Australian
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
19 Apr 13
14:28
Joined:
Date Joined:
13 Feb 04
Ziggy,
Heard Carl going for Sam Reid big time next year.
To many Big forwards and $$$ not add up at Syd i hear.
Just watched Reid is he worth it and does he get your nod to be a Navy Blue?
Id trade Cashbolt, McClean, AJ Superstar Joseph + a first round pick for a big man.
Also need a Backman.
Any news why Laidler not playing, as good as Jamison is scary with the ball. i close my eyes when in his hands.
Its going to be a Long year
Heard Carl going for Sam Reid big time next year.
To many Big forwards and $$$ not add up at Syd i hear.
Just watched Reid is he worth it and does he get your nod to be a Navy Blue?
Id trade Cashbolt, McClean, AJ Superstar Joseph + a first round pick for a big man.
Also need a Backman.
Any news why Laidler not playing, as good as Jamison is scary with the ball. i close my eyes when in his hands.
Its going to be a Long year
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 21
|
By:
Sam Reid just signed a 5 year contract last year? And he cant kick, and couldn't mark tonight.
|
|
By:
Ziggy is the man and if mail is right i dont know if its good or bad on his form.
Ziggy declared Kennedy a Superstar in his 1st season and was shattered we lost him. Carl needs a Big man and there is not many out there. |
|
By:
Would be a great player if he learned to mark the ball
 |
|
By:
Lack of skills based recruiting imo. Not sure of the stats, and they may prove me wrong, but from the outside it appears to me that....
Carlton have few who have aerial skills but many who have ground skills. Few with kicking skills. Marking strength up forward with the ability to grab it or bring it to ground for their talented small forwards. Would help. |
|
By:
He might be a good pick up for Carlton, but they would probably need to trade Murphy, Kruezer and maybe even Judd to get him.
|
|
By:
sam reid would be a ripper 'get' for carlton Lloydy, despite his kicking.Your mail is right and I'll add another name to the pot and this one will probably happen.Daisy Thomas.
|
|
By:
sam reid would be a ripper 'get' for carlton Lloydy, despite his kicking.Your mail is right and I'll add another name to the pot and this one will probably happen.Daisy Thomas.
|
|
By:
No way Eddie lets Thomas go,or any pie player to Carlton
IMO |
|
By:
What about Scott Heathland?
|
|
By:
Can hardly see Sydney giving Sam Reid up.
Carlton supporters and their management seem to think they have the divine right to buy any player they want. Little wonder they're considered to be breathtakingly arrogant. That's Carlton's solution to everything isn't it, the instant fix, you bought Judd trying to buy a premiership and it didn't work as you lost Kennedy in the process, how about just for a change trying to develop a player yourself like most other clubs do and why would Reid want to go from a premiership contender to a club that's just making up the numbers. |
|
By:
That was before Eddie,wasn't it,anyway they won a flag without him...
|
|
By:
No it wasn't Eddie's been President for ages.
|
|
By:
Well he hates mick,no way he lets Thomas go..
|
|
By:
Don't think Eddie hates Mick, I think Mick has no time for Eddie though.
|
|
By:
We lost our Superstar in Fev because of Judd.
Imagine Kennedy, Fev together at their Peak. Also Setanta was a loss. Id rather him than Cashbolt, Hamson and Warnock. Judd was good for Carl but we gave away to much to get him Our weekness is a Gorrilla and a Key Forward. Plus u said WC Soft we are soft as well. Football has changed its not about breeding your own anymore or they would have districts to recruit from. Its all about Money and TV |
|
By:
If Carlton are "just making up the numbers", you would have to think West Coast should merge on what I saw the other night. What an insipid bunch they are. Not sure what they are doing but they should be rebuilding and starting again. Maybe then they would keep up with the likes of Carlton
|
|
By:
don't worry about the relationship between mick and eddie....the relationships to focus on are daisy/mick versus daisy/bucks.will be in a blue jumper next year
|
|
By:
Is Thomas past his best? Or getting to age of only a couple of years left?
That would be my worry |
|
By:
I better back him to win Medal now
|
|
By:
Ziggy,
He either is not playing for Buck or is a 2nd rate player at the moment. Not sure would want him. I was hoping Gumbleton last year. Looking good now is fit. I think you said we should of picked him instead of Gibbs you said we should of taken Cotchin before Kreuzer |
|
By:
i did Llyody ,but it all turned pear dhaped when they paid overs for judd
|