Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 100 comments are related to the topic:
Mullins and the Gold Cup

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 100
By:
wellchief
When: 30 Mar 16 22:13
Got to go with Duffy on this one sorry impossible.

By your logic it sounds like every horse that doesn't win doesn't stay.

Did Djakadam fail to stay the Gold Cup trip? The Don powered away up the hill away from Djakadam much more than Blaklion did over Shaneshill, so that means Djakadam didn't stay, when we all know he does?
By:
timtin
When: 30 Mar 16 22:36
@Arkle, I'd rather have Yanworth all day in a re-match against Yorkhill, the way I saw it Ruby gave him the best possible ride while in a very rare occasion Barry gave his horse an extra mile to travel by going the widest route for no reason. Yanworth was closing him down and with a cleaner jump 3rd last that might've been the difference. Yanworth is all class, Yorkhill looks a stayer but over 2 and half and shorter Yanworth will take all the beating even from the this quality crop of novices - except Altior who is a monster in the making.
By:
impossible123
When: 30 Mar 16 23:12
Despite Djakadam finishing runner-up two years running in the CGC he definitely stays the trip - it was evident last year in the soft - but not only does DC stay the CGC distance DC is also a better horse. However, with regards to Shaneshill, he was beaten over 21f in the Navan by NMH having cruised up to take the lead after the last, looked the likely winner 2 out in the Daily Mirror (24f) won by Killultagh Vic, and led after the last in this year's RSA (24) but again headed before the line.

I can accept to not win after taking the lead at the last in the Navan (21f) was inconclusive, going well but tanking with 2f to run in the Daily Mirror (24f) was revealing, and leading but not winning against Blaklion - inferior hurdle form and rating - after the last in the RSA (24f again) to me was evidently clear Shaneshill does not stay 24f in a truly run race.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 30 Mar 16 23:19
At Cheltenham I'm sure the horse just runs out of fuel enough to make him vulnerable to a superior stayer. I'll be interested to see how he gets on if he goes 3 miles at Aintree.
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 04:13
timtin

Have to disagree, Yorkhill wasn't doing a tap on the run to the line and won with loads in hand, he also has stacks of pace IMO, personally I'd back him before Altior over 2 miles. I know we haven't seen him over 2 miles against the best novices but as good as Altior looked, I got an even better impression from Yorkhill's performance and have a hunch he's just a better horse and reckon he'd find the 2 miles no problem.
By:
impossible123
When: 31 Mar 16 09:42
duffy

Sorry to butt in, but I'd back Altior against Yorkhill over 2 miles on good going in a truly run race anywhere any day because the former has done it impressively thrashing Min, Beveur D'air and company in the Supreme and Open Eagle in the William Hill but the latter's win over 007 in the Tolworth did not overly impress me; the BHA has given a rating of 155 to Altior and 151 to Yorkhill.
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Mar 16 09:50
I've been dying to take 5's on Shaneshill at Aintree, but have resisted. Good ground and a flat, speed based 3m will be perfect for him, but Aintree antepost is probably a quicker way to the poorhouse than Cheltenham antepost!  Same with L'ami Serge too, really want to take the 4's but don't know if he's running.

Next year, I do think Shaneshill would struggle with the extra 2f in a Gold Cup, so I don't know what they'd do. They have huge talent in the Ryanair now, so I'd keep Shane for Aintree and Punchestown if he were mine.

On the other debate, I'd take Yorkhill over Yanworth every day of the week on good ground, and I'd take Yanworth on soft.

Yorkhill over 2m vs Altior? I'd have no idea, but possibly side with Altior. Both are strong stayers but once Altior gets his head in front I get the impression he'd be bloody tough to get past; proper battler with class to spare - I massivley underrated him before the Supreme.
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Mar 16 10:03
Sorry Cyclops, this thread has gone very off topic from Mullins and the Gold Cup!
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 13:19
Wouldn't say that, Yorkhill could be a GC winner in a couple of years timeGrin
By:
cyclops
When: 31 Mar 16 13:30
I was wondering, wellchief, but these things happen!
I was interested in people's response to the question posed but, other than firstimevisor's views, things have veered away.
Maybe it's not of interest but to me it's fascinating that he's now so dominant yet three of the big four prizes at Cheltenham elude him, particularly the Gold Cup.
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Mar 16 14:36
With Mullins and the Gold Cup it's a tough one. We've recently had a golden era of staying chasers like Kauto, Denman, Imperial Commander, Long Run etc and Mullins had nothing in his yard to trouble them.

