how much does it cost to keep a poor person alive?

In England about 30k apparently

I'm different. Laid a horse for £200 the other week and it died. I'd rather have lost my money.

You see i would of been glad mitchell

You can buy own brand noodles for about 8p a pack I, however, only buy superioe brand noodles such as Sharwoods. Large packs of Pasta can also be purchased for 24p. I would suggest this could sustain a person for two days, ergo 84p per week. However they would require extra nutritional input. Also they burn more calories crying due to the ridicule they are put through due to not buying superior brands of noodle

not being sanctimonious, it's a fact.

of course its sad to see innocent people die

i hate it when people say "isnt it sad" cos i always think, im not going to say no am i :s

yet you did, so i guess that line of questioning is reasonable

Fair enough Mitchell.

I'm interested in all interpretations.

Interestingly, are you a vegetarian?

Serious question.

Jim- look at it another way. 1 Million people lined up to be killed. Dr No offers you 1 million quid but if you refuse it he wont kill them. Is that ok.Or does Dr No know you only to well

no, I'm not a vegetarian, not eaten chicken for 5 years though, although it's delicious. I try and research before I eat meat, not that I eat a lot.

Murray, my thoughts exactly.

Dobbo, if they were lined up in front of me and I could see their eyes, I probably wouldn't be able to do it... but only because the thought would stay with me.

Mitchell, you could probably spare 500 animals over your lifetime and this is quite avoidable, yet you wouldn't let a horse die for your own gain. Is it because you think a horse is a superior animal, you just like them, or because your thoughts are influenced by other people (programmed at a young age)? ... Or a completely different reason?

I am actually fascinated by your thoughts on this matter, so keep them coming.

Thanks.

I agree in general, but I'd have to turn down the million pounds in your scenario. No chance I could live with the guilt, whether I knew them or not.

1 million pound would wash away any guilt i had

You say that but I don't think it would. Not to me anyway. I'd probably have nightmares the rest of my life if I'm being honest.

It depends on your definition of 'keeping alive'. And indeed, alive for how long and in what conditions? I have a figure in the archives of my memory that says the Nazis calculated that a slave worker would be useful for 3 months at 640 calories per day. The figure might even have been 460. Yes, they were that thorough! :-(

thatchers children all the same, and they couldn't give a fvck about the horse, let's not beat around the bush here.

You come cheap JMK.germany 1939 - 45 would have suited you

Phil, I understand what you've posted. Us humans have the ability to interpret thoughts, which can overcome natural instinct, which is the reason we exist in such a large quantity.

I think we need to remember that we are only intellegent beasts. In 70 years when when there is twice the current population and even the rich can't feed themselves, this will cause a real World War.

Politics is influenced by today's needs. Investing in the future doesn't gain votes.

Apologies for being a pesimistic bore, but I've had a few pints and I'm feeling philisophical (plus I wan't to put my mother straight!)

As long as none of the million are from my family, tell Dr No to send me the cheque.

I don't do guilt.

You dont need guilt you need mercy.

Yeah Yeah you dont do that either

its not sad when people die, people are meant to die. its just the way it is. everybody on the planet will die at some point. you may aswell say its sad all those sperm dont get to live, everytime you have a w@nk.

Sperm are a very simple life form. I call them cunnybobblers.

It Doesn't???

you must be a genius then dobbo, my iq is in the top 1%. and yes i know i dont use capital letters or punctuation.

Its not your punctuation thats troubling. Its your reasoning.

Dobbo, my grandparents came to England after the second war.

They have stories which many English youngsters (I'm only 24) have not heard... shooting babies because they wouldn't stop crying, then telling the inconsolable mother to stop crying otherwise they'd shoot her as well. I've also got a great Uncle (who's now dead) who was locked up in a Russian prison for 12 years and never told why and several other relatives who were burnt alive by German soldiers.

My Nan's life was saved by a German doctor in '45. He was bribed to help with jewellery as he said he would be shot if they found out he'd helped her.

I'm not a Nazi. I'm not racist. I no not dislike German people and in fact I even got stabbed when I protested in the pub at the last World Cup over idiots singing 'there were 10 German bombers in the air'. It was only in the arm and I was ok, but I'm likely to be repeating this venture in the Summer. My Grandparents had an Hungarian lodger living with them a few years after the war ended. I have a massive respect for this. Racism is a natural influence, yet from another more humane perspective, they overcame it.

Its the Henry Ford philosophy. History is**.

s punk

No wonder your mother is horrified.

But my guess is you would not really take the million

At least I'm honest (scientifically minded). I don't care about people I don't know. If I had the choice of a million quid and a million people get killed, or carry on as normal, I'd take the million in a flash.

So you take the option of killing a million people...

Going to have some trouble sleeping at night, I think.

how do you define a "poor person?".........gordon brown is a "poor excuse for a person"...does that count?.......or are we talking a down on his ar5e haitian with only his counterfeit watches to sustain him?

jimk 07 Feb 00:15
Murray, my thoughts exactly.

Dobbo, if they were lined up in front of me and I could see their eyes, I probably wouldn't be able to do it... but only because the thought would stay with me.

Mitchell, you could probably spare 500 animals over your lifetime and this is quite avoidable, yet you wouldn't let a horse die for your own gain. Is it because you think a horse is a superior animal, you just like them, or because your thoughts are influenced by other people (programmed at a young age)? ... Or a completely different reason?

I am actually fascinated by your thoughts on this matter, so keep them coming.

Thanks.


will do tomorrow, I'm too knackered now.

billions of people have lived and died, am i meant to have a minutes silence for each one?

im not saying its ok to go out and kill people, and im not saying saying you shouldnt do something to help other people, im just saying its not as big a deal as people make out.

i once watched a news item on starving kids in africa. the girl i was with said it was really sad. i said ok well lets go out now and sell your car and send the proceeds to the charity. noooo im not doing that. why not? whats more important, peoples lives or your car??? umm...my car. well its not that sad then is it...

Perhaps a little empathy for the tragedy of humankind rather than writing people off as equal to w ank residue

Interestingly, I've just read my thoughts again.

I started off with my instincts and my last post seemed to adjust into 'human' thinking. Dobbo, your comments have prompted me into noticing this.

It is a difficult situation to comprehend. I am alive because of millions of billions of trillions of freak coincidences, plus factors such as the German doctor I mentioned. I'm alive because someone got bribed. I'm also alive because one million years ago a velocirapta (or however you spell it) turned left instead of right.

hmmm. maybe i would turn down the money, but then again, if no-one would ever find out, maybe i'd take it.

An atheist has faith too just their faith is that there is nothing to have faith in.

My mum gets the State pension, plus a few quid from other places. I she "a poor person"?

jimk, thank feck you are not a political leader/dictator, or you would just keep your grubby mitts on all available money and turn a blind eye to the needy/poor. Your mum doesn't sound like the most logical of people either!