We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Cannuckistan surely this is the same as arbing
|
|
By:
I do not think 'value' matters that much if you are trading, as your words on WOM suggest.
Following momentum such that the price that you're getting matched at has a higher than 55% chance of being above the next saddle price will also be a profitable strategy. The traders, full-bookers and market makers making a lot of money out of the site are not necessarily taking positions that wd result in a profit were they to hold onto to them while the event runs to its conclusion. Given the ecology of the site, it may be both easier than you suggest to identify value in the conventional way and less important that a price's being value is a criterion for every bet. |
|
By:
@Daymor, it's not the same as arbing. You can't arb on Betfair anymore and make a gross profit on this site given the premium charge. I'm talking about bets that will make a gross profit on Betfair alone regardless of hedges and I'm suggesting that if you're doing that, you're betting at good value.
@askari1, any trader who is making consistent profits on Betfair even if they scalp or quickly offset is buying at good value and selling at a value that isn't as good and capturing the difference. The question remains, how to we identify fair value. |
|
By:
Traders on betfair don't need to be buying at good value, they just need to sell it off at worst value than they paid.
|
|
By:
^ exactly GJ. it's still net value, just calculated in a different, "fuzzy" way.
essentially the proposition is (or at least can be) "I don't know how these two bets relate to the actual probabilities of the even in question, but it's a logical necessity that if one of them is poor value, the other must represent good value that more than compensates for it." |
|
By:
*event
|
|
By:
I understand what you mean by a "proxy" - but I don't use any, I go about it in a different way.
Essentially I ask these kind of questions: "In what circumstances does the market typically show value?" "What does the market look like in these circumstances?" The simplest example is that IR GG markets tend to show all kinds of value when horses are being "panic backed" - so the goal is to identify this kind of behavior as it develops with sufficient accuracy that I can bet into the market and strip out enough value to cover me when I get it wrong. Easy in theory - hard in practice. All my betting is done automatically but I'm pretty sure I could do it manually if I had to (and wanted to). Having studied thousands of markets I know pretty well how a "value available" market looks at a glance now. |
|
By:
^excellent post, mr robot.
someone (askari?) said in another thread you can't win long term without a quantifiable edge. I don't really agree; I think it's possible to develop a feel for value you can't quantify through a combination of experience and common sense. |
|
By:
wouldn't you be able to quantify it by your long term results?
|
|
By:
I'm not sure this is a proxy, but I find it helpful - perhaps one way to see some value - is to derive the traded weighted average price (WAP) before the off. Watching how the price moves against the WAP can often be informative.
|
|
By:
Perhaps I should have made that a bit clearer. The WAP gives you the average price traded, adjusted by weight of money. Although this can obviously be skewed by traders, there is some correlation between the WAP and the sum total of what all the punters think and so may (with some caution) be considered as "Fair Value" given that in the round the mass of punters (albeit with sharks at one end and mugs at the other)tend to get the price about right. In these circumstances, any price deviation from that "Fair Value" could be considered either good or bad value, and traded accordingly.
|
|
By:
viva el presidente, I'm not sure that I've ever said 'quantifiable'. Skill-based winners have an edge and analysis of their results suggests they haven't won through chance. But this 'edge' can vary across events and derive from tacit knowledge.
Cannuckistan, I am not sure that the way that every winner wins is to look for and identify something called 'value'. It seems reasonable to suppose that winners win in different ways--some pick off value prices, some anticipate and get on price cascades early w/out a calculation of underlying chances, some exploit backers' impatience by tick trading and quick offsetting, some trade within a range, some have a good estimate of where prices are likely to go IR. To my mind it wd be better advice to a newcomer to say 'try to occupy a niche that is your own' than 'find a new way of identifying value'. Having said that, going against overshot momentum esp. in hcaps wd be my best form of both position taking and trading. |
|
By:
tobermory Joined: 01 Mar 08
Replies: 17355 09 Mar 11 19:23 wouldn't you be able to quantify it by your long term results? ------ you'd be able to quantify your edge as an agent, by definition. but you wouldn't necessarily be able to translate your methods into hard and fast rules that generated that edge, ie a system. |