Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
bilbobaggins
30 Sep 11 09:54
Joined:
Date Joined: 06 Jul 01
| Topic/replies: 11,047 | Blogger: bilbobaggins's blog
The short paragraph in the 244 page flotation prosepctus looked anodyne ennough.

Among 13 pages of risk factors was the generic heading: "Failure to adequately protect customer account information could have a material adverse effect on Betfair."

In one sentence the betting exchange, then shooting for a £1.39bn valuation, admitted it had "experienced a limited number of security breaches in the past [which have not had a significant effect on Betfair's reputation, operations, financial performance and prospects and in respect of which remedial action has been taken]".

No great drama there, then. Indeed, any potential investor weighing up last October's £13-a-share float was much more likely to have focused on the prominent description of Betfair's "unique" exchange technology, supporting more than 3m registered customers.

It "processed, on average, more than 5m transactions per day... more than on all European stock exchanges combined", page two of the prospectus trumpeted – a claim frequently echoed by David Yu, the man who graduated from chief technology officer to chief executive.

Nowhere did the prospectus – punted to investors by Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Barclays Capital and Numis Securities – detail what had really been going on lately with Betfair's renowned technology.

Namely, that a bunch of cyber-criminals, possibly originating in Cambodia, had breached the company's security systems on March 14, 2010. They had subsequently stolen, among other things, 2.28m "encrypted payment card account numbers and details", 3.16m "account user names with encrypted security questions" and 89,744 "account usernames with bank account details".

Indeed, a progress report marked "Betfair Critical Confidential" tells how "the attacker did indeed manage to copy the entire Sportex database" – the one that contains all cardholder details. The report is dated September 27, 2010. That's just six days after the company announced its "intention to list" – a statement containing Yu's explanation of how "Betfair's unique and highly sophisticated exchange platform technology is at the very heart of the company's success".

Such a confident statement is itself surprising. Just a month before the decision to press ahead with the float, Betfair had received a "Forensic Investigation Report" on the cyber theft from security consultancy Information Risk Management (IRM).

Its first conclusion was that: "Appropriate information security governance is not in place within Betfair and as a consequence the business has been exposed to significant risks."

Another one? That "appropriate technical controls relating to such elements as network segregation and file integrity monitoring that would provide Betfair the ability to deter, prevent and detect such an incident are not in place".

Neither did the prospectus detail the criminal and regulatory brouhaha unleashed by Betfair's belated discovery that, in the words of the "Project Brazil Progress Report, "a large volume of data" had been stolen.

The first Betfair knew of the theft was when a "production log server" crashed in its Malta data centre on May 20 – more than two months after the initial breach. That led to the discovery that "at least nine servers [had] been compromised in the UK and two in Malta".

The data was extracted, it turned out, "beyond Betfair's information systems perimeter via compromised hosts located within public internet service providers", themselves located in Belgium and Germany.

The theft was so serious that Betfair was forced to inform the UK's Serious Organised Crime Agency (SOCA), the Australian Federal Police and German law enforcement officials. It also notified the UK Gambling Commission and the Maltese Lotteries and Gaming Authority, as well as Royal Bank of Scotland, its "acquiring bank" – the lender responsible for accepting credit and debit card payments made via Betfair.

An "Incident Report to Regulators", dated July 15, 2010, explains that the thieves' haul included "approximately 850,000 unexpired credit card details" – a large number in relation to the company's current 949,000 "active users", or regular gamblers.

"We have taken the prudent view that the criminal has the expertise to decrypt the payment card details," Betfair admitted, though stressed that the "CVV2/CVC security numbers" were not stolen.

It said advice from RBS was that "this very significantly limits the ability of the cards to be used fraudulently".

On Thursday, in its first comments on the affair, Betfair insisted that the data were "unusable for fraudulent activity" and "there was no risk to customers".

Its July report to regulators states it had decided there was no reason to inform its customers, after taking advice from SOCA that "public disclosure would be detrimental to any intelligence operation or investigation".

It would have also been detrimental to its float. Betfair was, after all, listed on a racy earnings multiple thanks to some clever marketing that repositioned a business reliant on gamblers as a wizzy technology stock.

