Rugby
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
England: 15 Ben Foden, 14 Chris Ashton, 13 Owen Farrell, 12 Brad Barritt, 11 David Strettle, 10 Charlie Hodgson, 9 Ben Youngs, 1 Alex Corbisiero, 2 Dylan Hartley, 3 Dan Cole, 4 Mouritz Botha, 5 Tom Palmer, 6 Tom Croft, 7 Chris Robshaw, 8 Phil Dowson
Replacements: 16 Rob Webber, 17 Matt Stevens, 18 Geoff Parling, 19 Ben Morgan, 20 Lee Dickson, 21 Jordan Turner-Hall, 22 Mike Brown
Replacements: 16 Rob Webber, 17 Matt Stevens, 18 Geoff Parling, 19 Ben Morgan, 20 Lee Dickson, 21 Jordan Turner-Hall, 22 Mike Brown
Show More
Rugby Union has the most incompetent referees of any sport 
Rugby Union has the most incompetent referees of any sport
where the feck is the scot adv???
Clancy having a total mare here
Clancy having a total mare here
where did the penalty go then? refs gone mad
wtf did he do? overlap
incompetence abounds
wtf did he do? overlap
incompetence abounds
how does clancy get away with not eve giving the 10 secs advanatge on the other play?
total chimps tea party
ref the worst what a c o c k
and i'm a eng fan
ref the worst what a c o c k
and i'm a eng fan
This is ****ing extraordinary.
Tries not given, walk-ins utterly bombed, terrible fly-halves charged down. If England win this they will not be able to work out how.
Tries not given, walk-ins utterly bombed, terrible fly-halves charged down. If England win this they will not be able to work out how.
Scot have been robbed here. SHould have been a decent chance to be only 1 behind. Bad vid ref decision and then clancy lost the plot and forgot the pen
the Welsh will be looking forward to playing England I reckon
feck me they are **** today
feck me they are **** today
Scots didnt seem to complain about the pen not given for some reason, did they all forget too?
Feb 4, 2012 -- 6:34PM, gentlemanjohn wrote:
Scots didnt seem to complain about the pen not given for some reason, did they all forget too?
he probably called advantage ovger after 3secs..thought it was a bit odd he actually gave it in the 1st place as it would have meant scot getting 3
still holding out for 13/13 'ere, scots to score in last 2mins & then concede pen at the ko to give a last second tie 
Was clancy same guy who allowed the wales try against ireland last year from the illegal line-out?
that would be nice furelli
major flaw in that is scot try
major flaw in that is scot try
I don't give two **** about the penalty that Clancy forgot. Scotland had a chance to score a try, scored a try, therefore advantage is over.
The problem is the missing 5 points.
The problem is the missing 5 points.
when the coaches watch the DVD of this match they are gonna need a puke bucket
coz all these errors are sick making
coz all these errors are sick making
yep he sure well is irish...realised how stupid that was soon as i posted the damn thing!!!
scotland being robbed but not by england so sweaties dont blame us blame the officials
I am hoping that Sunday's game offers a lot more than Saturday's torrid affairs.
Not sure why I look forward to the start of the Six Nations!
At least Scotland have looked like scoring, They just cant find the last pass.
Not sure why I look forward to the start of the Six Nations!
At least Scotland have looked like scoring, They just cant find the last pass.
how is that not a pen.. Leave it 20 twice and no pen
when the boyos play england they are surely gonna do a number on them
they are ****
they are ****
"LEAVE IT 22 LEAVE IT 22 LEAVE IT 22 "
YOU ARE A CROOKED JOKE CLANCY!
YOU ARE A CROOKED JOKE CLANCY!
Mr. Purple Joined: 07 Feb 08
Replies: 236 04 Feb 12 18:41
how is that not a pen.. Leave it 20 twice and no pen
Beggars belief mate. Nothing more frustrating than a ref saying something, but not backing it up. Absurd.
Scotland have had a rough ride from the officials, but have done themselves up even worse.
Replies: 236 04 Feb 12 18:41
how is that not a pen.. Leave it 20 twice and no pen
Beggars belief mate. Nothing more frustrating than a ref saying something, but not backing it up. Absurd.
Scotland have had a rough ride from the officials, but have done themselves up even worse.
Max Evans the only quality player Scotland have at the moment
poor game, contested by two incompetent teams and officiated by idiots
I always thought clancy was decent until this today, its that bad it cant be for real...
