Ever get the feeling that you've been had? That fringe meeting in Manchester where they all drank Tory champagne and cheered Boris Johnson to the rafters must feel like a long time ago.
Ever get the feeling that you've been had?That fringe meeting in Manchester where they all drank Tory champagne and cheered Boris Johnson to the rafters must feel like a long time ago.
Johnson's Brexit proposal creates illusion of victory for both sides Under the plan, the whole of the United Kingdom leaves the EU Customs Union, in a big and important win for the prime minister.
Downing Street appears to have a credible Brexit proposal after a week which began with a Number 10 aide calling a deal "essentially impossible".
The proposal thrashed out between Boris Johnson and Leo Varadkar, in theory, deals with the main of the outstanding intractable issues.
The nascent plan, revealed by leaks to Sky News and others, appears clever because it creates the illusion of victory for both sides on the most difficult issue of all - customs.
Under the plan, the whole of the United Kingdom leaves the EU customs union, in a big and important win for Boris Johnson.
However, the EU tariff regime will continue to be applied on whole of the island of Ireland.
This means that the tariffs charged in Great Britain could be different to those in Northern Ireland.
But under the compromise agreement, all businesses in Northern Ireland will be able to benefit from UK tariffs by offering a rebate on goods sold, if the UK tariff is lower than the EU one.
This plan allows Europe to say the island of Ireland is in one customs zone.
Which is a win for them.
This plan also allows Mr Johnson to say the whole of the UK has left the customs union and Northern Ireland can - like the rest of Great Britain benefit from trade deals, which is a win for him.
This compromise comes in the spirit of the Good Friday Agreement, which allowed for competing interpretations of one set of rules to allow peace in Northern Ireland.
Though, in truth, Britain has probably compromised more than the EU in this process.
Putting together the various compromises offered by Mr Johnson, Northern Ireland will, under Mr Johnson's plan, now be in the same regulatory and agricultural zone and subject to the same tariffs as the rest of the EU.
There will be a regulatory and agrifoods border in the Irish Sea and potentially some customs checks too, albeit while ensuring that Northern Ireland businesses do not lose out financially from the arrangement.
Some have compared the plan to a version of Theresa May's Chequers deal, but for Northern Ireland.
Others call it a Northern Ireland backstop - rejected decisively by MPs time and again - in all but name.
Number 10 will reject both labels and probably call it a free trade zone.
There will also be the option for Northern Ireland - either via Stormont or another mechanism - to vote on the plan in a few years, details of which are yet to be spelt out.
Only Mr Johnson could have compromised like this, and - as of now - still appear to keep both the DUP and Brexiteers on side.
However, the government is not home and dry.
They need to convince the rest of the EU, and there may be reservations about whether the UK post-Brexit can be trusted to administer the EU external border, and whether they are prepared to tolerate the risk of smuggling.
Then they also need to convince parliament.
Mr Johnson does not have a majority and, since he expelled a number of Tories who were voting to block no-deal, his numbers have been going backwards.
Several have joined the Lib Dems, while others who support a second referendum are not minded to support Mr Johnson either.
Meanwhile, Mr Johnson's Brexit plan paves the way for Great Britain to be subject to the hardest possible Brexit, potentially allowing for a reworking of the entire economic and social model towards low-tax low-regulation states with small safety nets, such as Singapore.
This makes it harder for Labour MPs to support.
This battle is not over yet.
Johnson's Brexit proposal creates illusion of victory for both sides Under the plan, the whole of the United Kingdom leaves the EU Customs Union, in a big and important win for the prime minister.Downing Street appears to have a credible Brexit propo
Although, to be fair the actual line "you should never put so much faith in a foreigner" does deserve closer inspection.
Do tell aka, what is it about foreign people that makes them less trustworthy?
Although, to be fair the actual line "you should never put so much faith in a foreigner" does deserve closer inspection.Do tell aka, what is it about foreign people that makes them less trustworthy?
must admit I am quite impressed with Barnier and the eu today let me go to work he said ! Quite right , abd tekk the remainers to fk off
yes aka they are seething must admit I am quite impressed with Barnier and the eu todaylet me go to work he said ! Quite right , abd tekk the remainers to fk off
I think the eu will look favourably in boris’ deal if we can get the technical details sorted
It’s the remainers they are starting to get pissed off with And heaven knows who can blame them
I think the eu will look favourably in boris’ deal if we can get the technical details sorted It’s the remainers they are starting to get pissed off with And heaven knows who can blame them
Well I'm generally told I'm in the insulting throwing ranks. But glad to see you're accepting your place in the world. All about building blocks and moving on to better things eh.
