The nicotine-stained-tree-frog is a highly polarising figure, one of very politicians who can galvanise opposition against them personally (how else to account for his seven defeats?)
Having formally taken over the leadership of Reform yesterday, he must have chosen the easiest constituency in which to win, but Farage is prone to embarrassing outbursts and, when the going gets tough, has a track record of folding like a deckchair. On today's evidence, he is unlikely to be able to deal with the pressure of interviews.
There will be time for the opposition to coalesce around its opposition to Farage; and perhaps for the other parties to come to a repprochement locally, to make his election more difficult.
Of course England had no reason to declare war on Germany technically
Do were quite lucky that the Germans at Dunkirk let them escape without shooting at them
The rest is history , silly krauts
Of course England had no reason to declare war on Germany technically Do were quite lucky that the Germans at Dunkirk let them escape without shooting at themThe rest is history , silly krauts
Odds on Farage to win Clacton haven't eased, which surprises me. In fact 1.34 now.
I suppose when we drill down to individual seats, projections become more erratic?
Odds on Farage to win Clacton haven't eased, which surprises me. In fact 1.34 now. I suppose when we drill down to individual seats, projections become more erratic?
You think that greens are getting 8% in Clacton? MRP is very cumbersome, stated many times, it is modelling using polling data. Farage may or may not win in Clacton, but I advise against anyone putting money into individual consistency polls based on MRP data.
You think that greens are getting 8% in Clacton? MRP is very cumbersome, stated many times, it is modelling using polling data. Farage may or may not win in Clacton, but I advise against anyone putting money into individual consistency polls based on
But if we post them all we get an idea of how things are going. I posted a caveat about mrp but in absence of owt better it's all we have.
Pretty extreme test for it here, so it's a measure for future too.
I don't think anybody will.But if we post them all we get an idea of howthings are going. I posted a caveat about mrpbut in absence of owt better it's all we have.Pretty extreme test for it here, so it's a measurefor future too.
Personally I feel it's more likely to lead to misdirection from a single seat perspective. We know that the last few elections were dominated by the brexit narrative. This time that counts for nowt, the storyline is the disintegration of the Tory vote. Then we have to work out how that will play out in the particular dynamics of the seat, the arrival of RUK, and stay at home Tories. I feel we can outperform any model as requires a modicum of sophistication. Some seats the Tory vote will absolutely flow to RUK (eg Boston), some LD (eg Cheltenham), others Labour (eg Canterbury). In a few dozen seats it probably holds up against the tide.
And then you have the complexities of Scotland, which I personally don't even touch.
It's just a gentle warning from me to others, not to be unduly influenced by MRP in regard to single seat betting.
Personally I feel it's more likely to lead to misdirection from a single seat perspective. We know that the last few elections were dominated by the brexit narrative. This time that counts for nowt, the storyline is the disintegration of the Tory vot
Well I think you are judging it before you've seen if it works.
By all means treat with extreme caution but pick a few seats and follow the projections, then see where it's worked and where it didn't.
Could be money for jam down the road.
Well I think you are judging it before you've seen if it works.By all means treat with extreme caution but pick a few seatsand follow the projections, then see where it's workedand where it didn't.Could be money for jam down the road.
I can see how clunky it is already though. Take Survation and Brighton Pavilion as an example:Lab: 30.6%Con: 17.0%Lib Dem: 0.7%Green: 41.4%Reform: 9.2%
Tory, ukip and Brexit got 19.1% combined in 2019. htf are they getting combined 26% this year when there is no brexit contention . It also doesn't seem to be able to cope with LD not putting up candidates since 2015.
Tory, ukip and Brexit got 19.1% combined in 2019. htf are they getting combined 26% this year when there is no brexit contention . It also doesn't seem to be able to cope with LD not putting up candidates since 2015.
Cards on the table. I have backed Labour here at 17.5 (for a fiver at 17.5 and £2 at 12.5)) and the tories (for £30, highest price 5.9). I just can't see any value in the price of Reform. They have an edge but nothing that can't be overcome.
