Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
stewarty b
05 May 14 16:20
Joined:
Date Joined: 02 Aug 02
| Topic/replies: 41,487 | Blogger: stewarty b's blog
That is, if you started off at say 10%, you would then stay on the same system but with no weekly decay. And when you reached 2.5% that would be your permanent rate. I for one would go for this little plan of mine as I often take a break from punting from time to time and inevitably end up back on 5%.

I'm not sure if this would be a massive benefit to Betfair but given the choice, would YOU plump for my idea?
Pause • Switch to Standard View Would anyone on here be willing to...
Show More
Loading...
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 4:25 PM BST
* I should have added that if there were plenty in favour of my idea I would E.Mail Betfair and put this strategy of mine forward to them. At the very least, they might give it food for thought?
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 4:42 PM BST
When I say I would go for it, obviously, every forumite would be given the choice as to whether go down my route or stay as they are.
Report iprefertolay • May 5, 2014 4:42 PM BST
no
Report JML • May 5, 2014 4:44 PM BST
I much prefer an idea of much less commission and more PC.
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 4:53 PM BST
So, that's 2-1 in favour so far..
Report JML • May 5, 2014 5:01 PM BST
I make it 1--2
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 5:07 PM BST
It was tongue in cheek. Having said that, I stand by my way of being given the choice.
Report JML • May 5, 2014 5:15 PM BST
The biggest drawback with your idea is that when everyone is on 2.5% Betfair will move the goalposts.
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 5:21 PM BST
Not if it was set in stone. Plus a lot of punters might take years to reach the 2.5% meaning Betfair would coin it in. It would definitely suit me.
Report stewarty b • May 5, 2014 5:21 PM BST
*Even starting at 12%
Report unitedbiscuits • May 5, 2014 9:03 PM BST
Non starter.
Would make whole site unfriendly to the visitor.
Report stewarty b • May 6, 2014 10:29 AM BST
Non starter.
Would make whole site unfriendly to the visitor.




Do you mean by that the occasionally recreational punter? If so, it's not them that keeps Betfair afloat, plus they would still be better off with up to 20% better odds.
Report stewarty b • May 6, 2014 10:44 AM BST
Come to think about it, it would probably give Betfair more business as punters like myself would have the incentive to bet more to get down to the holy grail of 2.5%. When I reached that figure Betfair would receive all of my business instead of going elsewhere. ie. I want 500 on an even money shot and some other 'firm' can provide these same odds but with a higher commission. It  would be a no brainer. Better Betfair getting 2.5% commission of my business than getting nothing at all?
Report CoinFlip • May 6, 2014 10:54 AM BST
Seems a bit like the public pension where your revenue gets worse every year because the existing population grows without a corresponding growth in new people. 

That said, the logic does hold on the decay to an extent as a lifetime reflection on the value you provide.  With new customers redirected to sportsbook, you're going to get diminishing returns each year.  Might be the right way to treat your customers but unlikely any businessman will sign this off.

Bear in mind that the number of points to get to 2% wouldn't be 150,000 either.  I imagine it would be more like (150,000/15%) 1m points if it did go ahead.

Personally, I think I've probably only generated about 50,000 points, would get something rubbish like 9% and my proportion of bets on here would reduce from ~50% to about ~15% I reckon.

I've always been an advocate of what JML wrote as a purer economic model but it is incredibly risky.  BF would have to accept the risk of the slashing the revenue generator in return for potential growth.  In a pure exchange market segment, the current model is definitely cash cow in the BCG rather than star.  The question really is - are you willing to try it as a star in the sports gambling market or keep it as a cash cow in exchange betting?
Report stewarty b • May 6, 2014 11:25 AM BST
You make valid points CoinFlip. I didn't really take into account new members being directed to sportsbook, unless they have been recommended the exchange from a friend.

As for Bear in mind that the number of points to get to 2% wouldn't be 150,000 either., I'm talking 2.5% and I can't see any reason why the 150,000 points would have to change.

Perhaps my idea is only suitable for customers that have been here for say, five years plus. Having said that, I did mention that every member would have to be given the choice.

I don't know for sure but I'm pretty certain I've generated well over 1,000,000 points plus since joining BF.

