Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Australian

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 308 comments are related to the topic:
AFL Round 5

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 308
By:
BJT
When: 26 Apr 13 10:34

Apr 26, 2013 -- 4:12AM, Proud To Punt wrote:


Unless AFL withdraws its financial assistance and redistribution policies, the number of teams are here to stay. If the make clubs stand alone, then the number of teams would dramatically reduce. Personally, I would love to see a 12 team comp where they play each other twice then finals but doubt I will ever see that again in my lifetime


All they need is a 2 pool system.

Taken from final positions 2012 (ideally would be after GF but quickly found this ladder, so for this purpose will do fine)....
Pool A
Hawthorn
Sydney
West Coast
Fremantle
StKilda
Essendon
Brisbane Lions
Western Bulldogs
Gold Coast

Pool B
Adelaide
Collingwood
Geelong
North Melbourne
Carlton
Richmond
PortAdelaide
Melbourne
GreaterWesternSydney


Pool A plays each other twice, and Pool A plays Pool B once each team.
Season goes for 25 rounds, starts with the NRL so doesn't fall behind.  The pools are determined by finish position the year before, and are based on odds vs evens.
The draw is 100% fair, as each pool has 2 from top 4, 2 from 5-8, 2 from 9-12, 2 from 13-17, and either 17th or 18th.  100 % fair. 
Finals should be a knockout system, 1v8, 2v7, 3v6, 4v5, then that should carry on through the finals.  If 1 beats 8, then they play in the second week of finals the lowest ranked team, until the 2 unbeatens face off in the final.

In regards to "struggling" teams, you can kill them off if you like, but the reality is the higher based teams have more coverage.  This is why Essendon Collingwood play off every Anzac Day.  StKilda had to go to NZ to get a showcase, and show their skills in front of people that will never become members.
The teams mentioned, are the ones getting bonus money from the AFL because they aren't involved in the blockbusters, because they are not allowed to be.  Pure and simple.

And who would follow any of those clubs?  I am sure St Kilda gained many many supporters through the last decade considering they were one of the most dominant teams for a good period of around 5 years.  That is how teams get members.  That, and coverage.

The draw needs to be fair, which I have achieved, we need to start at same time or before NRL, check, and blockbuster days need to be given to the teams that draw that day in the random setup of the draw for the year

By:
Lloydy Trots Man
When: 26 Apr 13 10:35
Get rid of Nab Cup and have no Practise Games.
2 Clubs have to go.
Play each other 2 times
You have 42 players manage lists better and less teams more depth
By:
BJT
When: 26 Apr 13 10:47
In regards to depth of talent, the talent pool isn't limited to current players, those talented enough to excel at AFL is a percentage of the population of players.
All good to say get rid of a couple of teams and the talent depth increases, but it also does if you expose it to more people and have more people play.
If you work out the numbers, and suggest that the top 700 players out of 800 registered deserve to be playing at the highest level, then you are looking at around 1 in 1000 players being good enough to play AFL.  If you expose that and suddenly get 1 million people playing Aussie Rules, then that means you suddenly have 1000 players good enough to be playing AFL but only 800 spots to fill.

All good saying depth increases with smaller teams, but it also increases with more followers.  That is the whole point of expanding it nation wide, and international.
By:
Kye
When: 26 Apr 13 11:42
Bjt, fair concept except i think 22 rounds is enough. i would also have GWS & Swans in same pool.

Same concept with 2 less teams would be perfect.

Totally agree that draw is unfair every year. Sides are making finals simply b/c of favorable draw
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 11:56
Hi guys at game now after work Tigers off to a flyer
By:
Lets Elope
When: 26 Apr 13 12:04
Go tiges, the 3 bucks on offer was ridiculous for mine and have had a decent lick at them tonight, hopefully they can go on with it and open up a decent lead and take the crowd out of the game and get some reward for their early effort unlike last week's game.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:16
tigers are beating them in midfield and clearances.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:17
Conditions perfect for footy tonight, no wind,no dew.....expect game to open up as game goes on
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:18
Qtr time: Freo 12-32 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:19
Qtr time odds: Freo 2.25 v 1.72 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:21
Taken the line over 180.5 pts in play @ evens. for you guys on b365 have a tender on over 212.5 pts at 5/1! Wink
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:22
Tigers at 1.80 looks a tad over mine.........dockers not getti 1st use of the ball out of midfield.......but points scoring are my bets tonight
By:
wooky
When: 26 Apr 13 12:23
If Freo lose this like they look like they will I can't see them making the 8 this year. Nothing to like about their game play. This defensive low scoring crap does nothing for the fans and it's even worse when it doesn't result in wins. Would have been better off sticking with Mark Harvey.
By:
BJT
When: 26 Apr 13 12:24

Apr 26, 2013 -- 5:42AM, Kye wrote:


Bjt, fair concept except i think 22 rounds is enough. i would also have GWS & Swans in same pool.Same concept with 2 less teams would be perfect.Totally agree that draw is unfair every year. Sides are making finals simply b/c of favorable draw


Yeah, I think when I came up with that was before GCS GWS so was a perfect length season.  In regards to Swans GWS, you do that, then you start doctoring the draw, and pretty soon you end up with what we have now.
GWS Sydney same pool, bigger crowds, blockbusters, Essendon should be with Collingwood, Collingwood should be with Carlton..  Nah, **** all that, it should be 100% determined by finishing position as suggested, as that is 100% fair and there is nothing questionable about it. 

