Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
truehoncho
24 Aug 14 23:58
Joined:
Date Joined: 11 Dec 10
| Topic/replies: 6,716 | Blogger: truehoncho's blog
too much work!!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 4  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 123
By:
Oldgit1
When: 25 Aug 14 00:26
She is never off TV nowadays and probably no longer needs racing.
Who next to be the face of C4 Racing? Will it be another personality to try to draw the public?
By:
Kriskin
When: 25 Aug 14 02:06
Rishi

LaughLaugh
By:
Breedingmad
When: 25 Aug 14 02:50
She wants to work with Greg ****..
By:
Breedingmad
When: 25 Aug 14 02:50
****
By:
Breedingmad
When: 25 Aug 14 02:51
Dutch irrigationLaugh
By:
foolsgold123
When: 25 Aug 14 06:45
Good.
By:
jonjo
When: 25 Aug 14 06:46
Of course she's thinking of quitting, the reception for the new format has been derisory & after single handedly (with some help from Carson perhaps) dragging the BBC racing coverage to 'base level' she wont want to have two verdicts against her......
It was obvious to some what a poor signing she was when channel4 snaffled her services
Racing is a sport based around betting, not around a posh presenter talking up horses trained by her posh friends & being as patronising as humanly possible to the lower echelons lucky enough to watch her broadcasting........
Neither would be my cup of tea personally, but perfect choices for this gig would be Matt Chapman, or Patrick Kinghorn, both of whom can generate some excitement & can speak to the audience as though they are talking to equals.
Balding will be gone for sure & long term that's brilliant for racing imo
By:
millhouse
When: 25 Aug 14 07:35
Well said Jonjo - it's a pretty good bet, imo, that audiences would climb if she were no longer patronising everyone to within an inch of their lives.

The relentless silver spoon industry elitism when she and Jockey Club Nick are fronting the show makes C4 racing in its current form look like a party to which no one is invited, imho...
By:
paul the b
When: 25 Aug 14 08:04
Frankly who gives a damn......if anyone is mad enough to  listen to this silver spoon lot you would soon be visiting the poor house.
I am sick and tired of endless presenters mentioning at least 5 different horses in each race, and if one does happen to win they never stop pontificating about it, as if that was the only horse selected.
What is needed is someone who knows the form book upside down and is able to give a sound and reasoned selection in a race with a running profit and loss per programme.
As I have said on numerous occasions why do you need around 6 or more people to present a racing programme anyway?....it's proof the format does not work with ever more shrinking viewing figures year on year.
Producers keep fooling themselves they are going to attract a growing audience when it simple to deduce, most people only watch horse racing on tv if they already like it ....they are not going to switch on just because so and so is presenting it.
Proof perfect is the BBC dropped racing altogether because  unless your embedded in the sport no one outside of this equine bubble really cares.....imho anyway.
By:
sirdogleashcharnier
When: 25 Aug 14 08:07
Claire is a ravishing young lady
By:
mange
When: 25 Aug 14 08:11
Is there a Doctor in the house ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
By:
barry dennis
When: 25 Aug 14 08:28
agree jonjo, matt chapman or patrick kinghorn perfect choices, but, fear they both have too many skeletons, lydia hislop my vote
By:
hardestgame
When: 25 Aug 14 08:29
wants to spend more time at home with the girlie
By:
drlovepants
When: 25 Aug 14 08:43
Matt Chapman, the b@st@rd love-child of Derek "man of the people/punters pal" Thompson
By:
Johnny_Mustang
When: 25 Aug 14 09:06
Whatever happened to Patrick Kinghorn?
By:
mrcombustible
When: 25 Aug 14 09:12
Glad to see the back of her.
By:
Ramruma
When: 25 Aug 14 09:16
@jonjo & millhouse -- if Clare Balding makes viewers turn off, then there ought to be more viewers when she is not on than when she is. Has anyone checked the ratings data to see if this is actually what happens, or is this just blind prejudice?

And to blame a part-time presenter for the changes in the programme verges on the ridiculous -- that would be down to the producers, and in particular IMG's Carl Hicks -- who previously ran BBC's racing coverage.

@barry dennis -- Lydia Hislop is one of the better racing presenters BUT she did previously have the BBC gig which she quit.
By:
twizzle22
When: 25 Aug 14 09:21
Nauseating and patronising..that's Miss Balding in a nutshell.Cannot abide the woman.Another vote for Lydia here although if she did get the gig don't think McCoy would be too chuffedPlain
By:
Deltâ
When: 25 Aug 14 09:23
Let Taryna front it - - has the experience and knowledge, talks well to camera, more on vogue with her fashion lately, wots not to like!
By:
Deltâ
When: 25 Aug 14 09:24
^ and the eye candy for the team too ..
By:
chelsea girl
When: 25 Aug 14 09:33
Delta.....stop 'stirring' it please, this is a serious discussion.
By:
differentdrum
When: 25 Aug 14 09:40
So what?

