mo replay. The whole reason third umpires are in place is to overturn clear howlers by on field umpire - which he spectacularly facked up.
|
|
By:
I hate it when these umpires ****up, it takes the gloss away from Clarke's great 100 under huge pressure back home from the public to perform when we need it the most
Smith got lucky no doubt but you can't question the class of Clarke |
|
By:
Fair enough pixie,
I was being too flippant and did an Arsene Wenger on todays howlers so can't comment on them. Drs is not the problem though. The Third Umpire **** up's have to be remedied, that much I agree. Aleem Dar is a good umpire in fact Umpire of the Year twice I think. He made a couple of mistakes in the first Test one a real howler. Dharmasena isn't bad either. I have never rated Erasmus and am not sure about Tony Hill but no one is perfct. It is easy to make a real howler. If people who have commented here have played the game they should know it is easy to make some of these mistakes. Half the problem is the players pushing the envelope. DRS was brought in not to stop howlers but to relieve pressure on the Umpires. The memories of players hounding umpires and working them on mental disintegration still disgusts. The review is being used in a tactical way rather than by guys who know they have edged it before it hits their pads or guys who know for sure they haven't hit it when given caught behind. You can't blame the on field umpire for Khawaja's decision today. He got it wrong. The third umpire made the real howler. Overall I think they do a good job. I didn't see Smith non lbw but the ball is moving pretty quick and even the best guys can get these wrong. Who would you nominate to stand? |
|
By:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZ_DrLZpTQM#at=20
here you go. i am all for giving umpires the chance but he should not be doing the job if he doesn't give these out |
|
By:
Draw looks good here.
IF ENG bowl aussies out within a session tomorrow they score 400+ which is draw friendly. IF aussies get 500-600 pretty much takes ENG out of the game but draw will be shorter. |
|
By:
Just got in and the umpires have continued their totally inept performance on both sides. When is somebody with a set of balls going to can these three. The decisions that they are getting wrong are not even close.
|
|
By:
well said bob
|
|
By:
d13phe
Thanks but I have to say I am guessing Tony Hill probably thought he got hit outside the line. We all get the slow mo at home with Hawk Eye and it seems clear as day. Next time there is an appeal I challenge any of you to call it immediately before the umpires verdict and back it up with 25% of your stake in the game. All of a sudden it is a different call. Seriously call it before the decision and lets see who can get close to the Umpire. |
|
By:
come on mate
it does not get any more out than that these guys are trained and only have to look straight up if we make excuses for them it becomes acceptable, which it isn't |
|
By:
No way,
Dude the ball gets bowled seriously fast. he has a split second to call it. There must have been doubt in his mind about where it hit. he gave the benefit to the batsman as he should. (If he thought it was hitting outside the line then it doesn't matter to him if was hitting the stumps. I wouldn't call that an absolute howler. How many times does Broad use up reviews? so much so that they brought in a system where Captain, wicketkeeper and Bowler had to have a conference, which, incidentally is smart. I think a real howler is when everybody in the ground hears the inside edge except the umpire like when Broad got his hat trick ( and yes I call that poetic justice against India, they had it coming ) on Motd the pundits with the benefit of cameras can't agree on decisions at times. One manager says one thing and the other the opposite. Opposing fans berate the managers and officials. I don't want to see that happening in cricket. People at home who have the benefit of replay, slow mo and hawkeye think it is easy to make a decision. Well it is not. They listen to what commentators say and assume they are right and quite often they are not. Having said all that. the decision making this series hasn't been great and yes maybe the umpires need to be reviewed and the third umpire decision making needs to be redrawn |