Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
diktat
16 Mar 12 12:07
Joined:
Date Joined: 13 Jun 10
| Topic/replies: 1,973 | Blogger: diktat's blog
surely the owner should give the horse the best possible chance of winning the race rather than trying to give his son all the glory.  yes he won last year but he simply outstayed 2 older horses.  if this gets tactical or theres a drivng finish its gonna be difficult for SWC
Pause • Switch to Standard View Long Run - Selfish owner
Show More
Loading...
Report andy85 • March 16, 2012 11:10 AM GMT
Can do what they like its their horse ffs
Report pedrobob • March 16, 2012 11:13 AM GMT
it shouldn't get tactical with at least 3 front runners in the race and if Long Run has jumped cleanly through the race, doubt it will be a driving finish.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:14 AM GMT
of course they can do what they like, what im saying is they are more interested in giving the son the glory than the horse.  its hard to tell if LR would jump better with a professional jockey on board
Report ph. • March 16, 2012 11:15 AM GMT
they play for fun and glory,its an in house thing (outsiders and the general public not required).The corinthian spirit works for them,maybe somebody could stump up a million and give it a better chance elsewhere (my tongue is stuck tight to the side of my mouths interior)
Report Storm Alert • March 16, 2012 11:16 AM GMT
Why would a pro who doesn't know the horse be better than SWC who does know the horse has never fallen on him and has won three grade one's including the King George and the Gold Cup?
Report ph. • March 16, 2012 11:17 AM GMT
btw I know most racehorses are mollycoddled but I've never seen one running a twitter blog or reading the Racing Post looking out to see if it is mentioned in dispatches.The horse is already glorious after last seasons exploits.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:20 AM GMT
if you think jockeys make no difference to horses why do we all compare jockeys and who is good and who is bad.  why do trainers pick top stable jockeys?
Report pedrobob • March 16, 2012 11:24 AM GMT
jocks indeed make a massive difference, but:

(Long Run + SWC) = many lbs better than (any other horse in the race + AP McCoy / Ruby Walsh)
Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 11:27 AM GMT
@Storm Alert:"Why would a pro who doesn't know the horse be better than SWC?"

LOL It's the way you tell 'em. IF, and it's highly unlikely it will ever happen, Daddy Wally Cohen puts a proper jockey on LR, just watch his jumping 'problems' miraculously disappear.

And I think this is one of the main reasons why it will never happen, because it will expose just how bad SWC is.
Report Sigge • March 16, 2012 11:29 AM GMT
diktat: How can it be selfish of the owner to let his son take the ride? Quite the opposite.......
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:31 AM GMT
would SWC have won on Riverside Theatre yesterday.........i rest my case.
Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 11:33 AM GMT
Yes and, conversely, would Ruby or Barry, or virtually any pro for that matter, have won the last KG on Long Run? You betcha.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:36 AM GMT
no he wouldnt have won on Riverside yesterday, just watch the finish Geraghty rode, SWC is not capable of that.
Report 11kv • March 16, 2012 11:36 AM GMT
Sat Nav Sam has every right to ride it....

Ruby and Kauto will give him a race, he will need to be at his best and Long Run will need to jump out of his skin.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 16, 2012 11:49 AM GMT
So these jumping problems that Long Run has a SWC is being blamed for, you anyone tell me how many times the horse has fallen or it's even looked like SWC was coming off?

The horse beat 2 modern staying greats last season and watching the replay there is no way anyone who isn't biased against SWC could say that he looked any worse that the other 2 jockeys in his riding, and if anything he had the harder job of the 3 as his horse came under pressure earliest and he was the first to go for his whip just to get the horse running into contention. SWC also got 3 good jumps out of the horse for the final 3 fences and especially at the last but to read some of the rubbish some members write on here is embarrassing..............and I don't usually have to resort to comments like that as everyone is entitled to their opinion but facts are facts and can't be denied.

Oh and by the way, if the horse falls today then none of that changes anything that has happened so far up until now either.
Report judorick • March 16, 2012 12:00 PM GMT
he is also worth a £250 million or something so he can wtf he likes
Report unlucky_mike • March 16, 2012 12:07 PM GMT
I am not a SWC fan at all and don't believe amateur jockey's should be allowed to ride in the Gold Cup, that's why they have there own amateur races.
Report seeyouthen121 • March 16, 2012 12:11 PM GMT
Why should they let someone else have the glory. They bought the horse, they want to ride it, we all know the score and bet accordingly. I would do the same. your cash back or lay, you know where you stand. good luck, Wink
Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 12:13 PM GMT
@ima mazed66: "he had the harder job of the 3 as his horse came under pressure earliest and he was the first to go for his whip"

The reason Long Run came under pressure earliest was because of the hard time SWC gave, and always gives, him. It's long Run's massive engine that's winning these races. Ride like that on Kauto and he wouldn't make the last circuit.