Cards on the table. I have backed Labour here at 17.5 (for a fiver at 17.5 and £2 at 12.5)) and the tories (for £30, highest price 5.9). I just can't see any value in the price of Reform. They have an edge but nothing that can't be overcome.
there's no value in 1/3, certainly I would not bet that price. i cannot absolutely rule out dirty tricks from the establishment to keep Farage out of westminster.
there's no value in 1/3, certainly I would not bet that price. i cannot absolutely rule out dirty tricks from the establishment to keep Farage out of westminster.
The tories will be polling the seat, and we know they bet on politics. I doubt the others are polling here.
The MRP sort of matches the exchange prices
All that free research at your fingertips...
The tories will be polling the seat, and we knowthey bet on politics. I doubt the others are polling here.The MRP sort of matches the exchange pricesAll that free research at your fingertips...
Well, Farage won, unfortunately. When he was an MEP he was largely truant from the European Parliament; I hope constituency grunt work keeps him quiet for five years but expect the roar of the greasepaint and the smell of the crowd to prove irresistible.
Well, Farage won, unfortunately. When he was an MEP he was largely truant from the European Parliament; I hope constituency grunt work keeps him quiet for five years but expect the roar of the greasepaint and the smell of the crowd to prove irresisti
Reform deffo did for the tory ‘top brass’, their 14.3% of the popular vote nutted plenty of tories in some tight seats…with several only just hanging on with the skin of their teeth,
It’s a bit like The Night of the Long Knives The right wing vote getting shown what happens when they arn’t right enough, hopefully Reform can become the main voice of the Right as Labour fk it all up as always.
Just need a Reichtag Fire next….
Reform deffo did for the tory ‘top brass’, their 14.3% of the popular vote nutted plenty of tories in some tight seats…with several only just hanging on with the skin of their teeth,It’s a bit like The Night of the Long Knives The right wing
Well dustybin, it's a free country and I'm sure Kier Starmer will exercise that freedom by completely ignoring Reform until 2029. He's done his job for Labour. Thanks.
Well dustybin, it's a free country and I'm sure Kier Starmer will exercise that freedom by completely ignoring Reform until 2029. He's done his job for Labour. Thanks.
Done his job just being a cut-out. How many know what he has planned? He just waited as the tories imploded and the right emerged.
As soon as he starts to do anything people will see he has nowt.
Done his job just being a cut-out.How many know what he has planned? He just waited as the tories imploded and the right emerged.As soon as he starts to do anything people will see he has nowt.
I saw a doc on Bowie once where he showed how he came up with the lyrics for his songs; he just cut words out of newspapers and rearranged them. His fans thought there were some profound meanings to them…but it was just word salad.
‘The sunlight of hope, pale at first but getting stronger through the day shining once again on a country with the opportunity after 14 years to get it;s future back’
How many scripts were cut up for that one? Pure meaningless rhetoric….’get its future back’….he just moved ‘country’ and applied sunshine. What a quim this guy is.
I saw a doc on Bowie once where he showed how he came up with the lyrics for his songs; he just cut words out of newspapers and rearranged them.His fans thought there were some profound meanings to them…but it was just word salad.‘The sunlight of
Oh are you talking about Starmer now? You're right, dustybin, Farage is an irrelevance. Reform is not an option for grown-ups. This made me chuckle:https://youtube.com/shorts/KSIKPMkKw2E?si+NPnSwZc9lzc3hsX9
Ironic on a number of levels that I happened to walk down a street in Sheffield the other week I hadn’t been down for many years, called London Road.
And if it’s not barbershop it’s a take away shop. For about 2 miles out from town. And there were hardly anyone in any of the ones I looked in.
Apparently Farage is less of an irrelevance than you might have thought yesterday. At least he commits to something, unlike Starmer who is so scared of his back bench that if he dares imply anything close to jingoistic they will pounce on him calling him a racist. What does he stand for exactly?
