|
By:
It's nothing to do with resurgence. They've always tried farming the p!ss easy German middle distance group 1's that come thick and fast this time of the year. Neither of those horses are good enough to win group 1's in England, France or Ireland.
|
|
By:
The trainer change will see them win a fair few. NQAT
|
|
By:
German Group races....
if anything that gives you a indication of where this global operation has fallen in Europe |
|
By:
They ain't having a good season by any stretch of the imagination.
|
|
By:
Agree.
I think it is quite sad tbh that they dont have a horse,just one, good enough to win G1 over here. |
|
By:
What's happended to Rewilding and Cutlass Bay?
|
|
By:
A_T:-
Rewilding being aimed at the Leger. |
|
By:
rewilding ledger winner imo
|
|
By:
![]() |
|
By:
Rewilding must be a could hoss
|
|
By:
they still have passion for gold to run this season supposably only back in work now as i bet it for derby but got injured, as well as kingfort
|
|
By:
Burj Nahar will be out in the next couple of months :)
|
|
By:
One thing I will say about Godolphin they are open about targets for their horses supplementing if necessary and do not flood races with superfluous entries designed to confuse.
|
|
By:
Nothing wrong with the quality of the German Group 1s. Wiener Walzer was 2 lengths of the Eclipse winner and a horse who got within a length of Goldikova. Zazou wasn't far behind the French Guineas/Derby winner Lope De Vega and looked certain to improve for the step up in trip. Good work from Godolphin imo.
|
|
By:
Indeed....Buzzword might be the no1 for the St Leger not Rewilding.
better tactics than at Ascot. Made full use of his stamina this time and had too much in the tank for when Zazou went to win his race. |
|
By:
There's everything wrong with the German Group 1s. They're Group 2s in everything but name.
Campanologist will now follow the path Eastern Anthem took last year: Rheinland Pokal, Preis von Baden and Preis von Europa. Eastern Anthem took 3rd, 2nd and 2nd in those races. The winners: Wiener Walzer, Getaway and Jukebox Jury would be Group 2 horses everywhere except Germany. If Campanologist pulls it off he'll be a quadruple Group 1 winner although he's a Group 2 horse at his best in the UK. |
|
By:
I'm afraid that's nonsense, hippie.
It's bloody hard to win Group races in Germany as many English/Irish/French trainers have discovered to their cost. |
|
By:
I'm providing facts to back up my statements and can provide lots more.
"that's nonsense" and "it's bloody hard" doesn't cut it. |
|
By:
How would you like me to provide a measure then, hippie. There's lots to choose from. Shall we look at the Grosser Preis?
|
|
By:
You may also be confused by facts and opinion. Your 12:11 post has much of the latter, hippie?
|
|
By:
Nothing you've posted suggests you want a sensible discussion about German horseracing.
You just want a pissing contest. |
|
By:
Campanologist has definitely improved this year, took a Group 2 at Meydan and his first Group 1 is definitely a step up.
|
|
By:
The average ratings of Group 1 winners in Germany relative to British winners might be informative.
|
|
By:
Btw this is getting away from initial point of this season being a turning point for them.
Changes had to be made, they made them, its working. |
|
By:
Here is the race rating for the 2009 Grosser Preis, hippie - 121
Here is the 3 year average rating for the race - 119.83 Now, some say German G1s would be average G2s anywhere else....so let's look at the BEST Group 2 races from England, Ireland and France in the same period. Best British G2 in 2009 - Sandown Mile. Rating - 117.50 Best British G2 3 yr average - Ascot Summer Mile. Rating - 115.42 Best Irish G2 in 2009 - Derrinstown Trial. Rating - 112.50 Best Irish G2 3 yr ave - Derrinstown Trial. Rating - 112.25 Best French G2 in 2009 - Prix Foy. Rating - 118.50 Best French G2 3 yr ave - Prix Foy. Rating - 117.58 So, it is quiet apparent that this German G1 knocks the spots off the very cream of European G2s. In fact, it is an insult to be comparing them as the Grosser Preis Von Baden remains in the top 20 races in the world on thoroughbred rankings, as it has been for quite a while. It is also interesting to note the best German G2 of the last 3 years has an average race rating of 115.67, which compares favourably with the standard across Europe. What's a 'pissing contest' hippie??? |
|
By:
Jukebox only just got touched off in the Canadian International. another top quality g1.
Also have to look at the fantastic recent record of german horses competing in french group races. Excellent stuff. |
|
By:
They nearly won the Arc three years ago with a horse who was being spanked by Adlerflug and Kamsin at home, ELG. 'Group 2' indeed.....
![]() |
|
By:
....and I agree, ELG. The boys in blue are back and racing's much the better for it.
|
|
By:
They are certainly doing well targeting races abroad but as far as the British based operation in concerned let's be in no doubt British/French/Irish big races are the cream and Godolphin are not winning them.
|
|
By:
No runner in the King George this weekend.
Thats where the bar is set Galileo vs Fantastic Light was one of the Great races Now they can't even muster a 100/1 shot rag or a horse even worth its salt in such a race |
|
By:
The Sandown Mile wasn't the best British Group 2 in 2009.
