Cheltenham Festival
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
30 Jan 12
13:14
Joined:
Date Joined:
10 Jul 05
no not yul brenner,
the first 7 irish horses in the betting ,in the best champion hurdle of all time.
i ll start you off
brave inca
the first 7 irish horses in the betting ,in the best champion hurdle of all time.
i ll start you off
brave inca
Show More
The "best champion hurdle of all time" surely had Night Nurse, Sea Pigeon and Birds Nest in it?
I assume you are talking about the Hardy Eustace / Harchibald race with Macs Joy, Inca, Accordion Etoile, Back In Front and Al Eile.
Quite how you would conclude it was the best champion is a different matter. Very exciting race but not one of those would trouble the current champion or Istabraq (in my opinion of course).
Quite how you would conclude it was the best champion is a different matter. Very exciting race but not one of those would trouble the current champion or Istabraq (in my opinion of course).
Harchibald, Hardy Eustace, Macs Joy, Essex? Back in Front? Hmmm, pass!
It would certainly rank ahead of the 05 version thieves.
Hardy Eustace and Brave Inca were very good horses but I would not put either anywhere near the top of the tree among winners.
Hardy Eustace and Brave Inca were very good horses but I would not put either anywhere near the top of the tree among winners.
istabraq or fly - are just one horse,that year there was top class horses right up to 20/1,
not sure but wasnt it essex and not al eile
not sure but wasnt it essex and not al eile
we ve all got different - needs offically verifify,accordian yes,not sure about back to front
back in front 7/2
hardy 7/2
harchi 7/1
macs joy 7/1
essex 9/1
brave inca 10/1
accordian etoile 14/1
hardy 7/2
harchi 7/1
macs joy 7/1
essex 9/1
brave inca 10/1
accordian etoile 14/1
down the list
neptune winner
neptune winner/champion hurdle
nowt but crusing
irish champion
tote gold trohy
champion
cant think what this won
must be strongest line up,
neptune winner
neptune winner/champion hurdle
nowt but crusing
irish champion
tote gold trohy
champion
cant think what this won
must be strongest line up,
Essex and Accordion Etoile were pretty high class but certainly not the very top class.
Loads of supreme winners have contested subsequent champions with many disappointing.
Inca had not won a race all year at that stage and was only a supreme winner at the time.
Royal Gait beat 3 other champion hurdlers when he won the race and some other very high class horses such as Fidway and Oh So Risky. It depends what slant you take on it. Granville Again beat 2 previous and a subsequent winner when he won his renewal. How many were in their prime is different.
The 05 renewal had no star but I guess it had depth at a certain level. No way would I rank it as the best there was however, or anything close to it.
Loads of supreme winners have contested subsequent champions with many disappointing.
Inca had not won a race all year at that stage and was only a supreme winner at the time.
Royal Gait beat 3 other champion hurdlers when he won the race and some other very high class horses such as Fidway and Oh So Risky. It depends what slant you take on it. Granville Again beat 2 previous and a subsequent winner when he won his renewal. How many were in their prime is different.
The 05 renewal had no star but I guess it had depth at a certain level. No way would I rank it as the best there was however, or anything close to it.
1977 1 Night Nurse - double champion 2 Monksfield - double champion 3 Dramatist - Christmas Hurdle winner 4 Sea Pigeon - double champion 5 Birds Nest - multiple big race winner inc 3 Bula's(International) 3 Fighting Fifths 2 Scottish Champion Hurdles
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539