Who has played the best game in the Referendum?

Salmond has fought a shameful and sordid campaign, a rabble-rousing farrago that will divide his country and fuel resentment between neighbours for years to come.

0/10

fair play monster  how do you rate the others?

Salmond by far - but it's like congratulating Goebbels for effective propaganda.  Darling was decent but shouted down.  The best thing to come out of it is that Cameron may go.  Of course Nige will reap the benefits if he doesn't endorse too many loons.  Say what you like about Boris - unlike the vast majority of politicians, he does try to answer the question.  Just keep your wives and daughters away from him.

Well, I initially thought Cameron was a fool to sanction the referendum in the first place, holding him equally culpable for the troubles that are sure to follow.  I have since come to believe, however, that maybe he had little choice but to accede to the vote. 

His performance in the run up has been mixed in my view.  His speech the other day was very good, but I feel the NO campaign as a whole has not countered Salmond's nationalistic rhetoric very well.

5/10

I actually thought Gordon Brown has displayed the most common sense, and I normally cannot abide the man.

I think our shared military history has been underused by the NO campaign.

Our recent history I should add!

shared military??....the uneducated working class youth used as cannon fodder?

Amongst others, yes.

are you aware of how old the majority of deaths on both sides was in the Falklands conflict were?

But especially them.

No, but I'd hazard a guess at about 22.

Nnnnnnn-nineteen?

a bit lower actually but we agree in principle
are you aware we have in excess of 50 nuclear warheads in Scotland?
in England there are zero.

sry that reply was to poker.

Poker - ur living in the past.  It's time for change.  It's time for Scotland to stand on their own 2 feet.  If people have Scotland in their heart they will vote YES.  Short term pain for long term gain.  Other countries through out the World would love to have the chance that Scotland has tomorrow.