Well I'm generally told I'm in the insulting throwing ranks. But glad to see you're accepting your place in the world. All about building blocks and moving on to better things eh.
Problem with a cv aka is that it's all written down and people ask you about it.
I can only assume you've never written one as that concept clearly terrifies you.
Problem with a cv aka is that it's all written down and people ask you about it.I can only assume you've never written one as that concept clearly terrifies you.
Surprised that so many have failed to see through the SNP and their ineptitude. The Scottish NHS, Education, Police and Transport all toiling and have been for some time. Constantly blame Tory Austerity despite having the devolved powers to deal with it.
Surprised that so many have failed to see through the SNP and their ineptitude.The Scottish NHS, Education, Police and Transport all toiling and have been for some time.Constantly blame Tory Austerity despite having the devolved powers to deal with i
We have always known that , the EU is starting to see that also We could see that , Boris , Leo , Barnier ... They are beginning to see that, and are tiring of the remainers dirty tricks
We have always known that , the EU is starting to see that also We could see that , Boris , Leo , Barnier ...They are beginning to see that, and are tiring of the remainers dirty tricks
Can you imagine if the remainers went to Barnier and said we are trying to derail the talks for another few years
And he said fk off , you’re too much trouble
Can you imagine if the remainers went to Barnier and said we are trying to derail the talks for another few years And he said fk off , you’re too much trouble
I see someone has written to the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards complaining about Bercows lack of impartiality regarding Brexit. In particular his actions during parliament debates and his recent visit to the EU parliament to discuss Brexit. The complaint is in the name of a Rebecca Butler who describes herself as a Barrister at Law
I see someone has written to the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards complaining about Bercows lack of impartiality regarding Brexit.In particular his actions during parliament debates and his recent visit to the EU parliament to discuss Brexit.
I don’t know aka , little bercow isn’t the worst there are the labour MPs and libdems hundreds of them Maybe he hasn’t been strictly impartial I’m not sure well hopefully it won’t matter
I don’t know aka , little bercow isn’t the worst there are the labour MPs and libdems hundreds of them Maybe he hasn’t been strictly impartial I’m not sure well hopefully it won’t matter
Reading the complaint its evident that he has broken his code of conduct as the speaker. Certainly wasn't wise of him to declare his total opposition to Brexit at a recent talk he gave.
Reading the complaint its evident that he has broken his code of conduct as the speaker.Certainly wasn't wise of him to declare his total opposition to Brexit at a recent talk he gave.
Yes that’s true ,but i suppose in the end it depends on whether he has broken any rules I don’t think he’s that important in the scheme of things ( as long as he doesn’t get to vote )
Yes that’s true ,but i suppose in the end it depends on whether he has broken any rules I don’t think he’s that important in the scheme of things ( as long as he doesn’t get to vote )
The Democratic Unionist party has given a guarded response to Boris Johnson’s apparent U-turn on the Irish border, saying it will judge any Brexit deal on how it affects Northern Ireland’s long-term economic and constitutional interests.
In a statement on Friday night Arlene Foster, the DUP leader, reiterated the party’s opposition to the backstop but did not criticise the prime minister’s reported acceptance that there could not be a customs border on the island of Ireland.
“The DUP has always indicated that the United Kingdom must leave the EU as one nation and in so doing that no barriers to trade are erected within the UK,” said Foster, warning against any measure that would “trap” Northern Ireland in the EU’s single market or customs union.
She vowed to use the party’s “pivotal” influence at Westminster – it has 10 MPs and holds sway over some Conservative party Brexiters – to block any deal that violated the UK’s constitutional integrity.
However, the statement also recognised “the need to be flexible and look at Northern Ireland-specific solutions”, leaving the door open to a possible compromise between Downing Street and Brussels.
Ian Paisley, one of the party’s most ardent Brexiter MPs, said that the DUP would vote down any deal it did not like, but did not pre-emptively condemn Downing Street’s apparent backtracking.
Rival unionists, however, pounced on the reports.
Jim Allister, the leader of the Traditional Unionist Voice party, said: “If the proposals we’re beginning to hear about are correct it would totally disintegrate that economic unity … No matter how you dress it up, that is a fundamental assault upon our position within the United Kingdom.”
Jim Nicholson, an Ulster Unionist party (UUP) former MEP, said the region could be left on the “window ledge” of the union. “I fear that Northern Ireland is being offered up by Boris Johnson as the sacrificial lamb to save Brexit for the rest of the UK, the European Research Group and especially English nationalists.”