Hopeless 6, Clueless 13, & the Ref 'Useless' around about -18
Every fking time a mistake from Scotland, sh!tting themselves.
both sides will get destroyed by france..both will get beat by italy!
when they have the team review there is going to be so much groaning, rolling of eyes, slapping of foreheads and realisation that they fcked up badly
bout time they allowed promotion/relegation play-off between 6n's & Georgia, Georgia would challenge both these sides for sure.
Take it he was born in Scotland
Only decent player and he is an import
Only decent player and he is an import
GPT what did you expect??? Scotland should have had that try, replays shown ball was decked by Scotland player. Scotland just don't know how to put pressure on in the final 22
Final analysis on this game. Scotland had only themselves to blame. Too many mistakes, clueless in oppostions 22, Parks brutal, the list could go on & on.
Blair shoulda been screaming for that ball.... didnt see him my ar$e
I like Robinson but selecting Parks is unacceptable really.
clancy "forgetting" to award the peno afterwards as well dinny help the scots, 1 pt game at that makes it winnable
Looks like it could be a rubbish Six Nations after all. That was a truly terrible advert for the event. Start to end incompetence.
Ah well off to watch Eq Guniea over turn ivory coast now
Scotland worse than expected, England better than expected but only marginally.
One of the most brutal games I have seen for some time.
I ended up well up on the game due to bets placed pre-match, which makes a change at the moment, but haven't been that frustrated about a result since the 2nd Lions test in 2009. Had lumps on the draw and Scotland 1-12 so the video ref and Rennie are high on my list of idiots of the year. Dan Parks was so bad it was unreal though.
Would love to say England won that game, but we all know that's not what happened.
I ended up well up on the game due to bets placed pre-match, which makes a change at the moment, but haven't been that frustrated about a result since the 2nd Lions test in 2009. Had lumps on the draw and Scotland 1-12 so the video ref and Rennie are high on my list of idiots of the year. Dan Parks was so bad it was unreal though.
Would love to say England won that game, but we all know that's not what happened.
There was a stat up on the screen towards the end showing that England had managed 40 phases of play in the match.
To put that into context, Munster went through 41 phases in a single move to set up a drop goal against Northampton in the Heineken Cup.
That was horrible today. As bad a spectacle as you'd see in any sport.
To put that into context, Munster went through 41 phases in a single move to set up a drop goal against Northampton in the Heineken Cup.
That was horrible today. As bad a spectacle as you'd see in any sport.
standard calcutta cup match up at Murrayfield. The BBC comms seemed genuinely surprised the game was a total bag of shyte.
That is always the most likely outcome of this fixture these days.
That is always the most likely outcome of this fixture these days.
Surprised by some of the comments here. Clancy did very little wrong in that match as far as I'm concerned... and I generally think he's a guesser. Scotland had the chance to score a try 20 metres ahead of where the advantage was given, before it (the try) wasn't given, so that's advantage over as far as I'm concerned.
Kriskin above sums it up well for me and Parks wasn't even the worst player on the pitch. Ben Youngs was abysmal in every facet of play.
tell me big dunc if laidlaw had gone for a DG & missed rather than chip ahead what would have happened???
you know full well they would have gone straight back for the pen, the ONLY advantage Scotland could have gained from the chip ahead was scoring a try otherwise (to state the bleeding obvious) where the fek is the advantage over the pen. The TMO took so long to make his mind up (incorrectly) that the ref forgot, simple as that.
can't believe no scotland player reminded him though.
he also did nothing about foden's deliberate knock on which cost a try scoring opportunity & should have been a yellow card.
you know full well they would have gone straight back for the pen, the ONLY advantage Scotland could have gained from the chip ahead was scoring a try otherwise (to state the bleeding obvious) where the fek is the advantage over the pen. The TMO took so long to make his mind up (incorrectly) that the ref forgot, simple as that.
can't believe no scotland player reminded him though.
he also did nothing about foden's deliberate knock on which cost a try scoring opportunity & should have been a yellow card.
That is very much the problem NL. If you asked Scotland if they would like a kick for 3, or an outside chance of a try where their winger has to outpace 2 players who are ahead of him and then ground the ball, which is bouncing all over the place, which do you think they would take?
Advantage law is to get the game going and prevent negativity, but if teams are penalised for trying anything they will simply have to stop doing it and take kicks instead.
Advantage law is to get the game going and prevent negativity, but if teams are penalised for trying anything they will simply have to stop doing it and take kicks instead.
it's on the bbc i player. the pen was inside the 22 the kick came from the next phase of play and advantage over was never called. the dozy fekker forgot.
i think one of the players did ask about it after all, you can hear the ref say no to something.
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539