Is Carroll the most ineffective player Liverpool have signed ever ?

has had a good game today

how he stays on and bellamy on 4 gerrard i duno

He is a bit of a shocker

Has had no service today at all; when he has had the ball he hasn't wasted it; certainly rattled De Gea

put himself about well today...not much more he could do when LFC sat back after the goal

i cud rattle de gay mate

He wasn't ineffective when they signed him.

Not from your sofa you couldn't, Bhoys

true but dont takealot to rattle de gay if all u have to do is stand in front of him from a corner

nice knock on

hit the bar

I think the lad is improving game by game, just needs better crosses.

lfc have a striker who is very decent in the air, and yet he had one header all game, which he hit the crossbar with... service was ****

David Speedie probably beats Carroll to the title but on a lb for lb basis Carroll would romp in. I say romp; I mean lumber.

Speedie scored two against the mancs so will never be the worst buy.

Carroll struggled to settle but playing as lone striker role with players who can't cross does not suit him one iota.

That plus the fact that he's too heavy, he's too slow and he's lacking in skill.

Bustled up the mancs and played his part in kicking them out the Cup.

That will do for now ta cery much

Yep. It will do for now.
And that's why you're in the position you're in. Everything for years and years at Liverpool has 'done for now'. Not since Shankly have you had a manager who understands long termism.

You must have forgotten about the numerous leagues, Euro Cups etc won by Paisley and Fagan.

I know you mancs are young glory hunters though, so probably before your time as it was pre 'Premiership' era.

Not since Shankly have you had a manager who understands long termism.


what sloblocks


also, to say he's too heavy is unfair....there's nowt of him for a 6footer+

The Betfair forum is really strange.
We're on a gaming site and yet consistently there is misunderstanding when it comes to the basics of number and chance.
There's the conspiracy theory nutjobs on ChitChat who don't get conditional probability; and then on the football forum there are those who can't distinguish between long term and short term. You'd think the poker forum would be the bastion of this particular subject, but they're as bad.

Long may it continue by the way.

what a nugget

QED

Did you see how he chased down the Man U back 4 and DM when they had the ball?  He barely moved a muscle, incredibly lazy, even when the ball was close to him and he had a chance to nick it off them or intercept.  Lazy and slow.

Makes Berbatov look like an energetic athlete.

itcanbedone •

Makes Berbatov look like an energetic athlete.

Steady now.