The Democratic Unionist party has given a guarded response to Boris Johnson’s apparent U-turn on the Irish border, saying it will judge any Brexit deal on how it affects Northern Ireland’s long-term economic and constitutional interests.In a stat
The DUP are and have already been capable of compromise they will look carefully at these new proposals and hopefully will find them to be acceptable As usual it is the unionists and indeed the U.K. who are having to do the hard work , not the republicans who are incapable of compromise
The DUP are and have already been capable of compromise they will look carefully at these new proposals and hopefully will find them to be acceptable As usual it is the unionists and indeed the U.K. who are having to do the hard work , not the republ
Other than a No Deal there isn't a way that Northern Ireland can exit the EU on the same terms as the rest of the UK. There has to be same market rules for NI and ROI to avoid a border so the current proposals, if reports are correct, seems to offer a solution to that. The DUP can accept the compromise or vote for a No Deal. I suspect the majority would prefer the compromise. In some ways NI get's the best of both worlds in the arrangement being able to take the lowest tarrifs available.
Other than a No Deal there isn't a way that Northern Ireland can exit the EU on the same terms as the rest of the UK. There has to be same market rules for NI and ROI to avoid a border so the current proposals, if reports are correct, seems to offer
The remainers never cared about that , as we can see from the comments of pp abs others . They were only concerned to use it as a means to get their own way
This deal exposes that , they are revealed for what they are now They gave no place to hide their true nature
This deal protects the gfa , it maintains peace The remainers never cared about that , as we can see from the comments of pp abs others .They were only concerned to use it as a means to get their own way This deal exposes that , they are revealed for
Another obstacle to any Brexit deal is the lack of a functioning Stormont assembly and executive.
Unionist and nationalist parties voiced scepticism on Friday that they could break the region’s 998-day political impasse.
Any Brexit deal is expected to require democratic consent for Northern Ireland’s continued alignment with the EU’s single market in goods, a conundrum with no obvious solution if Stormont remains mothballed.
Almost 1,000 days on from the collapse of power-sharing, Sinn Féin and the DUP traded blame for the paralysis and unveiled no plans to restore devolution.
Robin Swann, the leader of the UUP, called the inability of Northern Ireland’s two biggest parties to share power an abject failure of politics. “Their toxic mixture of arrogance, disrespect and incompetence has led the country to where it is today,” he said.
Stormont collapsed in January 2017 over a botched renewable heating initiative, the so-called cash for ash scandal. The biggest obstacle to the restoration of power-sharing is an Irish language act.
Colum Eastwood, the leader of the moderate nationalist SDLP, said there was negligible progress despite urgency over Brexit and atrophying public services. “The cold truth is that we are no closer to Irish-language legislation now than we were three years ago. We are facing a national emergency on this island as a no-deal Brexit draws nearer.”
The murder of the journalist Lyra McKee in April by dissident republicans galvanised British and Irish officials to shepherd parties into talks at Stormont, with all sides expressing concern at armed groups filling the political void.
Talks stalled amid mistrust between the DUP and Sinn Féin. Not even the imminent decriminalisation of abortion on 22 October – unless the assembly reconvenes before that date – persuaded the anti-abortion DUP to return.
Naomi Long, the leader of the Alliance party, called the political stalemate “shameful”. A campaign group, We Deserve Better, is due to hold a protest outside Stormont on Sunday.
The gloom in Belfast contrasted with hope in Brussels after British and EU negotiators got the green light to intensify talks to try to hammer out a Brexit deal.
There have been two key sticking points: Downing Street’s insistence on a customs border on the island of Ireland; and a mechanism for gaining democratic consent for Northern Ireland’s alignment with the EU’s single market. The latter had raised anxiety in some quarters over a DUP veto on trading arrangements.
Thursday’s meeting between Johnson and his Irish counterpart, Leo Varadkar, ended with both sides declaring a “pathway” to a possible Brexit deal, suggesting compromise on both issues.
Julian Smith, the Northern Ireland secretary, told the BBC there would not be a situation where “one community has a veto” over Brexit plans.
He said there was “a range of options” for finding consent. He did not rule out a Northern Ireland-only referendum. “The key thing is we have to have regard to the Good Friday agreement and have regard to the need to have a cross-community approach to how we resolve this.”
Northern Ireland’s business community has repeatedly warned of ruin if the UK leaves without a deal.