And if you don't think looking as if you're having a serious Tourette's attack long before you're off the bridle doesn't look any worse than the pros then you're in urgent need of an eye test.

PS - I like your get out clause "Oh and by the way, if the horse falls today then none of that changes anything that has happened so far up until now either"
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 12:16 PM GMT
totally agree with bornunlucky here.  its the horse thats getting him out of trouble, i just wish they woulld try another jockey at least once and see what happens.  he simply outstayed 2 great old horses last year, he didnt have to be a tactical genius to do that.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 16, 2012 1:13 PM GMT
How exactly did he give the horse a hard time in last season's Gold Cup? What specifically did he do to cause any problems? It looked to me as if Long Run was the first to feel the pinch when it became a 3 horses race from 3 out and so SWC stoked the horse up and gave it a few cracks of the whip so that from being in 3rd and in trouble, they jumped the second last upsides and he drove the horse into the lead at the last and got a great leap out of it and then drove it out all the way to the line.

If it really was all about the horse and the jockey was a liability then he must be some machine when as a second season chaser with previously only 4 chase runs over here that in its next two runs it can win the King George and Gold Cup, beating two modern greats and previous multiple Gold Cup winners in the process.

Funny isn't it that when the horse wins it's apparently despite SWC but when it's beaten it's because of SWC. Confused

I posted this next bit on another thread but I keep reading how SWC is an inexperienced jockey as if it's his first season and he's never done anything previously in the game but he won a beginners chase on his Dad's horse Liberthine as far back as March 2004, the same horse he also won the Mildmay of Fleet on at the 2005 Cheltenham Festival, the Topham Chase at Aintree in 2006 and on which he jumped around Aintree to be 5th in the 2007 National won by Silver Birch.

He also won the big Aitree Foxhunters race in 2005 and 2006 and was 2nd in it in 2008 all on Katarino and has won multiple races on another of his Dad's horse Shatabdi, as well as wins on Roulez Cool in the Stratford Foxhunters Champion Hunters' Chase in 2010 and those are just the wins, he will still also have had plenty of rides from 2004 onwards and he might have been riding even earlier thn that.
Report maxheadroom • March 16, 2012 1:34 PM GMT
to quotespike milligan a Little Grovelling B@st@ard.
Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 2:56 PM GMT
LOL Wouldn't quite be my choice of words Max but no doubt pretty near the truthLaugh

As for ima mazed66, you say "How exactly did he give the horse a hard time in last season's Gold Cup?"

Sam Wally Cohen's main problem is not a lack of experience, but a chronic lack of ability, despite having the best of everything given to him on a plate. He rides too far back, virtually sitting on the saddle, more like a an eventer, and is unable to take fences at speed, looking to slam the brakes on at any opportunity. As a result he gets in too close, scrubbing off speed and resulting in a more vertical jump, requiring more effort to accelerate on the other side and using up valuable energy.

You also say "If it really was all about the horse and the jockey was a liability then he (Long Run)must be some machine when as a second season chaser with previously only 4 chase runs over here that in its next two runs it can win the King George and Gold Cup".

This comment is more encouraging because, at last, you seem to realise the point I have been making, which is that Long Run is a potential superstar horse, possibly an all-time great, but not with this clown on board.
Report Steamship • March 16, 2012 3:07 PM GMT
Arent you just jealous because Sam has got a lot going for him and you have not?

Look at the last race, you would go Walsh over Gillies any day of the week, buy I'm sure I've just seen him outridden by Gillies.

Yours is an irrelevant arguement Sam has already made his mark in NH history, not bad for a crap jockey.