In recent years he has only really had Djakadam and Vautour imo that were/could be genuine contenders.

He did manage to get On His Own to a shorthead, which was some acheivement and they may regret not appealing the result afterwards.

Because he wins some "soft" grade 1's in Ireland, people expect those horses to take on the best of them English in recent years, when they were never good enough in the first place.

Not having a go at Irish racing, but he won Grade 1's over 3m with Quel Esprit and Kempes, and they were never Gold Cup class.

I think he will win it sooner or later, as he will the QMCC. For years he was a bumper and hurdler specialist with very few festival Chase winners. However recently with Cooldine, Sir Des Champs, Don Poli, Vautour,  Douvan, UDS etc, his chase record is improving fast.
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Mar 16 14:48
Also, should say that for all the years that Ruby had the pick of Mullins and Nicholls horses, I can't ever remember him picking a Mullins one once (although I may be wrong).

Just shows that it is really only in the last year or two that he has had the ammunition to have a proper go at it.
By:
impossible123
When: 31 Mar 16 15:31
Killultagh Vic, Yorkhill, Nichols Canyon and Artic Fire to name four would be my future prospective candidates for the GC if WPM needs help in this department, and they all are serious contenders I'd think.
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 15:48
hows cyrus darius doing these days, back next year is he?
By:
trigger3
When: 31 Mar 16 17:42
Its true to say that Mullins has only really concentrated on producing chasers in recent years and most of his best novice hurdlers are now being sent down the chasing route and therefore you would think that he is bound to win a GC (and a CC for that matter) sooner rather than later. That said, he could have a lot of very good chasers in any given season but if he doesn't have the best one (which he obviously didn't this season) then the wait will go on. Next season he could feasibly have 5 or 6 darts to throw at the gold cup with not one definite candidate but with all of the following potential candidates:

Vautour: Either drops back down CC or goes GC (him and Douvan interchangeable)
Douvan: See above
Don Poli: Most likely of the Mullins to definitely line up in the GC at this stage unless he concentrates on national success which seems unlikely at this stage
Djakadam: Two good rums in the last 2 gold cups but is he good enough to win it? Still think he will go for gold again for one last time if he shapes up well in advance.
Valseur Lido: Very likely to go for gold cup, not sure he is good enough to win a GC but may have place claims
Black Hercules: Goes either Ryanair or GC, at a guess I'd say GC if Mullins has an outstanding candidtae for the Ryanair
Killultagh Vic: I imagine this will be Mullins outstanding candidate for the Ryanair which will free up Vautour and Douvan to split races and take a CC and GC bid between them.
Outlander: Ryanair most likely
Shaneshill: Ryanair most likely, with KV giving Mullins a strong hand in the race

So at this stage I'd guess:
Gold Cup: Vautour, Don Poli, Djakadam, Valseur Lido, Black Hercules
Ryanair: Killultagh Vic, Shaneshill, Outlander
CC: UDS, Douvan
By:
cyclops
When: 31 Mar 16 17:44
Nichols Canyon?
When was the last Gold Cup winner a former flat racer?
Alverton in the eighties? (May have forgotten one).
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 18:57
I don't get the theory of vautour going for the GC, in my eyes he's got less chance than this year. At the end of the day they decided he wouldn't stay the trip, they didn't decide he would stay but wouldn't beat Djak because if they thought he'd stay they'd have to think he'd win.

Deciding to run in it just because they now know Djak isn't good enough wouldn't be a valid reason to run and they'll still think he won't stay.