Ironic on a number of levels that I happened to walk down a street in Sheffield the other week I hadn’t been down for many years, called London Road.And if it’s not barbershop it’s a take away shop. For about 2 miles out from town.And there wer
Apparently your new PM - a decent, well meaning man, according to your last one - can safely ignore anything Farage says until 2029, because Reform has no leverage. Farage's job now is to hear the complaints of the good people of Clacton re sewage, potholes and Turkish barbers (and he can't do anything about the latter). I think I'll take my cue from Starmer and just ignore Reform too for the next five years.
Apparently your new PM - a decent, well meaning man, according to your last one - can safely ignore anything Farage says until 2029, because Reform has no leverage. Farage's job now is to hear the complaints of the good people of Clacton re sewage, p
Yes ub those two are like having a debate at Eton. They were phoneys just pretending to hate each other. Deep down neither gives a sh1t about Britain, or Brits and share almost the same ideology.
Yes ub those two are like having a debate at Eton. They were phoneys just pretending to hate each other. Deep down neither gives a sh1t about Britain, or Brits and share almost the same ideology.
The only direct influence over Starmer for the next 5 years will be his own infighting, but as an influence reform can shape what right of centre looks like going forward. The first stage is done, all the old form are out, and the way is clear for a couple of more fervent types to battle for the tory soul.
Starmer has the audacity to say he is more for the working man than the others, what utter bs.
The only direct influence over Starmer for the next 5 years will be his own infighting, but as an influence reform can shape what right of centre looks like going forward.The first stage is done, all the old form are out, and the way is clear for a c
The key lesson for labour is to not lean into the immigration argument. They will always be outflanked and as the tories showed, it's the route to disaster. Just state the case clearly about why immigration is where it's at and what the plan is for jobs, housing, education etc. Let the frothers froth, and then get on with rebuilding the country. Just get things working again. Party politics is one thing, but the big issue in the country is that things have just stopped working. Let's just have a couple of years of competence please.
The key lesson for labour is to not lean into the immigration argument. They will always be outflanked and as the tories showed, it's the route to disaster. Just state the case clearly about why immigration is where it's at and what the plan is for j
It's easy to get nett immigration down. (or should be)
[Not same as reducing number of migrants.]
We really don't need to keep increasing population by 500k each year.
Of course we may need some years of high nett intake but there should be many years we do not.
Surely student numbers cannot keep increasing at current rate.
It's easy to get nett immigration down. (or should be) [Not same as reducing number of migrants.] We really don't need to keep increasing populationby 500k each year.Of course we may need some years of high nett intakebut there should be many years w
I don't really get why students are counted in it. They come for three years, and they go. They're a massive boon for the economy while they're here. It's different if people are coming to work (not on a fixed term contract) or joining family, fleeing horrors etc.
I don't really get why students are counted in it. They come for three years, and they go. They're a massive boon for the economy while they're here. It's different if people are coming to work (not on a fixed term contract) or joining family, fleein
Well yeah they are only counted for the year they arrive in nett migration
And removed in year they leave.
For the years they are here they live in this country so use uk services and live in uk accommodation so need to be included
Well yeah they are only counted for the year they arrive in nett migrationAnd removed in year they leave.For the years they are here they live in this countryso use uk services and live in uk accommodation soneed to be included
Yeah, I've never liked the over-commercialisation of university education. But if that's the route you're choosing to go down, and the fees charged to foreigners are so much higher than to brits, then capitalism dictates that they'll want as many of the golden calves as they can possibly get.
Yeah, I've never liked the over-commercialisation of university education. But if that's the route you're choosing to go down, and the fees charged to foreigners are so much higher than to brits, then capitalism dictates that they'll want as many of
Yes ub those two are like having a debate at Eton. They were phoneys just pretending to hate each other. Deep down neither gives a sh1t about Britain, or Brits and share almost the same ideology.
The things you hate about Sunak and Starmer are the things I like about them, Cider.