By the way I have never backed LR. I just dislike seeing all these threads on how poor Sam is.
Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 3:56 PM GMT
@Storm Alert: "Why would a pro who doesn't know the horse be better than SWC

LaughLaugh
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 7:02 PM GMT
need to allow these ametuers to claim their weight allowance in championship races. not sure of the reason why they arnt allowed.
Report Kingmambo • March 16, 2012 7:19 PM GMT
You do realise R Waley-Cohen has lost one son.  My guess is he doesn't give a sh1t what anyone thinks and wants to give as much pleasure to his remaining son (or sons, I don't know) as he possibly can.  Everyone knows he's riding prior to the race dom't they?
Report Kingmambo • March 16, 2012 7:20 PM GMT
*don't
Report acey deucy • March 16, 2012 7:43 PM GMT
Kingmambo has got it spot on,tbh i think it is only the idiots that want to see a pro on the horse.
Report homefortea • March 16, 2012 7:52 PM GMT
What a load of envious people post on here.The man has put a lot into the game and if he wants to put his son up then good for him.I have seen some bad rides this week and those jocks are allegedly pro's.You know the horse you know the jockey  - bet accordingly and then return to your Council Houses and have another moan !!
Report acey deucy • March 16, 2012 7:54 PM GMT
Council houses?Confused
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 8:13 PM GMT
cant wait to see Rmonan Abromovich's son in a Chelsea shirt even if he is a pub team player
Report ima_mazed66 • March 16, 2012 9:37 PM GMT
I think bornlucky you are talking as if Long Run is the only horse SWC ever rides and do those jumping flaws also apply to all of the others?....And if Long Run is the machine you are suggesting he is then shouldn't he have still been able to get SWC out of trouble seeing as though they jumped the last upsides the leader and the winner came from behind, despite being more of a stayer having won at over 4 miles previously?

Nicky Henderson himself admitted Long Run has a tendency to jump the odd fence on UK courses the way they jump the French brush fences, as in fast and low where they can flick through the top of them but can't really get away with that here and since the horse first went chasing there when aged only 4 years old, then old habits will die hard and is why the horse was sent for specialist schooling sessions. Kauto Star is another ex-French horse that also had jumping problems earlier in his career too.

Maybe you could also explain how SWC was able to finished 2nd and 5th in the Grand National on two different horses and won a Topham over the same course if he has a chronic lack of ability and can't get horses to jump for him.
Report Cricketer • March 16, 2012 9:42 PM GMT
Jewish fighting spirit
Report Cricketer • March 16, 2012 9:42 PM GMT
Jewish fighting spirit
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 9:43 PM GMT
for those who dont want to apportion blame on the SWC please watch the race again from the last 2 fences.  2nd last he has to stop riding as he gets stuck behind 2 horses and at the last he stops riding 10 yards from the fence as if he is 5 lengths clear.  now watch McCoy at the last fence riding into it, asking for a big leap and kicking on.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 16, 2012 9:55 PM GMT
He doesn't get stuck behind two horses at the second last, there is plenty of room for him to challenge between them until they come in on him and from either side and squeezed him up which is something entirely different.
Report brigust1 • March 16, 2012 9:57 PM GMT
People like Ima are completely missing the point. I know the waley's own the horse but if you think their moral responsibility ends there you are wrong. SWC has had every chance to show he is up to riding this horse but he has failed. The horse goes out on the course risking life and limb and the Waley's moral responsibilty is to do the best they can for their horse. They are not doing that. The horse continually makes mistakes and one day it could be fatal.

If you think owning an animal gives you the right to do anything try taking your dog into the park at start hitting it with a stick. You will soon find out that owning an animal has responsibilities to go with it.

The horses SWC has won on were good jumpers and suited his amateurish ability, Long Run is not like that. The races he has won on him are in spite of SWC not because of him.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 10:26 PM GMT

Mar 16, 2012 -- 4:55PM, ima_mazed66 wrote:


He doesn't get stuck behind two horses at the second last, there is plenty of room for him to challenge between them until they come in on him and from either side and squeezed him up which is something entirely different.


and what about the last fence? no excuses for not riding into it and asking for a big one.  the fact is he bottled it. this is a Gold Cup, I think he thought he was riding in some point to point with his posh mates

Report bornunlucky • March 16, 2012 11:09 PM GMT
"the fact is he bottled it"

Absolutely right, and this is one of the points I made earlier. Sam Wally Cohen seems as though he's constantly expecting a catastrophe to happen and sits back ready to slam the anchors on. The poor horse must wonder what the hell he's supposed to be doing, and this was even more evident in the King George where he was doing this from the off, although his tactical shortcomings were possibly more evident today than in any previous race.