Given that scenario, I think I should get some kind of 'reward' from BF for being a loyal customer and I can't think of any other way of rewarding customers like myself.

No doubt if I spoke to BF about my idea it would probably be dismissed, but like I said earlier, it might give them food for thought.
Report stewarty b • May 6, 2014 11:31 AM BST
I wish my old forum friend was still posting so that he could give his viewpoint. Sadly, he doesn't post anymore.Sad
Report stewarty b • May 6, 2014 12:51 PM BST
I don't know for sure but I'm pretty certain I've generated well over 1,000,000 points plus since joining BF.



Having given that part of my post some thought I have E.Mailed my man at BF to get an accurate figure.


I'm guessing it's far more than a million and will post the amount here when I get a reply.
Report CoinFlip • May 6, 2014 1:12 PM BST
I agree that a reward scheme makes more sense as a genuine loyalty measure.  I think the decaying system is outdated and has probably been since the PC came in initially.  I think if you pose the question, "does my past use count for anything?" They would have to say that it counts for very little.  I suppose the counter is that you've got use of the product in that time as well and if you're up then you've done ok in that way as well.

My point about the 1m points was that if now, say, 2% of active customers have a
Report CoinFlip • May 6, 2014 1:15 PM BST
Hmm not sure where my post went.  Basically
- small proportion on that rate now, proportion would grow
- based on a year I reckon you would need a min of 600k pts for 2.5% and 1.1m for 2%
- Probably increase that by a third to adjust for bigger groups
- not sure if BF has much incentive to go for it though
Report bilbobaggins • May 6, 2014 5:00 PM BST
Loyalty scheme excellent idea and if the PC was removed I'd happily pay up to 12% to make sure it stayed that way.
Report askari1 • May 6, 2014 10:19 PM BST
They want outright bets not traders' money and surely 12% makes it prohibitive?
Report screaming from beneaththewaves • May 7, 2014 12:04 AM BST
I'd prefer the option of paying Betfair a monkey per month upfront with commission then falling to 0%.

Under that system Betfair would receive the same commission from me as they always have done, but the difference would be that the amount I bet on here would go through the roof. Nearly all the money I currently have to channel through betting shops would go through the exchange. At present, if a selection is available at 4.1 on here and 3/1 with bookmakers, I have to waste a morning cycling from shop to shop to get my money on at 3/1. The result is I can never turn over enough on here to get my commission rate below 4%, the rate at which 4.0 in a betting shop is no longer better value than 4.1 on Betfair.

The advantage of the system I suggest for Betfair would be that the exchange would swiftly come to dominate betting in every country in which it was available, with huge amounts available to back and lay, as the site would at last be competitive with commission-free bookmakers.

The advantage for me would be that I would no longer be a typical Betfair net loser, paying £500/month commission on gross profits of, say, £100. With a multitude of further bets suddenly becoming value at 0% commission, I am pretty confident I could generate enough gross profit to become a net winner.
Report Deltâ • May 7, 2014 7:20 AM BST
there's something wrong with a system that means my winning bets are placed here and the rest of my turnover and in the majority losing bets are turned away and have to go to Purple because of commission rate ... them bets/lays would provide extra liquidity here as would others...
Report stewarty b • May 7, 2014 4:10 PM BST
Having given that part of my post some thought I have E.Mailed my man at BF to get an accurate figure.


I'm guessing it's far more than a million and will post the amount here when I get a reply.



I did get a reply from BF but the E.Mail received had a link to it instead of giving me a straight answer. When I tried to get into the link, apparently I had to pay 9.99 DOLLARS to see it!!!

I'm on the case for a simple reply.
Report mardock • May 7, 2014 5:37 PM BST
That is, if you started off at say 10%, you would then stay on the same system but with no weekly decay. And when you reached 2.5% that would be your permanent rate.

For me weekly decay would be ok, even permanent 10% commision is ok for me - Just give me that 10% commsion instead of 50% Premium Charges and I can start thinking about come back to betfair.
Report stewarty b • May 7, 2014 7:19 PM BST
I can't comment on your PC charges mardock, but I have stated previously on other threads on this forum that if I incurred the PC charge, it would only be once...
Report stewarty b • May 8, 2014 2:37 PM BST
Dear Stewart,



Thank you for your call.

