Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 183 comments are related to the topic:
Hillsborough decisions 11:00am tomorrow..

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 183
By:
dustybin
When: 27 Apr 16 16:38
I dont think people who both offered sympathy for the loss and agree that lies were told and that errors were made, while still believing that its far too artificial to believe the conduct of fans meant they were nothing more than perfectly innocent parts....are in the minority tbh.
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 16:38
Dissent is acceptable.

Or is it only your view that matters?
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 16:39
^ that was to crystal
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 16:40
I think Orwell said in 1984, the truth is whatever you want it to be.

How true.
By:
jamesdean
When: 27 Apr 16 16:46
Well it clearly isn't for the Police involved in this case, wes.

The truth they wanted has been proven to be a pack of lies
By:
dustybin
When: 27 Apr 16 16:46
Nobody is rejoicing over the news, the whole bloody think was and still seems to remain a catastrophic, but people are entitled to their own view based on logic.
The way the politicians make out that based on the verdict its all now gospel is like popularism gone mad, jumping on bandwagons appeasing any and all as though they know exactly how things were.
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 16:50
james,

I'm not saying the police didn't lie.

The fact remains, the jury was not unanimous so I'm not exactly a rare beast for not toeing the accepted and politically correct line.
By:
jamesdean
When: 27 Apr 16 16:57
No, you said the truth will be whatever you want it to be.

The fact remains they lied through their teeth and tried to cover the whole thing up.

That's the facts of it. Nothing to be debated there. Lets hope the ones involved are now made to face charges.
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 17:00
Yes, and I was not referring to the actions of the police.
By:
lmfao
When: 27 Apr 16 17:00
So - Liverpool crowd were well behaved and blameless?- i guess some of you are too young to remember when 14 Liverpool thugs were found guilty of manslaughter for the killing of opposing fans in a european cup final stadium .....


The Heysel Stadium disaster (pronounced: [ˈɦɛizəl]; Dutch: Heizeldrama; French: Drame du Heysel) occurred on 29 May 1985 when escaping fans were pressed against a collapsing wall in the Heysel Stadium in Brussels, Belgium, before the start of the 1985 European Cup Final between Juventus of Italy and Liverpool of England. 39 people—mostly Italians and Juventus fans—were killed[1] and 600 were injured in the confrontation.[2]

Approximately 1 hour before the Juventus-Liverpool final was due to kick off, a large group of Liverpool fans breached a fence that was separating them from a "neutral area" which contained mostly Juventus fans. The latter ran back on the terraces and away from the threat into a concrete retaining wall. Fans already standing near the wall were crushed; eventually the wall collapsed. Many people climbed over to safety, but many others died or were badly injured. The game was played despite the disaster in order to prevent further violence, with Juventus winning 1–0.[3]

The tragedy resulted in all English football clubs being placed under an indefinite ban by UEFA from all European competitions (lifted in 1990–91), with Liverpool being excluded for an additional three years, later reduced to one,[4] and fourteen Liverpool fans found guilty of manslaughter and each sentenced to three years' imprisonment. The disaster was later described as "the darkest hour in the history of the UEFA competitions".[5]
By:
scandanavian_haven
When: 27 Apr 16 17:01
As a matter of interest, do they sell the sun anywhere in Liverpool? and do quite a few still buy it?
By:
jamesdean
When: 27 Apr 16 17:06
So because of what happened in Heysel, Liverpool fans were partly to blame for Hillsborough?

