England cannot avoid NZ in the semi-final They could possibly beat them?
For the rest- wide open any of SA AUST IRELAND to fill the remaining spot Dont think Wales/France get there due to inferior benches So to be very controversial
leif,no aus will not avoid nzealand, if both get through they will meet semi finals, Is it better for england to get hammered by france come 2nd and play wales, s africa and then new zealand ?
leif,no aus will not avoid nzealand, if both get through they will meet semi finals, Is it better for england to get hammered by france come 2nd and play wales, s africa and then new zealand ?
Wales are my dark horses. Extremely well drilled to win competition Rugby. May be good enough as a team to beat SA.
From what I have seen it is NZ v SA Final.
Could England spring a surprise on NZ. I think individually they have the players to be competitive but as a team they just do not have that All Black way of playing. It could be the match of the World Cup along with Wales v SA. I don't think the final will be as good as two close exhilarating semi's.
NZ v SA / WalesWales are my dark horses. Extremely well drilled to win competition Rugby. May be good enough as a team to beat SA.From what I have seen it is NZ v SA Final.Could England spring a surprise on NZ. I think individually they have the play
The Scotland Japan match is going to be a cliffhanger unless one team wins easily. After todays game Ireland have 3 bonus points, Japan and Scotland 2 each. Scotland will have a better points difference so even if Scotland beat Japan by a single point on Sunday, Japan would be knocked out. I still think Japan will win the game.
The Scotland Japan match is going to be a cliffhanger unless one team wins easily. After todays game Ireland have 3 bonus points, Japan and Scotland 2 each. Scotland will have a better points difference so even if Scotland beat Japan by a single poin
from what i heard , if scotland win with bonus point, scotland through scotland win and japan dont score bonus points , scotland through scotland say win 23-20 and japan score 4 tries but scotland dont score 4 tries japan through as they get 2 bonus point.
i might be talking complete bollocks though.
from what i heard , if scotland win with bonus point, scotland through scotland win and japan dont score bonus points , scotland through scotland say win 23-20 and japan score 4 tries but scotland dont sco
ps again, i said if scot win with a bonus point , scotland through, but just thinking it over, if scot win with bonus point theyll have max 5 pts, but japan could still get 2 points for tries and losing under 7 , so japan go through.
ps again, i said if scot win with a bonus point , scotland through, but just thinking it over, if scot win with bonus point theyll have max 5 pts, but japan could still get 2 points for tries and losing under 7 , so japan go through.
scot win with 1 bonus point qualify if japan no bonus points scot win with 1 bonus point japan qualify with 1 or 2 bonus point scot win no bonus point , japan qualify with 1 or 2 bonus point scot win no bonus point , scot qualify if japan no bonus point
bonus point winning team can only have 1 bonus point for 4 tries or more bonus point losing team can have 1 bonus point for 4 tries + or 1 bonus point for losing by 7 pts or less I THINK THATS BETTER AND COVERED IT.
scot win with 1 bonus point qualify if japan no bonus points scot win with 1 bonus point japan qualify with 1 or 2 bonus point scot win no bonus point , japan qualify with 1 or 2 bonus point scot win no bonus point , scot qualify if japan no bonu
so if japan-scotland gets cancelled, that's 2 points for each, japan obviously go through but ireland still have to play samoa so would likely win the group if they get a bonus point and have more points "for" than japan, is that right??
so if japan-scotland gets cancelled, that's 2 points for each, japan obviously go through but ireland still have to play samoa so would likely win the group if they get a bonus point and have more points "for" than japan, is that right??
think japan would win the group on HTH if they finish on level points but pretty sure unlike england and france they'll make every effort to play the japan scotland game
think japan would win the group on HTH if they finish on level points but pretty sure unlike england and france they'll make every effort to play the japan scotland game
be no credibility for the tournament otherwise and not a good look just waving the hosts through to the next round. would certainly think they'll try to play it on monday if they can't sunday but beyond that there's just no time realistically
be no credibility for the tournament otherwise and not a good look just waving the hosts through to the next round. would certainly think they'll try to play it on monday if they can't sunday but beyond that there's just no time realistically
I would say the fact Japan will go through makes their game against Scotland even less likely to go ahead if they are able to find an excuse for it not to be played.At one stage it looked like it was the Ireland game under threat and Scotland could benefit from it,now it appears to have swung in the opposite direction for them.
