Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
The Leopard
24 May 13 11:36
Joined:
Date Joined: 05 Apr 06
| Topic/replies: 48,023 | Blogger: The Leopard's blog
.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2013/may/24/sally-bercow-tweet-libelled-lord-mcalpine

Sally Bercow has lost her libel battle with Lord McAlpine over a tweet that falsely linked him with an allegation of child sexual abuse.

The high court ruled on Friday that her tweet – "Why is Lord McAlpine trending? *innocent face*", after BBC2 Newsnight allegations about a high-profile Tory politician – would have been understood to mean the former Tory chairman was a paedophile.

Bercow, who was not in court for the ruling, always denied her tweet was defamatory of McAlpine but on Friday said: "I very much regret my tweet." She has now agreed to settle with McAlpine, six months after her tweet at the height of the mass Twitter libel. Bercow's husband, John, is Commons Speaker.

Britain's most senior libel judge, Mr Justice Tugendhat, said in his judgment that her tweet meant "in its natural and ordinary defamatory meaning that the claimant was a paedophile who was guilty of sexually abusing boys living in care.

"If I were wrong about that, I would find that the tweet bore an innuendo meaning to the same effect."

The ruling ends a six-month legal saga which caused McAlpine "considerable unnecessary pain and suffering", his lawyer, Andrew Reid, said outside court.

Bercow said: "To say I'm surprised and disappointed by this is an understatement. However, I will accept the ruling as the end of the matter. I remain sorry for the distress I have caused Lord McAlpine and I repeat my apologies. I have accepted an earlier offer his lawyers made to settle this matter.

"Today's ruling should be seen as a warning to all social media users. Things can be held to be seriously defamatory, even when you do not intent them to be defamatory and do not make any express accusation. On this, I have learned my own lesson the hard way."

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 36
By:
Eeternaloptimist
When: 24 May 13 11:44
She is very lucky that he has allowed her to accept a previous offer when he could have really stuck the knife. Silly woman. Hope she learns her lesson.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 11:46
Ive been waiting to see how this one developed.
The ruling is disgusting imo.

The law says you can be found guilty on the basis of other's interpretation, irrespective of what you ACTUALLY said
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 11:46
thats like saying you are being found guilty of either wht you think or of what you didn't do/say
take a bow legal profession
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 11:48
*not 'the law' says, that should have read 'this ruling'
By:
jed.davison
When: 24 May 13 12:01
Are you for real dustybin?

Firstly, the meaning of her tweet was more than clear, and secondly, why are you posting a tweet like that if not for others to interpret it in the manner intended?

The judge has correctly applied the law.
By:
lfc1971
When: 24 May 13 12:10
In this particular case there would be nothing wrong in finding an innocent(which in any case she ain`t) guilty.
In fact it would be quite nice if the judge had said i`m not sure but in your case...guilty!
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 12:10
so had they argued that his name had been 'trending'
what then?
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 12:12
this should have been clean cut, was what was actually said (not interpreted to mean) defamatory?
yes or no
thats how law is supposed to be isnt it?
By:
lfc1971
When: 24 May 13 12:14
dusty...not in this case, normal service can now be resumed
By:
BillyBunnsLane
When: 24 May 13 12:15
She knew what she was saying and worse was using the slimiest tactic available in sly innuendo. Judge was right and I hope that she and her fellow tediocrats will now slope off to oblivion.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 12:19
BillyBunnsLane • May 24, 2013 12:15 PM BST
She knew what she was saying and worse was using the slimiest tactic available in sly innuendo. Judge was right and I hope that she and her fellow tediocrats will now slope off to oblivion.

