Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There are currently 2 people viewing this thread.
I've just been having a look back at this from Monday, and imo a staggering decision, what the apprentice said in her evidence is correct.
On a narrow track she patently became short of room on more than one occasion, and surely should have been given the benefit of the doubt given her obvious inexperience.
Surely this has to be overturned if they appeal?
https://www.racingpost.com/news/reports/big-non-trier-ban-and-two-jockeys-given-14-day-suspensions-on-dramatic-day-at-listowel-apAaj3X8eYny/
"The stewards took a dim view of Sonic Sabiha's run in the opening mile maiden on a dramatic day two of the harvest festival, with trainer David Marnane fined €3,000 under the non-trier rule.
The 50-1 shot appeared to be tenderly handled by inexperienced 10lb claimer Rebecca Parsons, finishing a never-nearer fifth behind Magna Victoria.
In her evidence to the stewards, Parsons said she "got stuck behind a bit of traffic in the home straight so she switched out and then ran tight for room again", but the stewards still found her in breach of rule 212 and suspended her for 14 days, while Sonic Sabiha was banned from running for 60 days."
On a narrow track she patently became short of room on more than one occasion, and surely should have been given the benefit of the doubt given her obvious inexperience.
Surely this has to be overturned if they appeal?
https://www.racingpost.com/news/reports/big-non-trier-ban-and-two-jockeys-given-14-day-suspensions-on-dramatic-day-at-listowel-apAaj3X8eYny/
"The stewards took a dim view of Sonic Sabiha's run in the opening mile maiden on a dramatic day two of the harvest festival, with trainer David Marnane fined €3,000 under the non-trier rule.
The 50-1 shot appeared to be tenderly handled by inexperienced 10lb claimer Rebecca Parsons, finishing a never-nearer fifth behind Magna Victoria.
In her evidence to the stewards, Parsons said she "got stuck behind a bit of traffic in the home straight so she switched out and then ran tight for room again", but the stewards still found her in breach of rule 212 and suspended her for 14 days, while Sonic Sabiha was banned from running for 60 days."
Show More
Was a truly awful ride, did she ever use her whip at all or ride out vigorous during the finish?
I get she is an apprentice, but is that an excuse for showing no effort towards a finish?
I get she is an apprentice, but is that an excuse for showing no effort towards a finish?
The replay seems to show a reasonably clear run in front of her while she makes no effort.
The head-on is unequivocal, as the track narrows in the home straight she sought a clear run but clearly had nowhere to go on two occasions.
If they're going to slur people in such a way and impose harsh penalties based on video evidence, then they need to be 100% sure imo, and I saw nothing to suggest she tried to prevent that horse from running on its merits.
If they're going to slur people in such a way and impose harsh penalties based on video evidence, then they need to be 100% sure imo, and I saw nothing to suggest she tried to prevent that horse from running on its merits.
no where to go perhaps for a moment, that doesn't excuse lack of effort once a clear run George?
I've given my opinion and you're entitled to yours.
One of the worst stewarding decisions I've ever known, imo.
One of the worst stewarding decisions I've ever known, imo.
It's not an opinion George, she had a clear run at several points and made little or no effort when so.
My only gripe is that they don't do same for 'bigger name' jocks
But a 14 day ban for her at this stage is a good sort of warning against riding with no effort in future IMO.
I watched it on sporting life, GEORGE, but no head on. Side view doesn't offer much.
saddo, the head-on showed that what Rebecca Parsons told the stewards, was in fact correct, ie:
She stated that she tried to keep her mount as relaxed as possible in the early stages of the race, then got stuck behind a bit of traffic in the home straight so she switched out and then ran tight for room again
And this on a narrow part of the track where the runners were spread out.
And the stable rep made the point that they had gone hard in front, which I suspect the sectionals will show was correct also, so she was closing on horses stopping in front of her, and probably made it look worse than it actually was.
She stated that she tried to keep her mount as relaxed as possible in the early stages of the race, then got stuck behind a bit of traffic in the home straight so she switched out and then ran tight for room again
And this on a narrow part of the track where the runners were spread out.
And the stable rep made the point that they had gone hard in front, which I suspect the sectionals will show was correct also, so she was closing on horses stopping in front of her, and probably made it look worse than it actually was.
I would be confident of winning an Appeal here.
They went off like their tails were on fire in front and anything coming from behind was flattered
They went off like their tails were on fire in front and anything coming from behind was flattered
She gave it a good ride.Shame on the stewards for treating a young Jockey like that.
wouldn't do that to an AOB horse in a million years
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539