Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
soldieroffortune
22 Aug 20 23:22
Joined:
Date Joined: 14 Apr 07
| Topic/replies: 7,828 | Blogger: soldieroffortune's blog
Figgis and sintonian, been a long time my friends and I hope you're both keeping safe and well in these extraordinary times.

A small post-script to Newmarket, Epsom and York, and the fact that her trainer has called her out as the greatest filly he ever trained, which in itself is a massive statement.

Let's hope they can produce some decent ground for her in Paris, but even if they can't she'll go across there and win it!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 61
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 23 Aug 20 09:44
Without doubt probably the best filly I`ve seen.
By:
A_T
When: 23 Aug 20 11:06
the statement from Aidan might be more credible if it look like when he runs 4 colts in a classic the stable has no idea which will be the best
By:
A_T
When: 23 Aug 20 11:07
*didn't look like
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 12:11
Wasn't Australia the fastest horse he had trained?

"We always thought this horse was special from the very first day he worked," said the bespectacled O'Brien, a racing wizard with the hint of an older Harry Potter about him.

Before the race, he had told of the horse clocking 11-second splits for four furlongs running. In other words, covering half a mile in about three quarters of a minute. Breathtaking.

"The way he goes from A to B so easily makes him unique. Horses like that don't normally get a mile-and-a-half," he said afterwards.

"To get a mile and a half like that at Epsom, every sinew in his body was going to be tested - he had to settle, quicken and handle the hurly burly and everything but what makes him different is his natural pace."
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 12:15
On fast ground he was beaten over 7 furlongs by Rennaisance Art, over a mile by Night of Thunder and over 10 furlongs by The Grey Gatsby and he only ran eight times.  The guy certainly knows what he is talking about, that's a fact.
By:
A_T
When: 23 Aug 20 12:23
at least with Love the hype won't be down to trying to sell stallion nominations
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 13:04
You are right AT.

I had a few quid on Raabihah at nice prices after Love won at York and shortened up.

On form through Cloak of Spirits, Alpine Star, Savarin, Tawakeel and Wangari she has a live, live chance. Lightly raced, unexposed three year old filly as well.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 14:07
I think what O'Brien actually said about Australia was he was the fastest Derby type horse he'd trained. I'd be inclined to agree with him as I couldn't see any of his other Derby horses running so close in that Guineas.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 14:36
Apologies SOF, yes I'm well thanks, hope you're the same. O'Brien is right, at least as far as middle distance fillies go. She's already clearly the best he's trained, although personally I'd put Minding's Guineas performance slightly ahead of Love's.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 15:36
Aidan O'Brien: Australia Epsom Derby win seals legend of trainer
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/horse-racing/27748900
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 15:37
Quadrilateral franked the form again today.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 15:42
One Thousand Guineas. One listed win from the next 5 home in 11 starts.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 15:44
Oaks. One listed win from all other runners since.
By:
penzance
When: 23 Aug 20 16:20
Passion won a GP3 today,Naas.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 16:26
Oaks. One listed win from all other runners since.

Well she did win it by 9 lengths Crazy
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 16:29
Figgis, it is you who told me "it is not the name of the race it is the quality of the opposition".
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 16:30
"The way he goes from A to B so easily makes him unique. Horses like that don't normally get a mile-and-a-half," he said afterwards.

As I said, he was talking about a mile and a half horse showing such speed, and all that article does is substantiate what I said. I can't see anywhere that he said Australia was faster than his best milers.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 16:32
Figgis, it is you who told me "it is not the name of the race it is the quality of the opposition"

Exactly. In most people's view a horse beating Listed horses by 9 lengths+ would be better than beating a Gp2 horse a length. It's basic maths.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 16:35
I am only telling the facts. You are free to interpret them any way you like.

