We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
Chit Chat
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Umpire said not out
Sri Lankans reviewed
Pad first
Hitting middle stump
Not out
Sri Lankans reviewed
Pad first
Hitting middle stump
Not out
Show More
Yes it has to pitch in line with the stumps to get an l.b.w. decision. It could have knocked middle stump halfway up and it is not out if it hasn't pitched in line.
Cheers spelling', bit of a wasted review. Pitched a foot outside off. Surely that was obvious to the bowler!
Unless no shot is played then you can be given out l.b.w. regardless of where it has pitched.
It can pitch outside off and still be out so long as it hits in line
Well he played a Boycott forward defensive. I s that a shot?
After the decision they flashed up on screen
Original Decision not out
Impact Umpire's call
Pitching Outside off
Original Decision not out
Impact Umpire's call
Pitching Outside off
I wasn't watching kenny but any attempt to play the ball even with the bat hidden behind the pad would be deemed to be a shot played so no l.b.w. I was a cricket umpire when I wasn't playing and would very rarely give leg before unless it was absolutely plum.
Joel
Joel
15 Jun 14 15:35
Joined:
14 Feb 04
| Topic/replies: 21,359 | Blogger: Joel's blog
It can pitch outside off and still be out so long as it hits in line
Sorry, but if it pitches outside off how can it hit in line?
Joel
15 Jun 14 15:35
Joined:
14 Feb 04
| Topic/replies: 21,359 | Blogger: Joel's blog
It can pitch outside off and still be out so long as it hits in line
Sorry, but if it pitches outside off how can it hit in line?
Ah, I've just wound back.
Gower says half the ball or more than half the ball has to be in line
That explains it.
Gower says half the ball or more than half the ball has to be in line
That explains it.
If it pitches outside off stump and a shot is played that is not out even if the delivery would have knocked middle stump flying.
Yes bob, Joel was right but Gower gave a fuller explanation.
yeh but its out if hes not offering a shot.
i just mean that when kenny said "if it pitches outside how can it hit in line" in reply to joel, i think joel meant pitch outside then be go on to hit the stumps, ie in line to hit the stumps.
i just mean that when kenny said "if it pitches outside how can it hit in line" in reply to joel, i think joel meant pitch outside then be go on to hit the stumps, ie in line to hit the stumps.
I'm getting confused now.Gower, Athers and Warney are discussing this and Gower says much depends on the original decision. ie if he'd been given out the decision would remain out!
if england reach close they cant really lose. shirley they can manage that cant they? cant they? or can they? 
well they can lose. if they reach close 300 ahead and 8 or 9 wickets down.
but 330 ahead and 6 or 7 wickets down they shouldnt lose from there.
but 330 ahead and 6 or 7 wickets down they shouldnt lose from there.
They could lead by 300 with Sri Lanka over a day to get the runs, and 400 has been chased down on this pitch this season.
Draw looks a good lay at 1.8 to me, assuming weather set fair
1 wicket in 5 balls
Batsman gloved it and walked
Hand was off the bat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Review would have been not out
Batsman gloved it and walked
Hand was off the bat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Review would have been not out
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539