Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
OneStar
28 Sep 11 17:43
Joined:
Date Joined: 13 Sep 11
| Topic/replies: 7 | Blogger: OneStar's blog
Has anyone much experience of this? Last week, i laid a horse at BSP with a limit set of 2.5 and liability of £300. During the day, checking my account statement on my phone, I can't see the bet either winning or losing, so i assume the BSP was above 2.5

However when i check the results page, i see the horse lost and the calculated BSP was 2.5, which i expected to be a winner for me!
Naturally i asked BF to investigate and they referred me to their help section which does state that there IS a possibility of this happening when the BSP is exactly same as a specified SP limit. In some circumstances, "Some, all or none" of the BSP bets or lays at the exact same limit price may not be matched.
Fair enough, it meant i didnt win the £200, bt it seemed to be pretty unusual so i wasn't expecting it really to occur again.
Lo and behold, the same thing happened yesterday! Again a 2.5 shot lost but my 2.5 limit lay wasn''t matched.

Does anyone know - is this a fairly common thing to happen?
I appreciate it could happen in my favour - the horse wins and my lay bet ISN'T matched.
BUT its happened twice and twice against me.

I'm not complaining, the scenario is set out on the BF site. However there is no indication of the chances of it happening?
"Some, all or non" seems to cover all bases!

Anyone got experience of this?
Pause • Switch to Standard View Unmatched BSP limit bets
Show More
Loading...
Report The Magician (100) • September 28, 2011 6:09 PM BST
Onestar

I assume on virtually EVERY Sp calculation the last bet to be used is partially matched. and other poeple at the same price unmatched.

so you might be unlucky to be unmatched twice when the SP is your price.... but it is very plausible
Report Honest.Al.2 • September 28, 2011 7:45 PM BST
Do Limit SP bets work the same way as keep bets? i.e. If there is a non-runner are 'limit'
prices subject to reduction factors with reduced liabilities. This could explain how you
missed laying at 2.50.
Report gettingbetter2 • September 28, 2011 8:18 PM BST
Magician is right there will usually be some unmatched at that price, the unlimited "market" bets get matched in priority, which is fair enough and what you'd expect.
All would be very unusual unless the amounts match exactly what's on offer.
Of course the unmatched normal bets from the site go into the auction, and I suppose if none of the BSP bets at the exact same limit price get matched it must mean the normal bets at that price get priority in the auction over the BSP limit bets, which again is fair enough.
What I don't like is that if I have been trying to lay at 2.52 and the strike price of the auction is 2.5, then I end up laying at 2.52, and I think it would be fairer and more normal if all bets matched in the auction were at the same strike price.
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 7:42 AM BST
Non runner does reduce the price of your limit SP bet as Honest Al suggests so I would check that to see if it could explain.
Report hazel • September 29, 2011 9:43 AM BST
gb2 pardon my response if I am talking nonesense, but taking your example, what about the person who was matched under the strike at 2.48, he would not want to take the strike price of 2.5.  In fact Betfair would not be able to offer him 2.5 if 2.48 was his price, and the BSP calculation would fail.  Or maybe I am misunderstanding the BSP?
Report askari1 • September 29, 2011 2:15 PM BST
gettingbetter, I was under the impression that all bets matched in the auction were at the same strike price.

Odds often spike on either side of the spread just before reconciliation and offers matched in this period are often at a slightly worse price than bfsp. But do you feel something else has been happening to you?

One Star, as far as I remember it was always the case that queue position (first exchange-submitted, then SP-submitted)determined whic offers wd form part of the settlement determining the sp price.
Report OneStar • September 29, 2011 10:13 PM BST
Thanks for taking the trouble to reply to me folks

I remember when BSP first arrived. I read all the stuff online about the mathematical equation(s) which lead to its calculation / reconciliation.
I'll be honest and say that a lot of it went over my head. I was always fairly happy with the simple result that BSP "usually" beat the bookies (when i was a backer)
I'm not a greatly experienced judge at figuring which way a price is going to go just before the off, so a BSP limit gives me comfort that

a. it will beat the shop price for backing (sadly by too much in the case of my lays)

b. I know my liability

I had never encountered my bet NOT being matched at my limit before last weekend. Then for it to happen again, was a bit galling.
However I do agree that it IS plausible. I'm not alleging incompetence or sharp practise.
I can't see how changing my limit would change the circumstances. I'm just as likely to be matched (or unmatched) at a limit of 2.52 as at 2.5?