I think that Douvan will be sent in search of the GC and vautour the CC.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 31 Mar 16 20:12
Depends if you think they are a bunch of liars or straight dealers? If you think they're pretty honest they said they rerouted Vautour because his work was poor in the run up and that the horse was only at around 90% of what they wanted to see. So according to them they went for the easier option. Presumably if the horse sparkles next year and is 100% they will go for the race they desperately wanted to all along. Wink
By:
firstimevisor
When: 31 Mar 16 20:23
I cannot understand why so many assume Djakadam somehow isn't up to winning a Gold Cup. He's been second in two above average GCs yet is still only a 7 yo. I thought he ran an absolute cracker again this year after the fall before that. He is 2 years younger than Don Cossack and Coneygree and these are the 3 horses which, right now ,are the benchmarks for next years race. If I had to pick one of these 3 today it would be Djakadam.

Thistlecrack will surely go the novice route and I'd safely say Vautour will go Ryanair again.Don Poli will have another crack. Killultagh Vic would be the only one of this year's novices that I'd rate as a contender, at this stage.There's every chance Douvan is going to become a serious contender. If not then I don't think next year's Gold Cup will be any better than the previous two runnings and I would think anything that can beat Djakadam will win it.
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 20:30
Thistlecrack will be 9 next year, if he takes to fences he'll be running in the GC next year, coneygree will have paved the way for novices and thistlecrack has time against him.
By:
GAZO
When: 31 Mar 16 20:33
agree about thistlecrack,its gold cup or world hurdle
By:
firstimevisor
When: 31 Mar 16 20:37
Thistlecrack is one hell of a horse for sure but he'll have to jump fences like a pro to win the GC as a novice. They don't all jump like Coneygree.
By:
duffy
When: 31 Mar 16 20:39
Agreed, and if he doesn't I think they'll abandon the chase route and revert back to hurdles.
By:
GAZO
When: 31 Mar 16 21:02
wont take much for him to go back to hurdles,thats if he even goes over jumps
By:
trigger3
When: 31 Mar 16 21:06
I think Djakadam is an excellent benchmark for Mullins to use in assessing his gold cup horses. He would have been good enough to win some previous gold cups but it would be ludicrous to drop him to the Ryanair as some have suggested simply because he hasn't won the race in 2 attempts. Second in 2 very good gold cup races is no mean feat in itself and he deserves another shot next season where he may get the softer ground he needs. For now he remains Mullins best chance unless either one of Douvan or Vautour can prove they can see out a trip past what many would see as their optimum distance.
By:
impossible123
When: 31 Mar 16 22:11
Could anyone remember if WPM ever had a novice fencer only over 16f going for the KG and/or the GC the following season? If not, I doubt very much Douvan would be aimed at the GC but instead tasked with recovering the CC throne for WPM. Hence, my two most credible new candidates would be Killultagh Vic and Outlander, alongside Don Poli (Giggistown, and too young for the GN) plus possibly Djakadam, again playing 2nd fiddle to either Coneygree, Cue Card, Don Cossack or More Of That even if the ground is soft.

As for Thistlecrack if connections are serious about the GC they must put him over fences asap to give him the best chance possible.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 31 Mar 16 23:05
I was thinking that impossible. Must be tempting for the owners to mop up at Aintree and Punchestown over hurdles seeing as he hasn't hard anything like a hard race this season but I'd be very tempted to give him at least one and possibly two low key novice chase outings instead and then stick him away.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 31 Mar 16 23:08
firstimevisor

Djakadam is an admirable horse but how many horses have run twice finishing second both times or even placed and then gone on to win the race? As well as the returning victors there are usually strong new challengers every year. No reason why the horse can't be placed again but you'd have to think that camp Mullins must think their chance of winning with him has significantly receded.
By:
wellchief
When: 31 Mar 16 23:16
I think Djakadam will struggle to win a Gold Cup too, especially as he's had a chance on both soft and good now.

Whilst I don't think this year's novices will pose too much threat, add Thistlecrack, Vautour, Coneygree and Valseur Lido to Don Cossack and Cue Card, I can see at least one of them finishing in front of Jack.

In terms of the novices, I highly rate Black Hercules and Killultagh Vic, but I think they'll be Ryanair bound.