Will Daddy WC see the light? I very much doubt it. So we're stuck with the spoilt Hooray Henry riding Long Run as if he's in the Calgary Stampede.
Report petethepunter • March 16, 2012 11:15 PM GMT
To tell you the truth I rather have SWC on my horse than Barry Geraghty. At least you know SWC will give his all not like Barry Geraghty who is likely to pull his horse up for no apparent reason i.e. Spirit River in this years Coral Cup and Bellvano in the 2010 County Hurdle. Funny how Spirit River drifted on the exchanges on Tuesday night/Wednesday morning from about 19 to 30. Coming up to the last hurdle in the Coral Cup Geraghty hit Spirit River 2 slaps with the whip and the horse responded and was going forward but then Geraghty pulled him up and hit him a slap on the neck to pretend he was still trying. He totally took the horse out of his stride and the horse ended up hit the hurdle and falling. Racing is totally corrupt.
Report BarryGrant • March 16, 2012 11:18 PM GMT
I don't think the horse is interested in having glory or how good the kid sitting on him is. As long as the horse and jockey are safe which I think they are there is no harm done. They have won a Gold Cup and a King George and been placed in each of them too. There is plenty of time to win more good races and they might do.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:19 PM GMT
when Kauto pulled up he may have thought he would win easily and thought he would quicken away after the last but he should have known after the first 2 runs this season that stamina is his forte.  he should have kicked on way before and blew them away.  Time for Rupert / The Giant Bolster should be nowhere near him yet they were both cruising well into the business end of the race.  just let Gereaghty ride it once and lets see what happens or will the owner be too scared to expose his son as second rate
Report flyingbolt • March 16, 2012 11:20 PM GMT
petethe**** = clueless twaat
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:23 PM GMT
lets put it this way, would SWC have won on the winner today?
Report flyingbolt • March 16, 2012 11:28 PM GMT
No of course he wouldn't Diktat. But this whole debate is pointless. The owners son will continue to ride the horse. That's the way it is. Get over it.
Report BarryGrant • March 16, 2012 11:30 PM GMT
I think flying bolt is right mate. You don't want to get into too many would haves and what ifs in horse racing or you'll go a bit funny.
Report diktat • March 16, 2012 11:32 PM GMT
thats the point of the thread.  the owner is not giving the horse the best possible chance to show its true ability.  as i read somewhere else, its like Roman Abramovich's son putting on a Chelsea shirt in the Premier League cos his Dad owns the club
Report BarryGrant • March 16, 2012 11:46 PM GMT
It doesn't hurt anyone if the horse runs a few lbs lower than it potentially could do with a different lad riding. The owner is happiest this way. The trainer has accepted arrangements. The horse doesn't care. The lad riding must be having a great crack.

It's got nothing to do with anyone else when you think about it. We all do things in life other people would like us to do differently mate.
Report guinness2dear • March 16, 2012 11:47 PM GMT
It is a gambling sport Barry..
Report Hayden • March 16, 2012 11:52 PM GMT
We had all this nonsense with John Thorne when Francome offered to ride Spartan Missile in the National , who knows if he had taken up the offer we most likely wouldn't have had the Aldaniti fairytale.

Don't know about anyone else but if I buy something I like to think it's down to me personally what I decide to do with it.

Well done team Cohen for looking to fulfil their own personal objectives rather than listen to interfering outsiders.
Report BarryGrant • March 16, 2012 11:56 PM GMT
It is a gambling sport yes. I'd like a top jockey on all the horses I like to want to bet on but it doesn't happen. I've always liked Knockara Beau and think it might have won a couple of nice prizes with someone else on board but it's not up to me.
Report guinness2dear • March 17, 2012 12:10 AM GMT
You never know, JP might put an offer in for LR..

He can afford it now..
Report Genuine • March 17, 2012 1:39 AM GMT
petethepunter - rather have SWC than BG?

Good grief.
Report punkha1 • March 17, 2012 2:02 AM GMT
Barry you're a top lad love your attitude to life.So chilled you'll live to be a 100 Happy
Report Shiekh Me Hand • March 17, 2012 4:33 AM GMT
Will Daddy WC see the light? I very much doubt it. So we're stuck with the spoilt Hooray Henry riding Long Run as if he's in the Calgary Stampede.

Hooray Bornlucky- I'm in Calgary and laughed at the mention of the greatest show on earth!! top man!!
Report RMB © • March 17, 2012 10:16 AM GMT
French chasers often lose it from the age 7 onwards, that's just the way they're raced. Got to say it's pretty cretinous not to understand that replacing SWC is a good thing, of course it is. It's like playing John O'Shea up front for United, yeah he might score, but I'd rather Rooney thanks...
Report flushgordon1 • March 17, 2012 10:26 AM GMT
swc is a reasonable jockey, the horse is overated  it won the gc and kg last year against an under par kauto,
this year kauto showed his true form and stuffed him twice,
if he did not have the injury prior to cheltenham i am fairly sure he would have done it again,
kauto in form would eat the giant bastard and synchronised for brekkie.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 17, 2012 1:56 PM GMT
And what people like brigust1 don't seem to realise is that the horse wasn't good enough on the day just as plenty of other GC winners weren't when they tried to win it back to back so presumably all of their jockeys were at fault there then?