She has completely failed to put bums on seats, at least not in front of Channel 4 racing. She is full of unwanted sound bites and her lack of actual knowledge outside the 'homework' is a regular embarrassment. In short she is simply not good enough but unfortunately she has been elevated to a status way beyond her ability. Channel 4 should be rubbing their hands at the thought they could see her leave sooner rather than later.
By:
Outpost
When: 25 Aug 14 09:49
C4 probably realise it's not working but can't afford to get rid of her so they are hoping she walks to save them some money.

having said that I don't think there's anyone who could bring back the audience they are looking for.
By:
Captain Christy
When: 25 Aug 14 09:52
I doubt Chapman would suit it, he actually does talk about racing beyond cliches and is not averse to questioning the integrity of the game.
By:
Ramruma
When: 25 Aug 14 10:01
@Outpost -- C4 probably realise it's not working but can't afford to get rid of her so they are hoping she walks to save them some money.

having said that I don't think there's anyone who could bring back the audience they are looking for.


More likely, Channel 4 is clueless. The problem imo is the format, not a part-time presenter. If Clare was the problem, then Channel 4 would see the increase in audiences on the weeks she is not there. This would also make the solution obvious: replace Clare with whoever fronts the show on those "good", high-audience weeks -- presumably, Nick Luck.
By:
Ibrahima Sonko
When: 25 Aug 14 10:15
Clare is a top notch presenter,  considering she only plays a tiny part in the overall show their is some real crass and personal attacks going on.

Horse racing is in decline, it has nothing to with miss balding.

For wanting a presenter who shouts yahoo says a lot about the viewer.
By:
swift-tuttle
When: 25 Aug 14 10:18
imagine by how much RUK subscriptions would go down if Olivia left to join C4
By:
chelsea girl
When: 25 Aug 14 10:42
Olivia?
By:
A_T
When: 25 Aug 14 10:46
if you're going to quit then quit - stop talking about it comes across as attention-seeking
By:
swift-tuttle
When: 25 Aug 14 10:47
A P O'Brien's pet name for Lydia Chelsea girl
By:
Marcce
When: 25 Aug 14 10:48
If Matt Chapman or Lydia Hislop took over, Channel 4 racing would be dead and gone within 12 months.

If viewing figures are to be believed the regular viewer of Channel 4 racing doesn't want probing questioning, they want the likes of McCririck, Tommo and Cattermole. In short it's an entertainment show almost as much as it's a racing programme. The racing channels provide the right platform for Hislop and Chapman. Channel 4 definitely doesn't.
By:
appformat
When: 25 Aug 14 10:56
she would play a good supporting role in cell block H.
By:
snorlax
When: 25 Aug 14 12:28
Bit of a suggestion from left field. But what about Gary O' Brien? I know it'd be a big step up from his current gig but he's quite knowledgeable and a likeable enough lad.
By:
grumpyjim
When: 25 Aug 14 12:46
best of the product the racing game can muster .. and very poor seldom watch it now  ...  A TURN OFF IS THE ANSWER ...
ONE POSTER SAID IT'S TIME TO MAKE UP YOUR OWN MIND ... The cream ??? of the game and programme gets little praise for the effort ?? that come with CLAIRE  BIGGER FISH TO FRY IN FUTURE FOR SURE .   Probably best she moves on ,as viewers are only  , racing people gleaning what they can  .PUNTERS get little from it  and ladies days  no place in racing ,, managed to stick a young lad in line up ...don't know what it was about as only saw the boy as came back to see what was going on  and yet again not a lot ... BRUCE FORSYTH  would do a better job ... nice to see you  ....SO IT IS   LOST YOUR HARD EARNED AGAIN    THERE THERE .. TRY AGAIN ...
By:
Deltâ
When: 25 Aug 14 12:50
a trainers view a trainers view

..


"It is disappointing the see that Clare Balding is considering leaving Channel 4 racing. She is by far and away the best presenter, is always well rehearsed and researched and puts everything over in a very professional way, also the public get to know her from her other broadcasting jobs, whether it be on the TV or the radio. I would hope they would try and offer her a package she couldn’t refuse, as we don’t want the viewing figures going down even more. A good racing product on TV is a must."

By:
theres only one best tonic
When: 25 Aug 14 12:52
was that trainer andrew balding
By:
Blackwater
When: 25 Aug 14 12:53
Thank goodness for Ibrahima and Ramruna.

The personal attacks are unfair and totally unwarranted. And that's without getting in to the homophobic stuff.

The Channel 4 coverage is a mess and drives people away from the sport. But that was true before Clare Balding arrived and it won't change if she's replaced.

The show needs a different tone, and content that reflects the mostly betting-related interests of the few remaining viewers.

But I don't think the people involved could make the change at this stage even if they wanted to.

In any event, the whole sport is in a death spiral (or 'laying the foundations for future success' as the BHA likes to put it. It won't be long before C4 yields to the inevitable and pulls the plug on the whole exercise.
By:
Makybe_Diva
When: 25 Aug 14 13:02
"If Matt Chapman or Lydia Hislop took over, Channel 4 racing would be dead and gone within 12 months."

If Matt Chapman took over, Channel 4 Racing ratings would soar!

I can't believe he hasn't been given the job already.
By:
sageform
When: 25 Aug 14 13:23
Don't blame presenters-they are only doing what the producer tells them to do. So long as the main channels assume that talking heads and fashion parades must take precedence over sport, nobody who is a serious fan will watch if there is an alternative. I watch RUK and ATR for racing, Eurosport for Athletics and Tennis when they cover it etc. They are not perfect either but if you are not prepared to attend a meeting in person, you have to watch what is available. Claire Balding is capable of high quality informed coverage of racing but is not allowed to do that. If she decides to leave, good for her.
Page 1 of 4  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com