And A O B is the biggest bulls  hitter to look through a bridle.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 16:47
And A O B is the biggest bulls  hitter to look through a bridle

I'm certainly no Coolmore sycophant and I agree that he's said a fair amount of crap about horses, but so have I Grin. So have all of us. It's perfectly reasonable for anyone to have doubts about how good Love is. All I'm saying is, at this stage, the form can also reasonably be interpreted to say that he's not talking nonsense. O'Brien hasn't had what you'd call a great middle distance filly before so it's not as outlandish a statement as it might sound. For me, she's the joint fastest winner of an Oaks in my time. Even that isn't as fantastic a statement as it may seem, as I'd argue most Oaks winners just aren't good enough to win an Arc. She hasn't run quite as fast as Treve did when winning the Arc as a 3yo, but then she doesn't need to win by 5 lengths, a short head will do Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 18:10
I don't buy this 'fastest' thing so it is completely wasted on me. I could go into a lot more detail but it would be wasted on you so I won't waste your and my time F.
We all know Love has a great chance because she is a three-year-old with the allowances because Enable has always looked beatable. Because Gaiyyath won't be allowed a soft lead and, as yet, does not have the form, because Stradavarius is not good enough, because Raabihah is unknown, because Mishriff is unknown, because Magical isn't good enough and the rest have no hope at the moment unless something unexpected happens.

Try not to wrap this up into something it really isn't.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 18:28
Try not to wrap this up into something it really isn't

No reason why I would try to do that. I've seen others do it though from races of years gone by. A mythical land where all horses miraculously ran to form in each race. Racing reduced to a simple schoolboy equation, where if A beat B by 2 lengths and C beat B by 1 length then A must automatically be 1 length better than C. No mention of some horses going into a race in peak form and others on a downturn. No mention of any track/pace bias. A race called the best in history, ignoring the fact that the only horse fancied to beat the favourite was an unspectacular winner of a French classic and you could throw a large blanket over the winner and some ordinary horses behind. And on it goes.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 18:31
Brigust, in the last 35 years which Oaks winning filly would YOU say was the fastest YOU'D seen? Please no cop outs of how you have no opinion on the matter. As if that's true then you're in no position to comment on Love in comparison.
By:
kincsem
When: 23 Aug 20 18:57
It was fast ground at Epsom and wind behind and from the left in the straight.
Love hasn't beaten one colt and only one horse older than three.
She could be the greatest ever, but then every Ballydoyle horse is the fastest ever.
Heavy ground at Longchamp or fast ground and a high draw will test her.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 19:05
Love hasn't beaten one colt and only one horse older than three

Treve and Zarkava had beat no colts going to the Arc. I think Zarkava had only beaten 2 ordinary older fillies. That obviously doesn't mean Love is going to win an Arc but it shows it's no barrier.

She could be the greatest ever, but then every Ballydoyle horse is the fastest ever.

But she doesn't have to be the greatest ever, or even close to it, just good enough to win an Arc.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 19:07
Figgis I really do not buy 'times'. If I told you Frankel, a front running, free running, pacemaker led racehorse ran 14 times but only managed to beat average time on two occasions and both were on newly laid racecourses with a definite history of those improvements improving the times you would poo-hoo it. And he never broke a course record, another poo-hoo.
I would normally have thought that it was important but when I mention it no-one cares. That's time for you.
Invisible Man, for example, has a faster time on the straight mile at Ascot than Frankel and he is, quite rightly, rated 40lbs below Frankel and if they met would be treated accordingly. The instances are endless. I am not sure 'times' even work in the US when all of the courses are flat and the same so what chance is there here?
I am sure 'times' are fun and interesting if you like that kind of thing but I don't buy it.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 19:14
only managed to beat average time on two occasions

This has been done to death, but still you choose to ignore it. ALL times on a day's racing are compared to the standard times. Just to repeat, ALL times. To compare one race on a card to a standard time is forgivable for a novice, but unbelievably ignorant for someone to keep banging on about when they've supposedly been following the game for years.

newly laid racecourses

See above
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 19:20
Figgis I really do not buy 'times'

I never asked you who had done the fastest time, I asked who YOU considered the fastest. Shouldn't be too difficult should it? I mean in a race where 2 horses are both suited to the trip, track and going I assume you back who you think is going to run fastest on the day? Or do you use some other abstract criteria? So, again, which filly would YOU consider the fastest YOU'VE seen?
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 19:24
That is, fastest Oaks winning filly from the last 35 years?
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 19:27

Aug 23, 2020 -- 1:24PM, Figgis wrote:


That is, fastest Oaks winning filly from the last 35 years?


