The Top 10 TV Racing Pundits - 2018 Update

Just the one female?

oh my days, the diversity mob are after me

Hang on, what % of racing pundits are female?

I'm probably OK with 10% proportionally

10% now, moving towards 30% by 2020.

Amy is proof of that.

I fear my list is lacking in representation from the gay and ethnic minority communities.

Tony Calvin a shocking omission.

A connossieurs (sp) list. Chris Dixon should be higher in my opinion. A good judge of a race.

I wouldn't be so sure George..

presume Zoe has been overlooked because you have her in the presenter not pundit cat?

Ally ?

Yes, presenters a separate category, TheFear

1. Nick Luck
2. Gary O'Brien
3. Lydia Hislop
4. Rishi Persad
5. Alex Steedman
6. Bob Cooper
7. Richard Holies
8. Ed Chamberlain
9. Stuart Machin
10. Angus McNae

Matt Chapman another shocking omission.

I'd probably have Hoiles higher up the list on reflection, he has a good mix of knowledge and presenting manner

Again, just the one female, and this is an area in which they tend to perform better than in punditry.

And what about the shocking omissions?

Hayley.

Shocking omissions, acey? It looks a good list to me.

Actually, there is another female presenter who warrants being in the top 10. Revised placings:

1. Nick Luck
2. Gary O'Brien
3. Lydia Hislop
4. Rishi Persad
5. Gina Bryce
6. Bob Cooper
7. Richard Holies
8. Ed Chamberlain
9. Stuart Machin
10. Angus McNae

And Gina.

Beat you to it!

murtagh for the pundits list for me

It's a good call, TheFear, but fair to say his appearances are sparse?

Not that that should be exclude him from inclusion!

How Rachel makes any list other than ugliest female going FO WORD is beyond me.

doorman99 a George Clooney lookalike..........NAP

Lol

i could easily MUTE 4/5 from the top(pundits) list,possibly around 7 from the presenters  and these are apparently the best?