
Nov 10, 2020 -- 12:20AM, eyeball wrote:
In your opinion .
No, the meta analyses aren’t in my opinion. That’s kind of the point about meta analysis. You need to look at actual trials of treatment, really double blinded trials, rather than non causal associations and lab stuff about immune mediation. There was loads of excitement about vitamin D 15 or so years ago but the actual evidence of benefit from trials of supplementation is not much better than marginal.
There’s a very famous story of how a set of well constructed treatment trials into using drugs post heart attack to reduce extra heart beats demonstrated that what had seemed like very sensible practice based on mechanism was actually killing large numbers of patients.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199103213241201
You don’t just need evidence, you need the right kind of evidence.


Nov 16, 2020 -- 4:38PM, nineteen points wrote:
some folk will be rubbing their hands thinking of the money to be made from this pandemic.
A lot of folk have been rubbing their hands all along, especially folk with the inside track to the top levels of the Tory Party.
Lfc, I’ll be sure to tell you.
Nov 16, 2020 -- 4:51PM, lfc1971 wrote:
normal people should get the vaccine sooner
As opposed to the abnormal people who are currently at the front of the queue?
Nov 16, 2020 -- 5:12PM, lfc1971 wrote:
no I wasn’t making any personal references to yourself fatslogger It’s just a general point
I know, but I was amused anyway.
Nov 16, 2020 -- 5:18PM, lfc1971 wrote:
19 has gone quiet
Maybe he’s getting treatment.
Nov 16, 2020 -- 5:53PM, nineteen points wrote:
so doctors have to forsake their path for flu?
As in not treat people who didn’t have a vaccine? No, of course not.
Nov 16, 2020 -- 7:59PM, Dotchinite wrote:
It wont put others in danger if they have had their vaccination.
It will, at least to an extent. The vaccine isn’t 100% effective so herd immunity will be part of protecting the vulnerable.