I have reached the figure of 366,896 for total commission points accrued on the account ******* - this is taking the weekly decay rate into consideration.



The total commission paid on this account is £20,331.66 over a volume of 902,391.40 in bets.



Kind regards,



This cannot be right imo. Any sharp minds on here care to comment as I may be missing something? Especially the words.....


this is taking the weekly decay rate into consideration.


I'm thinking and guessing that these figures may be from the new commission rate we have now. I'm sure there will be many on this forum who remembers when the weekly decay rate was 10%??
Report Eddie the eagle • May 8, 2014 4:50 PM BST
What is it that can't be right ?
Your £20,331.66 commission paid would give 203,316 points earned so that leaves 163,580 points earned on your losing bets.
  This again means you during your lifetime on here have earned roughly net £80,000 (100 k before commission and 20 k commission paid).   I've estimated you to be on average 4 % commission which can't be to far from the truth.

  this is taking the weekly decay rate into consideration.

Betfair points are calculated from your commission rate at the time of settling a market and not the market base rate, so it's (almost) impossible for them to calculate how many points you would have accrued had there been no weekly decay.
Report stewarty b • May 9, 2014 10:35 AM BST
Thanks for your reply Eddie. I will try my best to get my head around these figures. The 4% you mention is fairly accurate I would guess, but when it was the old commission rate I know that I got down to approx. 2.7% at one time.
Report stewarty b • May 9, 2014 10:56 AM BST
Just one other thing Eddie. Do you agree with my opening post? ie: Punters like myself should get some kind of reward for being a loyal customer? And let's just say that I have a break for a couple of months I should be put straight back to a commission rate of, perhaps 4%?
Report Latalomne • May 9, 2014 11:18 AM BST
If you're having breaks of a couple of months, what is there to say you are a loyal customer? 

Weekly decay is actually a pretty good indicator of your 'loyalty', I'm afraid. 

There are plenty of things wrong with how BF generates its revenue, but this is not one of them.

How many new punters do you actually think would be attracted to betting here knowing they'd be stung for 10/12% on each and every winning bet?  Sure, it might suit some of the old guard - particularly so if it were applied retrospectively - but with the continued existence of the spectre of PC, I can't for one moment see how it would have a positive impact on the exchange.
Report U.A. • May 9, 2014 1:40 PM BST
I think that your idea has a few problems.

Firstly your charging 10% for new customers. That's going to deter a lot of new clients who will just go somewhere cheaper/better value. The problem with your argument about them really wanting just big time bettors as opposed to recreational occasional punters is that I think people join and then evolve into this type of person rather than from day 1 saying "hey i'm going to join this company and be a big hitter right from the off." As such these people simply wont join in the first place.

Next there is the problem with the time that it takes to reach this 2.5% commission stage. At the moment there seems to be a lot of talk/belief that BF is going downhill, so won't people be concerned that they pay upfront now but by the time it comes to recouping their upfront costs it might be too late. Again another deterrent.

Also we have a bit of a problem with setting this structure in stone. How are we as punters going to believe that BF wont change the goalposts. Any kind of reassurance that they cross their heart and hope to die, stick a needle in their eye if they do change the rules wont be good enough. The only thing that punters will believe would be if there was a legal clause that simply meant that they couldn't change the rules. Only then would i be confident that it can't change in the future. The trouble with that is that it would be a suicidal move for any company to say this is what we are going to charge and no matter what happens in the future we will never be able to change it. BF just simply will not and should not do this.

Finally I'm afraid that I don't think you are a loyal customer. No offense but you talk about betting elsewhere and only using BF when it was in your own financial interest. That to me is not loyalty. A valued customer yes but not loyal. If you want them to change their charging structure for you what guarantee can you give them that you will put more business your way?
Report stewarty b • May 9, 2014 7:10 PM BST
Finally I'm afraid that I don't think you are a loyal customer. No offense but you talk about betting elsewhere and only using BF when it was in your own financial interest. That to me is not loyalty. A valued customer yes but not loyal. If you want them to change their charging structure for you what guarantee can you give them that you will put more business your way?



