Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
buddeliea
27 Nov 10 12:28
Joined:
Date Joined: 19 Mar 04
| Topic/replies: 15,799 | Blogger: buddeliea's blog
Should see now if my antepost bet is a lively one!!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 9  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 344
By:
Brooksielad
When: 27 Nov 10 12:33
go on the peddlers cross!!!
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Nov 10 12:33
i think its a lively contender now
By:
BJG
When: 27 Nov 10 12:33
Cool
By:
bigben
When: 27 Nov 10 12:37
Grin
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 27 Nov 10 12:37
Fantastic performance. Dont think Binoc ran anywhere nr to his best, but Peddlers is entitled to come on for the run just as much as anybody. Seems such a straight forward horse
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 27 Nov 10 12:38
Serious horse, one of my favourites in training
By:
bigben
When: 27 Nov 10 12:42
Where next?

Cheltenham might come to soon & im not sure that Kempton would suit him.
By:
topshot
When: 27 Nov 10 12:43
thanks to you guys talking about talking  this one a few months ago
I am on at 25s 20s and 14s.
Cheers
By:
topshot
When: 27 Nov 10 12:44
thanks to you guys talking about talking  this one a few months ago
I am on at 25s 20s and 14s.
Cheers
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Nov 10 12:44
yeh,no doubt Binocular will be different kettle of fish come march,but have to be happy with that and PC can only get better.
By:
Mooono
When: 27 Nov 10 12:45
I love this horses style..The unbeaten street fighter grinder..Follow untill beaten but even when beaten i will still follow great horse..
By:
downallstar
When: 27 Nov 10 13:06
Cool
By:
buddeliea
When: 27 Nov 10 13:06
travels well,jumps well and yer know he will get up the hill fine,seems real genuine,and looks good enough.Plenty going for him for sure.
By:
Brooksielad
When: 27 Nov 10 13:10
Personally i believe there's 3 horses that could win the CH at the moment Peddlers, The Fly and Silviniaco. Write the Champion Hurdle form off last season IMO
By:
stormey1
When: 27 Nov 10 13:51
Proper horse is Peddlers Cross and surely theyl go Haydock,Cheltenham then Aintree
By:
EastLower Gooner
When: 27 Nov 10 14:01
didnt half sprint today. very nice considering his stamina reserves.
By:
duffy
When: 27 Nov 10 15:30
didn't think he had the pace for 2....but if he ever could prove it ...then out booting binocular and starluck is a bloody good way to go about it....well done backers.....who said that this country is too PC.
By:
Steeplechasing
When: 27 Nov 10 16:16
Budd, I'd think Binoc would need to be two different kettles of fish to turn that run around today.  If anything  the winner has more potential improvement than Binoc - can't see Binoc beating him at Cheltenham
By:
unclepuncle
When: 27 Nov 10 16:38
Bino ran ok and I'd agree with the bookies that he should just about still be favourite. But it's wide open thats for sure.

Just wish Mullins would bring Hurricane Fly over for the Bula so we (and he) can get a proper idea of how good he is. He should never be aiming him at the Fairyhouse race over 2m4f - madness imo[smiley:crazy].
By:
Shropshire Lad
When: 27 Nov 10 18:35
I have been Championing Peddlars chances in the Ch Hurdle for months now. The owner wants the Ch Hurdle.   This is  a serious horse  and won going away today.  6 or 7 s at the moment is pretty good  value.
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 18:37
Bino blew up imo after the last hurdle. ApMcCoy knew this too, check his saddle motion and compare with Maguire on Peddlers.