You are suggesting the law basis its ruling on mind reading then?
So his name is trending, what then?
By:
Ken Masters
When: 24 May 13 12:19
In the absence of a "Just fking grow up" ruling, this will do perfectly. Grammatical pedantry is no defence *(apart from on here).
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 12:20
it is Ken, the whole legal system is based on it ffs
If we dont simplify it then the lawyers will continue to parasite on every trade they can over nonsense
By:
The Leopard
When: 24 May 13 12:40
.
http://theneedleblog.wordpress.com/2013/03/11/lord-mcalpine-nothing-disappears-from-the-web/
By:
Java
When: 24 May 13 12:58
I agree with Dusty on this one.  You can't have rulings based on what the judge thinks you might have intended to imply.
By:
rogerthebutler
When: 24 May 13 13:20
Bang goes making a libellious statement, followed by 'allegedly' as the fig-leaf!
By:
jed.davison
When: 24 May 13 13:31
We better stay off "Arsenal Chit-Chat" roger imo if that is the case.
By:
orioles
When: 24 May 13 13:33
Defamation has always included 'reading between the lines' so, as much as I generally frown on Tugendhat J, he is maintaining the law in this respect.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 13:49
I have seen you know more than most on these legal issues orioles so am interested in what you make of this.
Could you tell me what would have happened had the defence simply argued the statement was a question on the fact of the guys name which was actually trending at the time?
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 13:50
Surely fact trumps hurt feelings doesnt it?
By:
Arleystation
When: 24 May 13 13:52
What's really a tad annoying is that the police and the judiciary have to spend so much time dealing with what silly people put on trivial twitter, whilst the elderly are terrified in their own homes and ordinary folk are frightened to go out at night.
By:
orioles
When: 24 May 13 13:57
She didn't do that though, dusty, she qualified the statement. Don't get me wrong, this is at the limits of the principle IMHO, but an accusation that serious cannot be qualified like that.

Incidentally, the addition of 'allegedly' is not as formidable a bulwark as hignfy would have you believe!
By:
cooperman
When: 24 May 13 14:01
Odious woman gets just desserts shock! Move along, nothing to see here.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 14:02
but as a matter of fact he isnt maintaining the law is he?
He's simply assuming on the singular statement.
I havent seen what or how she is supposed to have qualified the statement, but if that occurred then it would have been on those statements she would have been judged, not on the one that she was seemingly found guilty of.
Cooperman, it isnt actually about who said it
By:
donny osmond
When: 24 May 13 15:01
seems an odd way to settle the dispute when a jury may decide the case
and ex tory ministers might not fare so well in their eyes...

i guess the damages must be less than 10k
By:
Yojimbo
When: 24 May 13 16:01
Law correctly applied here imo also. If she had written 'Lord McAlpine is definitely  NOT a **** (innocent face)' instead then imo the message would still have been clear, although it would still have would also have relied on a judge's interpretation of the meaning of the comment if it were to come to court.
By:
dustybin
When: 24 May 13 16:13
plenty of egos in law courts imo
replace the lot and get some algorithms in
get accurate rulings then
Wink
By:
alun2005
When: 24 May 13 19:36
So, if a TV News broadcast, for example, had drawn attention to the Twitter trending re: his Lordship via a "Top Ten Trending" feature, and one of the presenters routinely asked "Why is he trending?", would they have been equally culpable?

As much as I have a distaste for her antics, I have to say I think she's been extremely unfortunate with this outcome.
By:
Lee Ho Fooks
When: 24 May 13 19:44
May I just steer this debate towards the inevitable - I would Laugh
By:
alun2005
When: 24 May 13 19:45
AT LAST.

Something we can ALL agree on.
By:
Clungehungry
When: 24 May 13 19:48
alun, if a news report had asked 'Why is he trending?', wanting to know why he was trending...that would be a bit odd, but not libelous.

That was not the case here though, she KNEW why he was trending, and her tweet contributed to a false and malicious claim being spread still further.

Which is why she lost?
By:
moisok
When: 24 May 13 19:49
so would I  she looked quite perky leaving court  hmmmm!!!
By:
alun2005
When: 24 May 13 19:50
Her Tweet surely asks the very same question that my fictional news broadcaster asks?
By:
alun2005
When: 24 May 13 19:52
Thruppence ha'penny damages and not a farthing more with any luck.
By:
Clungehungry
When: 24 May 13 19:53
No Alun, it wasn't a question. That was the finding.
By:
Burton-Brewers
When: 24 May 13 20:12
what's trending?
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com