Question Time - bbc1 10.45pm

a good week to have a good representative as they will
likely have a big audience

brexit means brexit on me bingo card

David Dimbleby presents topical debate from Watford. On the panel are Conservative communities secretary Sajid Javid MP, Labour's Lisa Nandy MP, editor-in-chief of the Economist Zanny Minton Beddoes, talk show host and former director of Republicans Abroad UK Charlie Wolf, and singer Charlotte Church.

Really? Sure?

.
http://order-order.com

Have a different bunch.

When is Arron Banks launching his new party

no charlotte

Arron Banks pulls out

Javid....a souless dweeb !

what exactly is the chairman's role in this - he is clearly a remainer

Jeremy Paxman wants Dimbleby's job

Javid's having a shocker, come in to the ring too fired up and shipping a lot of punishment in the early rounds.

When Lisa Nandy's running rings around you, you know you're in trouble.

javid doesnt know the law

21 percent of medical researchers come from outside the uk  - did I hear that right?

70 million voters decided , now 600 MP's must decide? Possibly tell voters they know better

at gt ormond street hospital , and funded by eu ( our money)

70 million voted, and decided to leave

now one woman wants to take over

ffs

thankyou donny  for clearing that up for me

17 million....surely

Nov 3, 2016 -- 6:10PM, zorrostrikes wrote:

70 million voters decided , now 600 MP's must decide? Possibly tell voters they know better

It's like Huey said.. 'Some things are too important to let the great unwashed make a final decision on'

Or words to that effect.

It'z those ignorant norverneers wot dun it!!!

old chap not happy is he

panel loaded with yanks for next weeks vote

not great timing is it

zorrostrikes
70 million voters decided , now 600 MP's must decide? Possibly tell voters they know bette

Parliament won't be the problem, it's the unelected Lords that arte the threat.

the two yank guys give their opinion (as americans who might know something) and the audience applaud a brit woman who knows nothing about the USA   

the yanks as americans give their opinion and the audience almost to a man/woman choke on it  ha ha

ps
no brits have a vote anyway!!

Lisa Nandy right on Trump !

pure anti trump propaganda but we don't have a vote here??!!

QT audience absolutely clueless about American politics

of course they hate Trump 1.00000000000001

the wimmin on the panel have had a very good night

i'm no fan of nandy but shes understood and answered the questions

makes a change from a politician

It is funny isn't it.

I don't think the brits know what they are talking about as far as US politics and polices.

i dont know why the bbc want to put american political debate
on this show

many decent issues to cover before asking folk that are clueless
about it.

can we expect similar debate on german elections next year ?

It's like the difference between me giving an  opinion on a horse race in america and the likely winner at kempton or worcester.  I know nothing about the first but a fair amount about the other two.

true, but I doubt the US version of QT would put Billy Bragg and Jacob Rees Mogg on the panel and spend 15 minutes discussing Brexit.

I honestly think its purely to give the remoaners an extra 15 minutes to foam at the mouth

we've chewed up Brexit to bits, so lets give them the Trump bone

toooooo late - the cops have destroyed their records

not in the interest of the tory pa......  sorry  - not in the public interest

should be an enquiry into last questioner's syrup...

they died that we could play fifa 2016

I like that one
the yank pointing to his little usa flag and then the poppy.  'These colours don't run' - rather clever.

Bellend of an audience , show seen better days

nothing wrong with Watford

bbc once again filling the audience with "their type" of people (i.e crippled by political correctness)

the more they do it, the more people see thru it, as non-representative.

The whole show is well past it's sell by date and been like that for a long while.
Went downhill after wee Joeys asppearance.

they had a massive issue to deal with and pretty much failed

it needs a paxman type in charge these days

Farage in de chair for me not electric but maybe St pauls Bristol

mobo    03 Nov 16 23:32 
I don't think the brits know what they are talking about as far as US politics and polices.


The fact the British people voted the Tories in , proves they're pretty clueless on UK politics and policies imo.

Farage chairing it, in a pub with real people, not rent-a-PC-mob

Facts
The fact the British people voted the Tories in , proves they're pretty clueless on UK politics and policies imo.

And the fact that Labour have Corbyn and Mcdonnell as their top 2 shows you how clueless they are.
So clueless in fact that they have ensured a Tory government for the forseeable future.

^ we'll see.

The Labour Party will never be able to get power in Britain again, the only hope they have is for immigration to continue bringing in new voters.

England must stop immigration otherwise you give away the ability to decide the very nature and culture of this country. You will be outvoted. They are at it now, they are in parliament trying to overturn the will of the English people. They will succeed eventually.

Do not trust Corbyn and Mcdonnell or people who would vote for them, they do no deserve to be trusted.

In America you have voters voting massively on racial lines, they do not vote on the issues. This is happening now in Britain, in Britain historically religion was the underlying unseen factor in how people voted, but that didn`t matter so much because people had basically the same beliefs.

Now in Britain the driving force in how people vote is again going to be religion and now also race and culture.
This is extremely dangerous.

'.....Now in Britain the driving force in how people vote is again going to be religion and now also race and culture....

No it's not.....

Education
Healthcare
Employment
Housing
Transport
Environment

Just some of the real issues

Yes all those things are important, however how people vote in relation to these things will be determined by religion and race. As a stark example in N. Ireland over 80% of Catholics voted remain, a similar no. of Protestants voted leave.
Religion was the determining factor there hoe people voted.
But throughout England now it will be race and religion.