Peddlers was also the paddock pick beforehand.

taken the 5/1 at Korral.
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 27 Nov 10 18:38
I'm a massive fan of the horse but the current price for him is shocking imv
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 18:39
Uncle, everyone thought it was wide open last year imo , then Bino blew them all away in March. I suspect he'll win the Xmas hurdle next time out and end up being 2/1 or there abouts.
By:
eric_morris
When: 27 Nov 10 18:42
All I will say is read Hendersons post race comments today. Peddlars struggling to beat Starluck doesnt justify 5/1 the Champion Hurdle ... bookies having a laugh at your expense.
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 19:04
which 5/1 are you referring to Eric ? For Bino or Peddlers ?
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 19:07
Shocking in what respect FFT ? We know Bino has been there and done it. He IS capable of running to 172 .. are the others ??

Too me he didn't look fit today and they way he finished suggested as much. Think he'll improve a bundle for that run tbh.

Peddlers needed to be more ready today as this race was going to define where they went for the rest of the season. Connections needed to know how good he was and thus would have him pretty straight. The Bino camp dont need to prove anything and just need to worry about March.
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 27 Nov 10 19:09
I meant Peddler's price, not Binocular's
By:
Masterminded
When: 27 Nov 10 19:12
Ran a great race but was given a pretty strong ride. I still think Binocular will be the one to beat. He didn't blow up IMO he just was not given a crack of the whip. Whereas Peddlers had 13 from what I saw.
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 19:12
I see,I see. Cool
By:
aka
When: 27 Nov 10 19:35
Lovely horse. Trainer clearly proved right in saying the horse would have the basic speed for two miles and definitely now a strong contender for the CH. As the jockey said after the race though, the slightly tacky ground helped (or, at least I imagine he meant the ground may have disadvantaged PC less than Starluck and Binocular). And PC was ridden out to hold off Starluck, with Binocular seemingly running some way below the form of his CH win.

Starluck is a fair enough measure of the strength of the performance, but he is not the most likely to be among those fighting it out going to the line next March in the CH. Not putting Starluck down - he is a very good horse and may still have some further improvement to come. But the CH will be a step up again for PC, not least in the sense that the pace will likely be more relentless from the start, while the pace today was no more than reasonable. Arguably, an even stronger pace would suit PC on the stamina and class front, though it will also test his tactical speed even more rigorously than today and will be an even more severe test of his hurdling. His hurdling is very sound, but we still need to see how it looks in a bigger field at CH pace.

All-in-all, very encouraging start in open company for PC, but 6/1 probably about right for the CH and possibly a bit skinny. What a prospect though if he can translate the abilities he showed today when eventually going chasing. Blimey, we are lucky to have so many fantastic jumps horses around at the moment.

Binocular - difficult horse to get right from a punting angle, but the one race I wouldn't be against him for is the CH, assuming we get reasonable spring ground. It was a good trial today, but not the CH, not by a long way.
By:
Pleasegivemeanailedontip
When: 27 Nov 10 19:39
Bizarre. Totally igoring binos run as henderson doesnt care about this race. The flat horse didnt find the extra gear that he should of - and if he had of done then it would have screamed that peddlers needs further.
By:
Shropshire Lad
When: 27 Nov 10 20:13
Plenty of people looking at the poor performance of Bino rather than the comfortable vcitory by PC, who, was also having the first run of the season and will come on.

I repeat, the owner only wants the Ch Hurdle .

Nothing too experimental about todays performance.
What about the credentials of beating the quality field in the Neptune and following up at Aintree. How many horses have done that ?
By:
Howdi
When: 27 Nov 10 20:26
shropshire you are hardly telling us anything we havent known for months that the owner wants the champion.
By:
eric_morris
When: 27 Nov 10 20:29
Menorah is a bigger danger to Binocular then Peddlars Cross when they are all fully wound up imo.
By:
Steeplechasing
When: 27 Nov 10 20:44
Some interesting points. One of the fascinating aspects of racing, for me, is the different interpretation of a race by experienced form students. Binocular went into today on the back of very enthusiastic reports of his homework and with 21lbs in hand of Peddlers Cross on official ratings. The race was run comparatively slowly for the grade (just over 4 seconds quicker than the opening Novice) which should have been of disadvantage to the 'stayer' PC and in favour of Binocular. PC not only beat the speed horses but quickened twice in the final stages.