I've already touched on the fact that the horse is ex-French and they jump fences differently to how they do here and that was before SWC had even ridden it. Just as Kauto Star another ex-French has had jumping problems too where they can get away with flicking through the top of the brush fences there but can't do that here. Plus there was nothing wrong with the jump at the last and if anything the horse maybe even came out fractionally in the lead and even if he slightly steadied the horse, I bet Adrian Maguire wished he got as good a jump as that on Barton Bank a few seasons ago and McCoy was down going into the fence and met it on a good stride but that's purely how the stride pattern fell for him and he's ended up on the deck enough times when doing the same.

There was still plenty of racing to be done and ground to be covered from the last to the line and any of the three were in a position to win it by then and the jump Long Run made at the last was no different to the one Riverside Theatre made the day before.
Report brigust1 • March 17, 2012 3:30 PM GMT
Ima your are talking complete b ollo x. The horse doesn't know about back to back ffs. What about Best Mate? This past record rubbish is nonsense.
The horse was the best horse in the race. It was given a ride not suited to it's ability and allowed lesser horses a chance to beat it.
Long Run has never won a race when it was not leading at the last, why in heaven's name to you think that is?
I'm obviously wasting my time even thinking about discissing it with you. Sadly we are paying for SWC to learn his trade but I think he will not make the same mistake again.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 17, 2012 4:42 PM GMT
By all means disagree with me brigust1 but there's no need to repsond like that.

If I have to spoon feed it to you though then of course the horse doesn't know about back to back but the point that seems to have clearly gone over your head is that if was easy to win back to back GCs the we would have seen more of them do it and just plucking out one like Best Mate doesn't make the point any less valid. When was the last horse before Best Mate, as that one won it a decade age first time? Plus if we wanted to be a little harsh on Best Mate, what exactly did it beat other than a few various National types and struggled in two of the races to do that and a 12 year old See More Business. Even an all time great like Desert Orchid wasn't able to win back to back GCs and I doubt very much Long Run is an all time great and you have to go back to the mid-60s and early 70s to when Arkle and L'Escargot did it previously.

Just for good measure Long Run jumped into a mariginal lead at the last anyway but are you really saying that once over it there wasn't enough of a run in for the horse to pull away from the others if it was good enough to? If so then you should reconsider which of the two of us is actually talking b0ll0cks. Happy

As for SWC learning his trade, he's been riding winners under rules since the 2003-2004 season and has rideen multiple Cheltenham festival and Aintree festival winner too as well as plenty of winners not under rules too I would imagine.
Report petethepunter • March 17, 2012 6:55 PM GMT
FlyingBolt and Genuine you miss my point. Of course BG is a more talented jockey the SWC. My point is that in the two races that I highlighted BG in my opinion did not ride the horse out to give punters the best opportunity. I have never seen a race where SWC hasnt given his best. Did BG deliberately stop the horses I highlighted? I don't know. Spirit River did not look like a horse that was beat when BG clearly pulled him up going into the last hurdle. Same as Bellvano in the County two years ago. No surprise he won yesterday. Racing is totally corrupt and if FlyingBolt and Geniune think it isnt yous are havin a laugh.
Report petethepunter • March 17, 2012 6:55 PM GMT
FlyingBolt and Genuine you miss my point. Of course BG is a more talented jockey the SWC. My point is that in the two races that I highlighted BG in my opinion did not ride the horse out to give punters the best opportunity. I have never seen a race where SWC hasnt given his best. Did BG deliberately stop the horses I highlighted? I don't know. Spirit River did not look like a horse that was beat when BG clearly pulled him up going into the last hurdle. Same as Bellvano in the County two years ago. No surprise he won yesterday. Racing is totally corrupt and if FlyingBolt and Geniune think it isnt yous are havin a laugh.
Report brigust1 • March 17, 2012 7:35 PM GMT
Oh dear, Ima. Oh dear.

Long Run does not have a finishing kick. He is the fastest horse from A to Z but not from Y to Z. It is as simple as that.