I went to see Scotland play England in Euro 1996

Does that make me partly responsible for invading the pitch when Scotland played England at Wembley in 1977?
By:
dustybin
When: 27 Apr 16 17:09
I went to see Scotland play England in Euro 1996Laugh
By:
elise
When: 27 Apr 16 17:11
people make mistakes everyday, it's human nature and sometimes people die when these things go wrong as in this case

it is sad but a fact of life, i doubt anyone would say the failings were deliberate and that people set out that day to see others die

where the problem lies in this is that the police should have acknowledged their failings immediately

the fact is they didn't, they gathered evidence then hid certain aspects of the findings and tried to project the blame on others to save themselves, rather than accepting their part in the disaster

i can't accept that a senior policeman thinks it's acceptable to lie and then ask his men to amend statements to save his own skin, that's cowardice, anyone going along with that deception deserves the same punishment

if they'd come forward at that point with all of the factual truth it would have saved an awful amount of wasted time and hurt and perhaps both sides might have seen where errors had been made or contributing factors had occurred, but instead all we now hear about is cover up and bent coppers

i have some sympathy for the police that were just doing their jobs on the day and for those tarnished by the actions of a few who tried to mask the truth

all of this arguing and bickering does nothing for the 96 that lost their lives or their families, no matter who thinks they've won
By:
dustybin
When: 27 Apr 16 17:14
no it doesnt james, but what it absolutely do here with the case of Heysel is that the conduct of pre hillsborough fans, and in this case liverpool fans having been in the mindset of those responsible for policing them, so ergo, yes the club's fans have a deferred responsibility for their previous actions.

I didnt want to bring Heysel back into it tbh, but there you go.

My own feeling has always been the same....

That on the day there were absolute innocents that died, who did nothing wrong on the day, and there must have been some who died who having probably done nothing on the day had a culture of wrong doing previously and were caught up as a result of their actions in the minds of those controlling them. I rather suspect some also died who were chancing their arm on the day too.
By:
jamesdean
When: 27 Apr 16 17:21
Elise sums it up. Of course the police didn't want for any of it to happen and it was catastrophic but they deserve to face
jail time for their actions afterwards. Surely that can't be up for question


Never forgiven that spoon bending twunt geller yet dusty but that's not for this thread Mischief
By:
lmfao
When: 27 Apr 16 17:25
agreed dusty- point(s) well made:

this has been judged in todays light - those policing the crowds had a mindset very different from ours, coloured by routine terrace soccer violance and a Liverpool fanbase capable of over-running any policing

unlawful killing? - no
Never

a cover-up?
Yes
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 17:47
Stadium free-for-all that could have been a ticket for disaster
Tony Evans in Athens
Published at 12:00AM, May 25 2007

All over Athens in the early hours of yesterday morning, small groups of Liverpool fans were meeting up and commiserating with each other. There were a lot of hugs, rueful smiles and the same words exchanged again and again. “It’s all right. We only lost. Nobody died.”

Three hours after the game, Liverpool fans were much more ebullient than the AC Milan supporters. Scouse laughter was ringing around the bars of the Greek capital as thoughts turned to home and next season. Memories of Hillsborough, where defeats on the pitch were put into perspective in the most horrible manner, ensure that there will be few tears after Liverpool lose a mere match.

But yesterday morning there was little to laugh about. William Gaillard, Uefa’s mouthpiece, has laid the blame for the chaos outside the Olympic Stadium squarely on the shoulders of Liverpool fans. Uefa does not need the help of anyone to make a mess of an event, but the controversy throws up a number of questions for Liverpool supporters and, sadly, gives ammunition to those whose version of events in Sheffield on April 15, 1989 involves ticketless fans storming the gates.

Yes, some people wearing “Hillsborough Justice Campaign” badges probably rushed police lines yesterday in the quest to get into the ground. On the face of it, that would appear to be a crass conflict of ideologies. However, there are few parallels between Wednesday in Athens and that dreadful Saturday in Yorkshire.

In 1989, there were plenty of tickets available for the FA Cup semi-final against Nottingham Forest. Lord Justice Taylor’s report into the tragedy found that the design of the terracing was fatally flawed and that South Yorkshire police made a series of mistakes that led to the 96 deaths.

Liverpool fans were not to blame for the disaster and those who, like me, stepped over dead bodies that day resent any suggestion that we were the guilty parties. Sadly, few people remember the Taylor Report. They do recall the stories of drunken, ticketless fans that dominated the media in the aftermath of the disaster, however. The stories were untrue, but people still believe the ludicrous lies that had us stealing from our own dead.