I presume the 'your' in your post actually means 'their' way?


That aside, I have mentioned on this thread that proper punters should be given the choice. I know one forumite on here who pays approx. 4.7% commission and yet, he still pays 60% of his winnings via the PC charge. (he is a trader  I should add)



Finally I'm afraid that I don't think you are a loyal customer. No offense but you talk about betting elsewhere and only using BF when it was in your own financial interest


That is true, but when you get a telephone call from another 'firm' saying they will put me on 1% commission for two months then it's a no brainer. The 'firm' I speak about are happy to receive 1% commission from me rather than 0% of nothing..
Report stewarty b • May 9, 2014 8:01 PM BST
U.A. I'm probably wrong but you sound to me like a Betfair employee/shareholder.

I am not anti-Betfair, however I think they should treat a 'valued' customer better re: commission rates.

In the past, when Sporting Options went 'bust' BF kindly put a four figure sum into my account and the rest that I was owed by these shysters, BF to their credit gave me commission free points until the rest of my money which was retrieved that  was 'stolen' by SO.


Add to that, BF have given me 'credit' in the past due to a fck up by my bank. I was surprised by this to be honest, but perhaps they do value me as a 'valued' customer?
Report loper • May 10, 2014 8:36 AM BST
How long ago did Betfair provide this act of charity?

Having had a close relationship with Betfair prior to the original team selling out.

Now I'm just a cash cow that they just want to milk until I bleed.
Report TheInvestor2 • May 10, 2014 12:40 PM BST
A better idea would be to let people have a lot more 'Betfair holidays'.
Report TheInvestor2 • May 10, 2014 12:41 PM BST
And bring back the 50% decay for Christmas which was silently removed a few years ago! Laugh
Report U.A. • May 10, 2014 1:27 PM BST
HI Stewarty.

Yes i did mean their instead of your.
No I am not nor have I ever been a Betfair employee or shareholder. I'm sure that if I were an employee I would be busy ignoring this thread.
I do think people should look after valued employees definitely, however there is always the case that if you have no other serious competitors then this can easily be forgotten.

As for your whole thread I think bringing in a completely different charging structure to run alongside another one, well we both know it's not going to happen. Too confusing, too much effort and too much admin/cost. Like you mentioned rather than doing this they should just speak to valued customers to make sure they are happy and build some kind of relationship with them. I think your best chance if you want some kind of concession from them is to tell them you are not happy, that you will reduce your betting with them as you have better options elsewhere and then stop betting with them for a while. Then contact them again and see if they've had a change of heart. Of course I have never been a valued customer so I may well be talking rubbish so feel free to ignore.
Report stewarty b • May 10, 2014 2:03 PM BST
How long ago did Betfair provide this act of charity?


I can't remember the exact date never mind the year, but  they did stick 1k into my account and the rest of my balance with Sporting Options that was 'stolen' from me was used as a commission gesture.

To the best of my recollection BF carried out this action so that punters didn't get scared of an exchange system.
Report stewarty b • May 10, 2014 2:07 PM BST
Sporting Options was an English betting exchange, based in Sussex. The company was founded in 2000 by former City of London options traders Robert Byrne and Kevin Griffiths. Sporting Options went into administration on 15 November 2004 amid allegations of criminal wrongdoing. Industry leader Betfair stepped in with a rescue package.

Cause of collapse[edit]

Sporting Options appeared to be matching bets worth up to 15% of those matched at Betfair. But it was alleged the turnover was being financed by the owners of Sporting Options using their own funds to create the liquidity.

By late 2004, it was alleged Sporting Options was in fact fraudulently financing its apparent liquidity by using funds from its own clients' account. On 15 November 2004 administrators were called in. By 8 December the administrators had determined that the company owed £3.6 million to its clients, but held only minimal funds in the clients' account.


Betfair rescue package[edit]

Soon after Sporting Options went into administration, Betfair announced a rescue package to compensate the 5,342 Sporting Options clients who had lost money. The clients affected were required to register as customers of Betfair to be eligible. Each qualifying client owed less than £1,000 was compensated for the full amount owing (in the form of a credit to his or her Betfair account). Those owed more than £1,000 received either £1,000 or 20 per cent of their Sporting Options account balance, whichever was greater. Any amount owing over and above this payout could be earned back though a commission rebate program, valid through to 30 November 2006.

