Forums
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
mackies-fc
05 Feb 19 07:00
Joined:
Date Joined: 29 Feb 12
| Topic/replies: 3,094 | Blogger: mackies-fc's blog
ALL WELCOME TO JOIN AT ANY TIME ***

Overall  leaderboards over on Your Comps forum.

IMPORTANT NOTICES

To ensure the input of selections into the scoring spreadsheet is efficient and timely, could compers please take care to do the following -

1. Leave at least a line of space at the top and bottom of your selections, so for example -

Dickie Le Davoir
Ingleby Arch NAP
Stand Guard
General Tufto
La Estrella
Desert Strike

Good luck all

Is fine, but not -


Dickie Le Davoir
Ingleby Arch NAP
Stand Guard
General Tufto
La Estrella
Desert Strike
Good luck all (ie no line of space after the last selection).

2. Count your selections and make sure you haven't missed any races out

3. Name the selections. Dont just type 'FAV' or use race card numbers

4. Have your picks in 15 mins before the first race.

Thank you

First race: 1.50pm



ALL SELECTIONS MUST BE POSTED BEFORE
1.35pm

One selection per race
One nap per meeting

Winner selected scores 7 points
Second selected scores 3 points
Third selected scores 1 point

If SP is greater than 6/1 points are doubled
If SP is greater than 12/1 points are trebled
If SP is greater than 20/1 points are quadrupled
If SP IS EVENS OR SHORTER POINTS ARE HALVED (i.e a 4/7 winner scores 3.5, a napped 10/11 second scores 3)

All nap points won are doubled.

Any non-runners (which can be substituted at any time before the off) will automatically go on the favourite.

Non-Running Naps will be transferred to the selection in the Lucky Last (unless clearly instructed that you wish to make another of your selections, which has yet to run,  your nap). In the event the selection in the last is a n/r, the nap will transfer to the selection in the penultimate race and so on in the event that is also a n/r

In the event of joint or co- favourites for competition purposes the lowest racecard number will be treated as the favourite
Pause Switch to Standard View ++2018/19 Smiffy memorial AW Comp...
Show More
Loading...
Report Virgin February 5, 2019 2:11 PM GMT
Kempton STANDARD TO SLOW

Naughty Nigel
Poor Auld Paddy (Nap)
Magic Mirror
Wimpole Hall
Roman Spinner
Tin Fandango

Cheers Mackies gl
Report hollyday February 5, 2019 5:50 PM GMT
Sir Ox
Carriageway
Magic Mirror
Red Force One
Enthaar
Atomic Jack   NAP

Thanks Mackies
Report uptheboro February 5, 2019 7:53 PM GMT
Picture Poet
Tavus
Voi (Nap)
Technological
Enthaar
Casa Comigo

Cheers
Report angeleyz February 5, 2019 8:14 PM GMT
picture poet
poor auld paddy (nap)
alacritas
thaqaffa
kyllachy dragon
atomic jack

ty mackies
Report Shanelee1966 February 5, 2019 8:20 PM GMT
Naughty Nigel
Moonlit Sea
Magic Mirror
Villette
Roman Spinner (nap)
Queen Of Paris

Thanks,
Report buffythebookieslayer February 5, 2019 8:28 PM GMT
Lieutenant Conde
Tavus
Cash N Carrie
Kaser Nap
Enthaar
Queen Of Paris

Thanks
Report posy February 5, 2019 8:54 PM GMT
sir ox
percy alexander
chantresse
technological   nap
enthaar
casa comigo
Report Reynard February 5, 2019 9:07 PM GMT
Sir Ox
Moonlit Sea
Chantresse
Villette
Enthaar (NAP)
Rare

Cheers and good luck all .
Report s.kenbo February 6, 2019 6:27 AM GMT
Bi Markee
Don Jupp
Voi
Kaser
Fuwairt
Queen Of Paris NAP
Report TheNorfolkMafia February 6, 2019 8:15 AM GMT
Naughty Nigel
Moonlit Sea
Power Home
Red Force One
Fuwairt (NAP)
Butterfield
Report Smar Tarse February 6, 2019 8:25 AM GMT
Biz Markee
Moonlit Sea
Voi
Villette
Roman Spinner
Rare   NAp
Report Black Emperor February 6, 2019 9:46 AM GMT
Biz Markee
Moonlit Sea
Magic Mirror
Villette
Enthaar
Masters Apprentice (nap)
Report cosmik debris February 6, 2019 10:25 AM GMT
sir ox nap
gold fleece
lulu star
wimpole street
florencio
percy proscecco

cheers
Report lockup February 6, 2019 10:57 AM GMT
Biz Markee
Tavus
Cash N Carrie(nap)
Wimpole Hall
Roman Spinner
Casa Comigo

thanks gl all
   
well done Kenbo.
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 11:11 AM GMT
Lieutenant Conde
Wan Chai
Magic Mirror ( NAP)
Villette
Enthaar
Casa Comigo