Investors have since lost 43pc of their money. They might now wish, notwithstanding Betfair's insistence that "remedial action" had been taken, that they had heard how consultants IMR pithily summed up Betfair's technology: "The IT infrastructure has not been designed, built or maintained to best practices."

THIS IS A SCANDAL THAT COULD RUN AND RUN - WITH BF PURSUED THROUGH THE COURTS FOR INVESTORS LOSSES.

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 3  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 90
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 10:03
WOULD YOU BE SO KIND AS TO POST THE SOURCE OF THESE VERY SERIOUS ALLEGATIONS.
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 30 Sep 11 10:04
I read this in the telegraph today
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 10:05
...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/8797834/Criminals-stole-customer-card-data-from-Betfair-just-months-before-float.html
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 10:06
Should have just posted the link...

I always thought companies were legally obligated under Data Protection to inform customers if they lost their data
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 10:07
Betfair seriously need to get their PR sorted out.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 10:12
have reporters declared war on betfair
By:
hazel
When: 30 Sep 11 10:17
If this is true, it further highlights that the senior managers should not have been offered very lucrative pay and bonuses after the float, but rather that the man at the top should have resigned.   It makes shareholders look foolish.  It makes customers think there is no difference between Sony and Betfair when it comes to customer data security and customer services.
By:
bilbobaggins
When: 30 Sep 11 10:20
Telegraph - sorry.
By:
the silverback
When: 30 Sep 11 10:31
My word the knives are out.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 10:32
should not have been offered very lucrative pay and bonuses after the float


-----

Wonder what else they kept under the carpet before the float
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 10:54
A Betfair spokesman said: "Eighteen months ago we were subject to an attempted data theft. Because of our security measures, the data was unusable for fraudulent activity and we were able to recover the data intact. At the time, we contacted all the relevant authorities and worked closely with them regarding this matter and it was established that there was no risk to customers."

The statement doesnt make sense:

1. Subject to attempted data theft. (Was data stolen in this attempt?)

2. Data was unusable for fraudulent activity. (Data must have been stolen if they say it was unusable for fraud.)

3. Data was recovered intact. (How does this work? Was data taken leaving no copy at all at Betfair so it needed to be recovered to be used again by BF? If Betfair could use the recovered data how do we know no one else could (if it was encrypted could it not be cracked?)? Maybe it was a physical theft of a server that was recovered before the thief left the building?)
By:
hazel
When: 30 Sep 11 11:03
"no risk to customers"

Usernames, security questions, addresses, bank details, card details

Absolutely no risk there then.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 11:04
Im guessing it was data which could not be used for fraudulent activities such as a list of accounts numbers with the last 4 digits of card details like

23123123123 3525
21341252525 4343

which is usually the type of data which kept on local servers. It does makes for a powerful newspaper headline though "Cyber-criminals stole the payment card details of almost 2.3m Betfair customers"
By:
the silverback
When: 30 Sep 11 11:09
Is that sort of data really unusable when in the hands of professionals?
By:
mrbojangles
When: 30 Sep 11 11:16
Toyota and Sony are two prime examples of how not to do it with regards to damage limitation.

Toyota cars were allegedly responsible for hundreds of deaths due to sudden acceleration and other safety issues yet the company sat on vital data for years which could have prevented further fatalaties.

Eventually they got off the fence but layed the blame on poorly fitted floor mats which led to congressional hearings and humiliation across Toyota's global operations.

Two years later their market share is still in freefall and most industry commentators believe they will never recover.

More recently Sony buried their heads in the sand following data losses and the damage this has caused is rising daily.

Swift immediate action is the answer for any company suffering potential brand damage and this should start with a no nonsense statement from the very top clearly outlining the issues,and more importantly what action they are proposing to ensure no further repeats.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 11:20
As far as I know, yes.