A couple of days ago I was talking with a fella whose son was standing for Reform. He is a nice guy, Cypriot by birth, never voted before, rightly proud of his son. It was a good conversation for me to have. There is a time to put aside cynicism and acknowledge the debt we owe people who go into public service thinking they can make a difference: afterwards I thought: Farage proved the worst kind of Parliamentarian in Brussels: but this son of the guy I was talking to is 19.
What forums like this don't do is put people with opposing convictions facing each other over a dinner table. My paper does this and reports the conversation every Saturday. I could name some readers sneering as they read this but that interaction does make a difference.
Let's be positive, just for one day.
Yes ub those two are like having a debate at Eton. They were phoneys just pretending to hate each other. Deep down neither gives a sh1t about Britain, or Brits and share almost the same ideology.The things you hate about Sunak and Starmer are the thi
I don't believe it's difficult ub, effective leaders have conviction and aren't afraid of being unpopular in the short term in order to deliver their long term goals. In my own small world I am very familiar with those variables. Modern politics is simply about managing the media and keeping the London hacks happy (trying to). Keith or Sunak don't believe in anything other than achieving their personal goals (which aren't usually compatible with the country's). Example, Sunak spent months in the Tory leadership contest confirming he was open to fracking, his very first question at PMQs after finally getting the job was to reject fracking. When his team put together the absurd 5 promises all they did was select measures they though were guaranteed to happen anyway (absurdly cynical). Of course it blew up in his face as he has zero political nouse and actually thought the nhs wouldn't screw him over.
I don't believe it's difficult ub, effective leaders have conviction and aren't afraid of being unpopular in the short term in order to deliver their long term goals. In my own small world I am very familiar with those variables. Modern politics is s
Anyhow, exactly how this plays out nobody knows but Farage and the rest of Reform will disrupt the cosy world of westminster and the uni party. They will be a bigger thorn in the side of Keith than anything the feeble emasculated Tory remnants will be able to muster.
Anyhow, exactly how this plays out nobody knows but Farage and the rest of Reform will disrupt the cosy world of westminster and the uni party. They will be a bigger thorn in the side of Keith than anything the feeble emasculated Tory remnants will b
I suspect Labour are more worried about the four Green MP's than watching the tories rip themselves apart for a bit. Those greens could drag Labour across to the left a bit.
I suspect Labour are more worried about the four Green MP's than watching the tories rip themselves apart for a bit. Those greens could drag Labour across to the left a bit.
They will be a bigger thorn in the side of Keith than anything the feeble emasculated Tory remnants will be able to muster.
they will only be a thorn in the side of the tories. for labour they have so far have proved themselves very useful idiots
They will be a bigger thorn in the side of Keith than anything the feeble emasculated Tory remnants will be able to muster. they will only be a thorn in the side of the tories. for labour they have so far have proved themselves very useful idiots
Farage is somebody who likes throwing bottles from the back of the hall.
Farage will never be leader of the Conservative Party. That's all you need to know about him, for the next five years.
Poor Reform voters, what have they bought for £25 - plus £5 to see Farage appear? A Leader who would throw them under a bus if only the Conservative Party would take him in with some kudos.
Farage is somebody who likes throwing bottles from the back of the hall. Farage will never be leader of the Conservative Party. That's all you need to know about him, for the next five years. Poor Reform voters, what have they bought for £25 - plus
I don't see it like that at all, Labour support is very thin, a frankly embarrassing 1/3 of the voting electorate and a leader who inspires noone. Today's results show that many Labour seats are vulnerable to Reform. If you can only achieve 34% at your peak then it doesn't take much at all for that to weaken quickly. I feel like Reform and Farage will target further inroads into that Labour support and allow the Tories to self destruct. Let's see what Keith and his cronies will be able to deliver now that they are not just lobbing grenades from the cheap seats.