PAT

Sir Ox
Poor Auld Paddy (NAP)
Cash N Carrie
Red Force One
Roman Spinner
Tin Fandango


YES--I will stay awake till 5.00pm--so can do I/R
Report Billposter February 6, 2019 11:19 AM GMT
Biz Markee
Moonlit Sea
Voi
Gawdawpalin
Smokey Lane nap
Rare



Well done S.Kenbo on your win Cool Thanks George.B
Report qqking. February 6, 2019 11:45 AM GMT
Sir Ox
Percy Alexander
Lulu Star (nap)
Technological
Enthaar
Casa Comigo
Report ReynardJr February 6, 2019 12:32 PM GMT
Reynard Jr (ThatFoxInTheBox)

Sir Ox
Don Jupp
Chantresse
Galactic Spirit
Enthaar (NAP)
Rare

Good Luck :)
Report lux February 6, 2019 12:45 PM GMT
maared
moonlit sea
magic mirror
galactic spirit
smokey lane
Queen of paris (nap)

cheers gl
Report Virgin February 6, 2019 12:56 PM GMT
Gabrial The Giant for n/r Naughty Nigel Ta
Report GEORGE.B February 6, 2019 1:14 PM GMT
Um Shama
Don Jupp
Alacritas Nap
Thaqaffa
Fuwairt
Betsalottie

Good luck all
Report haplessamatuer February 6, 2019 1:36 PM GMT
Um Shama
Don Jupp
magic mirror
galactic spirit
Enthaar (NAP)
Rare


the old sandwich system

be lucky all
Report dukeofpuke February 6, 2019 1:39 PM GMT
Um Shama
Tavus
Princess Harley
Thaqaffa NAP
Florencio
Crindle Carr
Report mackies-fc February 6, 2019 1:40 PM GMT
Sir Ox
Tavus
Cash n carrie
Wimpole hall
Kyllachy dragon
Casa comigo nap

Gl everyone
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 1:45 PM GMT
3 after cut off time ???

new rules state---not allowed ??
Report GEORGE.B February 6, 2019 1:46 PM GMT
They're all on a final warming Roy Wink
Report pumphol. February 6, 2019 1:48 PM GMT
I assume I may be too late I thought it was wolver for some reason.
As a couple of others have posted late I understand if this is void though

Biz Markee
Tavus
Cash N Carrie
Galactic spirit
Smokey lane
Queen Of Paris Nap

Thanks
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 2:02 PM GMT
Might as well make rules--can post upto first race time.

will now have to add these 4 to my sheets of paper---scores will be late !
Report pumphol. February 6, 2019 2:06 PM GMT
I only posted because others had after the time, fully understand the line has to be drawn somewhere, mind you we are half way there & up till now not missed a meeting which is kind of a miracle Silly
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 2:15 PM GMT
scores after race 1

Cosmik=======14
Hollyday======7
Shane=========7
Posy==========7
Reynard=======7
TNM===========7
PAT===========7
QQking========7
Mackies=======7
That fox======6
uptheboro=====6
Angel=========6
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 2:21 PM GMT
Delay at Kempton--jockey(Rob Havlin I believe--after Beehaar was brought down)taken to hospital
Report Virgin February 6, 2019 2:23 PM GMT
By Bruce Jackson - 12 minutes agoBruce JacksonLATEST
Kempton (AW) latest: Havlin update
Rab Havlin was able to get into the ambulance unaided and is going to hospital for a check-up with a possible shoulder injury.
Report Virgin February 6, 2019 2:29 PM GMT
By Bruce Jackson - 2 minutes agoBruce JacksonLATEST
Kempton (AW) latest: few more minutes
The ambulance is back and in position so the jockeys are coming out for the next, which is likely to be 15 minutes late off.
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 2:48 PM GMT
after race 2

Cosmik===========17
That Fox=========13
George============9
Hapless===========9
Mackies===========7
Shane=============7
Posy==============7
Reynard===========7
Kenbo=============7
PAT===============7
QQking============7
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 3:14 PM GMT
table after race 3

upthboro===========20
Cosmik=============17
Kenbo==============14
That Fox===========13
Hapless============12
Hollyday===========10
Shane==============10
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 3:45 PM GMT
table after race 4

uptheboro===========27
Posy================21
Cosmic==============17
Kenbo===============14
QQking==============14
Hollyday============13
Hapless=============12
Shane===============11
PAT=================10
Pat's Plaything=====10
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 3:46 PM GMT
TNM==========10
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 3:47 PM GMT
That fox=========13


my number of post's are rising fast !!
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 4:18 PM GMT
one race to go

uptheboro===========27
TNM=================24
Posy================21
Kenbo===============21
Cosmic==============17
Shane===============17
George==============16
QQking==============14
Hollyday============13
PAT=================13
That Fox============13
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 6, 2019 4:46 PM GMT
table--unofficial

joint 1st---Hollyday & uptheboro===27 points

3rd joint--Cosmok & TNM============24

5th joint--Posy & Kimbo============21

7th PAT============================19
8th Shane==========================17
9th George=========================16
10th QQking========================14


