Chit Chat
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Have now watched this and even though 3 and a half hours long glad I did.
Story from imdb
Frank "The Irishman" Sheeran is a man with a lot on his mind. The former labor union high official and hitman, learned to kill serving in Italy during the Second World War. He now looks back on his life and the hits that defined his mob career, maintaining connections with the Bufalino crime family. In particular, the part he claims to have played in the disappearance of his life-long friend, Jimmy Hoffa, the former president of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, who mysteriously vanished in late July 1975 at the age of 62.
Polished performances as ever from De Niro, Pacino & Pesci along with many familiar faces including Stephen Graham who is also as good as ever as Tony Pro. Several key moments in history are placed in the film and it works very well and leaves food for thought. Obviously a genre very close to Scorsese and this is probabkly his parting gift to us on the matter. I am very grateful for it. Will deffo one day spare 3 and a half hours again watching it. Comparisons with Goodfellas are going to be obvious and doubt any film will come close to that classic but just enjoy this film for what it is. Solid 8/10 for me and would anyone with netflix to give it a go.
Anyone on here watched it already? What do you make of it?
Story from imdb
Frank "The Irishman" Sheeran is a man with a lot on his mind. The former labor union high official and hitman, learned to kill serving in Italy during the Second World War. He now looks back on his life and the hits that defined his mob career, maintaining connections with the Bufalino crime family. In particular, the part he claims to have played in the disappearance of his life-long friend, Jimmy Hoffa, the former president of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, who mysteriously vanished in late July 1975 at the age of 62.
Polished performances as ever from De Niro, Pacino & Pesci along with many familiar faces including Stephen Graham who is also as good as ever as Tony Pro. Several key moments in history are placed in the film and it works very well and leaves food for thought. Obviously a genre very close to Scorsese and this is probabkly his parting gift to us on the matter. I am very grateful for it. Will deffo one day spare 3 and a half hours again watching it. Comparisons with Goodfellas are going to be obvious and doubt any film will come close to that classic but just enjoy this film for what it is. Solid 8/10 for me and would anyone with netflix to give it a go.
Anyone on here watched it already? What do you make of it?
Show More
it's OK but it's no Goodfellas. The de-aging doesn't work for me - De Niro is 76 and moves like it - decrepit body with a funny head stuck on top. It's not very well written either.
I saw it in an independent cinema on Wednesday. It's a good film and the 3 and a half hour length was not a problem.
The much talked about "ageing" and "de-ageing" of the actors was not any sort of distraction to my eyes.
I'd read the book the best part of 15 years ago, and it was around 10 years ago I first heard De Niro talking it up as a film project. I think Pesci just edged it.
It's an absorbing film. The most obvious thing that's missing from it is some of those unforgettable scenes that lit up 'Goodfellas' and 'Casino'.
The much talked about "ageing" and "de-ageing" of the actors was not any sort of distraction to my eyes.
I'd read the book the best part of 15 years ago, and it was around 10 years ago I first heard De Niro talking it up as a film project. I think Pesci just edged it.
It's an absorbing film. The most obvious thing that's missing from it is some of those unforgettable scenes that lit up 'Goodfellas' and 'Casino'.
De Niro is 76 ,Watched him in Joker thought he Looked very well for his age
Agree that the de-ageing takes some getting used to. It's like watching Bugsy Malone in reverse.
Think it will appeal to the Goodfellas / Casino generation but no one else.
Decent watch 6/10.
Think it will appeal to the Goodfellas / Casino generation but no one else.
Decent watch 6/10.
Yeah a lots been said of the de-aging but it really wasn't a problem for me. Agree it doesn't have the unforgettable scenes like Goodfellas did but this is more of a character study to me.
glad this is on netflix, dont think I could sit in a cinema for over 3 hours
If it's mentioned in the same breath as goodfellas and casino that is good enough for me.
I think De Niro is overrated, but it’s still a very good film.
Agree with OP. It’s an 8 from me.
Agree with OP. It’s an 8 from me.
This is gangster Forrest Gump, where every historical landmark except Apollo11 is linked to "dis thing of ours."
I think that's as good a review as I've seen biscuits.
If you enjoyed Goodfellas (like me) it delivers: this time there is a scene where a whole parking lot of yellow cabs are set alight!
It's very well done, a bit like going to a Rolling Stones concert.
It's very well done, a bit like going to a Rolling Stones concert.
I also found the ageing process a little distracting, De Niro especially. As previously mentioned he moved like the old man he is; some things cannot be altered. That being said, the film was appealing and easily watched for 3.5 hours. Its an interesting take on the story too, which I'd like to go into more but don't want to spoil it for those yet to view. 6/10 is about right for me too and I may watch it again at some point, but I won't be going out of my way.
over 100% of them are benders. thats quite a lot. That did make me laugh!! 
