Forums

X Factor 2010

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Anaglogs Daughter
11 Oct 10 16:02
Joined:
Date Joined: 05 Jan 10
| Topic/replies: 29,477 | Blogger: Anaglogs Daughter's blog
LaughHappy

X Factor rejects FYD today blamed the show's running order for them being given the boot in the first week of live finals.

The group said that being the first act on Saturday's show had counted against them because some viewers missed the early minutes of the show.

The five piece boyband from London - Matthew Lawton, 26, Kalvin Lamey, 25, Alex Murdoch, 22, Ryan-Lee Seager, 22, and Jordan Gabriel, 22 - were left in the bottom three after the public vote.

They were booted off after competing in the sing-off against Cheryl Cole's controversial act Katie Waissel, and only their mentor Simon Cowell chose to try to save them.

Seager said: "There's a big part in going on first - it would have been about the votes.

"Some people don't tune in for that first part, some people don't tune in until about 8 o'clock and miss the first half an hour. It's one of those things when you're like 'Oh it started at eight', it's a thing that happens."

The band also felt let down by judge Louis Walsh for not choosing to save them.

Walsh had been critical of Waissel's performance on Saturday and if he had chosen to save FYD, the show would have gone to "deadlock" - which means elimination would have been down to the act with the fewest public votes.

Lawton said: "It would have been nice if he'd given us a deadlock, and then it would have been an even playing ground and we would have maybe stood a chance of being there for next week, it might have been a different outcome."

But he added: "It's a television programme and it's a competition at the end of the day, we'll never know the rhyme or reason, or why the judges pick who they pick."

The band, four of whom dance professionally, were criticised by judges Walsh and Dannii Minogue for dancing too much during their performance.

And in an apparent dig at judge Cheryl Cole the boys defended their performance, insisting they had proved they had more skill at being able to dance and sing live. Cole was criticised when she gave a lip-sync performance while promoting her single Fight For This Love.

Seager said: "A lot of credible artists mime when they have an all-out routine. So to sing live in front of 14 million people and have a full-out dance routine from (choreographer) Sisco Gomez, who is amazing, I feel proud of us."

Murdoch added: "So many artists these days dance and sing, people like Usher, Lady Gaga. It just seemed funny that they kept saying about the dancing bit. To me it just seems normal, even Girls Aloud dance, if you see their concerts."

FYD were the only original group to make it through to the final 12, as rival acts Belle Amie and One Direction were put together by Simon Cowell during boot camp.

They claimed Cowell had already decided he wanted boyband One Direction to win the show.

Seager said: "We reckon One Direction are the people that are going to end up winning and we think that's why we went out.
Pause Switch to Standard View FYD blame running order for early X...
Show More
Loading...
Report Angela Rebecchi October 11, 2010 4:08 PM BST
shrewd They claimed Cowell had already decided he wanted boyband One Direction to win the show.

Seager said: "We reckon One Direction are the people that are going to end up winning and we think that's why we went out.
Report Alkeyhole October 11, 2010 4:14 PM BST
Cowell deffo wanted them out.

Also 100% certainty they got more votes than Katie, which is why Louis dumped them rather than letting it "be decided by the public"....
Report stringerbell October 11, 2010 4:16 PM BST
listen to seagar, he knows, he knowsLaugh
Report jack12321 October 11, 2010 4:21 PM BST
They have a point to be fair, in 6 of the 7 years in the first week the first act on has been in the showdown. Bit unlucky for them.
Report Mikeeey October 11, 2010 4:28 PM BST
I think they were fortunate to go first.  At least they can then blame it on the running order and not their shyte act.
Report Goldie08 October 11, 2010 4:46 PM BST
lol, agreed
Report GeorgeBrush October 11, 2010 5:20 PM BST
There's been far worse. A little unfortunate I thought
Report LOU MACARIS TARTAN B October 11, 2010 5:31 PM BST
Thought they were unlucky to go with a few worse than them on the night.  First spot didn't help and they're not exactly a Rhydian or Alexandra who could have carried off going first no problem.  A bit hard done by i think but would have only surely lasted another two or three weeks.
Report deejayric October 11, 2010 5:37 PM BST
After criticising Katie's performance on Sat night, Louis' line "I have to do the right thing" just before choosing FYD was hilarious. At the very least the 'right thing' to him was deadlock.