I would say the fact Japan will go through makes their game against Scotland even less likely to go ahead if they are able to find an excuse for it not to be played.At one stage it looked like it was the Ireland game under threat and Scotland could b
just thought there might some flexibility. having booted italy out in similar circumstances although their chance of qualifying was tiny compared to scotland the organisers really got nowhere to go
everyone agreed to these ludicrous rules before the tourney so you can't really go complaining or running to rumpole whey they come into play
just thought there might some flexibility. having booted italy out in similar circumstances although their chance of qualifying was tiny compared to scotland the organisers really got nowhere to goeveryone agreed to these ludicrous rules before the t
Agree that all teams agreed to the rules prior to the competition,but in fairness they probably never expected them to actually come into play with an act of god like a Typhoon.
Agree that all teams agreed to the rules prior to the competition,but in fairness they probably never expected them to actually come into play with an act of god like a Typhoon.
Hopefully for Scotland the game goes ahead,and the best team goes through on merit(could still be Japan) but if the game wasn't to go ahead I fully understand why Scotland would be upset and feel hard done by.
Hopefully for Scotland the game goes ahead,and the best team goes through on merit(could still be Japan) but if the game wasn't to go ahead I fully understand why Scotland would be upset and feel hard done by.
Yep would have to agree.I think the main gripe everyone has is that the rule should have been if anything like this happened the games got rescheduled,rather than called a draw. Defiantly think they could and should have come up with something better when you consider how much time they had for the pre planning of the whole tournament.I had no idea Japan had a typhoon season,but surely this should have been looked into more thoroughly if they were aware this was a strong possibility.
Yep would have to agree.I think the main gripe everyone has is that the rule should have been if anything like this happened the games got rescheduled,rather than called a draw.Defiantly think they could and should have come up with something better
Trouble is weather can ruin most things,look at cricket can be ahead for 4 days then bad light comes along and its a draw. If you agree with the rules its no good complaining when they dont go your way. (almost brexit like)
Trouble is weather can ruin most things,look at cricket can be ahead for 4 days then bad light comes along and its a draw.If you agree with the rules its no good complaining when they dont go your way. (almost brexit like)
Yeah very true.I just wonder how much choice the teams were given or if they were told this is what happens in the case of postponed games. Water under the bridge now anyway,it is what it is I guess.
Yeah very true.I just wonder how much choice the teams were given or if they were told this is what happens in the case of postponed games.Water under the bridge now anyway,it is what it is I guess.
A bit of a joke that these teams plan a 4 year cycle around this 1 event, then can be eliminated by the weather Crazy
Looks like no team got eliminated by the weather in the end although I am sure Scotland will be making a legal challenge to their defeat by Japan!
The Nips should not be in a World Cup Quarter Final, that is an unwritten law!
Further more to all of you who think teams like Japan should not be in this tournament...well I am too polite!
I would concede the format is too long! If they could get it down to 4 weeks that would be great but it is a physically demanding game. There are more than 8 teams with a chance of progression and that is good for the Union!
I was extremely impressed by Uruguay today. Ok they lost to second string Wales but they played good rugby. Well done. Send them some money and coaches to improve! They deserve it!