I don't see it like that at all, Labour support is very thin, a frankly embarrassing 1/3 of the voting electorate and a leader who inspires noone. Today's results show that many Labour seats are vulnerable to Reform. If you can only achieve 34% at yo
Great Victory for Reform...4 seats..... 3 more than Jeremey Corbyn or twice as many as Jeremy Corbyn and Diane Abbott. Reform are going to be a great influence on this Parliament
Great Victory for Reform...4 seats..... 3 more than Jeremey Corbyn or twice as many as Jeremy Corbyn and Diane Abbott. Reform are going to be a great influence on this Parliament
Basically the next five years comes down to two things imo. Labour to achieve some things, start fixing stuff and get life somewhere back to where most of the electorate remember it. Do that and they've a really solid base to win the next and the next after that. Secondly, what the tories manage to do. They're still a huge brand and the election showed the loyalty of their base despite anyone with working eyes and ears wondering how anyone could ever support them. If the tories manage to draw a line, banish this period to the history books with a slew of new shadow ministers breaking the links to Johnson, Truss, Rees-Mogg et al then they will probably recover and be a force again. If they don't and carry on getting wrapped up in the stuff that's dragged them down, then I think they'll fade away and Reform or whatever they morph into will be the main right wing party.
Basically the next five years comes down to two things imo. Labour to achieve some things, start fixing stuff and get life somewhere back to where most of the electorate remember it. Do that and they've a really solid base to win the next and the nex
Everyone knows it's the function of the system. Even the staunchest of Labour nuts could mot legitimately claim that Starmer rides in on a massive public mandate and a wave of optimism. Everyone knew they would still get a big landslide and lots of MPs due to the quirks of fptp.
Everyone knows it's the function of the system. Even the staunchest of Labour nuts could mot legitimately claim that Starmer rides in on a massive public mandate and a wave of optimism. Everyone knew they would still get a big landslide and lots of M
Public turned to trusted parties to get rid of them.
Now Starmer is government and will be judged on it.
Mandate... Who cares at next election there will be 5 years to judge him on.
Ed Davey got 5 years for rehearsing stunts
Far right got 5 years of scrutiny... Actors, lol
Torys got 5 years in jail for fraud, will public give them parole?
He's not a corrupt tory.Public turned to trusted parties to get rid of them.Now Starmer is government and will be judged on it.Mandate... Who cares at next election there willbe 5 years to judge him on.Ed Davey got 5 years for rehearsing stuntsFar ri
Easy to say the biggest thing is the rejection of the tories. Certainly Reform would have done next to nothing if the right wingers hadn't fled from their safe homes. But you have to give Starmer credit. Labour were an utter shambles after the 2019 election. He inherited a basket case and was up against a very popular PM who was shoving through his main policy. That he has managed to go from there to winning such a big landslide is an achievement that political historians will write about for decades. It's pretty much unheard of. But the election campaign itself was about safety first. Labour had built a huge lead and all they could do was lose it. Don't do a Theresa and a death tax. Don't do a Corbyn and make uncosted promises. Just carry on being the face of boring competence. Where it mattered, and where people knew they needed to vote to make the change, then Labour easily convinced the public to come out for them. But equally, we all knew it was a foregone conclusion from months out so there was a lot of stay-at-homes who just couldn't be bothered.
Easy to say the biggest thing is the rejection of the tories. Certainly Reform would have done next to nothing if the right wingers hadn't fled from their safe homes. But you have to give Starmer credit. Labour were an utter shambles after the 2019 e
The interesting and amusing thing will be seeing how Farage tries to argue the case to do away with the FPTP system. Especially as the public were asked in 2011 and very firmly decided they wanted to stick with it. Is he so against the democratic will of the people or will he make the case that as things change then it is time to re-visit things like this and to re-test the will of those people? I imagine a lot of people will be listening very closely to what he says.
The interesting and amusing thing will be seeing how Farage tries to argue the case to do away with the FPTP system. Especially as the public were asked in 2011 and very firmly decided they wanted to stick with it. Is he so against the democratic wil
Indeed. But for him to open the door to it invites the obvious follow-up. Who knows? Maybe that's exactly what he wants: another enemy to rail against.
Indeed. But for him to open the door to it invites the obvious follow-up. Who knows? Maybe that's exactly what he wants: another enemy to rail against.
