Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 161 comments are related to the topic:
Melon - Supreme Novices Hurdle

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 161
By:
dyno-layer
When: 28 Feb 17 07:03
If HF decides to run Neon Wolf here instead of the neptune then this market is going to be tipped on its head.
By:
impossible123
When: 28 Feb 17 09:17
Ben Linfoot: "I've gone on record as saying I couldn't have Melon for the Supreme Hurdle at the prices, but if there was one horse I like to back at the Festival today on the back of trainer vibes, it is the one named after a large fruit."

The above - a 180 degree turn - has come about after he's be mesmerised by the head honcho at Closutton stable post a visit there; this is the same racing professional who not so long ago tipped Cilaos Emery for the same race (I believe); Cilaos Emery has since bombed out badly in his next race.

Melon has not been seen since his only run and win against very mediocre horses - the 2nd in that race has again been comprehensively beaten in his next race since by horses that were well beaten previously.

I think whichever race Neon Wolf runs in at Cheltenham he'll be fav; Finian's Oscar, if running here, would be vying for favouritism too.
By:
Jb23
When: 28 Feb 17 09:29
Melon has not been seen since his only run and win against very mediocre horses - the 2nd in that race has again been comprehensively beaten in his next race since by horses that were well beaten previously.

He could have won by 2 flights of hurdles should he have wished. Personally I think if your taking a 10 length demolition, with his head in his chest on the snaff as literal form, then its going to be a long couple of weeks for you. It wasn't what he beat, it was the way he beat them.

For what its worth- Gordon Elliott came out and said he wouldn't trust Broken Soul as far as he could throw him. This is the same horse which was half a length behind Anibale Fly and 2 behind Gurteen.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 28 Feb 17 12:11
Yeah you're probably right impossible. Probably best to completely ignore what the most successful trainer of all time thinks about anything, and stick with your literal interpretation of the form book.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 28 Feb 17 12:12
And the fact he works with all of the WPM novices every week, probably doesnt tell anyone anything. That one race really is the key here.
By:
HaylingBilly
When: 28 Feb 17 12:39
Based on history - especially where Cheltenham is concerned - anyone who places, or changes, a bet based on a Willie Mullins stable visit quote requires psychiatric help. He's playing with your mind !!! Trust me.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 28 Feb 17 13:12
Haha... I don't base it all on what he says. But looking at each horse and trying to weigh it up myself.
By:
HaylingBilly
When: 28 Feb 17 13:58
I have gone with 3 in the race. Always bet three in Supreme to try and get me off to a flying start. Not always a roaring successful strategy but great when it comes off :

Bunk Off Early @ 14/1
Movewiththetimes @ 33/1
River Wylde @ 25/1

If I added one I think it would be Henderson's Beyond Conceit who I fancy will relish the tough battling uphill finish. Dare I go for four !!! ConfusedConfused
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 28 Feb 17 14:29
Great price on Movewiththetimes.
By:
sageform
When: 28 Feb 17 15:19
Beyond Conceit much more likely to run in the Neptune but might be worth a nrnb.
By:
p_r_e_m_i_e_r__f_a_n_t_a_s_y
When: 28 Feb 17 15:21
That just your opinion sageform or have they said that? He was too keen the last day and still won and I'd worry he would be way too keen in the Neptune, the Supreme I thought would be the perfect race for him as he should settle much better off the faster gallop
By:
HaylingBilly
When: 28 Feb 17 15:47
I think the going will determine final destination for Beyond Conceit. From Henderson "He goes in soft ground and if it came up soft then we can go two miles and if it isn’t then he can go two miles and five. I am going to sit down and have a serious look at the entries at the five-day stage. When you can pick between the two then you may as well have a look at the opposition in both".
By:
macrocky
When: 28 Feb 17 17:08
If you beat Willie mullins you will back the winner. The guy is rewriting the history books. If he says that about MELON and he gets melon to the track in same shape as he was when those quotes were taken you would prefer to be with mullins than against mullins
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 13:22
Been given a rating of 153 after that one run Laugh

Would love to hear Phil Smith justify that one!
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Mar 17 14:11
I thought he did quite well justifying it, as it wasn't a rating, it's an assessment as he isn't qualified for a mark as only ran once and that could easily be wrong which he also said.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 14:26
Sorry yes I know its a guideline rating, but its still bonkers. How on earth could anyone justify it? Broken Soul 140? Only on the moon.

What did he say to justify it STS?
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 14:29
Ballyandy... who has some decent form in the book, and has just won the Betfair Hurdle has a rating of 147 btw.

Could anyone imagine Melon being asked to give him 6lb's if they ran in a Handicap tomorrow after winning one poor maiden in Ireland?
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Mar 17 14:43
It's an assessment. Nothing more. He will be properly assessed after running the min' required times for a proper handicap mark. If thats a lot less than the 153, a lot more or the same then that will be made after the min' number of runs to qualify for a mark.

