is murray the best defensive player ever???

From Scotland , yes .

But then , I might give that honor to Christian Dailly .

judy erskine one of the best scottish defensive players ever imo

novak and rafa both superior

nah andy is in a class of his own. he is the smartest player on tour imo

Nah novak is the guy whose won the slams...

true but andy desreves respect. a solid player who is always challenging

he gets plenty of respect, still doesnt make him best defensive player in history though

Andy is one of the best, but the retrieval power of Nadal is something beyond words

probably is Rafa but Murray not far off and has way more variety than Rafa.

YES

i think novak, then muzza then rafa.

same as bhoys

is andy due some respect now? i think this is final no5?  5 more than most players ever make

it must be 6 on second thoughts???????????????????????????

im a rafa fanboy by the way and thats how highly i rate djocko n muzzas return

Surely Agassi in the mix, or does tennis before 2008 not count

ferrer fourth

never seen aggasi so cant say

only about 50 players have ever made at least 5 grand slam finals and he's in an impossibly difficult era too

Sep 8, 2012 -- 9:59PM, The Bhoys wrote:

never seen aggasi so cant say

did you never see a tennis match til you were 20 odd

im 27 but pretty much yeah. i remember yrs ago sum boy called sampras serving bombs v him

Rafa is the best

Sep 8, 2012 -- 7:30PM, seahawk wrote:

From Scotland , yes .But then , I might give that honor to Christian Dailly .

Nah. Chris Iwelumo was best defensively.

Chang.

ouch darlo, we had tried to airbrush that iwelumo memory forever.
i was at hampden that day, extraordinary miss

^

Forum Meltdown that was

the commentator couldn't believe it had not  gone in

Actually said 'the ref has disallowed it!'

Iwelu-no!

Yes, he is. Even if you remove the word "defensive", the answer is still "yes".

Novak in top form is better. eg del potro match

Djok most definitely a superior defensive player