What 3yo averages have to do with the Grosser Preis Von Baden only you know. The GPVB made it into 19th place on thoroughbred rankings last year. The years before that it was 23rd (2008), 45th (2007), 105th (2006), 56th (2005) - that's hardly remaining "in the top 20 races in the world on thoroughbred rankings, as it has been for quite a while." In each of those years the best Group 2 figures in England would have been good enough to win the GPVB: 121, 122, 119, 118 respectively. Last year's best Group 2 figure (119) would not have been good enough to win the GPVB but the winner (Getaway) was still never good enough to win a Group 1 in any other country. This German G1 doesn't knock the spots off the very cream of European G2s. Based on figures already mentioned your best German G2 of the last 3 years does not compare favourably. If you do initiate a pissing contest make sure your figures are correct instead of making them up. |
|
By:
As you've shown you need to be better than a Group 2 horse to win the race, therefore these races aren't p!ss easy to win. The King George is obviously the best middle distance race this month but Campanologist's race is still a challenging Group 1 and the form of the race looks worthy of a Group 1 with the horses in there all capable of running big races in Group 1s throughout the World.
|
|
By:
my mistake, I misread - it's 3 year averages rather than 3yo averages.
It's still rubbish though. |
|
By:
I have quickly run Group 1 numbers through my database.
From 1996 onwards based upon 1048 Group 1 races, for horses aged 3 or over (excluding 2 year olds is obvious) the average winning rating is as follows: Globally (exc. Germany) 114 Germany 106 |
|
By:
ben, what I've shown is that, generally, you don't need to be better than a Group 2 horse to win the race. Piss easy may be dismissive but it's in relation to other Group 1s throughout Europe.
Incidentally, the best Group 2 rating of 2009 (119) was achieved by Bronze Cannon in the Hardwicke Stakes. He beat Campanology. |
|
By:
The Sandown Mile wasn't the best British Group 2 in 2009.
Yes it was, according to the European Pattern Committee. Maybe your figures are more official than that, though, hippie? Anyway, if you'd like to tell the class which British G2 you think was the best I'll tell you the race rating and where it really sits in the 2009 table. What 3yo averages have to do with the Grosser Preis Von Baden only you know. Oh dear. Not 3-y-o average. Three Year Average (as you have just deduced). It is the rolling figure that all European Pattern races are judged on. There appears to be a degree of ignorance here regarding the mechanism of European Pattern races, such as how they are rated, who rates them and what the ratings are. If you would like me to provide further insight into this, such as the parameters for various sections and how races are upgraded or downgraded, feel free to ask. The GPVB made it into 19th place on thoroughbred rankings last year. The years before that it was 23rd (2008), 45th (2007), 105th (2006), 56th (2005) - that's hardly remaining "in the top 20 races in the world on thoroughbred rankings, as it has been for quite a while." Fair cop - I made that very last bit up. It is still quite evident to anyone who can count that the GPVB performs to a higher level than any G2 in Europe and, as stated, it is an insult to compare them. In each of those years the best Group 2 figures in England would have been good enough to win the GPVB: 121, 122, 119, 118 respectively. Last year's best Group 2 figure (119) would not have been good enough to win the GPVB but the winner (Getaway) was still never good enough to win a Group 1 in any other country. I haven't a clue what figures you're computing, hippie, but they are not the ones, agreed by European Handicappers, that European Pattern races are judged on officially. My stats are rock solid and can be found in the 2010 European Pattern Book - an excellent publication and one you'd do well to track down. As a taster, I can exclusively reveal the highest single rating awarded to any 3-y-o or 3-y-o+ G2 in GB covering 2007, 2008 and 2009 was the 2008 Dante, which was awarded an end-of-season rating of 118.75. During that period there were 121 G2s awarded a rating in Britain yet, even accounting for that freakishly high number in the Dante, none of them could match any of the GPVBs in the same period. You are flogging a dead horse. This German G1 doesn't knock the spots off the very cream of European G2s. If it was demoted to G2 level it would be the best G2 in Europe by a margin. I think we can now safely say it does knock the spots of them, hippie. Based on figures already mentioned your best German G2 of the last 3 years does not compare favourably. This is a simple exerice of working out which numbers are biggest. We're in trouble if that's proving difficult. If you do initiate a pissing contest make sure your figures are correct instead of making them up. Firstly, what is a pissing contest? Secondly, have I won yet? And thirdly, if "my" figures don't match the ones available in the Hippie Beginners' Guide to European Flat Racing speak to HRI, France Galop, BHA, the Direktorium and UNIRE. I've played no part in them. Thanks. (Hardwicke btw - 113.50. Miles off the pace.) |
|
By:
my figures are "the official end of season assessments of the top thoroughbred racehorses" so yes my figures are more official than yours.
get over yourself. |
|
By:
2009 WORLD THOROUGHBRED RANKINGS
Rank: 65 Rating: 119 Cat: L Surface: T Horse: Bronze Cannon (USA) Sire: Lemon Drop Kid (USA) YOF: 2005 Sex: C Trainer: J.H. M. Gosden Trained: GB Position: 1st Race: Hardwicke Date: 20th June Group: 2 Distance: 2400 Race Run: GB |
|
By:
Nothing you've posted suggests you want a sensible discussion about German horseracing. You just want a pissing contest. I'm providing facts to back up my statements and can provide lots more. The Sandown Mile wasn't the best British Group 2 in 2009. My mistake, I misread - it's 3 year averages rather than 3yo averages. It's still rubbish though. This German G1 doesn't knock the spots off the very cream of European G2s. My figures are more official than yours.
...and finally get over yourself. ![]() |