So it's first come, first served with regards to the limits too? And that's after the 'normal' exchange offers get matched?
That might snooker me, as my limit bets aren't laid until around 1pm on a typical day.

Anyway, I will see what happens in the next couple of months. I will maybe have to rethink the strategy.

Thanks again all


(In fact, since you lot seem to know your onions (!), do most / any / all spread betting companies allow you to take a position on how many favs might win (or lose) on a certain days's racing? Either overall or by meeting?
Report OneStar • September 29, 2011 10:13 PM BST
Thanks for taking the trouble to reply to me folks

I remember when BSP first arrived. I read all the stuff online about the mathematical equation(s) which lead to its calculation / reconciliation.
I'll be honest and say that a lot of it went over my head. I was always fairly happy with the simple result that BSP "usually" beat the bookies (when i was a backer)
I'm not a greatly experienced judge at figuring which way a price is going to go just before the off, so a BSP limit gives me comfort that

a. it will beat the shop price for backing (sadly by too much in the case of my lays)

b. I know my liability

I had never encountered my bet NOT being matched at my limit before last weekend. Then for it to happen again, was a bit galling.
However I do agree that it IS plausible. I'm not alleging incompetence or sharp practise.
I can't see how changing my limit would change the circumstances. I'm just as likely to be matched (or unmatched) at a limit of 2.52 as at 2.5?

So it's first come, first served with regards to the limits too? And that's after the 'normal' exchange offers get matched?
That might snooker me, as my limit bets aren't laid until around 1pm on a typical day.

Anyway, I will see what happens in the next couple of months. I will maybe have to rethink the strategy.

Thanks again all


(In fact, since you lot seem to know your onions (!), do most / any / all spread betting companies allow you to take a position on how many favs might win (or lose) on a certain days's racing? Either overall or by meeting?
Report TheVis • September 30, 2011 7:39 AM BST
so where there no non runners in the races in question?
Report askari1 • September 30, 2011 4:43 PM BST
One Star, the answer to the favourites market on spread betting is yes, but the spreads are miserable.

It can be a value betting usually selling e.g. favourites or distances if you have an edge on knowing the ground conditions.
Report Honest Al • October 1, 2011 1:26 PM BST
One Star,

Was one of your selections Forest Edge which was returned at 2.50?
There was a non-runner in this race with a Rule 4 deduction, hence the
2.50 limit you placed was probably reduced to 2.40'ish. Therefore
NO BET.
Report OneStar • October 2, 2011 10:14 AM BST
Sorry for delay in replying

Vis, I have double-checked the non-runners, and yes Forest Edge was the horse that wasn't matched last week at Chepstow.
(the BF results service doesn't make any mention of non-runners, withdrawals etc, well certainly not at this stage. I think that info only becomes visible in your own profit / loss page if you drill down by selection? And as i had 'no bet' in that race, I don't see the detail)

However I don't get the point you make Al. BF declared the BSP to be 2.5. Are you saying that is then re-calculated AFTERWARDS and reduced to say 2.4? In that case surely they would apply the RF and then publish the revised price.

I had assumed the declared and published BSP was the actual one (after any reduction factors etc) ie this is the result and price that is still showing on the site.
Although obviously in the example you give, surely I WOULD be matched as I'm LAYING with a limit of 2.5.

If you're right, then I can't rely on the results / prices BF publish on their site?
That would screw up my record-keeping (and bank balance)


Askari, thanks for the spreads info. I was looking into effectively trying to hedge a potentially bad day or run of short-priced favs winning.
Looks like you're right. Margins look very tight and not worth it. Also tend to be meeting-specific. Have you any idea if these markets are fairly liquid / competitive?
Report Feck N. Eejit • October 2, 2011 12:49 PM BST
One Star, it's your max odds that are reduced. e.g. if there was a three horse race with odds 2.0, 2.0 and 1000.0 and you put in an sp lay of one of the 2.0 horses with max odds you'd be willing to lay as 2.0 you'd be unhappy if the other 2.0 shot was withdrawn and betfair didn't reduce your max odds.
Report askari1 • October 2, 2011 5:17 PM BST
OneStar, on distances, longest sp and to a lesser extent jollies the spread firms ready themselves for buyers and pitch fair value towards the lower end of the spread.

The liquidity is good on major meetings like Cheltenham and Royal Ascot where I have used these markets for hedging purposes / bet qualification, but generally if you need to churn or earn commission I wd not look at spread betting / exchange arbs.

There will often be reason to play the spreads off against each other e.g. to take advantage of special offers.
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com