Unlike a lot of Labour diehards I still love my country and would be as chuffed as anyone if Labour stopped the rot, never mind moved things forward. There's no indication they will do anything substantially or materially different to the Tory lightweights, all they are banking on is 'we're not them' as far as I can see.
I guess we don't have too long to find out what the actual agenda is.
Unlike a lot of Labour diehards I still love my country and would be as chuffed as anyone if Labour stopped the rot, never mind moved things forward. There's no indication they will do anything substantially or materially different to the Tory lightw
Is he so against the democratic will of the people
would hardly make him unique given the response by many to the Brexit vote...
I guess you mean me. But not the same case. All I (and my ilk) wanted was a vote to confirm whether leaving the EU was what was reallt wanted. And the country was denied that opportunity. Instead, Govt cemented the exit.
Eight years down the line, it is too late to change. So, we're poorer, but we're supposed to be happier.
What was sometime a paradox: after you give Leavers power, and they mess it up, they're still cross. Perpetually so, on today's evidence.
But, to quote, a loser is a loser.
Is he so against the democratic will of the peoplewould hardly make him unique given the response by many to the Brexit vote...I guess you mean me. But not the same case. All I (and my ilk) wanted was a vote to confirm whether leaving the EU was what
All I (and my ilk) wanted was a vote to confirm whether leaving the EU was what was reallt wanted
And you'd have asked for the same if remain had won. In your dreams.
All I (and my ilk) wanted was a vote to confirm whether leaving the EU was what was reallt wantedAnd you'd have asked for the same if remain had won. In your dreams.
No but Farage would, that's on record. To quote "unfinished business."
See, the reason many people just cannot accept Farage as a mature political operator is, he is only suited to the role of the constant moaner. When he carried voters hopes into the European Parliament, he abused the privilege. He was a truant. That is his character. It's ok lonely people giving him £25 to be his friend, but don't get in deep:- he'll throw you under a bus again.
No but Farage would, that's on record. To quote "unfinished business."See, the reason many people just cannot accept Farage as a mature political operator is, he is only suited to the role of the constant moaner.When he carried voters hopes into the
A Starmer fan critical of others throwing people under the bus. Takes the biscuits.
8 years on people still haven't gotten over losing a democratic vote. I guess that's the source of visceral hate directed at Farage. Yes you hate him I get it but it's going to be fun him showing up the rest of the lightweights in the HoC for what they really are.
A Starmer fan critical of others throwing people under the bus. Takes the biscuits.8 years on people still haven't gotten over losing a democratic vote. I guess that's the source of visceral hate directed at Farage. Yes you hate him I get it but it's
Ok. Please point out for the forum where he will sit in the House Of Commons. He could apply for an upgrade if he goes back to the Tories, but they probably won't have him. It's a it unfair, but the first word the electorate associate with Nigel is "racist."
Ok. Please point out for the forum where he will sit in the House Of Commons. He could apply for an upgrade if he goes back to the Tories, but they probably won't have him. It's a it unfair, but the first word the electorate associate with Nigel is "
Singlehandedly achieves over 4 million votes as a start up party and gets 5 elected MPs. Who else in parliament could achieve that? I give you the answer as well, none of them. They are all nothing without their respective party machines.
Singlehandedly achieves over 4 million votes as a start up party and gets 5 elected MPs. Who else in parliament could achieve that? I give you the answer as well, none of them. They are all nothing without their respective party machines.
tbf there's plenty of room on the opposition benches. absolutely no idea where they will sit, possibly with DUP. Not sure it's an uber critical variable.
tbf there's plenty of room on the opposition benches. absolutely no idea where they will sit, possibly with DUP. Not sure it's an uber critical variable.
who else could achieve that laugh? Keith would be invisible without the labour party, certainly nowhere near parliament via a democratic vote. Doesn't even get people motivated in his own seat !
who else could achieve that laugh? Keith would be invisible without the labour party, certainly nowhere near parliament via a democratic vote. Doesn't even get people motivated in his own seat !