I believe (although Im sure more clued up people can expand on this) that there are legal restrictions with storing financial payment details of customers which I think is why when you go to online shopping etc you only see last 4 digits of card when selecting previous payment choice as the rest of the details are stored elsewhere and are only called for the transaction.
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 11:28
In the early years the people at the top of Betfair would regularly communicate with their users. I cannot remember ever reading a statement from the current CEO directed to customers. Mark Davies used to be the public face of Betfair. Who is it now?
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 11:35
Surely every customer (of the 2.3 million) should have been sent an email informing them of the breach and then reassuring them that no customers were at risk.

The fact they shoved it under the carpet sends a disturbing message as to the changing priorities of this company.

Profit
Sharehodlers
Bonuses















Customers
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 30 Sep 11 12:05
Shocking stuff but you wonder why people feel the need to hack the site. If they want to defraud betfair customers why don't they just register and betfair will give them a helping hand to do the rest?
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 30 Sep 11 12:15
"We have taken the prudent view that the criminal has the expertise to decrypt the payment card details," Betfair admitted, though stressed that the "CVV2/CVC security numbers" were not stolen."

As far as I was aware companies aren't meant to keep a record of those numbers anyway? Does that mean Betfair were keeping a record and it was secure or that was the one item not stolen because they didn't hold it anyway?
By:
dave1357
When: 30 Sep 11 12:31
This is the end for me - they must think there customers are mugs, so I can't support such a company.
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 13:07
From the bank of america:

When is it acceptable to store CVV2 & CVC?

It is never acceptable for Acquirers, merchants, or service providers to retain CVV2 and CVC, which consists of the last three digits printed on the signature panel of all Visa and MasterCard cards, subsequent to transaction authorization. The Visa and MasterCard Operating Regulations prohibit such storage, whether encrypted or unencrypted
By:
Duncan Disordorli
When: 30 Sep 11 13:12
Surely not from the real Mark Davies...??? [:o]

markdavies
Today 11:48 AM
Recommended by
4 people
Last year betfair allegedly lost £10 million on a botched casino promotion.

betfair have welched on these payouts and in some cases have retrieved funds from peoples bank accounts

http://www.casinomeister.com/f...

then in the first set of results after this fiasco, betfair have incurred an an extra £10 million spend on IT which is declared as "assets"

The Telegraph is only scratching the surface at the moment, but the house of cards that is betfair will come crashing down.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 30 Sep 11 14:13
Years ago on the UltimatToryBoy forum one of the forumites was going on about some casino promotion which mistakenly meant the punter couldn't lose. Betfair ended up taking a large sum off him as a result of him having taken advantage of this offer. How unlike the way they handled the clock beating affair. It seems there's one law for them and another for their customers. Betfair seem to view their customers with the same disgust I would imagine prostitutes must view theirs.
By:
pittsburgh phil
When: 30 Sep 11 14:24
I don't know which is the most shocking: the fact that this happened, and customers were not informed for a year and a half, or the fact that few have bothered to read and understand this thread.

This is a serious issue and there can be no excuse for not informing customers at an earlier date. In 18 months accounts could have been emptied, bank accounts emptied, other sites such as paypal accounts emptied.

Why?

Because the vast majority of people use the same account details on different sites. If you use the same username and password on Betfair as you do with any of the other bookies, or facebook, or paypal then the cybercriminals could have logged into those sites and stolen money.

This is why data breaches like this must be reported to customers immediately. Any delay can cause significant loss and I can see a whole load of **** going Betfairs way because of this.

Rest assured the ICO will bark, wag finger, but take absolutely no action against Betfair because of this. And the fact that there is no equivalent of US Class Action in this country means that potential damage from compensation is limited. But make no mistake. Betfair are now tainted: trust has gone, and that can never be regained.
By:
howard
When: 30 Sep 11 14:34
Phil they didnt get passwords did they , just usernames ?
By:
racingguru
When: 30 Sep 11 14:46
I think the problem is that BF didn't come clean with what was stolen, how it compromises customer security at the time and leave the customer the option of making necessary changes like informing bank, changing card, closing account etc.