Not the first forum I've seen Menorah cited as a better prospect than PC.  I'd say today's form puts him ahead of Menorah whose Festival victory doesn't look strong form, especially measured against PC's Neptune where the runner-up won a Group 1 at Punchestown next time out and the 3rd won the Ascot Gold Cup.  Also, PC achieved the rare feat, these days, of following up at Liverpool (Menorah failed to do that).

Khyber Kim gets a couple of mentions elsewhere as a danger: he'll be 9 in March, has run 13 times over hurdles and, imo, had his chance this year - where is he going to find improvement from?

I think Hurricane Fly over-rated so wouldn't fear him; his training problems last year don't inspire confidence either.

Those mentioned above, plus the usual suspects, have another disadvantage compared with PC - we already know the depth of their talents. Nobody yet knows where the bottom of Peddlers Cross is. I think a literal reading of the Starluck form might also be misleading; on past evidence he's a very smart animal cursed by the fact that the Champion Hurdle is run at Cheltenham on easy ground. He very nearly snatched the Christmas Hurdle from Go Native before being confounded yet again by the Cheltenham hill in March. His trainer believes him to be a stronger and better horse this year and he looked it today.

Finally, although McCain has trained no CH winners yet, I think he's pretty shrewd and he and Maguire have always believed they have something really special in PC. I've already backed him at 25s for the CH and, with that in the book, I'd normally take an awful lot of convincing to go in again at 6/1. But I simply think he is still particularly good value. Some of you obviously don't but value, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder
By:
sintonian
When: 27 Nov 10 21:15
I think the positive reports were more in relation to how he was jumping in his homework compared to this time last year, and when you compare his jumping today to how he was for his first few races last season, then you can see the positive reports were justified. He jumped quickly and accurately and was much better than in the Fighting Fifth last season.

I have just watched the race again on RUK replay and if you look at PC and Bino as they are approaching the last hurdle, it looks as though Bino is just about to get PC's measure. After the last it looks like he was about to go on, and could possibly have been in front a nose (very hard to tell) but he never kicked on. It was a classic case of a horse blowing up imo. He then took a soft tap of the whip from McCoy whilst Maguire was very aggressive in the saddle and dished out 5 cracks of the whip in just in the final 80 yards or so.

Of course all three of them are entitled to improve for one reason or another .. but which horse do you think will improve the most ?
By:
R Carver
When: 27 Nov 10 21:20
PC more likely to win the CH than Menorah IMO.

Steeple, why do you think Binocular would be less disadvantaged by a sprint - all his best runs come off a fast, even gallop (and usually in the spring, when the trainer peaks them (excepting his run at Ascot in the Bula, although that was 'd-day')). One thing this horse does not want, particularly when over weight on his seasonal debut, 4 months away from his only target, is a sprint against a horse who was probably 99pc right. If you remember the Kempton a/w work the yr before last, he is a stuffy bull of a horse. The run of Staluck to me suggests everything we need to know about the race today from a form perspective, though i expect he has improved a bit and as I say, there is no doubt PC is top notch. Haydock last yr told PC is a CH horse.
By:
TD_Gunner
When: 27 Nov 10 21:25
No doubt in my mind that the Peddler would murder Menorah.

He's the Champion Hurdle winner imv.
By:
Steeplechasing
When: 27 Nov 10 21:28
Of course all three of them are entitled to improve for one reason or another .. but which horse do you think will improve the most ?

Improve for the experience?  PC, I think - it was only his 5th run over hurdles. As for which will be better for it fitness-wise, probably Binocular.  But was his fitness level close to two stone below what it should have been?  Taking the result literally on official ratings, that's what the argument would be, and I doubt NJH sends many horses to a grade 1 race two stone short of fitness or anyhere near that.
Page 1 of 9  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 9 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com