New Posts For Thread: Does anybody know who gives reviews and ratings on P2P.ie?......https://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pieBecause whoever they are they wouldn't know if they had enough eaten.....you'd want to see the rubbish he wrote about childrens list......I'd ignore the stuff written in the catalogue as pretty sure you can write what you like in that. There was at least one in the sale on Friday (W/D) that you wouldn't give tuppence for but would have probably gone for decent money.Ronnie did very wehttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542664795#542664795I'd ignore the stuff written in the catalogue as pretty sure you can write what you like in that. There was at least one in the sale on Friday (W/D) that you wouldn't give tuppence for but would have probably gone for decent money.Ronnie did very weSun, 14 Dec 2014 09:41:11 -0600mr o'leary has one for sale tonight..only won on Saturday?lol..he still holds the record for a sale 330.000 that pig he sold john hales and nicholls..not sure its won another race?https://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542641989#542641989mr o'leary has one for sale tonight..only won on Saturday?lol..he still holds the record for a sale 330.000 that pig he sold john hales and nicholls..not sure its won another race?Fri, 12 Dec 2014 15:25:54 -0600Having read the form guide for the horses entered in the Brightwells sale this evening one can only marvel at their ability to describe even the poorest entry in glowing terms.Judging by the numbers unsold or bought back it would appear the vendors whttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542641255#542641255Having read the form guide for the horses entered in the Brightwells sale this evening one can only marvel at their ability to describe even the poorest entry in glowing terms.Judging by the numbers unsold or bought back it would appear the vendors wFri, 12 Dec 2014 14:52:00 -0600Royalacademy, I discovered your p2p thread on the racing forum today, great read, keep up the good workhttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542512351#542512351Royalacademy, I discovered your p2p thread on the racing forum today, great read, keep up the good workWed, 03 Dec 2014 14:14:26 -0600Those reviews are all up on that website that evening so they can hardly be compromised by sales prices or who trains them next. I do remember Champagne Fever was highest rated 4yo of his generation and surely not easy to get em all right. Sounds likhttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542495977#542495977Those reviews are all up on that website that evening so they can hardly be compromised by sales prices or who trains them next. I do remember Champagne Fever was highest rated 4yo of his generation and surely not easy to get em all right. Sounds likTue, 02 Dec 2014 07:23:02 -0600yeah, its the 95 that's the issue...not the language imo...https://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542485459#542485459yeah, its the 95 that's the issue...not the language imo...Mon, 01 Dec 2014 05:56:13 -0600"Won going away in the style of something special"...."There are many more youngsters to run this season few will be more exciting than this half brother to Schindlers Hunt"....95+ was the rating given....which is very high for a maiden win....https://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542485429#542485429"Won going away in the style of something special"...."There are many more youngsters to run this season few will be more exciting than this half brother to Schindlers Hunt"....95+ was the rating given....which is very high for a maiden win....Mon, 01 Dec 2014 05:53:03 -0600post the review and the rating paulie...don't keep them to yourselfand I'd be surprised if you don't know who gives both so why not name and shame?I presume this horse had the rating before Mullins moved in so CheltenhamRoar's assertion is inaccuratehttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542485401#542485401post the review and the rating paulie...don't keep them to yourselfand I'd be surprised if you don't know who gives both so why not name and shame?I presume this horse had the rating before Mullins moved in so CheltenhamRoar's assertion is inaccurateMon, 01 Dec 2014 05:49:20 -0600That's a fairly good effort on the Talkinhorses site Gutfeeling,seems to be a one man operation by a fella who just has a gra for the ptp. I mightn't be using the site to its best but think he only covers what he has seen(ie maybe doesn't go up to thhttps://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542485273#542485273That's a fairly good effort on the Talkinhorses site Gutfeeling,seems to be a one man operation by a fella who just has a gra for the ptp. I mightn't be using the site to its best but think he only covers what he has seen(ie maybe doesn't go up to thMon, 01 Dec 2014 05:30:59 -0600Aye they keep it factual and don't let sales prices influence their analysis.https://community.betfair.com/irish_sports/go/thread/view/94110/30394271/does-anybody-know-who-gives-reviews-and-ratings-on-p2pie?post_id=542481053#542481053Aye they keep it factual and don't let sales prices influence their analysis.Sun, 30 Nov 2014 15:44:27 -0600