Either way, I think we had a golden age with Kauto, Denman, Imperial Commander etc, and after a few years of poor renewals, I think we're right in the middle of a golden age again.
By:
firstimevisor
When: 31 Mar 16 23:37
The vast majority of national hunt horses stay 3 miles. By their very nature they are stayers. 2 miles is not a sprint.Sprints are for speed horses at Royal Ascot in June. At the top of the food chain the best horses choose their own races while those of lesser ability avoid them as much as possible by going up or down in distance. There are plenty of races around to create many happy outcomes.It is not wise to put national hunt horses into a box as to having a specific distance. Faugheen began life as a point-to-pointer and 3m hurdler.He would be a group standard horse on the flat if they went down that road with him. Kauto Star, after winning a Gold Cup, went on to slaughter the best 2 milers around in the Tingle Creek the following year.Of course there are some that don't stay, but the vast majority do stay 3m. It gets trickier after 3 miles but ,again, I'd say most do.
The fact that Douvan has been kept to 2m thus far is of no significance...its a case of 6 of one, half a dozen of the other as to what distance he runs for this season.
By:
firstimevisor
When: 31 Mar 16 23:52
Eternal, The Fellow is one I can think of off hand. He was second as a 6yo, second as a 7yo, 4th to Jodami at 8 and won, beating Jodami, at 9. Desert Orchid ran in loads before he won as a veteran.
Next year Jack will still be a young horse by GC standards. Of course he can win it, there may be something to beat him, but he has a better chance of winning than any other.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 31 Mar 16 23:57
I can't agree with that firstimer. 2 milers given the right circumstances can eke out their stamina to longer distances but it depends on a variety of factors with class being the most important. A horse which is best at 2 miles which gets two and a half will often win a champion hurdle as has been shown in recent years. Put them in a low enough grade and most would also win at three. Doesn't mean they truly stay three miles. Just that they can lob along at a pace which is way below their ability level and thus appear to stay the distance. Until they do stay the jury is out in top class over 3 miles and especially over the gold cup distance. What Faugheen and Douvan would do over the distance in top class is conjecture.

Occasionally you do get a special one like Kauto but don't stick the rose coloured specs on about him. He wasn't up and down in distance like a yo yo and from memory didn't win a Tingle Creek after winning a Gold Cup. In that season I seem to remember him winning the two and a half miler at Aintree followed by a weak renewal of the Betfair before taking the Tingle Creek. After whch he went up in distance permanently.
By:
firstimevisor
When: 01 Apr 16 00:20
Yes your right about Kauto Star..he won the Tingle Creek before the GC, not after. I got the seasons wrong but my point remains the same. When he went up in distance, ie to 3m+,there was no need to drop him back in trip ever again. He was the best around over any trip but Gold Cups are the holy grail.
I cant think of too many champion hurdlers who didn't stay 3m. To compare horses with human athletes, would you think many 3000 meter runners wouldnt stay 5000m?
By:
timtin
When: 01 Apr 16 01:29
I'd give a hand if we can relocate to a parallel universe and Douvan wouldn't be owned by RR. The mention of him in the same breath of Faugheen is becoming obnoxious. As for top class racing over 3 miles I'd give my other hand to see Faugheen in the GC and see his versatility, if he truly has it or not at the top level of Chase stayers.. Unfortunately he's owned by a clueless banker and trained by a pragmatic man who listens to a jockey that wants to ride all the good horses in different races. These trio couldn't care less what racing needs in order to raise its profile. All they want is win another race so they can claim the Britain trainers title, which no one cares about outside of Mullins family. Hell of an operation.

Back to the topic, Mullins won't win GC, at least for couple of years, because he will keep Faugheen over hurdles. His background of a pointer indicates he'll relish the trip, of course he needs to be trained to relax early as in recent times he's been used of going hurdling pace so he'll need to settle down when tackling larger obstacles. Vautour did a far better job of what I anticipated in almost winning the KG and like we've seen Ruby doing with Kauto, he can win the GC with non-stayers in years when the strength in stayers depth is lacking but this is the era of Coneygree and Don Cossack who are not only out and out stayers but top class horses, so that won't work even with the best ride that Ruby can give..
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 01 Apr 16 01:55
firstimer

I cant think of too many champion hurdlers who didn't stay 3m.