But 25 games is ok.  Fcuk the practice games off and nothing changes, just better list management.

In regards to current teams, while a smaller number may be ideal, I think the way they would weed them down is not fair at all.  If you are going to weed them down, then every team must have a fair go at a decent draw and games, which they don't have now.  They really have little hope with longevity as it stands now, as they are basically being held at arms length and are guaranteed first ones to go.

Think there are plenty of options though.  If they want to keep them and give them a chance, then:
Cairns has a very nice AFL ground.  Darwin has a pretty handy team, so assuming nice ground.  Tasmania could easily hold a team.  And Canberra.
3 Queensland teams,
3 NSW (ACT included)
2 SA
2 WA
1 Tasmania
1 Northern Territory
6 Victorian Based.
Could even get one in Ballarat, or Bendigo even.

All of those places have plenty enough AFL support to support a team.

By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 12:29
Kepler Bradley injured but think its not too bad
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:06
Half time: Freo 47-45 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:08
Half time odds: Freo 1.46 v 3.10 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:10
Richmond about SP , might be worth getting on them. Bradley subbed off Will be interested to see how Freo cope with 1 player down
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:47
3/4 time: Freo 68-59 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:47
3/4 time odds: Freo 1.36 v 3.60 Richmond
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 13:48
Robin Nahas on, will give Richmond an injection of speed going into final term
By:
Lets Elope
When: 26 Apr 13 14:20
heartbreaking but what a game. The market was miles wrong as I thought but the dockers managed to stagger home.
By:
bigted.
When: 26 Apr 13 14:21
farkkkkkkkkkk

Sad
By:
Chariots
When: 26 Apr 13 14:22
Can't believe that the greatest after timer in history went the early crow.
By:
Aussie Driver
When: 26 Apr 13 14:24
lol same old Richmond. Huge win for Freo to keep in touch until they get some big names back
By:
Joel
When: 26 Apr 13 14:27
Just as well for Freo, would be a pretty lean year for WA fans if it wasn't for the Dockers propping things up.
By:
bigted.
When: 26 Apr 13 14:30
goal umpire cost me the cash..  **** Angry
By:
Aussie Driver
When: 26 Apr 13 14:35
Can't work out what everyone is talking about with that goal umpire, it was going straight into the post anyway. Changed nothing
By:
Proud To Punt
When: 26 Apr 13 14:39
Got me stumped why Hardwicke didn't send more numbers back after they hit the front. Shocked
By:
bigted.
When: 26 Apr 13 14:42
life imitating art ..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=mV1LWhNpTJU
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 20:09
Tight game last night. Had game lasted another 15-20 seconds, Richmond probably could have got at least a result over here. Just shows how tight games can be. Also learnt last night that games at Subi will be lower scoring than other games this season especially for the night games.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 20:10
Also bad luck for Kepler Bradley , his injury is season ending.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 22:51
With Russell Westbrook out, I think Houston Rockets have every chance of winning the series now........Houston should have won game 2 in Oklahoma
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 26 Apr 13 22:52
^^^^ Oops wrong thread
By:
Kye
When: 27 Apr 13 00:00
Dear goal umpires, keep your fkn legs off the playing field. last night it effectively cost Tigers the victory.

Not the first time either. A few weeks ago (pies game) it looked on the review that the ball rebounded off the umpires legs rather than the goal post.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 27 Apr 13 00:52
a couple of weeks ago, the goal umpire had to be stretchered off after colliding with one of the players. Liam Picken rushed a behind and the goal umpire did an ACL knee injury.(the goal umpire was a doctor and knew straight away) Agree they are too close to the play, should be standing at least 2 metres behind the goal line in my opinion.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 27 Apr 13 00:52
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjBvRZf5rbA
By:
wombleoz
When: 27 Apr 13 02:15
There are definitely too many teams in Melbourne - Lloydy can have the Ballarat Kangaroos, Bulldogs can go to Tassie and then get the Giants out of Sydney and move them to Cairns

I don't have a problem with games in NZ but they are a LONG way off getting a

Other option is to wind back to 12 teams in the AFL and introduce second and third tier national competitions with promotion and relegation like the EPL - bottom 2 go down, top 2 go up each year

Winners today

Crows, Suns, Port and the Cats

Cool
By:
wooky
When: 27 Apr 13 03:55
The Port/WCE game will be interesting to see where both are at. Port undefeated but look who they have played Melb,GWS,Adel,SunsCrazy WCE have played Freo,Hawks,Melb,Carlton. WCE not going great with with key players out but surely they'll improve in front of goal this week. Too much firepower to have another behind fest like last week. A week is a long time in footy, Cloke was dead eye dick last week and sprayin them this week. If WCE are switched on and kick straight this could be a flogging for a possibly ahead of themselves Port.

Put your house on the cats...(but gamble responsibly)Excited

Melb to beat Bris is my smoky. Rich is a huge out for a team playing poorly and if Melb can continue that last quarter effort they'll do em.
By:
West Coast Eagles
When: 27 Apr 13 04:19
I'm off to the netball today between West Coast and Melbourne, should be good to see the girls in action
Page 3 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com