It's true though me and my mate were extras in a film that needed horse riders, in the hospitality tent for lunch I was in the queue and he shouts ,oy gaylord get me a can of coke when your there, and they all turned as if he shouted them.
Went on far to long and very hard to follow....I was disappointed.
good film, will be the last of its type with those great actors.
stephen graham is top draw too. the scene in his shorts and late dfor the meeting with hoffa was excellent
stephen graham is top draw too. the scene in his shorts and late dfor the meeting with hoffa was excellent
Was good, but samey. Needed a couple of big set pieces more to go with Hoffa going to the house.
Stop with the seemingly obligatory bowing to the crowd involved in this rubbish! They all might have made a few good movies over the years, but this one`s dire! It`s not about Shearan, Hoffa or anybody else, it`s clearly, and purely, a swansong vehicle for Scorsese, De Niro et al to tell the world; `we`re all old now, here`s one last gangster movie to tell the world that we`ll be dead soon`. Self-indulgent drivel, if you haven`t seen it yet, don`t bother, it really is an embarrassment to all involved
Dec 1, 2019 -- 6:09PM, grappler wrote:
walofs. all these gangster films are offensive garbage, from the godfather onwards. no surprise the intellectually retarded wanchors that saturate this forum enjoy them. there is nothing glam about the reality of the squalid business of extortion drug smuggling and murder. all this bollox about honour and family and respect is the most risible nonsense.and all the gaylord actors that play mafiosi tough guys. in case you were unaware, all actors are preposterous pansies who should be deprecated rather than venerated. over 100% of them are benders. thats quite a lot.
And there they all were, admiring the vast, over-inflated balloon, when along comes grappler with the shiniest, sharpest pin you've ever seen.
That post must surely go in the chit chat hall of fame.
There is talk about Joe Pesci Winning The Oscar walofb.
Grappler may be right , remember the shock when we discovered the truth about Rock Hudson ?
Gorgeous looking man
Gorgeous looking man
Typical Scorsese -- 3.5 hours and still baffling for anyone who's not swotted up on the story beforehand.
I've not even seen it yet and am already having flashbacks to having to explain the basic con in Wolf of Wall Street.
I've not even seen it yet and am already having flashbacks to having to explain the basic con in Wolf of Wall Street.
Excellent film, although the CGI took a little time to get used to.
Direction as one would expect is excellent and cast list from the university of excellence.
Instead of the Super Human, Cartoon,Science Fiction,Fantasy rubbish churned out for the benefit of the
16-30 generation,an adult film to cherish.
I've no knowledge if Netflix funded this enterprise but by showing in cinemas it's now eligible for Oscars.
Direction as one would expect is excellent and cast list from the university of excellence.
Instead of the Super Human, Cartoon,Science Fiction,Fantasy rubbish churned out for the benefit of the
16-30 generation,an adult film to cherish.
I've no knowledge if Netflix funded this enterprise but by showing in cinemas it's now eligible for Oscars.
I'll wait till for the better technology to kick in for me to by into thesr type of de-ageing films...
It all looked too plastic for me.. I was half expecting De Niro's face from The Deerhunter to be plastered on in the flashback scenes...
Ctrl shift face on youtube has better effects on his channel. I'll all urge you to check him out.
After reading the above reviews.....
I'll wait till this is shown free on channel five.
It all looked too plastic for me.. I was half expecting De Niro's face from The Deerhunter to be plastered on in the flashback scenes...
Ctrl shift face on youtube has better effects on his channel. I'll all urge you to check him out.
After reading the above reviews.....
I'll wait till this is shown free on channel five.
still laughing now at grapplers line "over 100% of them are benders, thats quite a lot" lmao
The de-ageing was just silly, esp the first meeting of de niro and joe pesci.. they were supposed to be young 20s but moved just like mid 70 year olds. Imagine if they tried that in The Godfather 2.. would have been ridiculous.
Really did enjoy the movie/story though. Left me wondering how true the Hoffa ending was.
grappler and timbuctooth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puy_B6AeuKI
Really did enjoy the movie/story though. Left me wondering how true the Hoffa ending was.
grappler and timbuctooth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puy_B6AeuKI
The Irishman, was acquired by Netflix in 2017 after its previous backers Paramount and STX dropped out in 2017.
Finally found the 3 hours and 29 minutes to watch this.
As a gangster film nut I was hoping Scorcese and his pals would finish with a belter and at least not a turkey.
I thought it was fantastic , the de-aging bothered me not one bit ..... 10/10 for me.
As a gangster film nut I was hoping Scorcese and his pals would finish with a belter and at least not a turkey.
I thought it was fantastic , the de-aging bothered me not one bit ..... 10/10 for me.
I watched it about a Month ago and I cannot remember a single Scene from The Movie and that says it all for me...Absolute sh1te imho.
I watched it about a Month ago and I cannot remember a single Scene from The Movie and that says it all for me...Absolute sh1te imho.
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539