Another obstacle to any Brexit deal is the lack of a functioning Stormont assembly and executive.Unionist and nationalist parties voiced scepticism on Friday that they could break the region’s 998-day political impasse.Any Brexit deal is expected t
As always, the devil will be in the detail, and we have a government who will go to extreme lengths to avoid publishing detail.
And whilst the current focus is on two major sticking points specific to Northern Ireland, we have yet to see what is planned for the rest of the country.
And, as Leo has reminded us, “there’s many in the slip between cup and lip”.
As always, the devil will be in the detail, and we have a government who will go to extreme lengths to avoid publishing detail.And whilst the current focus is on two major sticking points specific to Northern Ireland, we have yet to see what is plann
Heart to God,with a few notable exceptions the thread disintegrated,Johnny Foreigner got a bit of a bashing as well! Prince Philip not in the slightest bit amused! Best to put this in the cupboard under the stairs and go away and listen to dj butterfly.
Heart to God,with a few notable exceptions the thread disintegrated,Johnny Foreigner got a bit of a bashing as well! Prince Philip not in the slightest bit amused!Best to put this in the cupboard under the stairs and go away and listen to dj butterfl
wonder if one day someone will calculate the time and billions wasted on 2 no deal deadlines if we eventually sign up to something the dup,erg could have signed up to 18 months ago,mrs may.s face sat behind Johnson wqhen he describesbasically her deal as an a work of art,he,l obviously miss out the bits about no british PM could ever sign up to,and some fat blonde fool labling the deal CRAZY
wonder if one day someone will calculate the time and billions wasted on 2 no deal deadlines if we eventually sign up to something the dup,erg could have signed up to 18 months ago,mrs may.s face sat behind Johnson wqhen he describesbasically her dea
Your bud Nigel looking to back a 2nd referendum.10 extra heads in the crowd for the peoples vote,
"true arrows"
feck the union we do what suits ourselves.
Your bud Nigel looking to back a 2nd referendum.10 extra heads in the crowd for the peoples vote, "true arrows" feck the union we do what suits ourselves.
Dup back brexit Dup block Mays deal Dup block Boris making deal New Gov and have lost influence. Deal agreed by UK and EU, Dup furious and blame everyone else. Dump AF and take instructions from UDA/UVF/UFF
The meeting Thurs with an Taoiseach looks a complete backtrack on the previous rhetoric re North/South talks.They are getting nowhere fast.
A brief summary;Dup back brexitDup block Mays dealDup block Boris making dealNew Gov and have lost influence.Deal agreed by UK and EU,Dup furious and blame everyone else.Dump AF and take instructions from UDA/UVF/UFFThe meeting Thurs with an Taoiseac
They get rid of Arlene Foster because she abstains on a vote about gay correction therapy, replace her with a total nutjob who thinks the world is only a few thousand years old, then chuck him out after a few weeks..what next for the dinosaurs of UK politics?
They get rid of Arlene Foster because she abstains on a vote about gay correction therapy, replace her with a total nutjob who thinks the world is only a few thousand years old, then chuck him out after a few weeks..what next for the dinosaurs of UK
The cautious but irreversible road to destruction................DUP
Thousands of Irish speaking kids in the North, running around with Hurls and Concertinas. HUP
The cautious but irreversible road to destruction................DUP Thousands of Irish speaking kids in the North, running around with Hurls and Concertinas. HUP
Think you are into trad music, i have a buddy who lives off Barrack St but he was out in his garden and spotted John Spillane passing with his guitar,bud said howya and said he likes his stuff, JS goes into the garden and plays "The streets of Ballyphehane" had a coffee and was off on a "gig". This happened this morning,bud was delighted and sent me the vid from his phone,fair play to JS,it was very good.
Hello PD,hope you are keeping well!Think you are into trad music, i have a buddy who lives off Barrack St but he was out in his garden and spotted John Spillane passing with his guitar,bud said howya and said he likes his stuff, JS goes into the gard
Hi Pa, i'm good thanks, hope your chipper yerself..
I remember you saying you werent a fan of Spillane.
His material is not for everyone, i wouldnt rush to pull his lp out first, but that said the fella is a BARD, a huge talent to be respected for sure, and clearly very down to earth also.He's fluent Irish and fairy forts and cherry blossom tree and all sorts HUP
Hi Pa, i'm good thanks, hope your chipper yerself..I remember you saying you werent a fan of Spillane.His material is not for everyone, i wouldnt rush to pull his lp out first, but that said the fella is a BARD, a huge talent to be respected for sure