I think !
Report Shanelee1966 February 6, 2019 5:32 PM GMT
Well done winners CoolCool
Report GEORGE.B February 6, 2019 5:42 PM GMT
Cheers Roy

Well done to hollyday and uptheboro who tie for first place. It was close for all places with cosmik debris and TheNorfolkMafia sharing the spoils for 3rd / 4th.

Well done also to the rest of the top 10.

The leaderboard will be updated shortly.

    Position        Competitor        Score   
    1        hollyday         27   
    1        uptheboro        27   
    3        cosmik debris        24   
    3        TheNorfolkMafia        24   
    5        s.kenbo        21   
    5        posy        21   
    7        Pat        19   
    8        Shanelee1966        17   
    9        George.B        16   
    10        ThatFoxInTheBox        14   
    10        qqking        14   
    12        angeleyz        13   
    13        Virgin        12   
    13        hapless amatuer        12   
    15        Smar Tarse        11   
    15        Billposter        11   
    17        PAT'S PLAYTHING        10   
    18        Reynard        8   
    19        mackies fc        7   
    20        lux        5   
    21        Black Emperor        4   
    22        lockup        3   
    23        pumphol        2   
    23        dukeofpuke        2   
    25        buffythebookieslayer        0   
Report posy February 6, 2019 5:50 PM GMT
George what's to be done with the 15 minute rule ??

Either it is applied in similar fashion to the 1 hour rule in the naps competition or it's scrapped.I don't really mind which route we go down however it's pointless having a rule that's ignored.
Report posy February 6, 2019 5:51 PM GMT
Well done hollyday and utb and thanks Roy and George.
Report hollyday February 6, 2019 5:54 PM GMT
Grincheers well done uptheboro tt thanks George
Report GEORGE.B February 6, 2019 5:55 PM GMT
Up to mackies. posy

personally, I favour the 15 minute rule, cuz if you allow up to the off, you then have people posting after they've jumped for the first, and we're in a similar situation. So a line has to be drawn somewhere.


The other good point about the 15 min rule is that no potential advantage can be gained from seeing the likely off odds eg 10/11 or 11/10, 6/1 or 7/1
Report lockup February 6, 2019 6:00 PM GMT
wd winners
Report Virgin February 6, 2019 6:00 PM GMT
hollyday  Cool

Cheers George

Makes no difference today but rules is rules so make an example of them and ban them for a couple of days (imo) Devil
Report TheNorfolkMafia February 6, 2019 6:08 PM GMT
A couple of days?

How about a couple of months!

To let some of us catch up!
Report posy February 6, 2019 6:10 PM GMT
Take your point George (and it's quite compelling) about the first race odds.

Suggest everybody is now on a yellow card and it's applied...unless Mackies decrees otherwise.
Report angeleyz February 6, 2019 6:41 PM GMT
lol skinto
Report angeleyz February 6, 2019 6:42 PM GMT
well done hollyday and utb

ty george
Report Billposter February 7, 2019 8:16 PM GMT
Well done Hollyday and Uptheboroon your win Cool Thanks George.B and Mackies-Fc
Report mackies-fc February 8, 2019 7:42 AM GMT
On the 15 minute rule..

My understanding was it was implemented to allow anyone scoring in-running time to input selections into a spreadsheet.

When I've scored I've not done in running scores nor used a spreadsheet for that matter. As a result I've always allowed some leniency. Pumphol has been playing longer than me and in that time I'm barely aware of any late posts so I'm more than happy to let today pass.

Should anyone be continually posting late then obviously we would have to address that. And obviously anything after the off would never be allowed.