So basically he's given him a mark to enable him to run in the Supreme based on opinion and he obviously believes Broken Soul's mark be a genuine one. Your entitled to your opinion of course. Out of interest, what mark would you give BS? Who's rating is actually 130

I'd like to add, i don't normally look at form or ratings. It's just one's opinion against another's. 99% of my betting is based around the markets. It works to allow others do all the hard work and try to pinch prices from those bookmakers whom are too slow to cut. Mischief
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Mar 17 14:46
I actually think there could be a small but valuable handicap in BS after looking quickly at his form. 4/11 for a race after Melon defeat was a laughable price, wish i new about it cos i'd of laid till cows come hom i think. Think the bookies were taking the pish there a little and he probably was a shade unlucky last time to be brought down by sound of his post race analysis.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 14:51
STS. I know how assessments work mate. But it means if he was giving him a mark now, that's what it would be.

I think Broken Soul's 130 looks perfectly fair.
By:
arrested development
When: 09 Mar 17 14:55
Broken Soul's highest ever RPR over hurdles was 126 15 months ago on his hurdling debut.

No one is saying that Melon might be a 153 horse or better in time but rationale is bonkers
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 14:56
Exactly ad. Simply from the vibes in the yard alone, you'd fancy Melon will get to be a 153 horse easily.

But its not up to Phil Smith to start factoring in hype. His 'assessment' is ridiculous to me.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 09 Mar 17 15:03
153 youre twisting my melon man?
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 15:29
What do you reckon he should give him?
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 15:34
Well considering Ballyandy has just won the Betfair Hurdle and has been given a mark of 147, I don't think anyone could justify giving him as high.

Id have thought 140... maybe early 140's if you are feeling generous.
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 15:41
I'd fancy him getting 6lbs from ballyandyGrin giving Melon 153 on pretty much hype alone is a bit much I agree, not far behind it is lumping up Ballyandy nigh on a stone for winning the worst betfair in living memory from a horse that didn't much want to go past.

If Ballyandy is being put into the "form horse" category then Melon's hype hasn't got to be too far adrift to be right in the mix IMO, I think Ballyandy is awful at 5/1 IMO.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 15:52
Im a Melon backer. I think he could be special. I just think its wrong that the handicapper starts using hype to give assessments or ratings.

Im not a Ballyandy fan either, but he does have form in the book.

I havent seen the full list, just sure a tweet about it. But was he given Bunk Off Early? If Melon has 153, then BOE must be given something in the mid 160's imo.
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 15:58
I don't think Ballyandy's form is particularly good, beaten twice by MR, the second time comfortably enough, MDO beat him where he just looked slow, and as I say, the Betfair was a poor renewal IMO, I think Ballyandy is going to be just too slow, at the crucial point coming down the hill he'll get outpaced IMO, he'll probably stay on well enough but won't win...I'm trusting WillieGrin, not blindly, but what we've got to remember is that in this Supreme the bar is not very high!! and Mullins in his assessment is understanding that.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 16:09
duffy. I absolutely agree with all of that.

But thats not really the point Im making. We are talking about rating a horse that has won one p1ss poor Irish maiden hurdle higher than him! The horse he beat has run awfully since and the third home is rated 70!
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 16:17
Just seen he's 5lb clear of the rest of the field on ratings Laugh
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 16:23
I agree with that too.....perhaps Smith thinks their campaigning of him has been one big ruse, and they are really targeting the summer hurdle at Market Rasen in the summer....I 'll put a fooking stop to their gamesWink
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 16:28
Haha. Lets hope Smith is bang on anyway, and he is 5lb clear of the field!

Will be a nice start to my week if he is 5l clear at the line.
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 16:33
Cool
By:
firstimevisor
When: 09 Mar 17 16:35
Totally agree CCM, absolutely ridiculous rating on based on god knows what. He may well prove to be up to the mark but how he can rate him that high on that one run is a joke
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Mar 17 16:39
Can't Catch Me 09 Mar 17 16:28 Joined: 02 Apr 03 | Topic/replies: 24,714 | Blogger: Can't Catch Me's blog

Haha. Lets hope Smith is bang on anyway, and he is 5lb clear of the field!

Will be a nice start to my week if he is 5l clear at the line.





Being sat on a 12/1 voucher myself, and plenty of trades between 15 - 12 and then finally 8.4 on here so do i Cool
By:
SEATHESTARS....NO1
When: 09 Mar 17 16:41
But i still think people are getting carried away, it's not a rating, its a guess. He basically said as much on ask the handicapper.

Smiths words were to the effect of "he may well turn out to be that good, he maybe better, i may be way off"

Personally think he was wrong to publicise what rating he thought Melon would get. This thread would be a page light for certain Mischief
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 16:44
I'd be interested to see his workings. He's 2lbs lower than Vautour wasLaugh
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 09 Mar 17 16:48
Bet a few poor Melon backers will log on tonight and see 40 odd new posts on this thread and be scared to open it for fear of bad news!
By:
buddeliea
When: 09 Mar 17 17:54
I think Ballyandy is going to be just too slow, at the crucial point coming down the hill he'll get outpaced IMO, he'll probably stay on well enough but won't win

duffy

you just described Al Ferof!! apart from the wont win bit.
And he had to get past Cue Card,Spirit Son and Sprinter Sacre.

A horse can get outpaced in a Supreme and still win.
And judging by some of the recent winners it can certainly help to stay pretty well........Al Ferof, Menorah , Champagne Fever, Vautour .
By:
duffy
When: 09 Mar 17 18:05
I've probably described countless others that haven't won too, there's always exceptions, they don't make it the norm though, however if the pace is a cut throat won where the ones in front are relatively out on their feet, he might win, I don't like him though and don't think his form looks good .
Page 4 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com