At Newbury he was nearly caught on the run to the line, not because he was stopping but because he can only go the one pace, but fortunately he put the race to bed long before that. And that is what he needs to do. Some horses quicken when they come under pressure because they save a bit, he doesn't. SWC should have sent him on long before they reached the top of the hill and from then on it would have been a procession. The time of the race was the length on the home straight slower than last year so work it out for yourself.

Long Run was 12s yesterday with PP (now 10s)and I took some of that and he is available to lay on here at 9s if you are interested?
Report topfarrier • March 17, 2012 7:41 PM GMT
Pointless thread imo.

Doesn't matter whether the lad is good enough or not his father owns it and has every right to insist his son rides the horse.

I'd do the same and so would most of you.

Unless you were a complete ****.
Report sickoflayinwinners • March 17, 2012 7:53 PM GMT
spot on farrier, its a family thing, why on earth anyone thinks the family should bow to media (punter) pressure to get their son off their horse is beyond me.
Report Steamship • March 17, 2012 7:58 PM GMT
brigust no jockey is perfect look at Ruby this week. It's heir horse it's upto them who rides it and that fact is built into his price, if the horse was so good then why was he not odds on yesterday all he had was a 12yo who'd had a fall and a load of hcappers.

I did write on here a few weeks ago that Long Run would not win another GC and I received some abuse, but I stick by that. When you have followed this game for 35 yrs then you learn that it is not that easy.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 17, 2012 9:31 PM GMT
Don't you just love it when you get the patronising "oh dear, oh dear" and in the very next paragraph the person doing the patronising total contradicts and loses himself within his own argument.

So let me get this right then going by what you are saying. Long Run was nearly beaten at Newbury when the RP post-race comments were:

Tracked clear leader, closed up 14th, challenged 4 out, led and went left 3 out, ridden and edged left last, driven run-in and 4 lengths clear, held on all out closing stages

so led at the 3rd last but almost got caught "not because he was stopping but because he can only go the one pace, but fortunately he put the race to bed long before that. And that is what he needs to do" but you wanted him to kick just as early in the GC with the extra distance yet say he was beaten because he didn't? Do you not think Burton Port would have won at Newbury if that race had gone on for an extra 2f 110y like the GC does?

I'm not really sure you know yourself what you are arguing and if Long Run doesn't quicken then look at the race again and 3 flights out there are 5 jumping it almost in line, Time For Rupert, The Giant Bolster, Long Run, Burton Port and China Rock with Synchronised a bit farther back. China Rock is the first to break and coming off the final bend and into the straight Long Run, The Giant Bolster and Burton Port are level with Time For Rupert about a length up on them on the flat until The Giant Bolster goes into the lead at the 2nd last. The Giant Bolster having hit the front then jumps the last with Long Run about a stride behind where Long Run then quickens away from both Burton and Time For Rupert to beat them 5l and 6½L respectively......he also seemed to quicken well enough away from Denman and Kauto Star last year too.

Last year he was the first 6YO to win the race since Mill House in 1963 but had either of the two 11YOs that finished 2nd and 3rd won then they were have been the first at that age to win since Mandarin in 1972. With the benefit of hindsight now Long Run maybe beat two horses past their best where one has since retired and didn't make this year's race and one probably will retire and maybe shouldn't have made this year's race either.
Report Loanwolf • March 17, 2012 10:48 PM GMT
Winning a race is 90% due to the horse and 10% due to the jockey.On the day Long Run was not good enough.If the owner wants  his son to ride the horse then so be it .Gold Cups are difficult to win and I would definitely choose a professional jockey over a gifted amateur every time.One daty the penny might drop.it will be interesting to see if SWC rides the horse next season.
Report Fayzer • March 17, 2012 10:59 PM GMT
Long Run missed denman taking it up at halfway and setting a relentless gallop, last year it seemed as if LR came up the hill doing hand stands, but he was just powering home off a pace that sickened everything else in the race.....like I mean there was half a dozen of them jostling for position turning in yesterday, the pace wasnt strong enough.

The differance between a McCoy and Sam is McCoy would have sensed this and gone on to make use of Long Runs huge engine.
Report brigust1 • March 17, 2012 11:02 PM GMT
I can see I am wasting my time. You said everything Ima when you said 3 flights out there were 5 in line. This is the Gold Cup ffs. It was reduced to a handicap and 4 of the 5 you mentioned have no right in a Gold Cup and they should have been killed off long before. Had Denman been forcing the pace that is exactly what would have happened. As I said earlier 'you go a bad horses pace and a bad horse will beat you'. It is a very old but very true saying. Had they gone Long Run's known pace there would not be 5 in line jumping the 3rd last. And that way to ride is what the top professionals do. SWC would do well to follow that.

