North American
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
who would win?
its a toughee i think, best qbs are white but best WR n RB are black
hmm?
its a toughee i think, best qbs are white but best WR n RB are black
hmm?
Show More
Really?
THAT'S your contribution to a football forum?
THAT'S your contribution to a football forum?
Not even worth replying too. Go join the soccer forum.
why is it not worth replying to?
black team would win about 50-7
no decent white running backs in nfl are there?
mcnabbs an awesome QB so no disadvantage there
black team would win about 50-7
no decent white running backs in nfl are there?
mcnabbs an awesome QB so no disadvantage there
its a forum, a debate,
sorry for asking a question on a forum
too may **s on this forum trying to be make funny remarks at every chance
sorry for asking a question on a forum
too may **s on this forum trying to be make funny remarks at every chance
White team:
QB: Peyton Manning
FB: Jacob Hester
RB: Peyton Hillis
LT: Joe Thomas
LG: Logan Mankins
C: Nick Mangold
RG: Chris Snee
RT: David Stewart
TE: Jason Witten
WR: Wes Welker
WR: Kevin Walter
____________________________________________________
DE: Jared Allen
DT: Kelly Gregg
DT: Mike Wright
DE: Chris Long
OLB: Brian Cushing
MLB: Stewart Bradley
OLB: Chris Gocong
FS: Jim Leonhard
SS: Sean Considine
CB: Eric Weddle
CB: Kevin Kaesviharn
K: Stephen Gostkowski
P: Shane Lechler
Coach: Bill Belichick
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Black team:
QB: Donovan McNabb
FB: Le'Ron McClain
RB: Adrian Peterson
LT: Ryan Clady
LG: Carl Nicks
C: Jamaal Jackson
RG: Jahri Evans
RT: Vernon Carey
TE: Antonio Gates
WR: Larry Fitzgerald
WR: Andre Johnson
__________________________________________________________________
DE: Robert Mathis
DT: Kevin Williams
DT: Vince Wilfork
DE: Dwight Freeney
OLB: James Harrison
MLB: Patrick Willis
OLB: Thomas Davis
FS: Ed Reed
SS: Brian Dawkins
CB: Nnamdi Asomugha
CB: Darelle Revis
K: Rodney Williams
P: Reggie Hodges
Coach: Mike Tomlin
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Okay, some artistic license taken there, there are no white starting cornerbacks in the NFL, and haven't been since Jason Sehorn. Kaesviharn has played there though, and Eric Weddle probably could. As for the Black guys, there hasn't been a black placekicker in about 20 years, and Reggie Hodges was the last black punter in the league. I've used Rodney Williams as the kicker.
So looking at it, the white team (IMO) has the edge at QB (to be fair, you could have put 6 or 7 guys here and they'd have had the edge), on the O-line (that would be some O-line), TE and in the kicking game. The black guys have the edge at RB, WR, Linebacker and in the secondary. I'd call the D-line's even.
Whilst the Black team has the better defense overall and the better playmakers on offense, I think the white team with that O-line and Manning at QB, would get enough going offensively to keep the scores level or maybe even in front, and would likely have the edge in the fourth quarter where Manning and Welker are at their best.
Plus having Belichick as coach would give them a cerebral edge in gameplanning and in-game adjustments.
It would be a great game, that's for sure.
