By:
agree joe - cant believe aussies shorter than when the day started
i feared they could be 3 for 400 so 5 for 326 is dissappointing for aust in my opinion when windies strength and aussies weakness to come maybe i'm on the wrong track? |
By:
i think we both on the right track craig.. can't see a derailment here :D
|
By:
price aided by the aussie media who have given to the windies - they have not taken into account their reasonable test form prior to their trip to england
|
By:
they bat deeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep, i say deeeeeeeeeeeep with ramdin at 8 and taylor at 9
Surely Ramdin is at 7 and Taylor 8? Unless one of Rampaul, Benn or Roach is going to bat 7. I think that makes a big difference. WI batting is certainly better than their bowling, but it could be argued that without Sarwan and with Gayle not having any warm-up time, it hasn't had the best of preparation. I'd want a chance of weather interruptions as well if I was backing the draw - Brisbane virtually never produces a draw without it (although obviously the Aus attack would usually have been better than this one). No bet for me on this still - Aussies very strong favourites but I'm not interested in backing 1.21 shots with 4 days left. |
By:
Reasons are simple....this brisy pitch usually flatens out on days 2 and 3
any evidence behind this statement Joe? Last 4 tests here 2nd inns has been sub 220 |
By:
looks a better bet now at 6/1 than before the start given an only steady-ish start and a not unplayable pitch
|
By:
Bowling attack can't be that bad Joe - we did just beat the mighty India on there home turf in the recent one dayers.
And didn't Australia beat South Africa over there. Ashes was disappointing but Hilfenhaus and Siddle bowled well and Johnson had a shocker. Can't think of to many draws at the Gabba in the last 10 years Joe? |
By:
Massive leap of faith to think the Windies will score 450+. 300 more likely imo
|
By:
Have to agree with Joe and Craig on this one, also might have to factor into account possibility of rain on days 3 and 5 from all reports, 30% and 70% likely (not sure how many overs will be lost)
An attack of Mitch Johnson, Hilfenhaus ,Siddle, Hauritz is OK but they are not world beaters. Would have loved to see a Ganga, and/or Kieron Pollard in this team. |
By:
I feel West Indies batting is ok from memory that scored 350 odd off 115 overs against QLD in 2nd dig in a warm up game.
For me batting time out is more valuable than scoring runs for West Indies, but both are equally as important. I feel there will be some lost overs in this match having a look at forecast. An innings of 300 runs off 150 overs is going to be just as valuable as an innings 350 off 95.0 overs. |
By:
West Coast Eagles 26 Nov 12:48
For me batting time out is more valuable than scoring runs for West Indies, but both are equally as important. :^0 |
By:
Funda yes indeed 2nd innings scores do not indicates pitch flattening out .. but the in most of the games aussies had piled up around or over 500 batting first..... and obviously quite a few of those were scored on 2nd day.... fact that kiwis, sri lanka folded after 2 days in field was more to blame then pitch as bo5th scored a lot more in thie 2nd innings on days 4 and 5 , which indicates pitch does get easier to bat on :0
But i repeat, the biggest reason is that this is a very weak Aussie bowling lineup... this is a very strong windies batting lineup.. this equates to a score of 450+ for windies imo.... and even if they only score 350 in first knock.. there is always the 2nd innings to come .. where as previous games shows, batting is easier ;) So all in all.... 7.0 for this aussie attack NOT to take 20 wickets in 3 days remains value of the highest order :D |
By:
west coast my biggest fear here is that the west indies start believing our media about how terrible they are
the caning they have got just doesn't add up - forget their last four tests as they are unrepresentative and previously in february they beat england 1 - 0 in a 5 test series does that indicate a team that doesn't dig in? previously they drew series's agains nz and sri lanka and won a test in south africa such a pity sarwan is out but the difference in the two sides isn't that great imo |
By:
big joe
If the Aussies bowling is that bad how did they beat the Injuns? |
By:
The other thing to consider is that this 7.0 is "almost" a free back ;)
Even if things go aussies way in next couple of days.. lets say they score 500...windies all out 250 :( ... no way will ponting enforce the follow on 250 ahead... he will bat on and try and set 500 in last 5 sessions.... in those circumstances, the draw would still only be around 8.0 at most ;) So whichever way you look at it... the HAS to be backed here ... imo its INEVITABLE that it will trade a hell of a lot lower..i believe it will trade nearer evens at sometime in this test....i say don't look a gift horse in the mouth... back the draw.. then decide if you want to lay off and take a profit .. or let it ride :) |
By:
jimmy k.. if they had to take 20 wickets in those odis games you refer to they would not have beaten injuns ;)
Why ? Cos the last time they had to take 20 wickets to beat india in india.. they failed misreably and were sent packing with a 2-0 series defeat :( You can judge tests with Odi form... i prefer to keep them as seperate entities ;) |
By:
As a draw backer as well
Im not sure whether I want Windies to bowl Aussies for say under 400 , or let them bat on and on and get around 500-550 If they decide to bat on and on, it eliminates more time from the game. This game for me has a very familiar feel to the current India V SL 2nd test match, I get the feeling day 3 will be D-Day here. |
By:
fact is..... Aussies have slipped to 4th in rankings cos they lost 2-0 away to injuns.. lost at home to saffers.... and lost to england in ashes... 1.22 on a team that has lost 3 out of last 4 test series is not value imo ;)
And the main reason they lost those 3 series is that their bowling failed to take 20 wickets ..... ok windies not as good as injuns or saffers.. but they did manage to beat england... they did beat saffers in a test away too and they are improving all the time. The prices in this series belong in the distant past when aussies were dominant... oppo are not scared of them any more .... their bowling really is carp in relation to what it used to be :0 .. the prices on aussies will slowly start to reflect that reality over the coming months... but till then, i say lets take advantage ;) |
By:
craig, that was perhaps the most flattering 1-0 series win in history on some of the deadest wickets i've ever seen. england were in turmoil after KP's sacking as well and still could won 2-1 having them 9 down in antigua and 8 trinidad. not sure has much relevance to playing oz away.