Some speculated[who?] that Betfair's apparent act of generosity was a bid to protect the reputation of the betting exchange industry, while simultaneously securing exclusive access to Sporting Options' clients. Betfair and most other exchanges have stressed their clients' funds are ring-fenced to ensure the exchanges' financial integrity.
Report logroller • May 11, 2014 5:24 AM BST
Sporting Options appeared to be matching bets worth up to 15% of those matched at Betfair. But it was alleged the turnover was being financed by the owners of Sporting Options using their own funds to create the liquidity


Stew, is it illegal for betting exchanges to seed their own markets?
Report stewarty b • May 11, 2014 7:35 PM BST
I don't know the answer to your question logroller, but if it isn't it should be imo.


There have been rumours of other exchanges carrying out this practice but that was a few years ago.

Perhaps someone else can answer your question, but this from the same post may be of help...


By late 2004, it was alleged Sporting Options was in fact fraudulently financing its apparent liquidity by using funds from its own clients' account. On 15 November 2004 administrators were called in. By 8 December the administrators had determined that the company owed £3.6 million to its clients, but held only minimal funds in the clients' account.
Report stewarty b • May 11, 2014 7:53 PM BST
I should add that I followed this case up for 18 months or so and to the best of my knowledge the two shysters who ran SO, Robert Byrne and Kevin Griffiths were never prosecuted.
Report logroller • May 12, 2014 6:16 AM BST
using funds from its own clients' account


I think the illegal practice was just that, or is now, maybe not back then. (Robert Byrne and Kevin Griffiths were never prosecuted) I am lead to believe that all exchanges, ALL, seed certain markets, weather thru a subsidiary company in Malta or under the guise of fixed odds betting departments.
Report iprefertolay • May 14, 2014 8:21 PM BST
dont give them more amunition to rip us off for god sake!
Report racingguru • May 15, 2014 4:28 AM BST
Wish someone would seed the freekin early price horse markets properly ......ghost town last few years.
Report stewarty b • May 15, 2014 3:53 PM BST
dont give them more amunition to rip us off for god sake!



I can't see it being a rip off if you're given the choice.
Report askari1 • May 16, 2014 10:06 AM BST
Bf do have a prob. w/ their charging structure in that it incentivises me to place they, the bookie/exchange, don't want and dissuades me from placing the bets and contributing the liquidity they'd be quite glad of.

Whenever I want to stick a few hundred quid on something at a marginal value price I fancy, I can do better in the shops or at another exchange. I have enough placers to get 200 quid ew on a 16-1 shot or failing that, I can get some on myself and some at BetButler (a concierge service). When I want to trade two ticks e.g. 14 down to 13, I'm always better off on bf than anywhere else. But this kind of bet just drains from the pool and isn't desirable for them.

If they made things harder for traders and rewarded opinion players / tissue-makers for contributing liquidity and keeping their money around longer, they'd have a better offer for the recreational loser. But they don't want to appeal to the recreational player's intelligence and be the best betting offer anywhere for any player.
Report askari1 • May 16, 2014 10:07 AM BST
*to place bets they don't want
Report stewarty b • May 16, 2014 4:19 PM BST
I'm going to put my idea forward to them on #AskBetfair – Customer Q&A Tuesday 27th May 18:00 – 19:30 (GMT). I hope I get a reply even if it's to say they will consider it, or a straightforward no.
Report U.A. • May 17, 2014 12:19 AM BST
Could you ask them to send me tickets for the world cup final whilst you are at it please.
Report stewarty b • May 19, 2014 4:06 PM BST
I take it that would be for the England end?
Report bingo bongo • May 19, 2014 6:25 PM BST
With no weekly decay a lot of bigger customers would quickly reach 2.5% especially starting at 10% commission. Then assuming the PC charge terms stay the same it will be a lot easier for people to reduce their PC bill. Betfair will lose out twice over after an initial gain from increased commission. So I don't think they'd go for it, unfortunately.
Report stewarty b • May 19, 2014 8:15 PM BST
Thanks for your input bingo bongo. Do you think U A is serious when he asks for world cup final tickets? I'm guessing his team might not reach that stage??
Report stewarty b • May 21, 2014 5:57 PM BST
U A, I did ask my man at Betfair if they could arrange your request. However when I told him it was for the England end for the final, he told me to stop taking the mickey and call him back in forty eight years time and he said he would see what he could do.


