Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
ballabriggs
28 Sep 11 10:02
Joined:
Date Joined: 11 Jul 11
| Topic/replies: 534 | Blogger: ballabriggs's blog
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/8792831/Betfair-will-only-refund-bets-for-punters-who-lost-out-on-16000-jackpot.html

Betfair will only refund bets for punters who lost out on £16,000 jackpot

More than 10 punters who lost out on a £16,610 Tote jackpot after Betfair failed to process their wagers in time will only have their stakes refunded, the betting exchange has said.

In a statement that infuriated some Betfair clients, the company on Tuesday admitted to "technical issues in transmitting bets into the Tote pools in the last 10 minutes before the pool closed".

However, Betfair refused to honour the bets of punters who thought they had won the jackpot after finding six winners at Newmarket last Friday.

Apologising, Betfair said it had only "returned funds for the failed bets", claiming that "at no point were these customers given confirmation that their bets had been successfully placed, or appeared as placed in their account statement".

That appeared to contradict remarks of some customers, including bloodstock manager Nick Bradley. He staked £12,000 – meaning he lost out on a £4,610 profit – and said the funds were "taken out of" his Betfair account. Company sources admitted the stakes may have been removed temporarily.

Some small punters lost out on a £16,000-plus profit.

One senior rival bookmaker said: "Betfair is hiding behind its rules but if I was them I'd pay."

A Betfair source said it wanted to "keep the goodwill" of customers, suggesting it may try to compensate by offering some free bets.
Pause • Switch to Standard View Telegraph: Betfair make decision not...
Show More
Loading...
Report DStyle • September 28, 2011 11:03 AM BST
can anyone who's bet on the tote before explain how the site and their interaction might appear to the user had they experienced what happened to these people?

i'm of the opinion that betfair probably acted entirely correctly if their software fed back to the users that their bets hadn't been placed; i'm a touch confused that they are prepared to weather such terrible PR in one of their secondary products if they didn't adequately inform the users.
Report ballabriggs • September 28, 2011 11:03 AM BST
Answer is simple BetFAIR - lots of peoples have had bets.  All peoples who lose on this races lose their stakes, this pays for winnings of people who have won.  Would cost BetFAIR nothing to fix, and would be FAIR!  Not fair to let peoples place bets and not find out till long time later that despite BetFAIR take moneys from their accounts, bets are not been placed!
Report DStyle • September 28, 2011 11:07 AM BST
well balla, i think that's the nub of it really. if the customers were under the impression that their bets had been "placed", because of what the website presented to them, i think the gripe is justified.

if the website presented information to the contrary after they submitted their bets, then betfair are in the right.

i've never used the tote so have no idea how it all works: hence the question.
Report lapsy pa • September 28, 2011 11:12 AM BST
Think bf would have to provide answers if  the tote bets placed screen goes green,anyone would assume they are "on" as the colour changing from yellow(pending) seems to confirm.Crux question did it go green?
Report CLYDEBANK29 • September 28, 2011 11:12 AM BST
The terrible PR is due to Betfair's irrational decision not to let the press into the AGM DStyle.

Then there's the impact the decision has on the morale of Betfair's PR team.  Bang goes any performance related bonus.

Still one set of people who must be only too happy with everything thats going on at Betfair are their recruitment consultants
Report ballabriggs • September 28, 2011 11:18 AM BST
CLYDEBANK29 do you think any others FTSE250 company would not allow press into AGM??  I do not think so.
Report CLYDEBANK29 • September 28, 2011 11:29 AM BST
I imagine it virtually never happens.  It's even crazier when you consider Betfair's customers are directly the public.  I think it's the worst decision the company has ever made.
Report hazel • September 28, 2011 11:29 AM BST
I think most of the major bookmakers would have paid out with no quibble.  The amount of goodwill and public relations lost for not paying out such a relatively small sum of money makes the decision not to pay all the more baffling. 

Betfair say the spend a large amount on advertising their product (including 50p per sheep in New Zealand), why not put a positive spin in this case, at least it would not be having a negative impact on their advertising.

One of the guys is reported to have paid £400,000 in commission, a good customer I would have thought.