Athens was very different. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the ticket allocation – and few could argue that 17,000 was enough to satisfy Liverpool fans’ demand – there were people at the stadium who were determined to get into the match by whatever means necessary.

In recent years, there have been a number of incidents – mostly unreported – where Liverpool supporters have charged turnstiles in massive numbers, setting up dangerous situations.

At Stamford Bridge in the Champions League semi-final two years ago, a very dangerous crush ensued when Scousers broke through the gates. Away to PSV Eindhoven in the quarter-final this season, there were frightening moments outside the ground and the behaviour of ticketless fans provoked some harsh exchanges on the internet forums.

It is a problem that will not go away. “Bunking-in” is not just the last resort of the desperate fan; there are a substantial minority among Liverpool’s travelling support who see getting into a game without paying as a badge of honour. A number of books written about the experiences of Liverpool fans in the 1970s and 1980s have mythologised bunking-in and the younger generation, seeking to emulate their elders, have little compunction about sneaking into a ground and occupying someone else’s seat.

Mostly, they are young Scousers – and those with out-of-town accents and tickets who try to get their seats back can find themselves in unpleasant confrontations.

As the game moves upmarket and seeks to keep its traditional constituency outside the stadium while the corporate fans feast like kings inside, bunking-in will become a bigger problem.

Some Liverpool supporters even see it as a guerrilla act, the ultimate revenge of the disenfranchised fan. Priced out of the game? That’s OK, it’s free to the bunkers and they have the added satisfaction of making sure that they are not putting any money in the filthy-rich coffers of football’s billionaires. It is a class war statement for some.

But what they forget is that such behaviour gives the police licence to crack heads – and invariably, like on Wednesday night, it’s not the Scallies and bunkers who suffer. Having seen their lines swamped earlier in the day, the police were taking no chances with a second humiliation and took out their frustration on people with tickets.

That horde swarming over the gates are the flip side of the fanaticism we saw at Anfield against Barcelona and Chelsea. The bunkers want to get into the ground and all the police in Athens could not stop them. It might take a disaster to do that.

If it does, then it will be a very different tragedy to Hillsborough. Because then we – the men and boys whose desperation to get into the game makes us take wild risks – will have to shoulder the blame. And that’s too high a price to pay to see a football match.
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 17:47
Stadium free-for-all that could have been a ticket for disaster
Tony Evans in Athens
Published at 12:00AM, May 25 2007

All over Athens in the early hours of yesterday morning, small groups of Liverpool fans were meeting up and commiserating with each other. There were a lot of hugs, rueful smiles and the same words exchanged again and again. “It’s all right. We only lost. Nobody died.”

Three hours after the game, Liverpool fans were much more ebullient than the AC Milan supporters. Scouse laughter was ringing around the bars of the Greek capital as thoughts turned to home and next season. Memories of Hillsborough, where defeats on the pitch were put into perspective in the most horrible manner, ensure that there will be few tears after Liverpool lose a mere match.

But yesterday morning there was little to laugh about. William Gaillard, Uefa’s mouthpiece, has laid the blame for the chaos outside the Olympic Stadium squarely on the shoulders of Liverpool fans. Uefa does not need the help of anyone to make a mess of an event, but the controversy throws up a number of questions for Liverpool supporters and, sadly, gives ammunition to those whose version of events in Sheffield on April 15, 1989 involves ticketless fans storming the gates.

Yes, some people wearing “Hillsborough Justice Campaign” badges probably rushed police lines yesterday in the quest to get into the ground. On the face of it, that would appear to be a crass conflict of ideologies. However, there are few parallels between Wednesday in Athens and that dreadful Saturday in Yorkshire.

In 1989, there were plenty of tickets available for the FA Cup semi-final against Nottingham Forest. Lord Justice Taylor’s report into the tragedy found that the design of the terracing was fatally flawed and that South Yorkshire police made a series of mistakes that led to the 96 deaths.