At the highest level which is what we are talking about I can't think of too many certainly in recent times who even ran over 3 miles.

To compare horses with human athletes, would you think many 3000 meter runners wouldn't stay 5000m?

That's an interesting question. I was probably marginally more talented but gravitated towards boxing and paradoxically academia but my brother was a grafter and he was on his day an international class age group distance runner until the Africans took over. It's so difficult to compare between disciplines. Between species it becomes that much more difficult. 3000 metres isn't really an event as such and for illustrative purposes I'd say that 1500 to 5000 is so much more informative. Occasionally you'll get a Moorcroft who sets the 5000 world alight having been a very good 1500 man. Maybe he was your Kauto. Most of the rest a la Ovett make a decent fist of it but can't quite make the leap to top class at the longer distance. Given the speed needed to run 1500 well but stamina requirements for rounds in championship events someone like Mo Farah who specialises in 5000 and 10000 would probably have had a very good stab at a championship 1500 given his one off ability.

Even so even your great 800 metres men would often train over very long distances for their long runs. I remember Coe's Sunday run would be a long steady 15-20 miler.
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 01 Apr 16 02:00
His background of a pointer indicates he'll relish the trip,

I've seen a pointing effort of his on you tube and he seemed to finish full of running but the same question raises its head. What did he beat? If he beat horses which went on to be rated in the 150's under rules then it seems reasonable to assert that he'd have a fine chance of getting home over 3 miles. If they were closer to 100 types then the jury remains out until he actually does it on the course over the distance. Sure the Gold Cup is the pinnacle but the Champion Hurdle isn't chump change in terms of kudos.
By:
wellchief
When: 01 Apr 16 09:08
Off topic again sorry, but if I owned a horse my holy grail races would be a QMCC or a Champion Hurdle.

Just love seeing the best 2 milers ping fences at speed.

I love the Gold Cup, but I'd love a Champion Chaser more.

On Mullins and the Gold Cup, because most of his are French breds, I'm recent years, outside of Kauto and Long Run, I can't think of too many Gold Cup winners that raced in France.

That could be another reason because alot race at a young age over there and are often knackered when they reach about 10 over here.
By:
wellchief
When: 01 Apr 16 09:09
* in recent years (auto correct!)
By:
timtin
When: 01 Apr 16 12:07
@EO, personally I think the CH is the pinnacle, its been around for much longer than the official Cheltenham 1927 have you believe and that test of speed and the class it takes to win any one of those its just far more exciting than the GC who has been won by proper donkeys in the past. I'm only saying that Faugheen already won it, the questions is whether he can achieve a greater feat in staying the GC trip in such a powerful era of stayers that has probably been in our lifetime. Thistlecrack will go that route but he's already a stayer and if he can accomplish the double it'll be a great achievement but for me, the question of whether Faugheen can conquer it is much more interesting and would give the sport alot of publicity and would be great to talk these things like we do in other sports where there are more ambitious trainers/managers/players than we have in racing where its all about cherry picking the targets and never having any resolution for the fans that don't watch it necessarily to bet on it but for the pleasure to see what a horse is capable of, especially since there are no downsides for geldings as that make it somewhat understandable(Frankel 1/half mile which he never took so that he attracts breeders that want more speed than stamina, as Galileo already had that need covered, etc.)
By:
cyclops
When: 01 Apr 16 12:43
Yes, there have been disappointing Gold Cup winners but also Champion Hurdlers. Flakey Dove, Hors de Loi, For Auction, Collier Bay, Make a Stand, Sublimity. None of those scream top class.

And, as for the 2 mile Champion, while it's a great race and, this year, an epic one, the strength in depth has been, and will always be, desperate. As Ruby Walsh says, no-one goes out to breed a 2 mile chaser and so few excel at the trip.

I think, timtim, your Faugheen dream is just that; never heard anyone discussing him going over fences since he reverted to 2 miles. And, if not the coming season, then it won't happen. But then, to my knowledge, only Dawn Run has ever turned to chasing as a reigning Champion Hurdler which, in effect, Faugheen is.
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com