Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Bloodstock & Breeding

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
jockeyhunter
05 Jan 15 16:51
Joined:
Date Joined: 14 Jun 06
| Topic/replies: 1,375 | Blogger: jockeyhunter's blog
What are people opinions? after all the stallions success in Australia then the hype here, i have not been overly impressed with how the stallion has done in Europe.
i presume the horse has covered a full book of mares.
Anyone have a theory why its not worked?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 13
By:
Wilycayote
When: 05 Jan 15 17:45
I am a big admirer of Coolmore and they rarely get it wrong, but they have used an undoubtedly brilliant stallion in completely the wrong way. Over 80% of his first 3 books of mares have been mares from the Saddlers Wells line. If you go through the return of mares the vast majority are by Saddlers Wells, Montjeu, Galileo with the odd other "Derby distance" broodmare sire thrown in.

They might be lovely mares but it is not the way to breed speed horses. Fastnet Rock has bred 18 Gr 1 winners from 5.5 crops in AUS, having been mated with predominantly speedy mares of which he has get very few in IRE.

Also, people think/thought they would be 2yo's and tried to get stuck into them early which did not help. Believe it or not, the Aussies are far more patient with their Fastnet Rocks, most of them don't even run at 2.

Once they stop trying to fit a square peg into a round whole he will be a serious stallion in both hemispheres. 9% stakes winners to runners when he's not being used to his best is a fair effort!
By:
The Gotchee
When: 05 Jan 15 18:55
I am not a great admirer of Coolmore so to put things into perspective, Fastnet Rock covered 150 mares in the N.Hemisphere in 2011.
He had 9 winners from 35 runners (6%) in 2014
5 stakes winners (3%)
Winning prize money of £105,000.

His fee at that time was believed to be €60,000.00 and at that price he had to be getting good mares.

IMHO, he is poor value and has got an awful lot to prove in these parts.
He may still turn the corner because he covered 183, 193 and 85 in his last three crops, although 85 seems to be a small crop in 2014.
By:
jockeyhunter
When: 05 Jan 15 23:09
35 runners in 2014 seems fairly low to me, may covering only 85 in 2014 means coolmore might be giving up on the stallion proving itself in the NH.
thanks for the interesting input.
By:
brain dead jockeys
When: 16 Jan 15 23:56
the northern hemisphere experiment has failed.
By:
jmc27
When: 25 Jan 15 15:41
Wilycayote 05 Jan 15 17:45 Joined: 31 Dec 10 | Topic/replies: 272 | Blogger: Wilycayote's blog
I am a big admirer of Coolmore and they rarely get it wrong, but they have used an undoubtedly brilliant stallion in completely the wrong way. Over 80% of his first 3 books of mares have been mares from the Saddlers Wells line. If you go through the return of mares the vast majority are by Saddlers Wells, Montjeu, Galileo with the odd other "Derby distance" broodmare sire thrown in.

They might be lovely mares but it is not the way to breed speed horses. Fastnet Rock has bred 18 Gr 1 winners from 5.5 crops in AUS, having been mated with predominantly speedy mares of which he has get very few in IRE.

Also, people think/thought they would be 2yo's and tried to get stuck into them early which did not help. Believe it or not, the Aussies are far more patient with their Fastnet Rocks, most of them don't even run at 2.

Once they stop trying to fit a square peg into a round whole he will be a serious stallion in both hemispheres. 9% stakes winners to runners when he's not being used to his best is a fair effort!


Havnt been on here in a while so didnt get to say great post! You have head the nail on the head perfectly.
Had a chat with a prominent fella from the operation last month and put these points to him, he was fairly blunt and was pretty much in agreement.
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 26 Jan 15 13:30
No sign of him in Tipperary last week. Methinks he must have been late for the plane. . . .
By:
jockeyhunter
When: 07 Jun 15 17:14
Maybe coolmore need to ask Aiden which mares are best to mate Fastnet with.
By:
Wilycayote
When: 28 Jun 15 17:48
A second European Gr 1 for Fastnet Rock this month, that is no small feat.

I was also very impressed by Cougar Mountain's close placing in the Queen Anne, hope he runs in the Eclipse.
By:
sageform
When: 29 Jun 15 13:24
He seems to have inherited the Danehill trait of being able to produce top class middle distance horses despite being known as a sprinter.
By:
Catch Me ifyoucan
When: 29 Jun 15 20:59
Put Lieutenant General in the notebook.
By:
Wilycayote
When: 13 Aug 15 22:45
80 individual stakes winners. That's fairly astonishing for a 14yo stallion which ever way you cut it.
By:
zygote
When: 24 Aug 15 22:38
Coolmore have got themselves onto the horns of a dilemma, one which is entirely of their own making. Their total obsession with the Northern Dancer line has been very successful commercially, and with Sadlers Wells and now Galileo they have had two of the greatest stallions in the last 100 years. However, they have a SURFEIT of mares by Sadlers Wells, Galileo, and Montjeu. Which stallions can they send these mares to? The demise of Danehill, and the lack of a natural successor, leaves them in a bind. They have been using Dansili and Oasis Dream quite a lot, and they clearly hoped that Fastnet Rock would deliver for them. But FR's apparent failure leaves them without a top-class cross of their own for most of their mares. Their recent investments in War Front, a son of Danzig, are driven by this. But of course he is across the water. They also cannot use Dubawi or Shamardal, as they are owned by their deadly rivals. It seems to me that Coolmore desperately need a top stallion to outcross. The degree of inbreeding to Northern Dancer is already a worrying issue, for which Coolmore are largely responsible. They probably should have bought Novellist, who as a son of Monsun would have given them the outcross they so clearly need.
By:
Wilycayote
When: 11 Sep 16 21:05
Zhukova, Rivet, Intricately. Gr3, Gr2, Gr1,  7f - 1m4f

not a bad weekend
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com