*This was after he stopped laughing. Having said that, I've maybe picked you up wrong and you're maybe a Holland fan?
Report U.A. • May 22, 2014 1:32 PM BST
In that case it's a good job you didn't ask for any tickets for a major competition in a Scotland end otherwise I think you would have sent him to hospital. For the record I do support England and no I don't expect them to get to the final.

Not sure what all this stuff is about that you would only want to watch a game if you supported one of the teams in it. Call me crazy but I actually like watching football games, well important games anyway. Not fussed about watching Panionios v Xanthi but more than happy to watch R Madrid v A Madrid CL Final even though I don't support any of those teams.

I only thought that if you were putting up crazy ideas/suggestions to betfair then I may as well get in there. By the way if you get yourself onto your suggested commission structure then I expect my tickets and if betfair wont provide them then I shall assume it's because you didn't try hard enough so will expect them from you instead.
Report stewarty b • May 22, 2014 3:27 PM BST
Call me crazy but I actually like watching football games


Nothing crazy about that, I enjoy watching most levels of football especially if I have a financial interest in them.


Given the lack of support I've had on here I doubt if I will take up my idea with Betfair, but I still stand by that valued customers should be given some sort of initiative to remain valued instead of going elsewhere.

My commission idea is the only one I can come up with.
Report DOUBLED • May 22, 2014 4:25 PM BST
Dont think its a lack of support more like the feeling that Betfair do these Q&A things as a PR exercise and dont actually give a **** what we think Shocked
Report getintheir • May 22, 2014 9:27 PM BST
NO
Report stewarty b • May 23, 2014 7:01 PM BST
getintheir




 


     getintheir   






  22 May 14 21:27 
Joined:


  29 Sep 01 
    | Topic/replies: 1,309  | Blogger: getintheir's blog   



NO



Thanks for your reasoning and input...
Report U.A. • May 23, 2014 11:52 PM BST
Don't worry about everyone else or some new elaborate structure, why don't you just ask them if you can have more holiday periods and explain that this will mean that when you do bet you will be able to bet much more with them and so they will benefit as well.

Seems like the easiest option and your best chance, and you've got nothing to lose.
Report stewarty b • May 27, 2014 7:26 PM BST
why don't you just ask them if you can have more holiday periods and explain that this will mean that when you do bet you will be able to bet much more with them and so they will benefit as well.


That sounds a good idea, and while I'm at it I could also ask for a free £1,000 bet every day..
Report U.A. • May 28, 2014 10:44 AM BST
OK now i am confused as you seem to have posted a rather facetious response to my comment, maybe one of the following might explain it.

1) Is it payback for me asking if you could ask betfair for world cup tickets.
2) Are you confused and did not understand that when i refer to holiday periods I am referring to 4 holiday periods that you have as a maximum where your commission does not decay by 15%
3) Payback for my slightly derogatory scottish football comments.
4) You genuinely feel that asking for say an extra couple of holiday periods is really taking the p!ss and they are going to think that you are being so greedy that they will tell you to go F!ck yourself.

If it is 4) I would have thought that this was a lot more reasonable than asking them to create a new charging structure for you and I wouldn't have thought that this concession would have been that high for a valued customer who would be able to reciprocate by giving them more business.

Oh well good luck whatever you do.
Report stewarty b • May 29, 2014 8:29 PM BST
Your idea of more holiday periods and my idea of getting down to 2.5% commission and staying there is like comparing a flea with a crocodile.


Having said that, I wish you a prosperous future.
Report Latalomne • May 30, 2014 9:10 AM BST
I agree with UA.
Report stewarty b • May 30, 2014 2:49 PM BST
Good. End of thread.
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com