QB: Peyton Manning
FB: Jacob Hester
RB: Peyton Hillis
LT: Joe Thomas
LG: Logan Mankins
C: Nick Mangold
RG: Chris Snee
RT: David Stewart
TE: Jason Witten
WR: Wes Welker
WR: Kevin Walter
____________________________________________________
DE: Jared Allen
DT: Kelly Gregg
DT: Mike Wright
DE: Chris Long
OLB: Brian Cushing
MLB: Stewart Bradley
OLB: Chris Gocong
FS: Jim Leonhard
SS: Sean Considine
CB: Eric Weddle
CB: Kevin Kaesviharn
K: Stephen Gostkowski
P: Shane Lechler
Coach: Bill Belichick
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Black team:
QB: Donovan McNabb
FB: Le'Ron McClain
RB: Adrian Peterson
LT: Ryan Clady
LG: Carl Nicks
C: Jamaal Jackson
RG: Jahri Evans
RT: Vernon Carey
TE: Antonio Gates
WR: Larry Fitzgerald
WR: Andre Johnson
__________________________________________________________________
DE: Robert Mathis
DT: Kevin Williams
DT: Vince Wilfork
DE: Dwight Freeney
OLB: James Harrison
MLB: Patrick Willis
OLB: Thomas Davis
FS: Ed Reed
SS: Brian Dawkins
CB: Nnamdi Asomugha
CB: Darelle Revis
K: Rodney Williams
P: Reggie Hodges
Coach: Mike Tomlin
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Okay, some artistic license taken there, there are no white starting cornerbacks in the NFL, and haven't been since Jason Sehorn. Kaesviharn has played there though, and Eric Weddle probably could. As for the Black guys, there hasn't been a black placekicker in about 20 years, and Reggie Hodges was the last black punter in the league. I've used Rodney Williams as the kicker.
So looking at it, the white team (IMO) has the edge at QB (to be fair, you could have put 6 or 7 guys here and they'd have had the edge), on the O-line (that would be some O-line), TE and in the kicking game. The black guys have the edge at RB, WR, Linebacker and in the secondary. I'd call the D-line's even.
Whilst the Black team has the better defense overall and the better playmakers on offense, I think the white team with that O-line and Manning at QB, would get enough going offensively to keep the scores level or maybe even in front, and would likely have the edge in the fourth quarter where Manning and Welker are at their best.
Plus having Belichick as coach would give them a cerebral edge in gameplanning and in-game adjustments.
It would be a great game, that's for sure.
Where peyton manning is jef saturday is surely lol..come on doggy ;) kevin curtis at WR surely
Eric Weddle covering Larry Fitz or AJ?
You could have Tavaris Jackson at QB and they'd put up 60 points!
You could have Tavaris Jackson at QB and they'd put up 60 points!
Whither Donald Igwebuike, DoggyLFC? Could still do a job at PK if he was willing to give up his taxi driving gig.
Nayim 24 Nov 11:42
Eric Weddle covering Larry Fitz or AJ?
You could have Tavaris Jackson at QB and they'd put up 60 points!
With Tavaris Jackson at QB, the White D would likely put up 60 points ;)
And H, I'm no Jets fan, but Mangold is brilliant. Best centre in the league.
Eric Weddle covering Larry Fitz or AJ?
You could have Tavaris Jackson at QB and they'd put up 60 points!
With Tavaris Jackson at QB, the White D would likely put up 60 points ;)
And H, I'm no Jets fan, but Mangold is brilliant. Best centre in the league.
black team quarter back . . . .
would young stake a claim?
would young stake a claim?
Young throws 18-20 short passes per game, he's basically a glorified game manager.
He does make very good decisions and does them well, but he's not a great QB, at least not at this time. Remember he has a very good running game to back him up and he's still putting up very very mediocre numbers.
He does make very good decisions and does them well, but he's not a great QB, at least not at this time. Remember he has a very good running game to back him up and he's still putting up very very mediocre numbers.
Wow! No Troy Polomalu! Some team that can leave him out IMO!!
Polamalu is Polynesian, so doesn't really come into the argument.
with McNabb throwing to Fitzgerald and AJ, both matched up against white CBs, it's a TD every drive. Unless you want to double them both in which case good luck stopping Peterson.
Black team hoses up imo.
Black team hoses up imo.
this is a banker...black team with ease...not even peyton can win with this lot lol
brandon stockley shocking omission (wr)
With those teams it's quite obvious that the white team would win - Bellichek would just **!
basically the white fellas excel where you do not have to have speed.
also, id use dallas clark as the 2nd reciever or anthony gonzales ahead of walters. Yet agree that the Black Team would win as White team secondary would conceed big plays.
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539