However I've tried and, it appears, failed to explain my reasoning so I will be happy to meet you back here after his next run. And I would be happy to eat humble pie should any of those you mentioned beat him.

And Steamship 'only 35 years' your just a kid.
Report Eeternaloptimist • March 17, 2012 11:10 PM GMT
I think we are losing sight of a crucial thing here. Racing like life isn't all about pounds, shillings and pence. If it was, hardly any of us would get involved as over the course of our lifetimes most of us lose. We love racing at least partly because of the romance of the sport. What the Cohen's are doing is brilliant in my view. Sam isn't the best jockey out there but he isn't dangerous and when we back any horse he rides we do so knowing full well who the jockey is.

He is an intelligent man. If the race was run again I don't think for one minute he would ride the horse the way he did even though he actually got the horse into a better jumping rhythm than last year. That's life.

I hope he comes back next year and kicks the horse on at the top of the hill and we once again see this horse special talent of class allied to stamina. So few horse are so doubly blessed.
Report Ramruma • March 18, 2012 4:58 AM GMT
Henderson has told us Long Run needs regular schooling from Yogi Breisner.

Nicholls has publicly questioned whether Long Run has trained on.

So while it would be nice to see a top pro (and let's be honest, some pro's are mere journeymen) on Long Run, especially as SWC has already won the King George and Gold Cup so has nothing left to achieve on the horse) it may not be the panacea many suppose.
Report topfarrier • March 18, 2012 8:02 AM GMT
I can partly see where your coming from Brigust1 in that all Long Run seems to do now is stay but

for me the horse doesn't do anything in front, in his prep race he nearly pulled himself up once

he took it up and i think that had a bearing on how he was ridden not that it made any difference.
Ima it wasn't a case of Long Run quickening away but rather that the likes of Time for Rupert emptying.
Report ima_mazed66 • March 18, 2012 8:49 AM GMT
Do you realise how far 3 flights out is at Cheltenham brigust1?

Maybe you are wasting your time and it would be better if you did a bit or research before making remarks like the 5 in a line at the 3rd last this year because last year approaching the same stage there were 6 of them being Imperial Commander, Kauto Star, Denman, Long Run, What A Friend and China Rock and with Midnight Chase a couple of strides behind and yet that was very similar to how things were in this year's race but last year's pace was supposed to be how it should be done.

I agree that the likes of Time For Rupert and Midnight Chase aren't GC winner quality and that's why regardless of anything else they usually finish behind Long Run and I expect them to do so in the future too. The Giant Bolster seems to either win or fail to finish at Cheltenham and Synchronised was considered merely an out and out staying until winning the Lexus, but they were still going fast enough to have him as one of the first in trouble and surely the kind of horse to benefit least from the pace set would be one like Synchronised that has won at 4 miles.

I think some of the knocking of the first two is because the winner is seen as a stayer only having previously won the Welsh National but so did Burrough Hill Lad, Cool Ground and Master Oats and they all went on to win a GC too.

Just out of interest topfarrier, does the same emptying description apply regarding Time For Rupert in relation to how the two in front of Long Run pulled away from Time For Rupert too? Even if the emptying description had merit, you still don't go away from the horse unless you are quickening too.
Report pumphol. • March 18, 2012 8:58 AM GMT
Almost every year since 2002 a genuine top class performer has won the GC but the race is littered with decent handicap winners in the 15 years before that, there is nothing to say this years winner may not go on to do it again next year.
Top quality winner ?
Probably not, did not stop it being a great race imo.
Report bornunlucky • March 18, 2012 9:55 AM GMT
@Loanwolf: "gifted amateur".

Laugh Could you please enlighten me just who this gifted amateur is you're referring to? Surely not the uber-privileged spoilt Hooray Henry?
Report topfarrier • March 18, 2012 10:38 AM GMT
ma_mazed66 • March 18, 2012 8:49 AM GMT

Just out of interest topfarrier, does the same emptying description apply regarding Time For Rupert in relation to how the two in front of Long Run pulled away from Time For Rupert too? Even if the emptying description had merit, you still don't go away from the horse unless you are quickening too.


The answer to the first part of that question ima is obviously yes,while the answer to the second part of the question is yes they do.

