Olympics 2012
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
02 Aug 12
15:28
Joined:
Date Joined:
17 Dec 10
Ogogo & Johsua were both put through and will now obviously win the gold in scandalous circumstances.
But does this not just show the desperation countries go to (ala china in boxing in 2008) to push themselves up the medal table.
Bad in the long run in my opinion. Ogogo & Johsua are average boxers at best and them winning gold will dilute the medals imho.
But does this not just show the desperation countries go to (ala china in boxing in 2008) to push themselves up the medal table.
Bad in the long run in my opinion. Ogogo & Johsua are average boxers at best and them winning gold will dilute the medals imho.
Show More
Sports that are decided by judges are not really sports to me. You can't fix athletics or cycling results unless you dope all of the other teams.
Hey lads I think ogogo has just lost. Not sure but I think they got countback figures which were added up wrong so decsion should be overturned. Nothing official yet
one of the worst decisions in the history of olympic boxing ...hang your heads in shame..your welcome to those medals if ye need it that bad ....
thats no reflection on the english ..a fine race of people ...the judges are at fault....
15-10 Ogogo? your having a laugh, the german won that fight, anthony was out on his feet in the 3rd round.
Thats 2 blatent robbery's, this sport is rotten to the core!
Thats 2 blatent robbery's, this sport is rotten to the core!
To be honest the judging in boxing has been p1ss poor for as long as I have been watching the Olympics (40 odd years). Yes Ogogo and Joshua were lucky in their first bouts but there have been some very strange markings. Tonight Joshua knocked the Chinese guy all over the shop in round 2 but only won 8-6!
For all the attempts at moving averages etc, amateur boxing seems tainted by dodgy judging.
The only way of doing it properly is to have a neutral panel of judges reviewing each round using all the TV angles to ensure all punches are recorded, not just those visible to the judges in real time. However, this would take about 5 minutes to resolve after each fight and this would be too long.
Maybe we should do away with boxing?
ps Phil can't agree with you re the second Ogogo fight. While German looked like he was doing loads, he was taking a lot of good punches from Ogogo.
For all the attempts at moving averages etc, amateur boxing seems tainted by dodgy judging.
The only way of doing it properly is to have a neutral panel of judges reviewing each round using all the TV angles to ensure all punches are recorded, not just those visible to the judges in real time. However, this would take about 5 minutes to resolve after each fight and this would be too long.
Maybe we should do away with boxing?
ps Phil can't agree with you re the second Ogogo fight. While German looked like he was doing loads, he was taking a lot of good punches from Ogogo.
yep that 2nd round scoring in the joshua fight defied credibility. he put him on the deck and did everything but stop him. should have been a 5 point gap minimum.
only dipped in and out of the boxing but nearly every time i have i've seen strange scoring
savannah marshall won the last round hands down this afternoon but the judges somehow gave it to her opponent by 2 points
only dipped in and out of the boxing but nearly every time i have i've seen strange scoring
savannah marshall won the last round hands down this afternoon but the judges somehow gave it to her opponent by 2 points
At least on the old scoring system it was visible what the judges were scoring. This present system is spectaator unfriendly and secretive
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539