Hope everybody feels this is fair. I don't feel this is the sort of comp where a hard line stance is required.
Report posy February 8, 2019 9:16 AM GMT
mackies thanks for posting. Can i put up a compromise suggestion which covers George's point regarding the first race betting shows and the advantage that could perhaps be gleaned from that and also shows some leniency to those posters who perhaps unwittingly misss the 15 minute deadline. The suggestion is that if someone's post is timed within the 15 minute zone then the selection in the first race only is voided and the remaining race selections stand.
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 11:11 AM GMT
What you mean posy is another rule to allow a broken rule to be allowed if it meets the criteria of the new rule Crazy

This makes no sense to me Blush.... someone will be upset either way ...that's what rules are for Devil
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 11:12 AM GMT
Maybe we can have a vote on this Mischief
Report posy February 8, 2019 11:34 AM GMT
Virgin I think i'm suggesting an objective rule to replace what would become a subjective interpretation of the existing rule.
Report mackies-fc February 8, 2019 1:10 PM GMT
posy, I'm absolutely certain that pumphol has not sought to gain any advantage on this occasion. If I felt anyone was abusing any of the rules then obviously its something to look at.

My feelings are though that all regular players adhere to the rules and a degree of flexibility is fair enough.

Virgin, without wishing to get political, allowing a vote probably wouldn't solve anything Wink
Report TheNorfolkMafia February 8, 2019 1:15 PM GMT
It certainly did for Brexit!

Laugh
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 1:35 PM GMT
What about a vote to see if everyone wants a vote or not Devil
Report posy February 8, 2019 2:03 PM GMT
mackies you may have misunderstood me as i've not for one minute suggested that pumphol sought to gain any advantage. He doesn't need to !!

There was a case a couple of weeks ago where qq posted late (again i'm not suggesting anything underhand) and that led to a bit of a debate as to whether or not the 15 minute rule should be strictly enforced and at that point George reminded everyone of its existance. I think you may have been out of the country at the time and missed the conversation.

Since then there have been a further few late received posts and the question was asked as to whether or not the rule should be abandoned and that's where we now are with George having made the valid point that scrapping the rule could lead to an advantage to very late posters.

I reiterate i'm not suggesting anyone has abused the rule;it's just a case of if there is a rule it needs to be adhered to.
Report mackies-fc February 8, 2019 4:46 PM GMT
I do agree posy that the rule should be adhered to.

However the hard core of 25 players who post almost daily over 6 months may have the occasional day where they are a couple of minutes late and i dont feel they should be exempt from posting on those days.

Ill leave it open to the floor...
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 4:59 PM GMT
What .... like a vote Confused

Devil
Report haplessamatuer February 8, 2019 5:57 PM GMT
Have I missed it be BECOMING a SERIOUS comp???DevilDevil

will take it serious next year thenWinkWink
Report Reynard February 8, 2019 5:58 PM GMT
As long as we all know exactly what we're voting for . We can't have people claiming afterwards that those who voted in a certain way "Were not aware of all the facts at the time of voting" . We must also ensure that both campaigns strictly adhere to their expenditure restrictions and that all financial support is completely transparent , in order to ensure a level playing field .
Plain
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 6:27 PM GMT
Obviously Laugh
Report posy February 8, 2019 6:59 PM GMT
Virgin you're a sparky sort of guy so why don't you organise the vote.In my view there are 3 options :

Leave the 15 minute rule as it is ,but strictly enforce it by voiding all selections

Leave the 15 minute rule as it is ,but void the first race only

Delete the 15 minute rule

All entrants showing on George's latest league table eligible to vote
Report Reynard February 8, 2019 7:58 PM GMT
When we have voted do we then offer a substantial pay off to the organising committee in order to get the rules changed and allow 3 years for the negotiations to be completed ? Cool
Report PAT'S PLAYTHING February 8, 2019 8:17 PM GMT
In case my view does not get carried--can it be best of 3--or 5  maybe 7Cool
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 8:34 PM GMT
The committee are going to have a meeting to decide whether this is a worthy use of the committees time....

They will discuss whether there should be a vote...

A sub-committee will meet and discuss whether the committee should hold the meeting in this decade or defer it to a sub-committee ...
Report haplessamatuer February 8, 2019 8:44 PM GMT
bloody'ell
If I posted after 3rd 4th race I'm  still not guaranteed pointsSadSad
so 15mins won't change my finish .
I'll vote out or maybe in, we will seeLaughLaugh
Report Virgin February 8, 2019 8:55 PM GMT
A minute after each race would be my tactic Devil
Report pumphol. February 8, 2019 9:08 PM GMT
Week 11 & that was the first time I have not beaten the deadline, I actually only posted cos three others had posted after the alloted time, I wouldn't have bothered otherwise  knowing I was well late, I have an even simpler solution, if you post 14 min to 1 min before off time, you can still participate but your first race selection will be deemed a loser & if that's a nap it goes on race two.
Report posy February 8, 2019 9:11 PM GMT
pumphol that is exactly what I suggested earlier in the thread and is the option i'd support
Report pumphol. February 8, 2019 9:14 PM GMT
Sorry Posy I never saw that,good idea Wink
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com