You don't really believe that any of the horses involved were travelling up the hill faster than they were turning in?
Report ima_mazed66 • March 18, 2012 11:21 AM GMT
I would have said the gifted amateur was the one who has won a King George, Gold Cup, Mildmay of Fleet and a Topham Chases when riding against professional jockeys with those in behind for the two last named races including Thomas, McCoy, Dobbin, Fitzgerald, Power, Brennan, Paul Carberry, Llewellyn, Geraghty, Murphy, Macguire, Johnson, Lee, Ruby Walsh and Andrew Thornton, which is a who's who of Gold Cup and Grand National winning jockeys.

The slight flaw in your line of argument topfarrier is that Time For Rupert was passed and lost the lead before jumping the second last which isn't really the hill at Cheltenham and even after the last there it's not as if it's a steep uphill immediately after the fence and it doesn't really kick in until about the final furlong.
Report brigust1 • March 18, 2012 11:43 AM GMT
Ima, and your reason for The Giant Bolster beating Long Run and turning around a 4lb and 12 lengths beating is what exactly?

The form does not add up. The only reason I can find for the form not adding up is the way Long Run was ridden as opposed to his previous successes. Add to that for the Gold Cup next season Long Run is 10s and The Giant Bolster is 33s. So the bookmakers agree that the form is unlikely to be confirmed.

What I do is 1) Watch the race. 2) Assess the finishing positions and riding tactics. 3) Consider whether or not there are reasons why horse a) beats horse b). From this information I can determine what likelihood the form is to be confirmed.

So I watched the race. I looked at the finishing positions of the main protagonists and compared their riding tactics with earlier races. The outcome of my review is that SWC rode a tactically poor race and that the form would not be confirmed by the 2 horses who beat him UNLESS the jockey rides to similar tactics. On that basis I will place my money when next they meet. You may not agree so you are free to put your money anywhere you like. The future may well prove me to be right or wrong. We will see.

In closing may I suggest you take the 10s now available for next year's Gold Cup before Long Run runs again. The current favourite for next year's Gold Cup is Sir Des Champs who has never even won a Grade 1 race.
Report acey deucy • March 18, 2012 11:55 AM GMT
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ...
Report bf_fananatic • March 18, 2012 1:52 PM GMT
we are back to blaming the jockey are we? its the horse that wins the race and the jockey that can get the best out of the horse and the best horses well its just a steering job really as they can jump the fences blind-folded!
Report Steamship • March 18, 2012 1:56 PM GMT
Why nit just accept that Long Run is not as good this season. The first 2 have improved enormously and to my eyes Long Run has run like he did at Newbury.
Report koikeeper • March 18, 2012 1:56 PM GMT
well its just a steering job really as they can jump the fences blind-folded!


I have seen loose horses fall with no jock onWink
Report ima_mazed66 • March 18, 2012 3:05 PM GMT
So because one bit of form goes one way does that mean it has to go the same way every time? Have horses never reversed form before brigust1?

You're not even including like for like anyway as Newbury and Cheltenham are nothing alike as courses and the Newbury race was 2½f shorter and with 18 fences as opposed to the GC's 22. Add to that The Giant Bolster has never won at Newbury in 4 attempts and has only won 4 races in total with 2 of those being ta Cheltenham and now a 2nd in a GC, my take on that would be that the horse likes Cheltenham but doesn't like Newbury. The Giant Bolster had also previously finished 2nd 1¾L behind Time For Rupert over 3 miles at Newbury at levels yet in the GC also at levels has beaten that one over 7L when taking it up 2 flights out in a 3m2½ race.

As to bookies prices for next season, although I've previously stated that The Giant Bolster likes Cheltenham, by that I mean the type of course it is with its undulations as opposed to flat tracks like Newbury but the fences still need jumping and the horse has only fallen once and unseated twice in its racing career (as opposed to none for Long Run) and all 3 times have been at Cheltenham.
Report 1st time poster • March 18, 2012 3:10 PM GMT
and scudamore rode a stinker on the bolster at newbury,think even the trainer bridges was fuming about it
Report brigust1 • March 18, 2012 3:29 PM GMT
Ima I have tried to explain my reasons for believing SWC rode a poor race and that I fully expect the form to be turned around next time they meet the 2 horses that beat him on Friday. Indeed I have already backed Long Run for next year's Gold Cup. I am right some of the time and wrong more of the time, that's racing.

You obviously disagree and that is your perogative. I will leave it at that.
Report 1st time poster • March 18, 2012 3:35 PM GMT
only hope for people like me who still believe in the horse is that, henderson will improve it next year or the horse gets over last years gold cup ,because swc will never give it a better ride,perfect posy all the way round and for him besides the 1st probably the best round of jumping you could expect
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com