Another PR disaster?
Report The Magician (100) • September 28, 2011 11:31 AM BST
ballabriggs

Do you think other FTSE 250 companies would allow a customer to constantly criticize them on their company forum.


Granted cant understand what upside there was to blocking journalist.... you just alienate them.


Why are you so anti Betfair recently... has the PC got you?
Report ballabriggs • September 28, 2011 11:34 AM BST
There must be peoples popping champain corks who thinks they have place bets which in the end lose but did not count.  Article is confusing though - it says peoples will get back stakes if they had had winning bets.  Surely peoples will also get back stakes if they had losing bets?  BetFAIR can't keep moneys from only bets which did not win??

Would be fair to take stakes from peoples whose bets were placed on BetFAIR and then lost.  Then give winnings to winners from these stakes.  Not all bets will be win on this race on affected bets!
Report The Magician (100) • September 28, 2011 11:43 AM BST
ballabriggs

all bets that did not ULTIMATELY get placed where refunded to the account (the money was taken out while they tried to place them - a little bit like taking out the risk on an unmatched exchange bet)

so if you would have won or would have lost.... you got your stake back, as the bet was deemed not to have been placed.
Report ballabriggs • September 28, 2011 11:43 AM BST
Magican I not anti Betfair recently.  Posted up news from news feeds about BetFAIR.  If is nice story I have post up like Steven Morana one saying future is BRIGHT.  I put up good and bad BOTH.  Is bad nearly every story is bad at moment. You must be BetFAIR worker?  If there is good news that will go up too! 

In the last 4 hours
Betfair Angers Online Punters With Response To Techie Glitch Casinos-Online.co.uk 09:36


In the last 6 hours
Betfair will only refund bets for punters who lost out on £16,000... Telegraph.co.uk 07:11
Betfair will only refund bets in jackpot error Telegraph.co.uk 06:28


Yesterday
Win a signed 2010/11 United shirt and stadium tours with Betfair United Rant 14:50 Tue, 27 Sep 2011
WIN tickets to see Manchester United v Norwich - courtesy of Betfair Daily Mail 13:58 Tue, 27 Sep 2011
Watch Manchester United stars play football bowling in new Betfair Mobile ad The Drum 11:49 Tue, 27 Sep 2011
Manchester United stars bowl over punters in Betfair Mobile ad Betting.Betfair 10:10 Tue, 27 Sep 2011
Betfair a 'shambles' says punter who lost £16k Telegraph.co.uk 06:03 Tue, 27 Sep 2011

Janos Jeszek wins Betfair Poker Live! Dublin Bluff Europe 00:07 Tue, 27 Sep 2011


In the last 7 days
Betchecker: Best odds on Betfair as Chelsea close the gap Betfair Football 10:07 Mon, 26 Sep 2011
Ructions At Betfair Annual Meeting Casinos-Online.co.uk 20:31 Fri, 23 Sep 2011
Betfair charges Tim Worstall (Weblog) 08:36 Fri, 23 Sep 2011
Betfair 'removed £52,000 from account' Telegraph.co.uk 06:01 Fri, 23 Sep 2011
Betfair pantomime sidesteps the critics Telegraph.co.uk 05:51 Fri, 23 Sep 2011

Ed Wray poised to stand down as chair of Betfair City AM 00:47 Fri, 23 Sep 2011
MARKET REPORT: Betfair shuffles top executives This is Money 22:51 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Betfair's losing streak guardian.co.uk 21:03 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Bounced from Betfair's annual meeting guardian.co.uk 21:03 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Betfair co-founder Wray to step down as chairman racingpost.com 19:02 Thu, 22 Sep 2011

Betfair Founder And Chairman To Step Down Casinos-Online.co.uk 15:40 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Feature - Q&A: Stephen Morana, CFO, Betfair eGaming Review 12:45 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Wray to step down as Betfair chairman eGaming Review 12:34 Thu, 22 Sep 2011
Report Lori • September 28, 2011 11:44 AM BST
Why would people need to be refunded stakes of bets that were never placed? Where did the money go?
Report CLYDEBANK29 • September 28, 2011 11:46 AM BST
good point Lori lol
Report DStyle • September 28, 2011 11:50 AM BST
you are, of course lori, absolutely right.

and it warrants a little more thinking about their PR here.

if they feel the customer was adequately informed that their bet was never placed, they have no case to answer regarding refunds as there is nothing to refund, because no bet was ever placed.

the notion that they have to refund is entirely at odds with their statement that no money was ever taken from the account.