That is the bo ll ocks you time guys talk. Fastest over what? A furlong, a yard, ten furlongs? Fastest where at Epsom? The Clerk of the Course cannot even tell you where the fastest place on the course is. How many days were the same? How many races were run the same? How many horses tan the same? It is total nonsense. You just cannot see it.

By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 19:59
I'll tell you what Figgis. I have had a bet on Raabihah and I have pointed out the form lines I used for everyone to see and they can work them out for themselves, positively or negatively. 

You think Love will nearly win because of times. Show me the time lines you used so I can work them out for myself.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 20:02
Like pulling teeth. If 18 of what you consider the best Oaks winners of the last 35 years were to meet in a race over 12f at Epsom on good ground at equal prices, which would you back?
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 20:05
Show me the time lines you used so I can work them out for myself.

The times are obviously in the results section, for anyone to interpret however they want.
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 20:21
Ha! Why did I think that was going to be your answer?

It's like you have lived in a cave all of your life.

Don't you know all horses are different? Some are lazy, some are free running, some are hard pulling, some are cowards, some are dogs, some are used to just win on the line, some like being allowed to run, some are not allowed to run but still win?  The possibilities are endless but you think every winner is the same horse. Do you know how stupid that sounds?
How do you know how much the jockey has in hand? How do you know how much the horse has let themselves down? How do you know how many had the correct action for the undulating track at Epsom?
It is nonsense. Get over it.
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 20:27
How do you know how much the jockey has in hand? How do you know how much the horse has let themselves down? How do you know how many had the correct action for the undulating track at Epsom?
It is nonsense. Get over it.


As good a reason for never having a bet in a race as I've ever heard. Would make perfect sense it was for anti gambling campaign advert. Strangely enough, not absolutely knowing such things for certain is what makes a betting market. And it never stops us punters from having an opinion or backing that opinion. However, as I've suspected for a while, you're not really a punter. Just some weirdo with a Frankel obsession Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 23 Aug 20 20:32
Lost the 'time' argument have we? I wondered how long it would take?

It's rubbish and you know it. Oh 'I've got this down as the fastest Oaks winner' look at me!
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 21:10
There is no time "argument", only in the mind of an imbecile. A time based interpretation of form is exactly that, an interpretation. No different from anyone saying that "I think A can beat B due to..." whatever reason. Not everyone is going to agree with the conclusion. When somebody puts up a horse because they think it can beat another horse for whatever reason, no sane person expects them to prove it before the race. It's accepted as an opinion. The punter thinks horse A is going to run faster than B on the given day using whatever methodology they choose. When someone has used times as part of their analysis it is no different. That person's conclusions might be right or wrong. However, there are some truly odd individuals who once times are mentioned expect concrete proof to the satisfaction of everyone. Bizarre.

I think Love is the joint fastest Oaks winner I've seen. I'm not expecting anybody to agree, that is just my own main reason for fancying her for the Arc. There are other ways of finding the best horse, and each to their own. I usually think Oaks winners have very little chance. The first time in years I fancied an Oaks winner for the Arc was Enable straight after Epsom and I posted it on here, so that time I was right. The only time before I backed an Oaks winner in the Arc was Ouija Board. Even though she had a troubled run she wasn't quite good enough, and I was partly backing her out of affection anyway. I think Love is better than any Oaks winner I've seen apart from Enable, who I have equal as a 3yo. I might be wrong as I was when backing Ouija Board, but I have never made a penny on Love before so at least there is no loyalty clouding the issue this time.
By:
A_T
When: 23 Aug 20 21:27
O'Brien has a very poor record in the Arc with his 3yos - remarkably bad given his domination of the classics. I think High Chaparral in 2002 was the last to get placed. But maybe Love is the fastest he's had since then ;-)
By:
Figgis
When: 23 Aug 20 21:42
A_T, very true, he does. He actually has a pretty poor return with any age group. For me his horses were always campaigned too aggressively in preparation for the Arc, so even if they were good enough to at least go close they were cooked by the time the race came around. To be fair, it seems that the way his horses were campaigned the Arc was more an afterthought than a priority. Dylan Thomas was remarkably resilient and still managed to run well after a hard season. Even though Found had a busy season, in my view, she went there on the back of an improved effort at Leopardstown.

This time things look very different. After Love won the Oaks I think we can say the Arc was uppermost in their minds. She goes there relatively fresh.
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com