Australian
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
14 Mar 13
10:23
Joined:
Date Joined:
25 Jan 12
Best horses to run against Black Caviar ...
Who do you include?
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Who do you include?
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 73
|
By:
Phar Lap
|
|
By:
Bomber Bill
|
|
By:
Bomber Bill ... what a legend !!!
|
|
By:
True Persuasion
Zedi Knight |
|
By:
Still a two horse race IMO
|
|
By:
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato 3. Miss Andretti 4. Takeover Target 5. 6. 7. 8. |
|
By:
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato 3. Miss Andretti 4. Takeover Target 5. Schillaci 6. 7. 8. |
|
By:
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato 3. Miss Andretti 4. Takeover Target 5. Schillaci 6. Placid Ark 7. 8. |
|
By:
special
|
|
By:
Mahogany(1st up)
Choisir Fastnet Rock Bernborough |
|
By:
Dandy Kid....shocking omission
 |
|
By:
I don't really agree with any of them 8 ball ...
Mahogany over further, Bernborough a little further, Choisir no, Fastnet Rock ummm but others might agree with you |
|
By:
If they go hard in front and she's set for it....Makybe Diva............... runs a place
 |
|
By:
Dandy Kid and Bomber Bill are in the Prelude event
|
|
By:
Runs second if it's transferred to HQ
 |
|
By:
I can't see them not going hard, but Makybe Diva surely has to go in another race, otherwise you'd be putting in every stayer that sprints well fresh
|
|
By:
Well maybe we transfer it, but down the straight? I hate straight 6 races
|
|
By:
Fair enough otto but TINS started it so how about Hi Hat ?
|
|
By:
Smokey Ruler. People have got short memories.
|
|
By:
Vain, Bletchingly, Zephyr Bay
|
|
By:
Oureone
|
|
By:
1. Black Caviar
2. Manikato 3. Miss Andretti 4. Takeover Target 5. Schillaci 6. Placid Ark 7. Vain 8. |
|
By:
TT is way too high up the list
|
|
By:
Are you doubting that it belongs in the top 8?
This list in in no order |
|
By:
Yes
|
|
By:
... and you're saying that Bletchingly was proven a better horse?
|
|
By:
your 4 were before my time, but Bletchingly only started 5 times ...
I followed racing from 1980 roughly to about 1997 and then from about 2004 until now |
|
By:
For longevity TT should be there, but thats it, he was a very very good horse but most overrate him because of his longevity. Head to head both at their best I would be on Bletchingly
|
|
By:
Would anyone put Apache Cat?
The reason I started this was because I thought a gutsy horse like Manikato might beat Black Caviar ... I doubt whether any of the others could |
|
By:
and I picked the Valley because Manikato loved it there and BC has also won there twice
|
|
By:
Hay List may have been top in another era, except for chemical scientists in Melbourne working wonders in our sports at present. Poor old Hay list will go down in history as the Raylene Boyle of Horse racing.
 |
|
By:
AC no
|
|
By:
I'd nominate Demus and hope for a wet track!
|
|
By:
MOONEE VALLEY Race 1: 1200m Hcp. Track: Good
All horses are at their peak of their careers. All horses jump perfectly. 1. Black Caviar (3) ... Luke Nolen ... 10/9 2. Manikato (5) ... Gary Willetts ... 7-4 3. Miss Andretti (6) ... Craig Newitt ... 7-1 4. Takeover Target (7) ... Jay Ford ... 20-1 5. Schillaci (4) ... Damien Oliver ... 11-2 6. Placid Ark (2) ... John Scorse ... 16-1 7. Vain (1) ... Pat Hyland ... 33-1 |
|
By:
haha your kidding? manikato would be BC around a turn any day or night of the week
|
|
By:
would be what
|
|
By:
I said that about 20 posts ago.
I'm glad you agree with me. |
|
By:
along with apache cat?? really haha
|
|
By:
I was looking for an eighth ...
What would you suggest ... Daybreak Lover? |