Confused

whilst i understand the mechanics of what will have happened (as explained in Magician's post), it's a very clumsy and thoughtless response from betfair.
Report Lori • September 28, 2011 11:52 AM BST
I'd somehow overlooked Magician's post.
Report metal guru • September 28, 2011 11:52 AM BST
well exactly.if the money left the customers account and was not re-credited to their account at any time during the duration of the jackpot races why on earth would they think there was a potential problem and why didnt betfair contact the people affected-particularly one who has paid 400k in commission?
Report The Magician (100) • September 28, 2011 11:59 AM BST
ballabriggs

perhaps I shot the messenger - as you quite correctly state - there are not positive BF stories at the moment.

just to clarify i dont work for them... AND NEVER HAVE
Report DStyle • September 28, 2011 11:59 AM BST
actually, rereading the statement they didn't say they refunded the  bets. the article incorrectly paraphrases their words which accurately describe what really happened.
Report The Magician (100) • September 28, 2011 1:05 PM BST
what happened was

1) money left account as bets placement was 'attempted'
2) money came back into account when bets was know to be 'unseccesseful'

what is less clear is what constitutes a successful bet as far as a customer is concerned, and the time taken for step 2 to occur.
Report catflmasppo • September 28, 2011 1:11 PM BST
To me it depends whether it is clear when submitting the bet it is clear to the users that there is a subsequent operation that may or not succeed.
Report Lori • September 28, 2011 1:21 PM BST
If these people were convinced their bets were on running into the last leg, there could be some horrible losses hedging against their win.
Report No_BS • September 29, 2011 7:24 AM BST
It has nothing to do with betfair if customers choose to hedge the bet, even if it was placed or not.

The only legal thing betfair needs to do is return all stakes on the bet type that was placed as they were unable to get the bets on.
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 7:25 AM BST
I place an exacta bet via the Tote on this site on Friday.  I got a warning message saying something along the lines of I needed to check my current bets as the bet was currently pending and hadn't been placed. 

Sure enough, when I looked in the Tote Bets section of current bets my bet said "pending" and was still pending after a few refreshes.  To be honest when the race started I didn't know if I was on or not.  After the race my bet (which lost anyway) was settled and was a loser so did get there eventually.

I guess similar may have happened with the jackpot bets which were "pending" but never got to the Tote.  Was everybody given the same warning as me?  I don't know.  If if they were would the bet have still said "pending" after race 1?
Report The Magician (100) • September 29, 2011 9:37 AM BST
Vis

Was that bet on Betfair...

and did the message say "check current bets" or check "account statement"

because poeple posted on another forum, the screenshot of the message and it said "account statement"
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 10:37 AM BST
Yes it was on here.  To be fair I can't remember what the message said exactly, other than there was definitely a warning.  I didn't look at my account statement, I just went to current bets to check in there if I was on or not.

Sorry this is a bit vague but I can't remember the wording of the message. 

Interestingly though my account statement shows me being debited at 13:56 for my exacta which was in the 14:05 at Haydock. So I was debited funds when I placed the bet but as I said above the bet was still pending up until race time and when I went to watch the race I didn't know if I was on or not.