|
By:
And to describe it as a "five-Test series" is slightly disingenuous, considering that one of the Tests lasted just ten balls!
|
By:
not sure windies bat so deep in this match.
Bravo is playing as a no.5 and not as a no7. where perhaps he should be. Dowlin is not a great no.3 and cant expect too much from Barath's debut. Too much depends on chanderpaul - hopefully batting 4, not 5! Taylor is a good number 9 but an ordinary no.8 - the last 3 can hold a bat, but no great shakes. If sarwan was playing and bravo played as the bowling allrounder not the batting one, than id agree they bat deep - but this test they don't! |
By:
The Windies test batting is pretty abysmal. They will do well to post 300 during any innings this series.
|
By:
Aussie media "caning" a visiting side? HTEHB?
|
By:
I think the 7.0 represent value though I feel by far the most likely scenario is Australia wn and win well from here.
Mit I think Bravo is virtually as good as any batsman WI has at present though this is unproven at test level. For a 25 year old who has had to bowl a fair bit, his average of 32 is quite good when you consider he doesn't have too many soft runs to his name and has often batted without too much support wich would tend to panic most young players at this level. I am a bit concerned about him bowling over 25% of the overs on day one and how that effects his batting here, but I do feel he will prove one of the better batsmen in the game in coming years. |
By:
18 smileys .. thats good nuff for me .. i'm going all in :|
|
By:
19 :D ;)
|
By:
A draw at Brissy when the visitors are undercooked?
Mmm, not sure I can see it happening but it would be pleasing nonetheless. Home win I would think. |
By:
ffffffffffffffúcking n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'n'ineteen is correct :(
|
By:
big joe... how deep they bat again?
|
By:
Only chance this Test will end in a draw is if it rains for 1.5 days.
Windies batting is poor and the Gabba wicket produces results. Not a lot of huffing and puffing required by the Aussie bowlers. |
By:
Nt quite going to plan then :(
After the arrogant declaration by tricky ricky :) windies were cooking at 49-0 .. but a short time lateat 63-4 it was clear that their cooking was more what you see in wormwood scrubs then a michelin star resteraunt :( BUT.i am nothing if not an optomist B-) ... always remembr its a marathon not a sprint ;) .. windies still have 15 wickets left.. and the good news for them.. and me .. was that after having windies 63-4 while ball was reasonably new ... as it got older, the rest of the sesion was 71-1 ;) ... in other words... there are signs of some hufing and puffing around the corner from the ausie bowling and there is still every chance that windies can avoid the follow on and the draw comes back into the picture ;) Een if the windies tail does not wag .. they stilgot their 2nd ings to come... they might not mesthat one up and they could score that 450+ in 2nd innings instead of the first ;) Add in the weather doubts..and its clear tat this marathon stilhas a long way to run ;) Good Luck ) |
By:
have you ever admitted you got it wrong in the middle of a test
you are one stubborn person |
By:
mitheimp .. 96-5 for top 5 wickets .... 38-0 for last 5 so far ... first sesion tommorow will see you get your answer :D
|
By:
daph3e..if i get it wrong i hold my hand up when test is finished .but just as you cannot judge a soup after the first spoonful.....so you cannot judge a marathon that still has 15 miles to run ;)
|
By:
don't count on a marathon
this test will be over tomorrow thats 2 days early by the way |
By:
thats funny .. i thought travis dowling was still at the crease @ stumps .. nah i must have read it wrong cos we know bj only deals in facts right ?
|
By:
no top up :0 :0
|
By:
What happening to the Windies looooooooong batting line up? :0
Looks like they're one wicket away from a looooooooong tail to me. :| |
By:
don't be daft birch .. they go waaaaaayyyyy deeeeeeeeeep .. expect them to be at least 150-200 ahead by end of their 1st innings :|
|