If Glasgow did not exist would the Scots have voted for Independence?

It does seem like the Scots who work hard and could prosper by themselves voted no and the ones who rely on the UK taxpayer made up the SNP core support.

Mind boggles, should be the other way round

The proletariat voted Yes not because they really thought they'd be much better off but for the reason that an incoming SNP (lefty) government would wreck the economy and drag down  the middle classes to their level...ie the overriding rationale was Envy.