Group A: Australia, Pakistan, New Zealand, Sri Lanka, Zimbabwe, Canada, Kenya Group B: India, South Africa, England, West Indies, Bangladesh, Ireland, Netherlands
Tom is right (for a change). As the only Champions Trophy semi-finalists in Group B, England must be very strong favourites to finish top of the group.
Tom is right (for a change). As the only Champions Trophy semi-finalists in Group B, England must be very strong favourites to finish top of the group.
the bigger groups mean less chance of a big team going out with 1 bad performance, you'd imagine of the the course of 21 group games the top sides will go through, personally i think it should go straight to semi finals
the bigger groups mean less chance of a big team going out with 1 bad performance, you'd imagine of the the course of 21 group games the top sides will go through, personally i think it should go straight to semi finals
No 2nd group stage, the group stage is simply a way of setting up which of the big 7 + either Ireland or Bangladesh plays who in the quarter final stage. something 1 game (ireland v bang) and a draw could have done. But should still be good fun, hard to see a major nation not making the top 4 of their group with such a lot of matches in the group stage.
No 2nd group stage, the group stage is simply a way of setting up which of the big 7 + either Ireland or Bangladesh plays who in the quarter final stage. something 1 game (ireland v bang) and a draw could have done. But should still be good fun, hard
Throw 2 extra teams in there afgans and bermuda or usa whatever, make it 4 groups of 4
24 group games top 2 qualify from each
straight to QF 4 games
semi finals 2 games
Final 1 game
31 games could be all done in 3 weeks 2 games a day group stages = 12 days 2 day break 2 QF one day 2QF the next, 1 day break 1st Sem Final next day 2nd Semi Final 1 day Break Final
21 days all done everyone happy, very little chance of any dead games. also chance of upsets due to short group format.
Throw 2 extra teams in there afgans and bermuda or usa whatever, make it 4 groups of 424 group games top 2 qualify from eachstraight to QF 4 gamessemi finals 2 gamesFinal 1 game31 games could be all done in 3 weeks 2 games a day group stages = 12 day
I like that idea dougy apart from the having 2 quarter finals on the same day. Gotta be able to watch all the quarters in their entirety. would be too long to play one after the other.
If they were only 40 overs long however.... ;)
I like that idea dougy apart from the having 2 quarter finals on the same day. Gotta be able to watch all the quarters in their entirety. would be too long to play one after the other. If they were only 40 overs long however.... ;)
42 pretty pointless matches and then sudden death to see who's best at tossing a coin.
In india, Sri Lanka and Pakistan
Can't wait.
Lori 07 Oct 16:15 This looks like the crappest format ever devised42 pretty pointless matches and then sudden death to see who's best at tossing a coin. In india, Sri Lanka and PakistanCan't wait.
Obviously think we should beat the Dutch, and anywhere other than the sub continent would think we would beat Bangla, but...
Beyond that its what WI team we have by then, and whether we can get justice this time against England.
Come on Ireland and the Blarney Army!
Oh, and betting on which team Ed Joyce will play for...! ;)
Obviously think we should beat the Dutch, and anywhere other than the sub continent would think we would beat Bangla, but...Beyond that its what WI team we have by then, and whether we can get justice this time against England. Come on Ireland and th
42 games to eliminate 6 sides (of which you can nominate 5 now)
A further 7 games to eliminate 7 more (Quarters, Semi, and final)
Whoever thought up this must be retarded - or trying to kill off the 50 over format. The Champs Trophy will have had more twists than the supposed one day showcase
42 games to eliminate 6 sides (of which you can nominate 5 now)A further 7 games to eliminate 7 more (Quarters, Semi, and final)Whoever thought up this must be retarded - or trying to kill off the 50 over format. The Champs Trophy will have had more
No danger of that. The one-eyed mob will only go to India games anyhow at which they will be in a continuous state of frenzied excitement each time Dhoni takes a throw or Tendulkar jogs to mid on.
No danger of that. The one-eyed mob will only go to India games anyhow at which they will be in a continuous state of frenzied excitement each time Dhoni takes a throw or Tendulkar jogs to mid on.
tournament clearly designed to ensure the top 8 qualify for the final stages this time....
:0
for me, the 1992 format has never been bettered...no meaningless teams clogging up the tourny - top 9 all played each other in a rouind robin (36 matches) - then top 4 went to semis and final - 39 games, was over in 33 days...
scrub the zimbos and add the bangas and repeat...keep the minnows to world t20s or some other rubbish...
tournament clearly designed to ensure the top 8 qualify for the final stages this time....:0for me, the 1992 format has never been bettered...no meaningless teams clogging up the tourny - top 9 all played each other in a rouind robin (36 matches) - t
So lets see, your basis would mean a team that beat both Pakistan and Bangladesh last time wouldnt even be allowed to qualify?
Someone get the straitjacket out!
So lets see, your basis would mean a team that beat both Pakistan and Bangladesh last time wouldnt even be allowed to qualify?Someone get the straitjacket out!
yes, the whole reason the format has been changed this time is so that even if an ireland or a kenya fluke a win against a pakistan or bangladesh, they will not advance to the last 8 as they have in the past..
might as well cut out the middle man...
yes, the whole reason the format has been changed this time is so that even if an ireland or a kenya fluke a win against a pakistan or bangladesh, they will not advance to the last 8 as they have in the past..might as well cut out the middle man...
Would possibly be a bit better if only two qualified from each group - might at least get a few meaningful games then. Group A in particular would get a lot more interesting.
What we've got at the moment is basically the same as the '96 World Cup format - a succession of mismatches and meaningless games until the knockout stages. Might just as well get 16 teams, seed them according to the rankings, and play a straight knock-out - at least then every game would count and the minnows would have something to play for.
Would possibly be a bit better if only two qualified from each group - might at least get a few meaningful games then. Group A in particular would get a lot more interesting.What we've got at the moment is basically the same as the '96 World Cup form
The Last WC was rubbish because Ireland and Bangladesh qualified for the 2nd group stage. Not a nice thing to say but its what I and many others felt at the time. Not knocking Ireland or Bang at all. Was a great achievement and fully deserved just left a lot of boring games.
The Last WC was rubbish because Ireland and Bangladesh qualified for the 2nd group stage. Not a nice thing to say but its what I and many others felt at the time. Not knocking Ireland or Bang at all. Was a great achievement and fully deserved just l
The thing about a World Cup is that if a side qualifies to play in it they deserve a few games. i like the Round Robin idea, but you need to ensure that each game is important - as it is sides could beat all the minnows and still qualify, which surely is wrong
I have no problems with the associate sides playing, but if you have the groups too large in the first round you create a lot of meaningless matches. Somehow you have to balance the chance of a big side being humbled (like last time) with minimising the pointless games.
Alternatively, just give the trophy to Aussie and we can forget about this pointless version of cricket ;)
The thing about a World Cup is that if a side qualifies to play in it they deserve a few games. i like the Round Robin idea, but you need to ensure that each game is important - as it is sides could beat all the minnows and still qualify, which sure
What about winner from each group qualifies for semi finals ,while 2nd from one group plays 3rd from other group in 2 play-off games for other 2 semi final places . Will ensure that most games are meaningful and gives a reward for winning the group .
What about winner from each group qualifies for semi finals ,while 2nd from one group plays 3rd from other group in 2 play-off games for other 2 semi final places . Will ensure that most games are meaningful and gives a reward for winning the group .