A bit of a joke that these teams plan a 4 year cycle around this 1 event, then can be eliminated by the weather CrazyLooks like no team got eliminated by the weather in the end although I am sure Scotland will be making a legal challenge to their def
elisjohn • October 11, 2019 3:34 PM BST just one thing about the rwc its too long, and far too much un competitive matches, its great that little teams are in , but maybe , 4 groups of 4, ok 4 teams would miss out . then teams would have 1 less group game,and the length would be shortened by at least a week, and also definetly then much more competitive group matches.
agree with you whispering, it is too long,
elisjohn • October 11, 2019 3:34 PM BSTjust one thing about the rwc its too long, and far too much un competitive matches, its great that little teams are in , but maybe , 4 groups of 4, ok 4 teams would miss out . then teams would have 1 less gr
I had all of the 4 qf line ups right on Oct 8 and I see no reason to change my prediction of the sf and final. My only bet is on Japan again to beat SA.
I had all of the 4 qf line ups right on Oct 8 and I see no reason to change my prediction of the sf and final. My only bet is on Japan again to beat SA.
FELTFAIR 08 Sep 19 20:43Joined: 01 Jun 10 | Topic/replies: 6,222 | Blogger: FELTFAIR's blog Will back New Zealand and South Africa. I anticipate either to win their group which will then split them up from a quarter final and if successful from a semi final standpoint. Meet again in the final. That`s the plan.
Plan still on target.
FELTFAIR 08 Sep 19 20:43Joined: 01 Jun 10 | Topic/replies: 6,222 | Blogger: FELTFAIR's blogWill back New Zealand and South Africa. I anticipate either to win their group which will then split them up from a quarter final and if successful from a semi
Wales were awful. Can they play that badly two weeks in a row? Well Ireland managed to play badly after beating Scotland so I think yes. I did think it would be an awesome confrontation with the Welsh fronting up. I am sure they have pride but cannot see them getting past South Africa. At some point SA will click and if it against Wales it will be carnage.
It is a semi and these things are usually done with a fine margin so I will not rule Wales out completely.
France finally sand the Marseillaise. They were desperately unlucky. It was a forward pass and Ntamack missed 5 points.
Can't call NZ v England. NZ are a better side but I don't rule out England under Jedi Master Eddie! England could win if the stars are aligned. They have everything to front NZ but NZ are as tough as teak. Something has to crack.
Wales were awful. Can they play that badly two weeks in a row? Well Ireland managed to play badly after beating Scotland so I think yes. I did think it would be an awesome confrontation with the Welsh fronting up. I am sure they have pride but cannot
Well done to Wales. Didn't think they would have enough. SA were very disappointing and negative but I guess that sometimes how finals are won.
Good luck to them kicking back to England in the final. I thought Faf's kicking was excellent. Plenty of height and distance giving the chasers plenty of time to mark their target. Wales high kicks on the other hand were poorly directed lacking distance and the kick chase was even worse.
It was a demanding match but SA look like coming through without injury. I just think England have the stars aligned. They have an amazing team and strength off the bench. I don't think the Boks will roll over but still I wouldn't be surprised to see England stretch away from them. Finals are usually tight but England are playing with so much confidence.
The Boks 7 Du Toit was like Thrush today. I expect to see a batle royale with him next week
Well done to Wales. Didn't think they would have enough. SA were very disappointing and negative but I guess that sometimes how finals are won.Good luck to them kicking back to England in the final. I thought Faf's kicking was excellent. Plenty of he
Wales are not the Brazil of Rugby. It is a tiny country with limited resources. Those resources were stretched thinly today. You can only play with what you have. SA on the other hand are giants of the game. I take your point. I wouldn't call it the worst game. It was a titanic arm wrestle yes, not good rugby true but was played with incredible intensity and commitment by both sides.
Wales are not the Brazil of Rugby. It is a tiny country with limited resources. Those resources were stretched thinly today. You can only play with what you have. SA on the other hand are giants of the game. I take your point. I wouldn't call it the
Wales said they would not miss the 2 players out through injury but no one mentioned that you need back-ups on the bench and their third choices were non existent. Wales are a small country but so are New Zealand and Ireland.
Wales said they would not miss the 2 players out through injury but no one mentioned that you need back-ups on the bench and their third choices were non existent. Wales are a small country but so are New Zealand and Ireland.