Education  -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Healthcare -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Employment- doesn't get better with more people sharing it-
Housing    -doesn't get better with more people sharing it         
Transport  -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Environment - jury out.

Just some of the real issues- that are not helped by importing more people.

when the demographic shift is concluded you may not even be allowed a vote as some of the cult are not keen on it

An NHS worker provoked fury last night after she wished illnesses on the children of Brexiteers live on BBC One's Question Time show.

The worker, who said she worked at Great Ormond Street children's hospital and is from Watford, now faces calls to be sacked.

.
http://tinyurl.com/greatmoron

How come nobody mentioned this on here last night?

There is only one issue,immigration.

Big business want it for cheap labour.
The London elite want it for cheap nannies and maids.
The Tories want it for their wealthy donors.
Labour want it because they can't convince the indigenous voters so they want to import millions of voters.

The people against are the people badly affected by it,the working class.
The only party speaking for these people are UKIP

bbc kind of cut her off as she was having her rant and the mike was moved away from her

she stated something along the lines of the funding for her research is from europe and
this will be removed under brexit. she went on that she hoped some brexiteer had a kid
that would have some illness that might have been helped by the research so they would
understand what the vote had done.

she could still be heard after the mike was removed as she was shouting.


why mention it, shes a nutter

Aye, and she went unchallenged. Had she been espousing an equally disgusting right wing view they would have destroyed her.

She's an example of the remaniacs who work with children, that's why it's important to mention her. It's also why the Beeb tried to play it down. They always try to portray brexiteers as the loonies.

she wasnt unchallenged by the audience , there was quite a bit of
disgust at what she was saying.

i'm surprised bbc didnt edit her out.

her social media will be buzzing today

Dimblebore heard it and brushed it away, Donny.

the daft Bint conveniently forgets that its it us taxpayers who gave the money to the EU in the first place before they gave it back (and only a fraction of it) to the NHS


BTW, wildmanfromborneo nails it

platini, that was the point i made last night about it being our money

saddo    04 Nov 16 09:13 
Education  -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Healthcare -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Employment- doesn't get better with more people sharing it-
Housing    -doesn't get better with more people sharing it         
Transport  -doesn't get better with more people sharing it
Environment - jury out.

Just some of the real issues- that are not helped by importing more people.



These important entities are failing through lack of money and resource from the Tory government. The solution is to put adequate funding.
Eg. Fund the NHS properly, not deliberate underfund it, so it fails, leaving the gate open for privatisation.
Eg. Stop paying private Landlords to house people who require housing benefits. And build the necessary Council houses to at least replace those that were scandalously sold off by Thatcher.

The failure of this government with regards to the above, is not the fault of immigrants.

no pressure from the 8 million foreigners now here then?

have you taken in any of your friends from across the sea then facts:?

I agree with the criticism of the woman from Great Ormonde St.
She was making a valid point about funding from the EU to help in research.
Unfortunately, sh then completely lost it, and her stupid closing ( emotive) comments, completely undermined all she had said before and put herself in an extremely bad light.

mobo

8 million (?) ' foreigners '  ?

You mean the legitimate immigrants who are legally in the Uk, and provide a net contribution to the economy ?

no they don't - that has been exposed as eu funded propaganda

how many have you taken in and given a bed?

Who ' exposed it '
Where's the data ?

Most of em are low paid and being subsidised by HMG, if the opposite was true they'd be ramming figures at us to prove it. As for the likes of the Calais thieves, they'll get everything given.

Those Roma are hardly contributors
Those Eastern European metal thieves wouldn't be contributing much either.
Romanian ATM scanners not too hot in the contribution stakes.
And now my personal favourites the dole drawing polygamous Imams who end up with three or four houses and plenty of pulpits.

The Roma are skilled in taking a quite run down area and absolutely devastating it.

* Blair told em they could come in any quantity whenever they wanted.

the institution that provided solid figures for immigrant positive contribution 'facts' is funded to the tune of 72 million euros

the study was led by a german and an italian

can you wonder at the balance two europhiles would give to the study

facts and the others just want the flood gates jammed open, backing the big bosses to allow non unionised cheap labour in

I think some of em see it's gone a bit awry tbf, admitting they might be wrong is virtually impossible though, so we will probably continue towards conflict.

That women is mentally ill and shouldnt be allowed anywhere near a hospital.

Yes an exact description of your politics and the end result of them.

When I first started working early 1980's I was on £10k pa. But looking back through my racing programmes the admission for Sandown was £3.50. You could get a house for £30k, 30 years on were looking at about a score to get in the poor young workers are starting on about £16k pa, if that. We didn't realise that we had it so good then. I'm from down South but I completely empathise with anyone up North, struggling. I feel really as if we have been overridden by those who make more money in 10 minutes than most people make in a year. Like that news story last week, I would like, as a Southerner, to apologise on behalf of those down South, to anyone up North who voted to leave. Sorry, guys.

Those Roma are hardly contributors

Many of them are Big Issue sales people,having pushed many of the genuine homeless off their patches. They are classed as self employed which eneables them to claim working tax credits,a system taht has balloooned from £4bn per year when first introduced by Gordie to nearly £34bn last time  I saw figures for it. How many hospitals could we build and staff with that ?