Cheryl a coward

it looked a set up to me

strange how simon went last when 2 of his acts against each other

ERM NO. BECAUSE I THINK YOU WILL FIND THAT TREYC WAS BOTTOM OF THE VOTE SO WOULD HAVE GONE IF IT HAD GONE TO DEADLOCK

ok how do you know treyc was bottom of the vote .you say i shall find that she was bottom of the vote.where then do i "find" this ,then i shall have a look and maybe beleive it was a fair vote off (maybe not)!

Treyc and Weasel being the bottom 2 was hardly a shock - a bit of drama livened up a dull show and gets people talking about it again - just what Cowell wants.

THE PREDICTOR  PROGRAM SAID TREYC WOULD BE BOTTOM OF THE VOTES BUT IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE ME. ITV WILL BE SENDING THROUGH THE VOTING PERCENTAGES THIS MORNING SO I WILL LET YOU KNOW THEN

Two things make this stink - first, the rumours of a double eviction, then Cheryl not being asked to vote last (as per normal practice when a judge has bottom two acts).  It was a total cop-out and betrayed the fact that Cowell still wants Katie in the competition (presumably due to column inches rather than singing talent, as her days are effectively numbered anyway).

I made good money on Treyc (had both her and Katie well covered as the obvious bottom two looked a foregone conclusion), so I'm not speaking out of my pocket - but I do think this was a total farce.

ALL OLD NEWS

IN 2007 SHARON OSBOURNE WALKED OFF THE SHOW WHEN SHE WAS ASKED TO CHOSE BETWEEN TWO OF HER ACTS AND IT WAS LEFT  TO THE REMAINING THREE (SAME THREE) TO DECIDE

LAST YEAR SIMON SAID IT'S A SINGING COMPETITION AND SLATED JEDWARD EVERY WEEK BUT HAD A CHANCE TO SEND THEM HOME WHEN THEM AND LUCIE JONES WERE IN THE BOTTOM TWO BUT SENT IT TO DEADLOCK AND THEY WENT THRU. HE HAD BEEN SEEN DISCUSSING WHAT TO DO WITH THE SHOWS EXEC PRODUCER


STOP MOANING PEOPLE THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS AND THIS IS HOW YOU MAKE MONEY OUT OF THE X FACTOR

Not really old news less than 12 hours later!  They should have gone to Cheryl last.  Would have made better TV and she would have been forced to go to deadlock.

Besides, this is what Cheryl asked for herself - she said go to the other two, come back to me and I'll take it to deadlock.  It's just bizarre that they didn't do that...

OLD NEWS  READ MY POST. SHARON REFUSED TO CHOOSE SO IT WENT TO THE OTHER THREE JUDGES.

AS SOON AS THE VOTING FIGURES COME THRU WE WILL KNOW WHO WOULD HAVE GONE IF IT WENT TO DEADLOCK. I SUSPECT THE RESULT WOULD NOT HAVE CHANGED

She had the chance to vote and refused, knowing there was already a vote against tracey she could have voted to make it 1-1, her choice.

TEMPLE - SOME ADVICE FOR YOU! PLEASE DO NOT BET ON THE X FACTOR YOU ARE A CLUELESS MUG

HTH

Mike has it spot on

Amazed there's any fuss, it's even on the Nicky Campbell phone in

Speaking as a Tracy backer OC

Thanks, HorsePlace it does help, though I would never bet on such matters anyway. I would, however, be interested in a more detailed explanation on how you formed your opinion.

I disagree that it would have made better TV by going to Tweedy last and inevitably going deadlock.  It would have been what the masses expect.  Better TV to force Tweedy to make a decision.  So what if they're both her acts.  I can't understand why this this should be so hard.

Problem with this show there is no Rules when it comes to the judges voting.making it scandalous in my Opinion.How can cherly be aksed 2nd yesterday and simon asked 4th earlier on in this series.The show should have set rules when it comes to the judges making there vote count.

So there is  inconsistency with rules of the show which makes it scandalous from what i see,and has no credibility as a tv show anymore.

Give her five pints of Stella and put a large black toilet attendant in front of her and we'll see who's a coward

GeorgeBrush Joined: 16 Jun 02
Replies: 11705 08 Nov 10 23:03
   
Give her five pints of Stella and put a large black toilet attendant in front of her and we'll see who's a coward 

LOL

Post of the series for me!

What difference anyway, neither has the faintest chance of winning.

Like it or not it made great Telly and has got everyone talking about it which is exactly as Cowell planned it.

Tracey is this years Jedward not Wagner.  People actually like Wagner where as the majority hated Jedward and the majority hate Katie!