So I am unsure as to when my funds got to the Tote, but certainly not at 13:56.
Report The Magician (100) • September 29, 2011 10:54 AM BST
TheVis

did you get this message for a Exacta at 13:56 - you can see in your statement when the exact funds came back - when was that>
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 11:11 AM BST
2011-09-23
13:56   
GB / Haydock Park / 23-SEP-2011 13:05 GMT / Exacta - Stake debit

This is what I have in my account statement.  The funds for the exacta were debited at 13:56 but I know at that stage and for several minutes after my bet was still showing as pending in my current bets. (the race time is in GMT hence why showing 13:05 rather than 14:05)

The money never came back as the bet was eventually accepted and was a loser.
Report Special Cargo • September 29, 2011 11:15 AM BST
It would be really interesting to know if it was only ' accepted ' after it was a known loser.
Report ballabriggs • September 29, 2011 11:40 AM BST
Does BetFAIR's own traders have position in this markets?  IS can of worms if there is any chance can be decided after finish whether bets stand or not,....
Report The Magician (100) • September 29, 2011 12:26 PM BST
Special Cargo

I had losing bets refunded after they lost - so I think any suggestion of selective returns in unfounded and logistically unfeasible.

**** 6 days later they their IT department still don't know what went wrong - so you think they could be good enough to keep losers and refund 'still live' tickets.... NO CHANCE
Report askari1 • September 29, 2011 1:07 PM BST
They need a better confirmation screen to avoid the hideous PR.

But if there is always going to be a time lag (say of over a minute) before bets placed w/ the tote can be confirmed, they are rather in the position of imposing ridiculous obligations on the customer to keep checking his account or should take some proprietary risk themselves.

Imv the system of exchanging bets is no more than a metaphor and they are always taking on some proprietary risk.

W/ disputes over bet placement, there shd be a clear criterion of whether a bet can be taken to be on or not. If systems fail, they shd take the risk.
Report birch2 • September 29, 2011 1:36 PM BST
A couple of years ago, I used to put significant permed placepot bets on every day - until the day the above happened

Askari is right - the confirmation screen needs to show that the bet has been received by the tote - the fact that you have a trans no. and time of bet from BF means nothing (although it should)

Point im making is this is not new -  just that BF dont learn from previous mistakes and then shoot themselves in the foot in their handling of this damaging fiasco  -  alas something else thats not new
Report Biscar Two from a mile back • September 29, 2011 1:58 PM BST
Whilst it is pending you have no control over it, if betfair don't process the bet immediately then you should have the option to cancel and take your business elsewhere.
However you don't get the option to go elsewhere.
Report askari1 • September 29, 2011 2:08 PM BST
The instantaneous 'matching' of bets is illusory--it's a metaphor.

Placing bets at affiliates like the Tote may also be subject to some time delay.

It wd seem to me that the answer is taking some proprietary risk--or else employing someone to phone people up before any leg of the perm is run to say, 'sorry, but your bet is not on'.

If it doesn't go on at the Tote's end, bf have an issue with the Tote.

But it seems that it was bf's bottleneck due to their system straining under unprecedented volumes--something they shd have been able to anticpate.
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 6:26 PM BST
....especially as they were offering 10% discount on jackpots to attract even more volume in via this site.
Report TheVis • September 29, 2011 6:29 PM BST
also "pending" is no use to anybody.  If the bet cannot be placed there and then it should be a "sorry, please re-try" job.  Imagine submitting your 12k only to be told it is pending.  Just what the hell do you do in that case?
Report ballabriggs • September 29, 2011 6:41 PM BST
TheVis in cricket you can make bets of no result in case of draw or tie or something.  Maybe BetFAIR can make market of no result in Tote bets, so you can bet on bets not being match on BetFAIR after you have submit?
Report Feck N. Eejit • September 29, 2011 7:04 PM BST
It might help matters if the tote updated their sinclair spectrum zx and stopped prattling on about fkng "gateways".
Report The Magician (100) • October 1, 2011 5:08 PM BST
terrible tote systems surely dont help....

how the tote ruined or failed to take advantage of a monopoly for 40 years is beyound me....

must be the only (gambling) case in the world where a goverment monopoly failed.
Report bf_fananatic • October 2, 2011 2:34 AM BST
One senior rival bookmaker said: "Betfair is hiding behind its rules but if I was them I'd pay."

Since when have rival bookmakers ever paid anyone when they have an excuse not to pay winners, unless there dragged too court and told to by a judge, possibly the rival bookmaker that stated betfair should pay on a goodwill basis is yet again pulling the wool over everyones eyes
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com