Liverpool fans were not to blame for the disaster and those who, like me, stepped over dead bodies that day resent any suggestion that we were the guilty parties. Sadly, few people remember the Taylor Report. They do recall the stories of drunken, ticketless fans that dominated the media in the aftermath of the disaster, however. The stories were untrue, but people still believe the ludicrous lies that had us stealing from our own dead.

Athens was very different. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the ticket allocation – and few could argue that 17,000 was enough to satisfy Liverpool fans’ demand – there were people at the stadium who were determined to get into the match by whatever means necessary.

In recent years, there have been a number of incidents – mostly unreported – where Liverpool supporters have charged turnstiles in massive numbers, setting up dangerous situations.

At Stamford Bridge in the Champions League semi-final two years ago, a very dangerous crush ensued when Scousers broke through the gates. Away to PSV Eindhoven in the quarter-final this season, there were frightening moments outside the ground and the behaviour of ticketless fans provoked some harsh exchanges on the internet forums.

It is a problem that will not go away. “Bunking-in” is not just the last resort of the desperate fan; there are a substantial minority among Liverpool’s travelling support who see getting into a game without paying as a badge of honour. A number of books written about the experiences of Liverpool fans in the 1970s and 1980s have mythologised bunking-in and the younger generation, seeking to emulate their elders, have little compunction about sneaking into a ground and occupying someone else’s seat.

Mostly, they are young Scousers – and those with out-of-town accents and tickets who try to get their seats back can find themselves in unpleasant confrontations.

As the game moves upmarket and seeks to keep its traditional constituency outside the stadium while the corporate fans feast like kings inside, bunking-in will become a bigger problem.

Some Liverpool supporters even see it as a guerrilla act, the ultimate revenge of the disenfranchised fan. Priced out of the game? That’s OK, it’s free to the bunkers and they have the added satisfaction of making sure that they are not putting any money in the filthy-rich coffers of football’s billionaires. It is a class war statement for some.

But what they forget is that such behaviour gives the police licence to crack heads – and invariably, like on Wednesday night, it’s not the Scallies and bunkers who suffer. Having seen their lines swamped earlier in the day, the police were taking no chances with a second humiliation and took out their frustration on people with tickets.

That horde swarming over the gates are the flip side of the fanaticism we saw at Anfield against Barcelona and Chelsea. The bunkers want to get into the ground and all the police in Athens could not stop them. It might take a disaster to do that.

If it does, then it will be a very different tragedy to Hillsborough. Because then we – the men and boys whose desperation to get into the game makes us take wild risks – will have to shoulder the blame. And that’s too high a price to pay to see a football match.
By:
Wesdag
When: 27 Apr 16 17:49
apologies for the double post
By:
alun2005
When: 27 Apr 16 18:38
I now look forward to the thousands of victims of the Muslim Paedophile Gangs of Rotherham, South Yorkshire also getting justice, after the catastrophic non-investigations by South Yorkshire Police into the affair.
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 18:43
dustybin  • April 27, 2016 4:38 PM BST 


I dont think people who both offered sympathy for the loss and agree that lies were told and that errors were made, while still believing that its far too artificial to believe the conduct of fans meant they were nothing more than perfectly innocent parts....are in the minority tbh.


I believe you dusty
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 27 Apr 16 18:44
Would anybody have died if the fans weren't caged in like animals? The mistake in policing would have resulted in fans spilling on to the pitch. The true responsibility for what happened that day rests on the reason why it was felt necessary to put the fences up in the first place.

As for the aftermath nobody these days is surprised with coppers lying. It wasn't a widely held view in those days admittedly. I can certainly attest at a lower level how dishonest and political the police force was in those days and it cost a very good copper his job.
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 18:50
The reason fences were put up was because of the fans I am afraid....invading pitches and throwing things.

But it meant nobody could overflow onto the pitch which was needed here.

Regretfully in this world we often solve one problem only to create another.

Nobody foresaw this happening sadlySad
By:
scandanavian_haven
When: 27 Apr 16 18:53
Nobody foresaw this happening!