Now in recent times a high st electronics chain here in Canada informed me that their membership database had been hacked, so my address, phone number etc had been compromised but at least I heard it from them and not a newspaper. BF should have been upfront with this - it just looks too shifty and whatever they say now will be treated with utmost suspicion.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 15:10
The delay is what concerns me most, i can accept they have been victim of a hack but not informing customers at all (we would still not know if telegraph did not get sight of report) is worrying.

But having said that, apparently SOCA advised Betfair not to inform customers after it was determined that no customers were put at risk.

So for me, question is what should betfair have replied to SOCA

Sorry, we are going to inform our customers. This is a serious breach we want to make our customers aware of the theft, reassure them that the data stolen could not have been used for fraudulent activity

Or

OK, we wont inform our customers as this could damage your investigation, besides we're annoucing to float on the stock exchange next week

I actually think they are hiding behind that SOCA advice. Like racingguru, Ive received a several emails down the years from companies informing me that they have been subject of a hack, full details such as exact time it happened and what actions have been taken and what was stolen etc

Nothing worse than reading about it in the paper EIGHTEEN months later.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 15:18
Nine servers in total were downloaded. So let's just get this straight;

Hackers accessed these servers through a back door, 1 by 1 downloaded the entire server. Not 1 alarm went off, no firewall detected it or logged all the data leaving, no light flashed up and the onyl way they found out was 2 months later when one of the servers fell over and they realised all the data had been siphoned off!

WHat is the IT manager doing there, he must be like Homer Simpson at the power plant
By:
frog2
When: 30 Sep 11 15:18
The article on information-age.com...

The Telegraph claims that Betfair had not informed customers of the breach on the advice of SOCA, which it quotes as saying that "public disclosure would be detrimental to any intelligence operation or investigation".

However, a spokesperson for SOCA told Information Age that this is an overstatement by the Telegraph for a number of reasons, including the fact that it is not always SOCA's policy to make such a recommendation. The spokesperson added that informing SOCA of a data breach is not the same as initiating a criminal investigation.

Betfair would not comment on this part of the story.
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 15:19
Yeah i thought so. Hiding behind that!
By:
Total Bosman
When: 30 Sep 11 15:31
Quite aside from the actual substance of the report, the whole thing really highlights what a mess Betfair has become in terms of reputation.

The leak comes from a confidential report, presumably from an unhappy employee.
The report is being eagerly reported by the media, presumably unhappy at being banned from the AGM.
The report will further worry customers already unhappy at rising charges, reliability failures and other negative PR Betfair is generating.
The report will further aggrieve shareholders already unhappy at huge drop in value, this important information having been kept from them at the time of their investment.

So, apart from Messrs Yu and Morana with their fat bonuses, not a lot of happiness around.  Looks like Betfair are starting to reap what they've so arrogantly sown.
By:
brendanuk1
When: 30 Sep 11 15:34
The company admitted the theft, but said the data leak wasn't a threat to its customers because the stolen data was recovered.

“Because of our security measures the data was unusable for fraudulent activity and we were able to recover the data intact,"


Anyone like to guess what this means? Seems like gibberish to me, stealing data is not like stealing a car Confused
By:
modk
When: 30 Sep 11 15:37
THey need to get an email out to customers or something on the forum/website as this is rumbling throughout the media now and people are going to interpret this differently

THey need to state exactly when it happened what they did what was stolen why they never informed customers (cant use SOCA anymore, sorry).
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 30 Sep 11 15:41
Betfair "transparency". Cry
By:
brendanuk1
When: 30 Sep 11 15:43
Wonder if the crash was a running out of disk space, at that point they looked and saw some file growing large.

SOCA might have been hoping that the theft was still ongoing? If they know they are from Cambodia they must have seen them coming into and on the network. Would have to be very sure indeed to say that the crims didnt download it Confused
By:
brendanuk1
When: 30 Sep 11 15:44
they will hide behind the justifiable we dont talk about our security measures publicaly
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 30 Sep 11 15:56
Someone is saying Pittsburgh Phil has tweeted that Betfair have deleted his account for commenting on this thread. If that's true betfair's getting more like the Borgias by the day.
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 30 Sep 11 16:05
yes I have seen that tweet, also clicked on phil and his profile has disappeared
Page 1 of 3  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com