Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 59 comments are related to the topic:
Top 100 non-tragic tragedies

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 59
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:03
ice, snow, travel disruption etc
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:04
you are cheapening the actual meaning of the words you are using.
It's simple, don't say something is a tragedy when it isn't.
Sparrow dies ,its tragic, Dad dies ,its tragic.
Dad dying is as tragic as a sparrow dying.
Nonsense.
Therefore don't use the word tragic, imo.
Melodramatic hogwash.
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:05
its either severe or it isn't. bit severe is bowlocks ,imo
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:07
wtf so you can't use a common word because it has to be reserved for family members?

pmsl

so someone like baby p didn't die tragically then?
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:08
trag·ic (trjk)
adj.
1. Relating to or characteristic of dramatic tragedy or tragedies: tragic plays; the tragic hero.
2. Writing or performing in tragedy: a tragic poet.
3. Having the elements of tragedy; involving death, grief, or destruction: a tragic accident.


nowhere does it say it must only be used when talking about mum or dad dying etc
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:12
My use of the sparrow /dad comparison in talking about a tragedy is to illustrate the disparity in 2 events that some people could call tragic ( animal lovers) that obviously are not on the same level.
Much like you, a stranger to a celeb, calling her death a tragedy.
You don't analogies I've noticed in that past.
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:13
don't get *
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:15
yes a 32 year old girl with great talent dying is a tragedy

why should i not be able to recognise that on a human level?
By:
Hoss
When: 22 Dec 09 12:16
Did the Greeks realise what they were starting with their plays? and come to that Was Willie Shakespeare really think his ''tragedies'' were tragic ?
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:17
the problem with your attempt at an analogy is that it made no sense

never in my entire life have i heard anyone call the death of a sparrow tragic

animal lover or otherwise

you've basically just made that up
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:17
You can cb, grieve away.
To me she is the sparrow or something in between sparrow/dad
I don't agree its a tragedy is all.
No biggie.
By:
Hoss
When: 22 Dec 09 12:17
Not was but DID ^
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:19
Yes I made the analogy up! To emphasise what irrelevences people will call tragic! Anyway, lets just agree to disagree as usual, ofah is on ,didn't realise.
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:20
i'm not grieving at all

i've already stated i felt no sadness

but as a human being i can recognise it as tragic
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:21
but how can you emphasise what people call tragic when they don't?

lol
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:22
well i need to get some kip anyway

enjoy
By:
Gene Hackman
When: 22 Dec 09 12:22
CB
I think you using the phrase "great talent" about an actress that most of us had never heard of,and who has,by all accounts,a very limited career in that profession,belies your attitude to "celebrities" and their lives.
You seem in thrall to such persons.I suspect that you are under 30 and have grown up with this celebrity dominated culture.You are a modern victim of a very modern phenomenen.
By:
Brodie
When: 22 Dec 09 12:22
lolling on a tragic day like this. poor form
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:26
i don't thrall in them at all

and i'm over 30

also, her imdb page doesn't exactly suggest a limited career
By:
canaryboy
When: 22 Dec 09 12:28
nor do i watch reality tv

in fact i find it pointless

which would be a bit odd for someone who loves celeb culture
Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com