Ebul everything I've heard from fans who were in that end in years gone by said it was a death trap and an accident waiting to happen, eventually it did, Liverpool fans were just unlucky it was them, could have been any set of supporters.
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 19:07
Another reason for the fences is that fans were very violent then, they throw things at one another, they would attack one another.

They had to be fenced off from another.

Well all I can say scandanavian it is a pity nobody listened, it could well have been an accident waiting to happen.

Life is easy in hindsight...it does seem a pity that this was not for seen at the time. One can argue it should have been.
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 19:08
In fact it was an accident waiting to happen r.i.p.
By:
dustybin
When: 27 Apr 16 19:14
damn right
thats a good ground is that and it should still be having cup matches played there
By:
lmfao
When: 27 Apr 16 19:17
i'd have some respect for Liverpool as a city if today they also put banners up to mark the manslaughter of 14 by Liverpool supporters in the Heysel stadium and , as a city and a football club, chose this time to reflect and to apologise.Sad
By:
elise
When: 27 Apr 16 19:29
i thought they had a memorial at anfield for heysel, might be wrong maybe i've dreamed that up
By:
DancingDenman
When: 27 Apr 16 20:23
Lets also not forget after all the years n years of campaigning,protesting, lobbying against this great injustice this same clubs ticketless fans stormed the Athens 2007  champions league final. If i'm right where offically described by UEFA as Europes worst behaved fans.
It just does'nt add up to the neuterals.
By:
donny osmond
When: 27 Apr 16 20:33
the took the fences and cages away, and less trouble happened

misguided laws brought in by control freak forces
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 21:05
They also introduced seating.......
By:
donny osmond
When: 27 Apr 16 21:23
and the seating in the ground improved behaviour outside the grounds ?

or was it just the fans staying out of the cages as long as possible ?
By:
ebulGery
When: 27 Apr 16 22:13
From to 1960s into the 1990's here was a major problem with football hooliganism, and supporters

had to be fenced off from each other.

The football hooliganism came first not the fences!

It was for worse in our country than any other country.

The fences were at Hillsborough were because of football hooliganism.

Tragically no one thought what would happen if these became overcrowded.

Football hooliganism is under control now. The easiest way was to have every sitting down

so there is no longer a need for the fences.
By:
donny osmond
When: 27 Apr 16 22:17
wonder why they didnt think of this simple solution sooner ?
By:
scandanavian_haven
When: 27 Apr 16 22:29
Tragically no one thought what would happen if these became overcrowded.




Pretty strange you're trolling this kind of topic ebul, you said this earlier and then backtracked and now saying again, and I told you earlier, thousands of fans who had been in that end in many previous games for years prior said it was a deathtrap!

You only have to see this video and read the comments to know it was coming

.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtzHVe2mEN0

*read the part @ 1:35

and .https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66ZeFtviJiM
By:
TheBetterBettor
When: 28 Apr 16 14:01
Mentioning that 'ticketless fans were not to blame' will always have questions to be answered no matter how many times the bishop of LIVERPOOL on the so called independent panel said so

Saying that ticketless fans were not too blame, to me was admission that there where ticketless fans present on that day 10 mins prior to kick off.

So...if so, how many?
10, 100s, 1000s? and how would that be factored in on the crush that was beginning to start outside the gates?....would the disaster still of happened if that element of the crowd were not present on that day?


Even if the gates weren't opened would the SY police still be facing the Unlawful Killing rap 27 years on?
With this jury and in this climate probably yes.
By:
jamesdean
When: 28 Apr 16 14:01
To get attention, trolls have to try and be controversial s_h. That vermin Katie Hopkins is prime example, ebul is no different (imo)
By:
dustybin
When: 28 Apr 16 14:15
It has all the makings of going from one extreme of miscarriage right over to the other extreme.
I believe had those in charge not fabricated the established truths simply to save themselves then we would have reached the proper verdict in the first place.
Two wrongs dont make a right.
Page 4 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com