If I was FYD I'd be mightily f*cked off. Instead, as a punter losing £12.50 on them @ 89, I'm just quietly seething.
Report GymTanLaundry October 11, 2010 5:38 PM BST
the right thing was to do what he'd been told and vote out FYD, because all the judges knew that if they sent it to deadlock, katie was gone, which they couldn't have.
Report LOU MACARIS TARTAN B October 11, 2010 5:39 PM BST
deejay

Yes I thought it would go deadlock and that on the night FYD were better than Katie but there you have it.  £12.50's just a drop in the ocean to you anyway.
Report GeorgeBrush October 11, 2010 5:40 PM BST
I'd like to see Louis's comments after both 1st  performances  again Plain
Report deejayric October 11, 2010 5:49 PM BST
Gym - that was why it was so funny - "I have to do the right thing" just smacked of doing the right thing by Simon, with the instructions still ringing in his ears. Maybe he didn't realise he'd said it out loud Blush

GB - all the judges were favourable to FYD - 'great start to the show etc' - while Katie got a hard time, esp from Louis. iirc.
Report GeorgeBrush October 11, 2010 5:51 PM BST
That is what I surmised dj, cheers
Report GymTanLaundry October 11, 2010 6:09 PM BST
it's great fun though isn't dj?

the entertainment part of x factor is in watching the mass-manipulation rather than the extremely average acts!  brilliant!
Report limited ability October 11, 2010 6:14 PM BST
They couldn't let the WEASEL go in week 1, it would have shown up Ms Cole over her selection ahead of GAMU.
Report limited ability October 11, 2010 6:17 PM BST
I marked off what judges made positive and negative comments about each act and to be fair to Louis he was negative about FYD and The Weasel.
Report deejayric October 11, 2010 6:20 PM BST
Totally Gym. The contrived drama and suspense of the results show has me laughing out loud every week (apart from Louis on Sun Cry ) The mass-manipulation is normally quite profitable too tho Cool
Report EMPIRE DAY October 11, 2010 6:37 PM BST
that black guy in FYD the one with the glasses, he was an annoying cnut, worth watching too see his face at the end
Report GeorgeBrush October 11, 2010 6:55 PM BST
Was it not still black?
Report johnnyrant October 11, 2010 9:22 PM BST
Not surprising, I suppose, that it hasn't occurred to the deluded wannabees, the reason they got the boot was because they were sh*t.
Report Cider October 11, 2010 9:25 PM BST
They are right of course, but were happy to get on the ride and play along, no point in sour grapes afterwards. At least turkeys are unaware it is Xmas, until it is too late.
Report deejayric October 11, 2010 9:45 PM BST
johnnyrant Joined: 14 Feb 07
Replies: 5923 11 Oct 10 21:22 
Not surprising, I suppose, that it hasn't occurred to the deluded wannabees, the reason they got the boot was because they were sh*t.


lol, this is X Factor - on that premise 16 acts could've reasonably have got the boot. In relative terms, FYD had much more about them than any of the other groups imo. One Dimension (cheers) are way way duller and sh*tter for example.
Report jack12321 October 11, 2010 10:57 PM BST
They'll be avoiding deadlock largely this year, NAP. They're perfectly aware the public was annoyed how much they used it last year. Am expecting it to be 75/25 in favour of majority votes. Could provide a decent betting opportunity at the last second.
Report GeorgeBrush October 11, 2010 11:01 PM BST
It'll be 4-0 when Bellamy and Diva are in the sing off [;)]
Report jack12321 October 11, 2010 11:16 PM BST
Yep, Bellamy will be gonnas Grin
Report stringerbell October 12, 2010 8:20 AM BST
deejayric has this absolutely spot on, no need for me to repeat it - louis was ordered, really tough on fyd
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com